VALAR WATCHTake action
Independent fact-check

What the public records show about Valar Atomics in Castle Country

The strongest findings so far, each checked against its source. Every line links to the documents, and each Claims vs Record entry names the record that would settle it.

What you can do about it →
Map: Every site, to scale. Numbered as in the full map's key: 1 Project Beehive, 2 the lease approved for Valar, 3 the RW 453 claim area, 4 the Jurassic Spark parcels (no Valar link found), 5 the state lab and the parcel next to it that Emery County approved selling to Valar, 6 Valar's Green River application, 7 to 9 state site-study permit applications (no record read names the applicant).
Every site, to scale
Map: Around Price. Centered on Price. Project Beehive (1), about 9,700 acres as drawn from NPR's map (outline approximate), takes in the lease approved for Valar (2) and part of the RW 453 claim area (3). Southwest of Price, state site-study permit application 7674 (7) covers 5,382 acres; no record read names the applicant. The Jurassic Spark parcels (4): no Valar link found.
Around Price
Map: Between Price and Green River. State site-study permit application 7676 (8), in Emery County: 488 acres of state trust land within the two survey sections drawn, for site-suitability studies toward 'a potential industrial and manufacturing development'. No record read names the applicant.
Between Price and Green River
Map: Near Green River. Valar's Green River BLM application (6): 10,271 acres, listed as pending in late September 2026; Valar told a reporter it decided not to pursue the site. State site-study permit application 7672 (9) covers 1,813 acres across several sections; no record read names the applicant.
Near Green River
Map: Near Orangeville. The state-owned parcel that holds the lab's address, where Ward 250 operates, about 34 acres by the county parcel map (DOE describes the lab itself as a 20.6-acre site), and the parcel next to it that Emery County approved selling to Valar, about 112 acres. This map is much closer in, so its square is 40 acres.
Near Orangeville

Meetings and coverage

What the county's record and outside news coverage show happened, newest first, as of October 17, 2026. Points from the news are each outlet's own account, linked; an outcome goes on the record once a story or the county's minutes, audio or video show it.

  1. Wednesday, October 7, 2026 · Carbon County Commission, 4:30 p.m.

    The commissioners' regular meeting: no Valar item on the agenda

    On the agenda: routine county business (contracts, grants, and property-value changes as the Board of Equalization), and no item on Valar, nuclear power, the Section 16 lease or a county permit. No public-comment period is listed. The agenda was posted October 5. (dir-016)

    Not yet on the record: the meeting's outcome. No news coverage was found as of October 9, and no minutes were posted as of October 17, 2026; the county's video of the meeting (44 minutes) is linked below.

    The record: Carbon County's video of the meeting (YouTube, 44:12); The meeting's notice and agenda (Utah Public Notice Website)

  2. Tuesday, October 6, 2026 · Carbon County Planning Commission, 4:30 p.m.

    Valar presents to the county planners; more than 100 attend, FOX 13 reported

    On the agenda: a presentation from Valar Atomics about its proposed project in Carbon County (item 6, added October 2), and a conditional use permit for a technology park sought by other companies (no record read links it to Valar). No public-comment item was listed. (loc-037, dir-015)

    What the county's audio recording shows

    • Those attending were told it was 'not a public hearing' and that anyone causing an outburst could be removed (0:11:23).
    • The attorney advising the commission described the technology-park application as a phased project whose first phase would be power generation (0:07:39).
    • He set out the test the planners must apply (whether the 'reasonably anticipated detrimental effects' can be mitigated), said a decision either way needed 'substantial evidence', said the county was still identifying the project's uses and effects, and recommended that the planners 'table this for one more month' (0:03:18 to 0:09:14).
    • The planners voted by voice to table the permit, then amended the motion to table it until their next regularly scheduled meeting, with November 10 named (0:48:05 to 0:53:18).
    • During Valar's presentation, Valar was asked to show 'the full scope of the project'; the questioner said Valar releases it 'one section at a time' (1:19:45 to 1:19:53).

    As reported by KUTV and FOX 13

    • More than 100 people attended, FOX 13 reported; KUTV reported that the room was packed, with more people standing outside, and that public comment was not allowed.
    • As the Valar team introduced itself, a member of the audience shouted opposition, KUTV reported.
    • Valar's CEO, Isaiah Taylor, named jobs as the primary benefit (KUTV) and said data centers provide 'a pretty incredible tax revenue' (FOX 13).
    • Taylor said, 'If the community doesn't want us here, we won't do it,' and the room applauded, KUTV reported; the county's recording has the same words at 1:19:09, where the speaker calls it something 'you shouldn't say as a CEO'.
    • The two stations reported different sizes: KUTV wrote of 'around 70 small nuclear reactors'; FOX 13 wrote that Valar's team wanted 'a couple hundred reactors on a 640-acre parcel' of state trust land, and that Taylor called the BLM land 'sort of an eventual phase 2'. In the county's recording of Valar's item, a Valar speaker describes 'about a 640-acre parcel' of state trust land (0:58:50) and, for the land Valar would start with, 'something like 70' reactors, saying the number is 'probably wrong' (1:21:37); no 'couple hundred' figure was found in that part of the recording, as of October 17, 2026.
    • No decision on Valar was made: FOX 13 noted the item was a presentation only.

    Coverage: KUTV 2News, “Residents push back against plan to build nuclear reactors in Carbon County” (October 6, 2026); FOX 13, “Residents raise concerns over potential future of data centers in Carbon County” (October 7, 2026)

    The record: Carbon County's audio recording of the meeting (Utah Public Notice Website, 1:31:54); Carbon County's video of the meeting (YouTube, 1:31:57); The meeting's notice and agenda (Utah Public Notice Website)

Radiation exposure

Project Beehive's used fuel, worked out from published numbers

NPR reports Valar's Project Beehive would run about 456 small reactors near Price. By our math, they would leave the radioactive leftovers of 6 to 10 large U.S. reactors every year, in less uranium but much more bulk. Holding one used fuel pebble for five minutes, a day after it leaves a reactor, would give the whole body about 30 times the top of a CT scan's range; a year later, about one scan's worth. (The pebble is our stand-in: no Valar statement of what shape Beehive's fuel would take was found in public records. This is a 'what if' that shows how strong the fuel is, not an estimate of anyone's exposure.) The low radiation figures found in the public record come from test reactors: Valar's CT-scan comparison is about Ward One, a 100-kilowatt reactor planned to run less than a month, and DOE ties Ward 250's small radioactive inventory to its 'very low thermal power and short operational period'. Each Beehive unit, as NPR describes it, would make 25 megawatts of electricity: at least 250 times the 100 kilowatts of heat Valar's draft safety paper lets Ward 250 run at continuously, and at least 100 times the 250 kilowatts of heat in DOE's description of the reactor.

Open Radiation Exposure →
County transparency

The Planning Commission would decide Valar's county permit. A Valar presentation was added to its October 6 agenda four days out.

Under Carbon County's 2023 Development Code, the Planning Commission's appointed members, named on the County Transparency page, approve or deny the conditional use permit the state's lease memo says Valar needs. On October 2, the notice for their October 6 meeting, posted September 23, was edited to add a Valar presentation. As of that day, no Valar application had appeared in their notices, and no separate notice of the change had been posted on the state's public notice website. Notices for their earlier meetings since June went up 25 to 29 days ahead, and one earlier agenda amendment about 8 days ahead. The edit met Utah's 24-hour minimum and is logged in the notice's public revision history; as on all their agendas since June, no general public comment item is listed.

Open County Transparency →
Taxes

What Valar could mean for Carbon County's budgets and a home's tax bill

If the campus described to the Trust Lands board were built (no county permit application had appeared in the planners' public notices as of October 17, 2026), our model's middle result, with a campus size we estimated from Valar's Emery County figure, gives public budgets millions a year on average over 2027-2046, about $1.22 million of it to county government, before any new county costs, which no record we read estimates. At Utah's default rates, a $215,000 home outside the towns would pay about $22 less in its best year and about $15 more in 2046 than with no Valar (from $56 less to $110 more in most model runs); bills fall by more only if officials choose lower rates. The lease as approved, with nothing built, would bring county government at most about $3,140 a year, or $0 if the lease does not give Valar exclusive possession of the land.

For Carbon residents, on the Taxes page →
Heat

Project Beehive's 456 reactors would make about as much heat as 7 or 8 big U.S. reactors

NPR's figures are electricity: about 9.6 gigawatts, or 456 reactors of 25 megawatts. Reactors make about 2 to 3 times as much heat as electricity, so by our math Beehive would make about 24 or 28.5 gigawatts of heat, one for each NPR figure: about what 7 or 8 big U.S. reactors make (21.3 to 34.5 gigawatts, or 6 to 10 reactors, depending on the unknowns). Its used fuel keeps giving off heat, as all used fuel does: one year's used fuel would still give off about 280 or 330 kilowatts ten years later (220 to 450 depending on the unknowns). In Valar's favor, studies find it gives off less heat for each unit of electricity made than big reactors' used fuel, and our numbers agree unless the reactors turn the least of their heat into electricity. The downside is bulk, because each grain of fuel sits in graphite: for the same electricity, its used fuel would take about 21 times the room of big reactors' used fuel if it is in fuel pebbles (8.5 to 54), or about 19 times if it is in blocks like those DOE cleared for shipment to Ward 250 (12 to 35).

Open the heat section →
The timeline: Valar's website, its moves, and government dealingsDated records in three lanes, each linked to its source. 51 dated records.OpenClose
no public record found from the time, or no name givenpublic meeting or record
Valar’s website
Valar’s moves
Government
2023
2024
2025
2026

Government items carrying the marker had no public record found from the time (no agenda, notice or posting found), or were public without Valar's name; each item gives its date and links its record. 'No public notice found' means none on the state's notice website.

Findings

  1. The reactor's public safety agreement lists different fuel than DOE approved shipping to it.

    Valar's safety agreement for Ward 250 says its fuel is 4.95% enriched uranium, and its public copy did not change from at least November 2025 to late September 2026. DOE's own shipping review approved sending the reactor HALEU fuel, enriched up to 19.9%, and a DOE slide prepared for the NRC Commission's 21 July 2026 meeting describes Ward 250's fuel as '19.75 wt% TRISO'. The agreement is marked 'Draft' and says fuel-design changes will be carried into a later safety analysis; that analysis, which may have been updated, was not found in public records.

  2. The accident math assumes the public stays 400 meters away. The lab it sits on is about 20 acres, as DOE describes it.

    Keeping the public 400 meters back, as that math assumes, would take about 124 acres. No record read says the public is kept off the land beyond the lab. Valar has since bought, or is buying, about 112 acres north of the lab; no record read says whether that covers the 400-meter circle. The 400 meters is the distance Valar's draft safety paper uses for its public-dose math and calls 'the nearest point of public access'; no DOE record read makes it a required boundary, and DOE's review says access is controlled during operations without saying where.

  3. Project Beehive: NPR reports a plan for about 456 reactors on more than 9,000 acres of federal land near Price.

    NPR reported on 30 September 2026, citing a Valar proposal to federal regulators that it reviewed, that the plan also includes data centers, a nuclear fuel facility and places to store nuclear waste, with the first reactors in 2028. BLM told NPR it is reviewing the application for completeness. The proposal itself was not found in public records.

  4. Spent fuel is barred from the leased land, but the deal lets Valar buy part of it for interim spent-fuel storage, if licensed.

    The state's slides told the Trust Lands board that nuclear waste storage is 'strictly prohibited on the lease'. The memo's terms add a purchase route: Valar must first buy any portion it needs for 'interim storage of spent fuel', and that storage would need federal and state licenses. Valar officials have said used fuel from the Carbon County project would first be stored on site in dry, sealed casks under federal licensing, and that a future national storage or disposal option could eventually be used, but no specific long-term disposal site outside the area had been identified (ETV News, 30 September 2026); NPR also reports waste storage at Project Beehive's site, and no written storage plan was found in public records. Whether Utah's limits on high-level nuclear waste reach used fuel stored at a reactor is not settled in any record read.

    How much used fuel that could be, and how strong it stays: Radiation Exposure →

  5. Up to $106.7 million in state tax credits for Valar's Emery County project, payable only if a local incentive is also approved; none has been found.

    The credit is paid only after new state tax revenue comes in, and the board's terms require a local incentive approved by its Incentives Committee. At Emery County's April 7, 2026 hearing, the minutes record that the county had given Valar no incentives and that Valar had not asked for one. The board's agendas named none of its 13 tax-credit applicants from April to September 2026; Valar's was handled the same way.

More findings (6) The rest of what the records show, each with its evidence.
  1. No public copy of the reactor's approved safety analysis was found.

    No approved safety analysis, operating limits, DOE review of them or signed startup approval was found posted, and DOE's occurrence-report database is closed to the public. DOE has said federal teams reviewed contractor safety submittals for the pilot reactors and took part in Ward 250's readiness review before startup; the review documents themselves were not found. A DOE slide prepared for the NRC Commission's 21 July 2026 meeting lists the preliminary safety analysis as approved in February 2026 and the safety analysis as approved on April 23, 2026. Valar, whose unlisted June 2026 draft page calls it 'a very open and transparent company', has published its draft safety design agreement and its quality program; no requirement to post its other safety papers was found.

  2. The safety papers credit prototype tests whose data were not found in public records, and the page titled 'Ward Zero Whitepaper' holds no Ward Zero data.

    Valar's safety agreement credits its non-nuclear prototype, Ward Zero, for key safety points, such as cooling without pumps. No published Ward Zero test data was found. An unlisted page titled 'Ward Zero Whitepaper' contains no Ward Zero data; its text matches a 2019 essay on reactor exports by another author. It may be leftover placeholder text (no Valar statement on it was found), and it was still online in late September 2026.

  3. No NEPA environmental review open to public comment.

    DOE used a 'categorical exclusion': no environmental assessment or impact statement and no comment period on the project. Formal objections to the exclusion itself were filed in March 2026; no DOE response to them was found on its NEPA page as of late September 2026. The exclusion is the environmental (NEPA) step only; DOE's safety approval of the reactor is a separate process.

  4. Local checks: district minutes record a staff report of a sewer tie-in 'without prior authorization', and that the state declined to review the reactor building's fire plans.

    The water district's approved minutes record a staff report that Valar 'tied into the county sewer system without prior authorization' and that its sewer plans 'were not submitted to the State as required'; the request was for restrooms only. No Valar response or later resolution appears in the record read. For the reactor building's fire-code review, the fire district's minutes say state agencies declined to review the plans and recommended a third-party review, and that the county lacked a fire inspector. The March minutes say it 'has been addressed with chiefs and is not currently a concern', not how.

  5. A lease of up to a century for a nuclear campus north of Wellington; its bid notice and first state posting did not say 'nuclear'.

    The state's bid notice and its April posting for agency comment named neither Valar nor a nuclear use; the board packets for the August and September board meetings did. Carbon's commissioners signed a support letter; how it was approved is not in the records read. The board meetings were in Salt Lake City, with online attendance possible, and no comment opposing the lease was recorded.

  6. A mining claim two miles from the approved lease site, where the only nearby mineral records are gravel pits and a carbon dioxide field.

    A Notice of Location names Valar Atomics Inc as locator of the RW 453 lode claim (12 Sept 2026). Public mineral records for the area list only sand-and-gravel pits and a carbon dioxide field; a claimant may know of a mineral showing those records do not list. The county and BLM filings due in October and December may show more.

What holds up: DOE did authorize the reactor, DOE says federal teams reviewed its readiness before startup, it reached criticality on 18 June 2026 (ahead of the 4 July goal), a DOE slide prepared for the NRC Commission's 21 July 2026 meeting lists full power, 100 kWt, on 2 July 2026 (the slide gives no data), it was flown in without fuel, DOE checked the fuel's shipping package, and DOE says the fuel type, TRISO, is 'more resistant to neutron irradiation, corrosion, oxidation and high temperatures' than traditional reactor fuels. And a Valar plan for a Carbon County manufacturing hub was in the local paper in October 2025, though no local record read from before the state's vote tied Valar to the site. safe-039 loc-034 dir-031 orig-010 plan-006

About these records

Public records change. Agencies update their databases, move pages, restrict access and take documents down, often without notice. Every item on this site is as accurate as the public record allowed on the date shown with it, and every line links to the record it rests on.

We keep saved copies of the sources we read. When a record we cite changes, moves, becomes harder to reach or disappears, we note it on that item rather than quietly rewriting it.

If a fact or a calculation here is shown to be wrong, we correct it and say what changed and when. Every calculation shows its inputs and its steps, so anyone can check the work.

When a check is found to be incorrect via sources and evidence that concretely refute it, a correction will be posted.

This is an independent fact-check of public records. It is not legal, tax or financial advice.

Every correction, with what changed and when →