Corrections
Every correction made to this site: what was wrong, what it says now, and when.
When a fact or a calculation on this site is shown to be wrong after it is published, it is corrected on the record itself and listed here: what it said, what it says now, and when. Records that only gained detail or a newer source are not listed. To report an error, see the About page.
2026-10-18
Was: A record said Orangeville's minutes record that Valar's Harry Hanson spoke at the 10 September open house.
Now: The minutes record, under a heading about the open house, that 'Harry Hanson spoke', and list a Harry Hanson among that council meeting's visitors; they do not say where he spoke. The record now says exactly that.
Where: Local
Records: loc-001
2026-10-17
Was: Two records said Valar's head of projects first came to Utah and to Carbon County in 2024.
Now: Valar's own public accounts give two years: 2024, at the Trust Lands board on 20 August 2026, and early 2025, in later public remarks, including at the Carbon County Planning Commission on 6 October 2026. The records now give both years and say the records do not settle which is right.
Where: Carbon site; Local; People; Process
2026-10-17
Was: A Claims vs Record entry said DOE had confirmed only Ward 250's criticality, and that full power and electricity rested on Valar's account alone.
Now: A DOE Office of Nuclear Energy slide prepared for the NRC Commission's 21 July 2026 meeting lists full power of 100 kWt on 2 July 2026, with electricity generation. The entry now gives that date beside DOE's release on the zero-power criticality, and says the slide gives no data or source for the line.
Where: Claims vs Record
2026-10-17
Was: A record said KUTV reported Valar's CEO making his 'if the community doesn't want us here' remark in answer to a commissioner, and credited the room's applause to the county's recording.
Now: KUTV's report does not say the remark answered a commissioner. The record now says KUTV attributed the words to the CEO and reported that the room erupted in clapping, and cites the county's recording for the words alone.
Where: Local
Records: pcm-001
2026-10-17
Was: A Claims vs Record entry said the date of each of Ward 250's DOE approvals rested on Valar's word.
Now: A DOE Office of Nuclear Energy slide prepared for the NRC Commission's 21 July 2026 meeting lists the dates of the two safety-analysis approvals (February 2026 and 23 April 2026), matching what Valar said. The entry now says so; the dates of the other approvals still rest on Valar's word.
Where: Claims vs Record
2026-10-12
Was: A record said no source tied Ward 250 to Ward One, and the CT-scan check called Ward 250 a different reactor.
Now: At its September 29, 2026 town hall Valar said Ward One was renamed Ward 250 when the executive order came out. The records now give that statement beside Valar's 2025 account of a Philippine test, and a new record (rnm-001) holds it. The CT-scan check's numbers are unchanged: they already used Ward 250's figures.
Where: Radiation and safety proofs
2026-10-05
Was: The timeline said Valar posted its $1 billion Series B on 3 August 2026. A record's headline said BLM's records show three pending Valar land applications 'in its Price office'. A record's detail said all three were in BLM's Price Field Office.
Now: Valar announced the round on 3 August, as TechCrunch reported, and its website post is dated 4 August; the timeline now says so. The headline says two of the three are in BLM's Price office: the saved records give the field office only for the two named cases.
Found in a final review of quotes and citations against Valar's post and BLM's saved case records.
Where: Main page (timeline); Mining Claims; Carbon County Site; Radiation Exposure page; Take Action
2026-10-05
Was: The Taxes page said the state lab's director was reported saying Valar planned a manufacturing hub in Carbon County. A record said Carbon County's commissioners called Valar a partner 'since the beginning' and praised it for 'not hiding anything'. A fire-review record stated as fact that the State Fire Marshal declined and that the county has no fire inspector. A Claims vs Record title gave the same phrase to 'Officials'.
Now: ETV News reported the manufacturing-hub plan in its own words, not the director's, and the page now says so. Both quoted phrases are Commissioner Jared Haddock's; the letter all three signed says the county had worked with Valar for over a year. The fire-review statements are attributed to the fire district's minutes, their only source.
Found in a final review of language and attribution against the ETV article, the 20 August 2026 Trust Lands transcript and minutes, and the fire district's minutes.
Where: Taxes page; People; Carbon County Site; Carbon & Emery; Safety Related Issues; Main page; County Transparency; Claims vs Record; Valar Transparency
2026-10-05
Was: Some statements of law said more than the law does: that agendas must say what will be decided and that every board must post minutes within 30 days; that a mining claim is only a right to dig; that a claimant must file with the county and BLM every year; that Utah's 2026 law exempts test-reactor waste, without its limits; that any reactor selling power needs an NRC license; and that 1 mSv a year is the most a licensed operation may add to a member of the public's dose.
Now: Agendas must give the topics with reasonable specificity; the 30-day rule covers state bodies and county commissions, other boards within a reasonable time, and an emergency meeting is the exception to the bar on acting off-agenda. A claim also allows processing and uses reasonably incident to mining. A yearly fee paid to BLM replaces the yearly filings. The waste exemption covers only interim storage from a DOE-authorized test reactor at a state-owned, state-licensed facility. The executive order covers reactors that produce no commercial power, and the NRC licenses demonstration reactors run as part of a utility's power system. The NRC may approve up to 5 mSv a year.
Found in a final review of every statement of law against the saved text of Utah Code 52-4-202 and 52-4-203, 30 U.S.C. 612 and 28f, Utah Code 19-3-321, Executive Order 14301, 42 U.S.C. 5842 and 10 CFR 20.1301.
Where: Take Action; Public Process; Mining Claims; Carbon County Site; Safety Related Issues; Plans & Sites; Radiation Exposure page; Their claims, annotated; Connections to Government
2026-10-05
Was: Three places left out records in Valar's favor: the entry on Valar's CT-scan sentence did not mention this site's own check of it; the emergency-planning entries compared Valar's request only with big power plants; and a record called a newspaper's '100 kilowatts of electricity' wrong without giving DOE's 250-kilowatt figure.
Now: The CT-scan entry and explainer say the site's check finds the sentence can hold for part of the fuel, or for all of it after about 10 to 130 days of cooling, but not for all of it a day after shutdown. The emergency entries give the NRC rule for small, non-water-cooled and research reactors (10 CFR 50.33(g)(2)). The newspaper record gives DOE's 250 kW thermal figure and Valar's own account of electricity at the July 1 event.
Found in a final review of fairness: every Claims vs Record entry and every record about Valar's claims was read against the records that favor the company.
Where: Claims vs Record; Safety Related Issues; Explainers; Origins; Carbon & Emery; Plans & Sites; Their claims, annotated
2026-10-05
Was: The key under the Project Beehive outline on the region and Price maps and on the handout's map said 'NPR, Sept. 30, 2026: more than 9,500 acres, over 9,000 of them BLM land'; no record this site keeps gives the 9,500 figure (no copy of NPR's article is kept), and the maps page itself gave only 'over 9,000 acres of BLM land'. The maps page said every outline is drawn from official boundary data, though the Beehive outline is traced from NPR's map. The Wellington map's label and the RW 453 entries said the claim land is zoned rural residential, though about 37% of it is federal land, which Utah's county land-use law does not put under county jurisdiction.
Now: The key says 'NPR, Sept. 30, 2026: over 9,000 acres of BLM land', and its heading gives the outline's 9,700 acres 'as drawn'. The maps page says the Beehive outline is traced approximately from NPR's map. The label and entries say the county zoning map shows the land as rural residential, and that about 37% of it is federal land.
Found in a final review of the maps' printed keys and labels against the records.
Where: Maps; Mining Claims; Carbon County Site; Handout
Records: dir-013
2026-10-05
Was: A record said Carbon County must approve a conditional use permit before anything is built on the Wellington parcel; only the state's lease memo says so. The claims entry on the RW 453 notice said a lode notice 'amounts to a statement that a vein was found', and it and the front page said the October and December filings 'will state what is claimed'. A mining-claim summary said no claimant may build on a claim without BLM's approval, leaving out the rule's 14-days-in-90 limit; another described the claim-notice crime without the law's 'intentionally or knowingly'. A record gave 'the county had no nuclear standards' as the reason no county land-use review of the reactor was found, and called some local steps 'taken quickly'. A record said Emery County's land sale 'followed state law', a conclusion no cited record makes. A record argued that 'the public was first told about a small, short test' without noting Valar's early talk of commercial deployment and 'gigasites'. A claims entry set the lab director's words against the agreement's confidentiality clause without saying that no record read shows anything withheld under it.
Now: The county-permit requirement is attributed to the state's lease memo. The claims entry says what the law requires before a location, and that the filings 'may show more'. The summaries follow 43 CFR 3715 (more than 14 days in 90; BLM's concurrence) and Utah Code 40-1-11. The lab-review record gives the state-land rule instead of a cause and drops 'taken quickly'. The sale record describes the route the county used. The record notes Valar's early talk of commercial deployment and 'gigasites'. The claims entry says no record read shows what, if anything, was withheld.
Found in a final review of language, law and fairness.
Where: Main page; Carbon County Site; Carbon & Emery; Public Process; Connections to Government; Mining Claims; Claims vs Record; Their claims, annotated
Records: csite-012, mine-023, dir-004, loc-030, gov-022, mine-019
2026-10-05
Was: A record's headline counted 'one lease' and 'one unbuilt abroad' among Valar's sites; no cited record shows a site abroad, and the lease was approved but not shown signed. A record said Ward One was still unbuilt in the Philippines as of April 2026, which its cited sources cannot show. A founding record said the legal entity was confirmed as a Delaware corporation, which none of its published sources shows. A Claims vs Record entry said Valar reached full power by 24 June, a date no source on that line gives. Records, the maps page, the handout and Take Action said nothing had been built at the Carbon County site, which no cited record says.
Now: The headline counts U.S. sites: one test reactor, one approved lease, three pending BLM files. The Ward One record says Valar's post describes building and testing it in the Philippines. The founding record drops the Delaware line. The entry says Valar's Castle Country page reports full power days after criticality. The pages say all required permits must come before any construction, as the state's lease memo says.
Found in a final review of every statement against the sources its record cites.
Where: Plans & Sites; Origins; People; Claims vs Record; Maps; Handout; Take Action; Carbon County Site
2026-10-05
Was: A record said Carbon commissioners called Ward 250 a 'commercial reactor'; that word is in ETV's own narration, and the commission's minutes do not record it. Pages called the Trust Lands board's August and September meetings 'hearings', though both were regular board meetings, and described a Valar employee only as 'one speaker from Emery County'. A record said the notice rules 'kept' Valar's name and plan out of the first notices; the rule allows the omission but does not require it. The front page and a record said Valar 'calls itself very open and transparent' without saying the words are from an unlisted draft page.
Now: ETV's report, not the commissioners, is credited with 'commercial reactor'. The pages say 'board meetings', and the speaker is described as a Valar employee who spoke for the lease. The record says that under those rules the first notices named neither the company nor a nuclear use. The self-description is credited to Valar's unlisted June 2026 draft page, and the front page adds that no requirement to post its other safety papers was found.
Found in a final review read as Valar's counsel, county and state officials, and a local reporter would read it.
Where: Main page; County Transparency; Carbon County Site; Carbon & Emery; Take Action; Valar Transparency
2026-10-04
Was: Five figures were rounded twice or cut short: '8 to 33 times' a CT scan's top dose for Ward One's used fuel; a hand dose of '84 to 600 times' and '0.52 to 4.2 times' a radiation worker's yearly limit; 'about 129 days' for the pebble's hand dose to fall to 10 mSv; and '10,270 acres' for Valar's Green River application.
Now: 7.5 to 33 times; 84 to 610 times and 0.51 to 4.2 times; about 128 days; 10,271 acres.
Found in a final review of the numbers: rounded once from the model's own values (74.57 mSv, 606.8 and 0.5148 times, 128.47 days) and from BLM's 10,270.61 acres.
Where: Evidence: CT scan proof; Radiation Exposure page; Main page; Take Action; Mining Claims; Carbon & Emery; Maps
2026-10-04
Was: Two map labels said more than the records show: the Wellington map labeled the lease '640 acres; 480 in the first phase', and the Orangeville map's title called the parcel next to the lab 'Valar's land'. The Green River caption said BLM's case map 'shades whole sections', which read as the reason its red area is larger than BLM's 10,270.61 acres.
Now: The lease label says 480 acres were approved, 640 if the National Guard lease moves; the Orangeville title says the land next to the lab was approved for sale to Valar (the records disagree on whether the sale closed); the caption says the case map shades only some sections whole and that BLM's record does not say how its acreage was counted.
Found in a final review of the maps against the Trust Lands memo, the Emery County records and BLM's case map.
Where: Maps
2026-10-04
Was: The Taxes page's 2025 breakdown of property taxes charged in Carbon listed general county, schools and special districts, which do not add to the $33,962,354 total beside them. A funding record counted 'six funding rounds'. A check note on four state site-study permits said 'four comment letters'.
Now: The breakdown includes cities and towns ($2,505,320), so its parts add to the total (to within $1, as the Tax Commission's table prints them). The funding record says 'its funding rounds' (the six counted a loan). The check note says three comment letters (permits 7674, 7675 and 7676).
Found in a final review of the numbers against the Tax Commission's Table 2F, the funding records and the permit files.
Where: Taxes page; Funding; Mining Claims
2026-10-03
Was: Table rows 'One Ward 250 compact' (353 mSv whole-body a day after removal) and 'Ward 250-type block' (81 years to cool to one CT scan) read as figures for the fuel in Valar's Ward 250 test reactor. The pages also said 'The fuel in Valar's Ward 250 test reactor', that the reactor 'uses graphite fuel blocks', and that its fuel is 'pressed into small pellets', though no public record found says which fuel, or in what form, is actually loaded in the reactor.
Now: Those rows are labeled as Ward 250-size or Ward 250-type fuel used in a power reactor, which is what the calculation assumes (like Beehive's). Ward 250's own fuel is used far less: DOE says less than 1% of its fissile material is consumed and describes its fission-product inventory as 'orders of magnitude below that of commercial power reactors'. Where the pages described the reactor's fuel as fact, they now describe the fuel DOE cleared for shipment to it.
Found in a review of the radiation figures: the calculation burns these pieces like power-reactor fuel, about 760 to 14,000 times Ward 250's planned burnup.
Where: Radiation Exposure page; Evidence: Beehive proof; Claims vs Record
2026-10-03
Was: DOE's categorical exclusion was paraphrased as saying its 'approved safety analysis' keeps offsite doses 'well below DOE guidelines'.
Now: It now follows DOE's wording, including the EPA part: DOE says the Documented Safety Analysis shows calculated offsite doses 'well below DOE evaluation guidelines and EPA Protective Action Guide thresholds' under bounding accident conditions, and, in its summary of overall impacts, that 'Off-site radiological doses are insignificant compared to natural background.' The thyroid-dose estimate now carries DOE's statement and the draft paper's figure for the nearest residence.
Found in a review of the radiation figures: the paraphrase left out the EPA part, and the determination does not call the safety analysis 'approved'.
2026-10-03
Was: The front page said 'Keeping everyone 400 meters back', as if 400 meters were a requirement rather than the distance Valar's draft math assumes. Three sentences put Valar's dose argument at a fence (emergency planning that can 'stop at its own fence'; a worst case that 'stays small beyond the fence'; 'the dose at the fence'), though Valar's paper calculates those doses at a 400-meter site boundary. One sentence offered only two explanations for the gap between the circle and the lab.
Now: The front page says 400 meters is the distance Valar's draft safety math assumes. The fence references now speak of the 400-meter site boundary or of Valar's own term, 'on-site response'. The 400-meter fact adds a third explanation (the final safety analysis may use a different boundary) and notes that DOE's determination says 'No expansion of site boundaries occurs.'
Found in a review of the 400-meter finding: Valar's paper calculates doses at a 400-meter site boundary, while DOE describes a fenced area of about 2 acres.
Where: Main page; Claims vs Record
2026-10-03
Was: Title: '8 to 33 times a CT scan's top dose a day after shutdown, not one'. Summary: 'Where Valar left things out, we picked the choice that helps Valar, and we show the whole range', and Valar's sentence 'only matches in a special case Valar never described'.
Now: The title says the figure is for all of Ward One's used fuel one day after shutdown, and that a small piece, or fuel cooled for weeks to months, stays under one scan. The summary says which choices favor Valar and when Valar's sentence would hold: for part of the fuel one day after shutdown, for all of it only after weeks to months of cooling, or only if the reactor ran no more than about two hours at full power.
Found in a review of the radiation figures: the headline rested on the whole-core reading without saying so.
Where: Evidence: CT scan proof
2026-10-03
Was: 'Two models were built independently ... matching each within 0.1% and 2.1%.'
Now: The two independent models' middle results for the campus differed ($3.05 million and $5.29 million a year), mostly because one treated Valar's Emery County figure as the most likely capital, which no record read supports. One rebuilt model, run on each model's own settings, reproduced each result, which checks the arithmetic, not the assumed ranges.
Found in a review of the tax model.
Where: Taxes page
2026-10-03
Was: The 'Hundreds of reactors' scenario: 'nothing in the record ties it to Carbon.'
Now: It is shown for scale, apart from the campus scenario. The page now notes that the local paper reported Valar's founder aiming for hundreds of reactors in Carbon and Emery, and that NPR reports a plan for about 456 small reactors near Price whose outline, as this site traced it from NPR's map (approximately), takes in the state section that holds the lease, though NPR's text describes BLM land.
Found in a review of the tax model: the site's own records contradicted the sentence.
Where: Taxes page
2026-10-03
Was: The front page gave a home's 2046 change as 'about $15 more' with no range and did not say the campus size is our estimate. The Taxes page said 'every possibility is shown' and 'Every number on this page is worked out from these public records.', with no mention of assumptions, and labeled the county's gain 'Of that', as if it were part of Valar's tax.
Now: The range ($56 less to $110 more, which includes no change) and the estimated campus size appear with the figures. The page says its numbers come from public records and stated assumptions, shows several cases and ranges, notes that the campus scenario has no separate allowance for data-center computing, and no longer labels the county's gain 'Of that'.
Found in a review of the tax model.
Where: Main page; Taxes page
2026-10-03
Was: Commissioner Haddock's figure was shown as $1,000,000,000 of taxable value lost over a decade.
Now: The amount now carries the label 'roughly, as ETV reported it' and is set beside the Tax Commission tables: centrally assessed value down about $243 million from 2015 to 2025 and $879 million from 2008 to 2025, while total taxable value rose over both periods, plus the $48 million drop in 2026 recorded in the county's minutes.
Found in a review of the tax model: a rounded figure from a news report looked exact.
Where: Carbon & Emery; Carbon County Site; People; Public Process
Records: loc-002
2026-10-03
Was: Some short labels gave the credit as 'Valar's $106.7 million tax credit', 'Valar's $106.7 million state tax credit', 'The $106.7 million tax credit in the news' or '$106.7M tax credit', without 'up to'. The front-page finding did not say it is for Valar's Emery County project, and one Take Action sentence said neither that nor that it is paid only from new state tax revenue.
Now: The labels now give the credit as up to $106.7 million. The front-page finding names Valar's Emery County project, the timeline label names the Emery project, and the Take Action sentence names the project and says the credit is paid only from new state tax revenue after it comes in.
Found in a review of every page that mentions the credit.
Where: Main page; Take Action; Valar Transparency; Taxes page
Records: csite-024
2026-10-03
Was: The homeowners'-share chart caption, a note on the commissioners' letter and the Utah Code 59-2-919 summary named only 2020 as a year the county adopted a rate above its certified rate, and the discussion of the commissioners' letter called 0.002495 the county's 'general levy'.
Now: All three now also name 2017, when the county adopted its main county levy above its certified rate (0.003355 against 0.003078) and the Municipal Services Fund slightly above; the chart caption and the note now also name 2024, when both were set slightly below; 0.002495 is labeled the county's general and health levy. A new chart shows the county's own rates from 2012 to 2025.
Found in a review of the State's yearly tax-rate reports, read twice independently.
Where: Taxes page