VALAR WATCHTake action

By their accounts, officials talked with Valar about Carbon County from 2024 or early 2025; the first public agenda found naming Valar for the Wellington site is from Aug 2026

analysisconfirmed
2024 · ppl-027 · Max Ukropina, Jared Haddock, Carbon County Commission, Utah Office of Energy Development, Governor's Office of Economic Opportunity, Southeastern Regional Development Agency, Utah Trust Lands Administration, Valar Atomics

Testing whether the public knew, against what the people involved have said on the record. Officials and Valar: Valar's Max Ukropina told the Trust Lands board that in 2024 he met the Office of Energy Development, the Governor's economic office, SERDA and Carbon County (ppl-006, mine-018); Carbon County's minutes of 19 August 2026, summarising Valar's presentation, say they 'relocated to the region from California two years ago'; the state energy office's MOU with Valar, naming Ukropina, was signed on 16 May 2025 (gov-011); Commissioner Jared Haddock said the county worked with Valar 'since the beginning, when they were looking at other states' (ppl-020); the county's 29 June 2026 letter says the county had worked with Valar for over a year (mine-013); Carbon's October 2024 minutes note that Commissioner Martines phoned in while traveling home from a trip to Idaho National Laboratory connected with the San Rafael lab; no mention of Valar was found in those minutes (csite-026). The New Republic reports that before the May 2025 executive orders Valar staff were exploring land in southern Utah for a first 'gigasite', and the lab director says a contract followed about two weeks after Valar said it wanted to build at the lab; in July 2025 the state called its agreement a non-binding MOU (ppl-018). Public: the state's lease map is dated 9 April 2026 (mine-048); the 20 April 2026 state notice called it an unnamed industrial and power project (csite-032); the first public agenda found naming Valar for the site is dated 10 August 2026 (csite-018); the first ETV News report of the lease that was found came on 18 September, the day after approval (mine-011). Finding: by the officials' and Valar's own accounts, county, state-agency and regional officials were in contact with Valar about Carbon County from 2024 or early 2025 (Ukropina gave 2024 to the Trust Lands board; at the Carbon County Planning Commission on 6 October 2026 a Valar speaker introduced as Max put the company's first arrival in Carbon County in early 2025), and in any case more than a year before a public agenda named Valar for the site (the county's 29 June 2026 letter says it had worked with Valar for over a year). The 2024 contacts, as Ukropina described them, concerned making fuels from coal-plant flue gas; when the Wellington parcel itself entered the talks is not settled by the records read (Ukropina's line in the auto-transcript, 'the first property I looked at was actually property', is garbled, mine-018; the state's lease map is dated 9 April 2026; the county's 29 June 2026 letter says it had worked with Valar for over a year). This is a gap in time before public notice, not proof of any intent, and the board's notices met the meeting law's timing (csite-016); no record of what was said in those 2024-2026 contacts was found in public records.

In plain termsBy their own statements, Carbon County's commissioners and several state offices had been talking with Valar since 2024 or early 2025 (Valar's own accounts give both years), at first, by Valar's account, about making fuels from coal-plant exhaust. The Wellington parcel shows up in state records from April 2026 (a lease map), but the first public record found attaching Valar's name to it was an August 2026 meeting notice, about five weeks before the vote. The emails and meeting notes from that period would show what was discussed, and they can be requested.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read the 20 Aug auto-transcript (Ukropina; Haddock), TNR (delivered part) and UIJP; quotes exact. Fixed: the finding said officials 'knew of Valar's interest in Carbon County' for two years; the record shows contact from 2024, first about coal flue-gas fuels, while the Wellington parcel appears in public-agency records only from April 2026 (map) and by name in August 2026. Plain's 'The people in charge knew' removed. Cross-refs mine-013, mine-018, mine-041, mine-048, csite-018, csite-026, csite-032 checked. Quote marks removed from wording taken from the county letter and minutes (mine-013, csite-026), which were not re-opened in this check; the substance rests on those facts. Corrected in late September 2026: the closing sentence on intent shortened to 'not proof of any intent'. Corrected 2026-09-30: the October 2024 county minutes record only that Commissioner Martines phoned in while traveling home from Idaho National Laboratory. Corrected 17 October 2026: Corrected 17 October 2026: Valar's own accounts give 2024 or early 2025 for the first contacts, not 2024 alone. Corrected 17 October 2026: Valar's own accounts give 2024 or early 2025 for the first contacts, not 2024 alone. Corrected 17 October 2026: Valar's own accounts give 2024 or early 2025 for the first contacts, not 2024 alone. Corrected 17 October 2026: the year talks began is given as 2024 or early 2025, since Valar's own accounts give both.

Code: ppl-027 · short link: valarwatch.com/ppl-027

In tabs: People, Carbon County Site, Public Process, Timeline