The printed handout, with the source for every line: each small number matches the source list at the end.
Valar Atomics in Carbon & Emery: What the Public Record Shows
An independent fact-check. Not from Valar or any agency. Public records as of Oct 2, 2026; meeting dates as of Oct 17, 2026.
WEBSITE: valarwatch.com (QR code on the back)
What is happening
- Valar runs a test reactor, Ward 250, at the state lab near Orangeville. The U.S. Department of Energy authorized it; the Nuclear Regulatory Commission did not license it.1,2
- On Sept 17 the state approved leasing Valar 480 acres, up to 640, five miles north of Wellington, for a nuclear campus. Before any construction, Valar must obtain all required permits, and no county permit application appeared in the planners' public notices as of Oct 17, 2026.3,4,5
- A Notice of Location puts Valar on a mining claim, RW 453, two miles south of that land.6
The lawsuit, and Orangeville
- In late 2024, the states of Utah and Texas and a nuclear startup sued the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, the federal agency that licenses reactors. As Valar describes it, they argue small reactors should not need its license, and states should oversee them instead. Valar joined in 2025. The court paused the case that year for settlement talks; in January 2026 the NRC reported it still on hold, and a copy of the court record lists a joint status report filed Sept 2, 2026, with no settlement or dismissal shown.7,8,9,10
- Orangeville is not part of the lawsuit. In July the city was writing a nuclear zone so land next to the lab, 112 acres the county agreed to sell to Valar, could join the city; the city's draft minutes of Sept 10 record that the annexation has been held up over mineral rights and that the city is waiting for the purchase to be finalized.11,12,13,14,15
What the records show
- Fuel: Valar's only public safety agreement lists 4.95% uranium. DOE cleared fuel up to 19.9% for shipment to the reactor; a DOE slide for a July 2026 NRC meeting lists the fuel as '19.75 wt% TRISO'.16,17
- Safety papers: no public copy of the approved safety analysis, operating limits or startup approval was found. DOE says federal teams reviewed readiness before startup (July 2026).18,19
- Emergencies: Valar asked DOE for an on-site emergency plan only. City minutes put Orangeville's ambulance availability at 13% in June 2026.1,11,20
- No environmental assessment: DOE used a NEPA 'categorical exclusion', with no public comment period. It is an environmental step, separate from DOE's safety approval.18
- The quarter-mile line: Valar's accident math assumes the public stays 400 meters away. That circle is 124 acres; the lab site is 20.6. No DOE record read sets 400 meters as a required boundary.1,18
Where residents can take part
County Commission: first and third Wednesdays, 4:30 PM, 751 E 100 N, Price, in person only. Its Oct 7 agenda (posted Oct 5) lists no Valar item and no public comment item; next expected Wed Oct 21 (not yet noticed as of Oct 17). Planning Commission: usually first Tuesdays, 4:30 PM, same place; next regular meeting Nov 10. Agendas: utah.gov/pmn.4,21,22,23
- Oct 6: the county planners heard a Valar presentation, with no public comment taken; a Valar speaker said its plan would be submitted at the end of October. Ask the county in writing for a public hearing on Valar's permit.23,24
- Carbon's planners are drafting rules for 'highly contested industries', and the zoning administrator would like a public hearing in November (the only hearing noticed for Nov 10, as of Oct 17, 2026, is on a zone change for part of one parcel); the minutes do not say whether nuclear plants or Valar's campus are in view.4,25
- The state's lease memo says the county permit for Valar's Wellington campus requires notice and a public hearing; state law does not require a hearing, and the conditional-use chapter of the county code's 2023 edition does not require one either; ask the county which applies. Records requests are ready to send on the website.5,26,27
Fair to say
- DOE authorized Ward 250, it reached criticality on June 18, 2026, and DOE says federal teams reviewed its readiness before startup. None of this shows the reactor is unsafe; it shows what the public cannot check.2,19
Scan to open the websitevalarwatch.comMaps, the source for every line of this sheet, and ready-to-send records requests.

Around Price and Wellington, numbered as on the site's full map. 1: Project Beehive, outline traced from NPR's map (approximate). 2: the lease approved for Valar (Section 16). 3: the RW 453 claim area. 4: the Jurassic Spark parcels (no record read links them to Valar). 7: a state permit application; no record read names its applicant. Not a survey.3,6,24,28,29,30
Sources
1. Ward250 Nuclear Safety Design Agreement, No. 100403, Rev 02 (status: Draft; issued for Public Release), Valar Atomics https://assets.tina.io/4215523c-c18f-4dfd-be97-5dd4e7a42d77/Public%20Documents/%5B100403%5D%5B02%5D%20Ward250%20Nuclear%20Safety%20Design%20Agreement%2002.pdf
2. Department of Energy Celebrates Second Advanced Reactor Achieving Criticality, U.S. Department of Energy https://www.energy.gov/articles/department-energy-celebrates-second-advanced-reactor-achieving-criticality
3. 09.17.2026 TLA Board of Trustees Meeting Audio Transcript (auto-generated), Utah Trust Lands Administration (Utah Public Notice Website) https://www.utah.gov/pmn/files/1492511.pdf
4. Carbon County Planning Commission: notices (May 5 to Oct 6, 2026), Utah Public Notice Website https://www.utah.gov/pmn/sitemap/publicbody/1652.html
5. 09.17.2026 TLA Board Packet (Item 10A: SULA 2095-OBA memorandum, Carbon County letter, lease map), Utah Trust Lands Administration (Utah Public Notice Website) https://www.utah.gov/pmn/files/1488167.pdf
6. Utah Code Title 40, Chapter 1, Mining Claims (40-1-1 to 40-1-12), Utah State Legislature https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title40/Chapter1/C40-1_1800010118000101.pdf
7. Valar Atomics is Suing the NRC (The Nuclear Necessity and our decision to sue the NRC), Valar Atomics (Isaiah Taylor) https://www.valaratomics.com/docs/Valar-Atomics-is-Suing-the-NRC
8. Litigation Status Report (as of January 27, 2026), ADAMS ML26028A093, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission https://www.nrc.gov/docs/ML2602/ML26028A093.pdf
9. NRC lawsuit could hand states power over advanced reactors, E&E News by POLITICO https://www.eenews.net/articles/nrc-lawsuit-could-hand-states-power-over-advanced-reactors/
10. State of Texas et al v. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (6:24-cv-00507), Texas Eastern District Court, PacerMonitor (copy of PACER docket) https://www.pacermonitor.com/public/case/56345846/State_of_Texas_et_al_v_US_Nuclear_Regulatory_Commission
11. July 9, 2026 City Council Meeting Minutes (Orangeville), Orangeville City https://www.utah.gov/pmn/files/1474921.pdf
12. Emery County Commission Meeting Minutes, January 20, 2026, Emery County Commission (Utah Public Notice Website) https://www.utah.gov/pmn/files/1387463.docx
13. Emery County Commission Meeting Minutes, May 19, 2026, Emery County Commission (Utah Public Notice Website) https://www.utah.gov/pmn/files/1445015.docx
14. Castle Country Project Area Plan & Budget Amendment #3, Utah Inland Port Authority https://www.utah.gov/pmn/files/1440133.pdf
15. September 11, 2025 City Council Minutes (Orangeville; notice text), Orangeville City https://www.utah.gov/pmn/sitemap/notice/1029477.html
16. Safety Evaluation Report, Letter Amendment of Certificate of Compliance No. 9979 for the Model 9979 Package, Docket 26-35-9979, U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Packaging and Transportation (Packaging Certification Program) https://rampac.energy.gov/docs/default-source/doeserps/9979SER-R20-LA1.pdf
17. Ward250 Nuclear Safety Design Agreement, No. 100403 Rev 02: Internet Archive copy of 7 Nov 2025, Valar Atomics (via Internet Archive) https://web.archive.org/web/20251107214356/https://assets.tina.io/4215523c-c18f-4dfd-be97-5dd4e7a42d77/Public%20Documents/%5B100403%5D%5B02%5D%20Ward250%20Nuclear%20Safety%20Design%20Agreement%2002.pdf
18. NEPA Determination DOE-ID-26-005: Valar Ward250 Research Reactor (categorical exclusion B5.26), U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Nuclear Energy (Idaho) https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2026-06/CX-271015.pdf
19. EM Specialists Help DOE Achieve Criticality Milestones for Advanced Reactors, U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Environmental Management https://www.energy.gov/em/articles/em-specialists-help-doe-achieve-criticality-milestones-advanced-reactors
20. Orangeville City Council approves resolutions, discusses EMS and Valar (Kevin Butler), ETV News https://etvnews.com/articles/community/orangeville-city-council-approves-resolutions-discusses-ems-and-valar/
21. Carbon County Board of Commissioners: notices (June to October 2026), Utah Public Notice Website https://www.utah.gov/pmn/sitemap/publicbody/1148.html
22. Carbon County Commission Meeting, October 7, 2026 (notice and agenda, posted October 5, 2026), Utah Public Notice Website https://www.utah.gov/pmn/sitemap/notice/1112913.html
23. Carbon County Planning Commission, October 6, 2026: audio recording of the meeting (posted October 7, 2026), Carbon County Planning Commission (Utah Public Notice Website) https://www.utah.gov/pmn/files/1498213.MP3
24. Carbon County Planning Commission Regular Meeting, October 6, 2026 (notice; amended agenda, last edited October 2, 2026 08:49 AM), Utah Public Notice Website https://www.utah.gov/pmn/sitemap/notice/1110647.html
25. 2026-08-04 AUG MINUTES-SIGNED (Carbon County Planning Commission; scanned), Carbon County Planning Commission (Utah Public Notice Website) https://www.utah.gov/pmn/files/1483263.pdf
26. Carbon County Development Code on the county's code site; its download gives the 2023 edition, dated 8/28/23 (sections 5.1 and 5.3, conditional uses), Carbon County, Utah (civiclinQ code hosting) https://hosting.civiclinq.com/carboncounty/books/development-code/preface
27. OPRO Conditional Uses, Utah Department of Commerce, Office of the Property Rights Ombudsman https://commerce.utah.gov/propertyrights/find-the-law/legal-topics/conditional-uses/
28. BLM National MLRS Land Use Authorizations - Rights-of-Way (records for Valar Atomics), U.S. Bureau of Land Management https://gis.blm.gov/nlsdb/rest/services/HUB/BLM_Natl_MLRS_LUA_ROW/FeatureServer/0
29. Right of Entry No. 7674 - Geotechnical Survey (permit map), Utah Trust Lands Administration (via the RDCC project register) https://maps.publiclands.utah.gov/server/rest/services/RDCC/RDCC_Project_Public_View/FeatureServer/0/556503/attachments/204254
30. A startup wants to build a massive nuclear-powered data center on public land in Utah, NPR https://www.npr.org/2026/09/30/nx-s1-5983482/valar-atomic-nuclear-data-center-project-beehive-utah
Independent fact-check from public records; not affiliated with Valar Atomics or any agency. The source for every line: valarwatch.com/handout | valarwatch@proton.me