VALAR WATCHTake action

Public Process

What was made public, when, where and by whom (notices, hearings, votes, filings, comment periods), and what the rules would expect that was not found.

recordconfirmed Truth in taxation: certified rates leave out new growth; from 2027 new structures without residential or commercial building area stop counting as new growth; 7% of state-assessed new-growth tax goes to the State
2026 · ptax-006 · Utah State Legislature, Utah Division of Finance

Utah Code 59-2-924 (Title 59 Chapter 2 Part 9 PDF). In the version in force in 2026 (superseded 1 January 2027): a 'certified tax rate' is a rate that will provide the same ad valorem property tax revenue for a taxing entity as it budgeted for the prior year ((1)(i), PDF p.22). It is the prior year's budgeted revenue divided by this year's taxable value adjusted for incremental value, the three-year average equalization change and the five-year collection rate, less the collection rate times eligible new growth ((4), PDF p.27); for this calculation 'taxable value does not include eligible new growth' ((7)(b), PDF p.28). Eligible new growth is the sum of locally assessed new growth (the year's rise in county-assessed real property value, not counting factoring, reappraisal, residential-exemption or farmland changes), centrally assessed new growth (each state-assessed industry's value above its average of the previous three years) and project-area or hotel new growth ((1)(f), (h), (l), (t), PDF pp.21-24). In the version effective 1 January 2027 (PDF pp.30-40), locally assessed new growth no longer includes taxable value from improvements to an existing structure or construction of a new structure 'that does not add new building area related to residential or commercial use' ((1)(u)(ii)(E), PDF p.35), and an assessor may not use permit value to set the market value of construction in progress as of January 1 ((11), PDF p.40). The section does not say whether a power plant or factory counts as commercial use. Utah Code 59-2-924.5 (effective 1 January 2026; enacted by 2025 Laws ch. 258): by December 31 each year the county treasurer remits to the State Division of Finance 7% of the centrally assessed new growth revenue of every taxing entity in the county ((2)(a)-(b)); entities still count the full centrally assessed new growth in the next year's budgeted revenue ((2)(c)); from 2027 the money is deposited in the Species Protection Account ((3)).

In plain termsUtah has a rule called truth in taxation. Each year a local government's 'certified' rate is set so it collects about the same property tax it planned for the year before, and value from new buildings is left out of that math, so new buildings bring in extra money. From 2027, a new building that adds no space for homes or commercial use stops counting as new, so its value goes into the math that sets the rate. When state-valued industry grows, 7% of the extra tax goes to the State.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read 59-2-924 in the Part 9 PDF: the 2026 version (PDF pp.20-29, marked superseded 1/1/2027 on PDF p.19) for (1)(f), (h), (i), (l), (t), (4) and (7)(b), and the version effective 1/1/2027 (PDF pp.30-40) for (1)(u)(ii)(E) on PDF p.35 and (11) on PDF p.40; it keeps (4) and (7)(b) and does not define 'commercial use'. Re-read 59-2-924.5 (effective 1 January 2026, 2025 Laws ch. 258), subsections (2) and (3). All quotes and page numbers match.
recordconfirmed No air-permit application, utility filing, generator entry, BLM review, oil-and-gas listing or water right in an Altigen company's name was found in the records searched; the only water right with a point of diversion on the land is an 1869 stock-water claim
2026-10-09 · alt-003 · Altigen JS, LLC, Duct Tape, LLC, Utah Division of Water Rights

Searched 8 and 9 October 2026, none of these names an Altigen company: the Utah Division of Air Quality's list of current notices of intent (new and modified sources); the Utah Public Service Commission's site; EIA's August 2026 inventory of U.S. generators (EIA-860M), planned and operating; BLM's NEPA register; the Utah Division of Oil, Gas and Mining's operator list; and the Division of Water Rights' points of diversion. In FERC's eLibrary, 'Jurassic Spark' found nothing, and 'Altigen' matched two filings (testimony and exhibits) in an unrelated Southwest Power Pool rate case (ER24-254) that were not read. The one water right of record with points of diversion on the permit land is 91-3260, owned by Duct Tape, LLC: a diligence claim to Soldier Creek water for stock watering, with an 1869 priority. At the 6 October meeting the company said its first water would come from existing industrial water rights it is negotiating for (the county's recording, about 0:22:32), and that it would recycle its wastewater (alt-002).

In plain termsNo state or federal permit, filing or listing in Altigen's name was found in the records searched. The only water right with a point of diversion on the land is an old stock-watering claim on Soldier Creek held by the co-applicant, Duct Tape; Altigen says it is negotiating for industrial water rights.
verified 2026-10-09: Checked 9 Oct 2026 (V1.4) against the saved search results, the operator list, the generator inventory and the water-right report.
recordconfirmed Oct 22 and Nov 19: the next regular meetings of the Trust Lands board, which approved leasing Section 16 to Valar
2026-10-09 · mtg-001 · Utah Trust Lands Administration

The agenda of the Trust Lands Administration Board of Trustees' 17 September 2026 meeting, at which the board approved leasing Section 16, T14S R11E, north of Wellington, to Valar (mine-011), lists under 'Confirmation of Upcoming Meeting Dates': 'October 22, 2026 - Regular Meeting', 'November 19, 2026 - Regular Meeting' and 'December 2026 - No Board Meeting'; it gives no time or place for those meetings. The September meeting was set for 9:00 a.m. in the 6th-floor boardroom at 102 South 200 East, Salt Lake City; the board encouraged online attendance and allotted 15 minutes for public comment, three minutes per speaker, with remote speakers to use the 'Raise Hand' feature. As of 9 October 2026 the board's notice list on the state notice site showed no notice or agenda yet for 22 October.

In plain termsThe state Trust Lands board, which approved leasing the Section 16 land north of Wellington to Valar, next meets October 22 and November 19, 2026 (time and place not yet posted), and not in December. In September it set aside 15 minutes for public comment, three minutes each, in person or online.
verified 2026-10-09: Read 9 Oct 2026 (V1.4) from the state notice site: the board's September 17 notice and agenda, and its notice list.
recordconfirmed Nov 12: the state economic development board's next meeting, on its posted schedule; its October 8 agenda had no Valar item
2026-10-09 · mtg-002 · Governor's Office of Economic Opportunity

The Board of the Governor's Office of Economic Development, which approved up to $106.7 million in tax credits for Valar in July 2026 (csite-024), prints its 2026 meeting dates on its 8 October 2026 notice; the remaining ones are 'Nov 12, 2026, 10:00 AM' and 'Dec 10, 2026, 10:00 AM'. The schedule gives dates and times only; the October meeting was held at 60 East South Temple, Suite 300, Salt Lake City, with a video link. The 8 October agenda had no Valar item.

In plain termsThe state board that approved Valar's tax credits next meets November 12, 2026, at 10 a.m. (place not yet posted). Its October 8 agenda had nothing on Valar.
verified 2026-10-09: Read 9 Oct 2026 (V1.4) from the state notice site: the board's October 8 notice and agenda.
recordconfirmed Oct 7, 2026: the Carbon County Commission's regular meeting (first Wednesday, 4:30 p.m.); its agenda, posted 5 Oct, had no Valar item
2026-10-07 · dir-016 · Carbon County Commission, Carbon County Planning Commission

The Carbon County Board of Commissioners' notices on the Utah Public Notice Website show regular meetings on the first and third Wednesdays at 4:30 p.m. (3 and 17 June, 1 and 15 July, 19 August, 2 and 16 September 2026; the 5 August meeting was canceled), at 751 E 100 N, Price. Wednesday 7 October 2026 is the first Wednesday of October; no notice for it was posted as of 2 October 2026, and its notice and agenda were posted on 5 October, two days ahead. That agenda's 15 items (staff awards, contract and grant approvals, a Board of Equalization session on property values, and departmental reports) include no Valar, nuclear or Section 16 item. The agenda for 16 September was posted on 10 September, six days ahead; it had no Valar, nuclear or Section 16 item and listed no public-comment period. The day before, Tuesday 6 October, was set for the Planning Commission. Its agenda (first posted 23 September) has one permit item, for a different applicant; on 2 October it was amended to add a presentation from Valar Atomics about its proposed project in Carbon County, which Valar gave on 6 October, with no vote on it (loc-037). Before that amendment, the only Valar item found on the Carbon County Commission and Planning Commission agendas read was the commissioners' August 19, 2026 'Valor Atomics presentation' (about its Orangeville operation, per the minutes; csite-026); it did not concern the Wellington site or a permit, and no county permit application by Valar appeared in the planners' notices (csite-012). The county's rules for 'highly contested industries' are at the drafting stage, and the zoning administrator would like a hearing in November (csite-013); under Utah Code 17-79-803 (in the version read, in effect until May 2026) an application was judged by the rules in effect when it was complete, and a conforming one approved unless the county had formally started changing them first or found a compelling, countervailing public interest (dir-014), and the Trust Lands memo describes a county conditional use permit with notice and a public hearing as part of the process for the lease; the conditional-use chapter of the county's 2023 Development Code does not require a public hearing (csite-015).

In plain termsThe county commissioners' regular meeting was set for Wednesday, October 7 at 4:30 p.m. in Price; its agenda, posted October 5, had no Valar item. The day before, October 6, Valar gave a presentation to the county Planning Commission, added to that agenda on October 2; there was no vote on it.
verified 2026-10-17: Read in late September 2026: the commissioners' notice list (every notice June-Sept 2026: all Wednesdays at 4:30 p.m., first and third of the month; 5 Aug a cancellation), the 16 Sept notice (posted 10 Sept; agenda items 1-15, none on Valar, no public comment listed) and the 6 Oct Planning Commission notice (items 1-7). 7 Oct 2026 is a Wednesday. Whether the 7 Oct meeting would be held, and what would be on it, was not known until the notice posted. Re-read 2 October 2026: no notice for 7 October yet (the latest is the 16 September meeting); the 6 October Planning Commission notice was amended that morning to add a Valar presentation (loc-037). Updated in V1.2 (7 Oct 2026): the 7 October notice and its signed agenda were read from copies saved that day. Corrected 17 October 2026: The entry now gives the 7 October 2026 agenda, posted on 5 October, instead of a forecast. The 7 October agenda, posted 5 October, had no Valar item. The plain-language summary now reports the 7 October agenda and the 6 October presentation.
recordconfirmed Oct 6, 2026 agenda: 'Jurassic Spark' technology park east of Wellington, about 1,240 private acres shown as Mining & Grazing on the county zoning map, went to the planners, who tabled it to their next regular meeting (named as Nov 10)
2026-10-06 · dir-015 · Carbon County Planning Commission, Altigen JS, LLC, Duct Tape, LLC

The Carbon County Planning Commission's notice set its regular meeting for 6 October 2026 at 4:30 p.m. in the Commission Chambers, 751 E 100 N, Price (in person only per the notice). Its one permit item is a conditional use permit for 'a phased Technology Park and associated infrastructure located East of Wellington' on parcels 2A-1320-0000 and 2A-1656-0000 for Altigen JS, LLC and Duct Tape, LLC (csite-012). The application's vicinity map ('Project Jurassic Spark', added to the notice 28 September 2026) covers all of Section 36, T14S R11E and all of Section 2, T15S R11E, along U.S. 6. County parcel records list 2A-1320-0000 at 640 acres and 2A-1656-0000 at 600.74 acres, both assessor class 'Commercial' and neither in the state's government-owned parcel layer (privately owned); the county zoning map shows both in the Mining & Grazing zone, though Carbon County Commission minutes of 3 January 2024 record Ordinance 574 changing a 13-acre portion of 2A-1656-0000 from M&G to C-1, which the map layer does not show. In May the county agreed to begin holding a BLM gas-pipeline right-of-way for Altigen, whose stated plan is natural-gas power plants on private land east of Wellington (mine-050). The project lies about three miles southeast of Section 28 and about four miles from Section 16, which the state approved leasing to Valar. At the 6 October meeting (the county's audio recording), the attorney advising the commission said the application, received about two weeks earlier, was very large in scope: a project whose first phase would be power generation and which 'ultimately may include data centers, critical minerals processing, semiconductors' and manufacturing. He set out the test the commission must apply (whether the 'reasonably anticipated detrimental effects' can be mitigated), said a decision either way needed 'substantial evidence' and could not be 'arbitrary or capricious', said the county was still identifying the project's possible uses and effects, and recommended that the commission 'table this for one more month'. The commission voted by voice to table the permit, then amended the motion to table it until its next regularly scheduled meeting, with November 10 named (recording, about 0:48 to 0:53). No link between this project and Valar was found in the records read (as of late September 2026).

In plain termsA big land-use permit near Wellington was on the October 6, 2026 agenda: a technology park on about 1,240 acres of private land east of town, where the developer has said it plans gas-fired power plants. No link to Valar was found in the records read. On October 6 the planners tabled it until their next regular meeting, named as November 10, after the attorney advising them said the county was still identifying the project's uses and possible harms. It comes while the county's rules for big, contested projects are still being written.
verified 2026-10-08: Notice page read in late September 2026 (attachments: agenda; region map, one page, 'page 28' of the application). Parcel acres/class from UGRC LIR; government-owned layer returned no match for either id. Distances from section centers. Revised before publication (late September 2026): lease wording now 'approved leasing'. The parcel figures were first read from those layers in late September 2026 without keeping a copy; copies were saved on 9 October 2026 (alt-004). The zoning query result is kept. Updated in V1.3 (8 Oct 2026): the 6 October outcome from the county's audio recording, transcribed twice; only words both transcriptions agree on are quoted.
recordconfirmed Oct 6, 2026: Valar told the Carbon County Planning Commission 'if the community doesn't want us here, we won't do it'
2026-10-06 · pcm-001 · Valar Atomics, Carbon County

Presenting to the Carbon County Planning Commission on 6 October 2026, Valar's chief executive said he had said it at the town hall, and that 'if the community doesn't want us here, we won't do it' (county audio, about 1:19:11). KUTV attributed the words to Valar CEO Isaiah Taylor and reported that the room 'erupted in clapping'. KOAL reported a similar pledge from Taylor at the 29 September town hall. The item was listed as a presentation, and the county's recording shows no motion or vote on it.

In plain termsAt the October 6 county planning meeting, Valar's chief executive repeated a pledge from the town hall: if the community does not want Valar here, it will not build. KUTV reported that the room applauded.
verified 2026-10-17: Words read from two independent transcriptions of the county's recording, which agree on the quoted words (V1.6). Re-checked 17 October 2026 against two further independent transcriptions of the recording, which also agree on the quoted words, and against KUTV's report. Corrected 17 October 2026: KUTV's report does not say the remark answered a commissioner; that detail was removed. Corrected 17 October 2026: the record no longer says KUTV reported the remark as an answer to a commissioner; KUTV's report does not say that.
recordconfirmed Carbon County's planners added a Valar Atomics presentation to their October 6 agenda on October 2
2026-10-02 · loc-037 · Carbon County Planning Commission, Valar Atomics, Utah Public Notice Website

The Carbon County Planning Commission's notice for its regular meeting on Tuesday, October 6, 2026 at 4:30 p.m. in the Commission Chambers, 751 East 100 North, Price, was edited on October 2, 2026 at 8:49 a.m. The amended agenda adds item 6, 'Presentation to the Planning Commission from Valar Atomics regarding their proposed project in Carbon County'. The agenda first posted with the notice (a one-page PDF created September 23, 2026, still on the state site as file 1492435) had seven items and no Valar item, and the notice read on September 29 matched it. Neither version lists a public comment item, and the notice says neither electronic nor telephone participation is available. The edit also removed the agenda PDF from the notice. The meeting was held on 6 October. On 7 October the county attached its audio recording of the meeting to the notice, and as of 17 October 2026 no minutes of the meeting were listed on the state notice website. In the recording, item 6 was a presentation, with no motion or vote on it; a Valar speaker said 'We will eventually submit a proposal' (about 0:54:35), and later that the plan would be submitted at the end of October (about 1:17:42). The speakers described 'a site proposed up north of Wellington', with the near-term focus on 'about a 640-acre parcel' of state trust land and federal BLM land as 'sort of a eventual phase' (about 0:57:38 to 0:58:51; FOX 13 attributes the BLM words to Isaiah Taylor). A Valar speaker said that 'if it were to work out' the project would bring 'hundreds of jobs' (about 1:00:57), and that ground would not be broken 'until sometime next year if it is approved at all' (about 1:19:34). Asked about the full scope, a Valar speaker said the first patch of land could hold 'something like 70' reactors, a number the speaker called 'probably wrong' (about 1:21:39). KUTV wrote that Valar 'is looking to build around 70 small nuclear reactors'; FOX 13 reported that the Valar team said it wanted 'a couple hundred reactors on a 640-acre parcel', a figure not found in the county's recording of the presentation as checked on 17 October 2026, where the only reactor count found is 'something like 70'. The agenda's other items are separate matters.

In plain termsOn October 2 the county planners added a presentation from Valar about its proposed project in Carbon County to their October 6 meeting in Price. The agenda listed no public comment item and no vote on Valar, and the meeting was in person only. Valar presented that day: its speakers described about 640 acres of state trust land north of Wellington as the near-term site, with federal land as a later phase, and 'something like 70' reactors on the first piece of land. The county posted its recording on October 7; no minutes had been posted as of October 17, 2026.
verified 2026-10-17: Read on 2 October 2026: the notice as edited that morning, and the agenda PDF first posted with it on 23 September (one scanned page). The earlier version of the notice was read on 29 September. Re-read 17 October 2026: the notice as edited on 7 October, the board's notice list (no minutes), the county's recording of item 6 (only words that two independent transcriptions agree on are quoted), and the KUTV and FOX 13 reports.
recordconfirmed No Valar permit item was found in Carbon County Planning Commission notices, 5 May to 6 October 2026
2026-09 · csite-012 · Carbon County Planning Commission, Valar Atomics

The Planning Commission's notices on the Utah Public Notice Website from 5 May to 6 October 2026 (ten on the commission's notice page) listed rezones, subdivisions and routine hearings, and, until a Valar presentation was added to the October 6 agenda on October 2, no item for Valar, a reactor, Section 16 or the Wellington trust-land parcel. The June and August 2026 minutes (scanned) do not mention Valar. The agenda for 6 October 2026 (posted 23 September) has one land-use item, a conditional use permit for a different applicant's project. The October notice says it was sent to a local newspaper, radio stations KOAL and KUSA, ETV Channel 10 and the state website. As of late September 2026 no Valar conditional use application, site plan or rezone appears in these records. Valar gave its presentation at the 6 October meeting; the agenda listed no action or hearing item for Valar, and the county's recording of the meeting shows no motion or vote on it. In the recording a Valar speaker said 'We will eventually submit a proposal' (about 0:54:35), and later a Valar speaker said 'the plan that we'll be submitting at the end of this month' would not be building permits (about 1:17:42). As of 17 October 2026 the commission's notices list no Valar application, and its next noticed hearing, on 10 November 2026, is on a zoning map change for part of one parcel, from C-1 to R-1-20K, that does not mention Valar.

In plain termsBefore anything can be built on the Wellington parcel, the state's lease memo says Valar must get a Carbon County conditional use permit (csite-015, dir-014). No Valar item was found in the planning board's posted notices from May to early October 2026, as read on 29 September; on 2 October a Valar presentation was added to the 6 October agenda, and Valar presented that day with no vote on it (loc-037); as of 17 October 2026 no Valar application was found in the board's notices. The state memo says Valar's site plans would go to the county planning commission for review.
verified 2026-10-17: Holds. Re-read in late September 2026: the commission's notice list; October 6 notice and its attachment; the scanned June 2 and August 4 minutes. Date changed from the future hearing date (6 Oct) to the as-of date of the finding; the claim that every notice names ETV's publication date was not re-checked and was removed. Second check, late September 2026: the commission's full notice list returns eleven notices, 5 May to 6 Oct 2026; only one item, for a different applicant, matches a land-use keyword. Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): the county-permit requirement is attributed to the state's lease memo; see Corrections. Re-checked 9 Oct 2026 (V1.4): no Valar permit application in the Planning Commission's or the County Commission's notices on the state notice site; the planners' latest notice is the October 6 agenda, with Valar's presentation (loc-037). Re-checked 17 October 2026: the notice as edited on 7 October, the commission's notice list, the 10 November hearing notice and the county's recording of the 6 October meeting (only words that two independent transcriptions agree on are quoted).
recordconfirmed None of Valar's public pages or published technical documents mention the Carbon County site (as of late September 2026)
2026-09 · csite-027 · Valar Atomics

Read in late September 2026: Valar's home, Ward 250, Technology, Mission, Careers and Castle Country pages; its Library page (five company posts plus media links); and the Ward 250 Nuclear Safety Design Agreement and QA Program Description in its 'Public Documents' folder. None mentions Wellington, the Trust Lands lease, Section 16 or a Carbon County campus; on the Castle Country page 'Carbon' appears in its 'Carbon & Emery County' headings and history and as a partner logo (extends mine-020). The company does state its general plan there: 'Valar Atomics is building America's first nuclear gigasites', which it describes as energy campuses powered by fleets of reactors, without naming a location. The same page says 'Our doors remain open through tours, town halls and straight answers.' As of the pages read in late September 2026, the only Valar statements about the Carbon site found were its staff's remarks to the Trust Lands board (mine-018) and to the Carbon County Commission, whose 19 August minutes do not name the site (mine-013). That evening, at Valar's town hall in Price, KOAL News reported its chief executive saying Valar would expand onto BLM land 'if and when we outgrow the SITLA land', and ETV News reported Valar officials saying 'the 640-acre parcel is only the first step in its plans'; on 6 October he told the Carbon County Planning Commission that Valar would not build if the community did not want it (pcm-001).

In plain termsThe company tells residents on its local page that it offers 'straight answers', and it says there that it is building nuclear 'gigasites', but none of its own public materials read in late September 2026 says the state has approved leasing it land north of Wellington for a nuclear campus. In the records read, the site was first named in public in state board records, and the first local news report found came after the vote.
verified 2026-10-17: Holds, with the company's own 'gigasites' line added for balance. Re-read in late September 2026: home, ward-250, technology, mission, careers, castle-country and docs pages; QA PDF (24 pp.) and NSDA PDF (56 pp.) text-searched for Carbon, Wellington, trust land, Section 16, gigasite: none.
recordconfirmed State boards and legislators heard about Valar's Emery reactor; no agenda found names the Carbon site
2026-09 · csite-031 · Utah Legislature, Utah Energy Council, Utah Office of Energy Development, Southeastern Utah Association of Local Governments, Utah Nuclear Consortium

Agendas on the Utah Public Notice Website and legislative materials read in late September 2026: the Legislature's Public Utilities, Energy & Technology Interim Committee heard 'Valar Atomics Nuclear Test Reactor' on 18 June 2025 (its agenda describes a plan for 'a new nuclear test reactor running by 2026', and the approved minutes record public comment on the nuclear discussion later in that meeting; gov-040); slides for the Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment Interim Committee's 19 August 2026 data-center item list the 'Valar Atomics-Nvidia Partnership' as an example; the Utah Energy Council's 31 March 2026 agenda has 'Valar Atomics at San Rafael Lab Update', with a general public-comment item next on the agenda (gov-041; its 31 March and 29 September 2026 agendas also list closed sessions on buying, exchanging or leasing real property, unnamed); the Southeastern Utah Association of Local Governments (SERDA) board agendas list 'Valar Atomics Groundbreaking' (September 2025) and 'Nuclear Community Campaigns' updates (May and July 2026); the Utah Nuclear Consortium's 25 March 2026 agenda discusses its new duties under S.B. 135 and H.B. 78. None of these agendas or the attachments read names the Wellington parcel, Section 16 or a Carbon County campus. No Valar item was found in the Carbon Community Economic Development Board's notices since June 2025, and the Carbon County Redevelopment Agency's four notices (September to December 2025) have none. For most of these meetings, minutes or audio were not found or were not read. The Energy Council's approved 7 July 2026 minutes, the transcript of its 25 August 2026 meeting and its 29 September 2026 agenda were also read: none names Valar or a Carbon site.

In plain termsValar's reactor in Emery County has been discussed repeatedly by state boards and legislators, in public. Several of those meetings also had public-comment periods, listed on their agendas or recorded in their minutes (gov-040, gov-041, gov-042). The Carbon County site has not appeared on any of their published agendas that we found. What was said inside closed sessions or in meetings without posted minutes is not known.
verified 2026-10-02: Holds, with fixes: the slides' author is not named in their text, so the attribution to the Office of Energy Development was removed; the SERDA September 2025 'Valar Atomics Groundbreaking' item was added. Re-read in late September 2026: PUET agenda (June 18, 2025); the 8/19/2026 slides; UEC notices (6 Feb, 6 Mar, 31 Mar, 'May 26' listed with a 26 June event date); UNC 25 Mar notice; SERDA notices 25 Sept 2025, 28 May and 16 July 2026; CEDB and RDA lists (Utah Public Notice Website notice lists, read again). Second check, late September 2026: UEC notice list: closed real-property sessions on 13 agendas (30 Oct 2025 to 29 Sept 2026), not four; RDA body 3749 lists four notices (3 Sept to 15 Dec 2025), none naming Valar, so 'no notices were listed' was wrong; UEC minutes 1480375, transcript 1480517 and agenda 1493643 searched (no Valar, Carbon, Wellington, trust lands). Date set to the as-of date of this negative finding. Corrected 2026-10-01: wording made more exact against the cited records.
recordconfirmed Where the RW 453 notice places the claim, most land is private: federal land is about 37% of Section 28's north half
2026-09 · dir-002 · Valar Atomics, Bureau of Land Management, Carbon County Assessor

BLM's survey grid places Section 28, T14S R11E SLM at 39.572-39.586 N, 110.683-110.702 W, directly two miles south of Section 16 (the land the state approved leasing to Valar) and about 3.4 miles northeast of central Wellington. Carbon County's parcel records (compiled statewide by UGRC; parcel shapes current as of 26 November 2025, ownership layer of 18 June 2026) show one federal parcel, 2A-1292-028F (200 acres, recorded as federal land), in four pieces: about 80 acres in the NE quarter and about 40 acres in each other quarter. Everything else is private. Laying the parcel shapes over the section on a fine grid, the north half (the NW and NE quarters, 320 acres, where the notice places RW 453) is about 120 acres federal (37%), and the rest is in private parcels. BLM's surface-management layer, read on 12 October 2026, shows the same pattern: just over 200 acres of the section as BLM land (about 80 acres in the NE quarter and about 40 in each other quarter) and the rest as 'Private or Unknown'; the parcel records are the finer source. A lode claim is valid only over federally owned minerals: on the federal pieces if the land is open to mineral entry, and on private surface only where the United States kept the minerals. On Stock-Raising Homestead Act lands, a claimant must first file a notice of intent to locate with BLM, serve it on the surface landowner by registered or certified mail, and wait 30 days before entering (43 CFR 3838.11). Who owns the minerals under the private parcels is not shown in the layers read, and because the notice's survey tie points outside the section (dir-001), where exactly the claim lies within the north half cannot be told from the notice.

In plain termsMost of the land in the part of Section 28 named on the claim notice is privately owned; a little over a third is federal. A mining claim can only cover minerals the federal government owns. Whether this claim sits on the federal pieces, or on private land over federal minerals (which, on Stock-Raising Homestead land, requires advance notice to the landowner), cannot be told from the notice itself.
verified 2026-10-16: Re-checked and rewritten in late September 2026. The earlier version (from five point look-ups) said the federal parcel sat in the NE quarter; the shapes show four pieces across all quarters. Method: Section 28 and its quarters from BLM's survey grid (CadNSDI), with the federal parcel's four shapes laid over them on a fine grid. Checked again 16 October 2026: BLM's surface-management layer, queried 12 October 2026, shows about 206 acres of BLM land in the section (NE about 83, NW 42, SE 42, SW 40) and about 124 acres of the north half (38%); the county's federal parcel gives about 120 acres there (37%). The county figures come from parcel layers read in late September 2026; BLM's layer gives the same picture. Private parcel holders are not named here on purpose. Revised before publication (late September 2026): lease wording now 'approved leasing'.
recordconfirmed No 'RW' claim was in BLM's public claim layer in late September 2026; federal rules allow 90 days after location to record it
2026-09 · dir-005 · Bureau of Land Management, Valar Atomics

Every claim in BLM's not-closed mining-claim layer that intersects Carbon County was pulled in late September 2026: ten open claims (AMBERIA 1-9 in T14S R8E-R9E, BLACK RIFLE placer in T15S R11E), none RW and none naming Valar (mine-002). A second check the same day, by legal description, found no claim, open or closed, anywhere in T14S R11E (the township of both the lease and RW 453), and no Utah claim named RW among the 134 Utah claims BLM created from September 12 to September 29. Federal rules require recording with BLM by the 90th day after location (43 CFR 3833.11), so RW 453 (located Sept 12, 2026) is due by December 11, 2026 and may simply not be filed yet.

In plain termsThe RW 453 claim was not in BLM's public database when checked in late September 2026. The filing was not yet due then: Valar has until December 11, 2026 to file it.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-checked in late September 2026: a search of BLM's open and closed claim layers by legal description found no claim in T14S R11E (the same search found 8 in T14S R9E, showing the search itself worked); none of the 134 Utah claims created from 12 September 2026 is named RW. Revised before publication (late September 2026): the deadline sentence now reads 'the filing is not yet due'. No copy of the query results is kept; the figures rest on BLM's layers as they stood when checked.
recordconfirmed County zoning map: Valar's lease is Mining & Grazing; where the RW 453 notice places the claim is mapped rural residential
2026-09 · dir-013 · Carbon County, Valar Atomics

Carbon County's own zoning map service (the county's 'County Zoning' layer, checked in late September 2026 at the center of each area) shows: Section 16, T14S R11E, Valar's Wellington lease, zoned M&G, 'Mining and Grazing Zone' (matching the Trust Lands memo, csite-015); the NW quarter of Section 28, where the RW 453 notice places the claim, zoned RR-1, 'One-acre Rural Residential Zone', and the NE quarter zoned RR-2.5, 'Two-and-one-half-acre Rural Residential Zone' (the notice names both quarters, mine-453). Utah's county land-use law does not give the county jurisdiction over land the United States owns, unless other law provides it (Utah Code 17-79-306), and about 37% of Section 28's north half is a federal parcel (dir-002); the rest is private land under the county's zoning. What the county's residential zones allow is set by Carbon's development code, which this record does not summarize for those zones.

In plain termsThe county's own zoning map puts the square mile the state approved leasing to Valar in its mining-and-grazing zone, where, the state's lease memo says, big industrial projects need a county permit. On the same map, the land named on Valar's mining-claim notice, two miles south, is in rural residential zones; about 37% of it is federal land, which Utah's county land-use law does not put under county jurisdiction unless another law does.
verified 2026-10-02: Read from Carbon County's public zoning map service at the center of each section or quarter named (BLM survey grid): Sec 16 M&G; Sec 28 NW quarter RR-1; Sec 28 NE quarter RR-2.5; Sec 36 M&G; Sec 2 T15S M&G. Quarter-center points only: zone lines inside a quarter were not mapped. Revised before publication (late September 2026): lease wording now 'approved leasing'. The federal share (about 37%) was computed from the state's government-owned parcel layer and BLM's survey grid, checked in late September 2026; no copy of the parcel layer is kept, and the figure rests on it as it stood then. Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): the zoning map's rural-residential land is about 37% federal land; see Corrections.
recordconfirmed Utah land-use law: the county land-use chapter gives no jurisdiction over state or federal land unless another law does, and applications vest under the rules in effect
2026-09 · dir-014 · Utah Legislature, Carbon County

Utah Code 17-79-306(2) (amended 2026) says that, unless otherwise provided by law, the county land-use chapter does not give a county jurisdiction over real property 'owned by the state or the United States'. Valar's Wellington parcel is state school trust land; no zoning provision was found in the Trust Lands statute (Title 53C, searched in late September 2026), yet the Trust Lands memo describes the county conditional use permit as part of the process (csite-015); the lease document itself was not found in public records (as of late September 2026); its terms would show whether Valar agreed to seek county approvals. Separately, Utah Code 17-79-803 (the version effective 6 Nov 2025; amended May 2026) entitled an applicant to review under the land-use rules in effect when a complete application is filed, and to approval if it conforms to them, unless the county formally found on the record that approving it would jeopardize a compelling, countervailing public interest, or, before the filing, had formally initiated proceedings to amend its rules in a way that would bar it (that exception lapses after 180 days if no such enactment results); the current text was not checked. Carbon County's planners are drafting rules for 'highly contested industries', and the zoning administrator would like a hearing in November (csite-013).

In plain termsState law says the county land-use chapter does not by itself give counties jurisdiction over land the state or federal government owns, unless another law provides it; the state's lease memo still lists a county conditional use permit as a required step. And under the version of Utah's law read (in effect until May 2026), a project is usually judged by the rules on the books the day its complete application is filed; a county that wants new rules to apply has to formally start them first.
verified 2026-10-02: Statute texts read in late September 2026; quotes exact. The 17-79-803 text read is the version superseded 6 May 2026; the current text should be checked before relying on details. Not legal advice.
recordconfirmed No Form D from Valar Atomics Inc. was found on EDGAR for any round, $1B included; only nine outside investment pools filed; the SEC ties the notice to Regulation D sales, and which exemption Valar used was not found
2026-09 · fund-010 · Valar Atomics, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Sydecar, CGF2021 LLC

EDGAR, the SEC's filing system, has no registrant named Valar Atomics, Inc.: its company search for 'valar atomics' returns seven series of CGF2021 LLC (investment pools administered by Sydecar, orig-056) and nothing else, and a full-text search of all filings for 'Valar Atomics' (31 hits, re-run in late September 2026) finds Form D notices only from nine such pools (ten filings, one of them filed twice: eight CGF2021 series and one Alumni Ventures fund), plus lenders' and other companies' reports that mention Valar. So no Form D from the company was found for any of its funding rounds in the records read (fund-002 to fund-007), including the $1 billion Series B. The SEC's guidance says a company selling under Rule 504 or 506 of Regulation D 'must file this notice within 15 days after the first sale of securities'. The SEC's pages describe Rule 506(b) as a 'safe harbor' under Section 4(a)(2) of the Securities Act, which exempts sales 'not involving any public offering', and tie the Form D notice to the Regulation D rules; they do not say that every private sale needs one. Which exemption Valar used was not found in public records. The Form D itself asks for each executive officer, director and promoter (Item 3) and the amount sold (Item 13); without one, Valar's board and round totals are known only from the company's own announcements, press and investors, not from an SEC filing (fund-002, fund-008, ppl-010). This is a gap in the public record and nothing more.

In plain termsWhen a U.S. company sells shares privately under the SEC's Regulation D rules, it files a short public notice called a Form D, listing its officers and directors and how much it sold. None from Valar was found on the SEC's EDGAR system, even for a $1 billion round; only small investment pools that bought into Valar filed them. The SEC's pages tie the notice to those rules, not to every private sale, so its absence does not show that a filing was required or missed. But it means Valar's directors and the amounts it raised cannot be checked against an SEC filing.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-verified in late September 2026: EDGAR company search (7 CGF2021 series) and full-text searches (31 hits; 10 Form Ds, 9 entities, none by Valar) re-run. The claim about what a Form D names was not in the pages first cited: now sourced to the SEC's Form D; the line on other exemptions was reworded to what the SEC pages say. Corrected in late September 2026: closing sentence now states the gap only. No copy of the three EDGAR search results is kept; the counts rest on EDGAR as searched in late September 2026. One Form D filing from each of the nine pools is cited and kept. Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): 'six funding rounds' now reads 'its funding rounds'; see Corrections.
recordconfirmed In the Federal Register, Valar appears once: on a list of 84 fuel-pact signers; no notice about Ward 250 itself was found
2026-09 · gov-029 · Federal Register, U.S. Department of Energy, Valar Atomics

A search of the Federal Register's public API on 29 September 2026 for 'Valar Atomics', 'Valar', 'Ward250' and 'Ward 250' returns one document: the 6 July 2026 Defense Production Act agreement listing Valar among 84 signers (gov-001). The searches, re-run on 12 October 2026 with the same results, found no Federal Register notice naming Ward 250, the San Rafael Energy Lab, a Valar environmental review, a DOE authorization or a comment period for Valar. The rules that governed Ward 250 did appear there in general form: Executive Order 14301 (29 May 2025) and DOE's categorical exclusion B5.26 (2 February 2026, effective on publication, comments taken afterward to 4 March; safe-029, csite-020). The Ward 250 categorical exclusion itself (22 April 2026) was posted on DOE's website, with a June 2026 web path, not in the Register. The Reactor Pilot Program request for applications ran on FedConnect (gov-007). No Valar-specific Federal Register notice or comment period for this reactor was found; the one Valar-specific federal decision document found, the categorical exclusion, was posted on DOE's website.

In plain termsThe Federal Register is where the U.S. government announces things the public is entitled to know about and comment on. Valar's name appears there only once, in a list of companies that signed a fuel-supply agreement. No Federal Register notice was found that told the public a company planned to start a reactor in Emery County and invited comment. The rules that allowed that were announced in general terms, but nothing specific to this reactor was found in the Register; DOE posted its environmental decision on its own website.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-ran the Federal Register API for 'Valar Atomics', 'Valar', 'Ward250', 'Ward 250' and 'San Rafael Energy' in late September 2026 (1, 1, 0, 0, 0 results) and re-read the CX (signed 2026.04.22). Holds; last sentence made more exact.
analysisconfirmed Government connections in brief: what holds, where officials' words and the record part, and what is still not found in public records
2026-09 · gov-035 · Valar Atomics, U.S. Department of Energy, State of Utah, Utah Office of Energy Development, Emery County Commission, Carbon County Commission, Utah Inland Port Authority

Holds on the record: DOE did select (12 Aug 2025) and authorize Ward 250, the only one of DOE's four summer-2026 criticalities outside a national laboratory (gov-006, orig-010); DOE's agreement with Valar carries $0 of federal money, like all nine pilot agreements on file at USAspending (gov-003); Valar's federal lobbying is modest, disclosed and aimed at Congress (gov-004); Emery County's land sale followed state statute (gov-022); Valar's statement that DOE reviews and approves its design holds for the test reactor (gov-039). Where statements and records part: KUTV reported the governor speaking of NRC oversight while the state's signed MOU named DOE rules and Utah was suing to keep small reactors out of NRC licensing (gov-012, reported); the state lab's FAQ still tells the public 'the planned reactor' gets NRC licensing and NRC-tested operators, which the lab's only operating reactor does not have (gov-026); the state lab calls 18 June 'full-power' criticality when DOE's release and a DOE slide prepared for the NRC describe it as zero power (orig-012); Valar told the state's incentive board of plans for more commercial units and behind-the-meter sales, which the DOE route does not cover (gov-033, gov-039); Valar said in April 2026, at the Emery parcel hearing, it would 'be open with all plans'; the first public record found tying it to the Carbon site is the August 2026 agenda (gov-038); DOE counted reactors at Idaho National Laboratory toward a goal titled 'outside the National Laboratories', though its own application rules allowed lab sites (gov-006); a think tank's release called NOVA the pilot's first criticality, DOE says Antares was (gov-028); officials' statements on transparency and the MOU's confidentiality term and its bar on publicity without both parties' consent sit side by side in the record (gov-011, gov-020); the DOE-Utah campus pact cites Ward 250's 'successful permitting', but no state permit was found as of late September 2026 (gov-030); county and Inland Port records disagree on whether Valar's land is in a tax-capture zone (gov-023); Valar's groundbreaking date differs from the state's (gov-015). Not documented in the public records read: where Valar's HALEU came from, given it is in none of DOE's announced allocation rounds (gov-008). Not found in public records as of late September 2026: the OTA text, the DOE safety approvals themselves (a DOE slide prepared for the NRC Commission's 21 July 2026 meeting, found on 17 October 2026, lists the PDSA and DSA approval dates, February and 23 April 2026, but is not an approval document) and the readiness report Valar described to the state board in May 2026 (DOE confirmed in July 2026 that a federal readiness review covering Ward 250 ended in a final report to the startup authority; safe-007, gov-037, dir-031), and the state lab use agreement and board-approved terms (gov-013). The pilot program's application rules are posted on the FedConnect portal, which was not read (gov-032). Process: no Federal Register notice or comment period specific to Valar was found as of late September 2026 (gov-029), no local-government consent required under the pilot's rules as summarized (gov-032), and local approvals given quickly, sometimes with no review recorded (gov-021, gov-022). None of this record shows intent; it shows gaps that records requests can close.

In plain termsOn the government side, the basic facts check out: the Energy Department approved the reactor, it paid no cash for it, and the local land sale followed the law. In several places officials' descriptions of oversight and openness differ from their own papers: the NRC was cited as a safety check it never became for this reactor, a state web page still describes NRC licensing, and the state's May 2025 MOU with Valar carried a confidentiality clause when its lab director told residents in June 2025 'We are not trying to keep anything from anyone.' Valar's April 2026 'open with all plans' was said at the Emery parcel hearing; the first public record found tying Valar to the Carbon site is the 10 Aug 2026 agenda. Money and fuel questions remain: who supplied Valar's special uranium, and what the government's free safety reviews cost. No hearing or comment period on the reactor's safety case (its safety analysis or DOE's approval of it) was found at any level as of late September 2026. Emery County held a general public hearing on nuclear industries in June 2025, where residents raised safety concerns (gov-020), and state meetings that took up the lab and Valar had general public-comment periods on their agendas (gov-040, gov-041, gov-042). The open questions list says exactly which records would settle each point.
verified 2026-10-17: Summary rewritten in late September 2026 to match the verified facts: gov-012 now 'reported'; the FAQ, DOE commercial-licensing and INL-siting nuances added; new facts gov-037 to gov-039 included. Corrected in late September 2026: openness comparisons restated with dates and context; headline absence now worded as 'not found in public records'; restored the MOU's 'without both parties' consent' qualifier (gov-011, gov-020). Corrected 2026-10-01: wording made more exact against the cited records.
analysisconfirmed The local paper: 47 ETV items on Valar, July 2025 to Sept 2026; a Carbon plan ran in 2025, the site only after the vote
2026-09 · loc-011 · ETV News, Emery Telcom, Valar Atomics, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab

ETV News describes itself as a free weekly delivered to every home and business in Carbon and Emery counties (circulation 13,800), with a website and cable channels that air government meetings; its contact address is at emerytelcom.com. The two other local papers' sites (Sun Advocate, Emery County Progress) did not answer when tried on 29 September and 7 October 2026. ETV's search feed for 'valar', read in late September 2026, returned 48 items: 47 from 3 July 2025 to 23 September 2026 and one unrelated 2017 column; 46 of the 47 name Valar in their text and one (a 25 February 2026 Carbon Commission report) refers to the Emery reactor without naming the company. All 47 were checked. Two 2025 items told readers the plan was bigger than one test reactor: the 17 September 2025 state release on the groundbreaking ended with Valar's description of itself as building 'gigasites' of thousands of reactors, and a 10 October 2025 article reported that Valar's 'current plan' was a manufacturing hub in Carbon County after about three years (loc-034); neither named a site. The first report of the Wellington lease is dated 18 September 2026, the day after the vote (mine-041); no earlier item links Valar to Wellington, the Section 16 trust land or a Carbon lease (two earlier items mention trust land in other contexts: 640 acres across the road from the Emery lab, 9 April 2026, and a Farm Bureau speaker on the Trust Lands permit process for solar, 1 May 2026). Six items are press releases printed as articles: from the state lab (23 Jan and 23 Sept 2026), from Valar (24 Feb 2026), from the Office of Energy Development (17 Sept 2025, orig-067), from USU Eastern (26 Mar 2026) and from Southern Utah University (19 Sept 2026). Most of the rest are meeting reports. Residents' concerns appear in them (the June 2025 county hearing on nuclear, the April 2026 land-sale hearing, a resident's data-center presentation in July 2026, a candidate forum where one candidate called nuclear the most expensive source), but no ETV item read quotes an independent expert assessing Valar's reactor or its safety. ETV's post-vote article (18 Sept) reports the lease terms and supporters' remarks and notes that permits are still needed; it reports no opposing comment, which matches the hearing record (mine-014). ETV's town-hall report of 30 September 2026, published after the feed was read, repeats the 18 September lease paragraphs nearly word for word and adds that 'SITLA allocates 96% to public education within the state' (a Trust Lands figure for all trust-land revenue, loc-021); it attributes most answers to 'Valar officials' without saying who gave each, and names the chief executive, the head of projects and the director of Utah operations as presenters.

In plain termsThe one newspaper that reaches every home in both counties mentioned Valar or its reactor in 47 items between July 2025 and late September 2026. In 2025 it did tell readers that Valar aimed at clusters of thousands of reactors and planned a factory hub in Carbon County, but no article read named the Wellington site before the day after the state approved it. Six of the 47 items were press releases printed as articles and labelled as such, four of them from Valar, the state lab or the state energy office; most of the rest were meeting reports. Readers relying on it could have known a Carbon County plan existed, but not where or when, until it was decided.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read the feed (all three pages) and the item pages. The count of 47 holds, but one item does not name Valar. Correction: 'none named the Carbon site before the vote' holds for the site, but the analysis had missed that ETV reported a Valar plan for a Carbon County manufacturing hub on 10 Oct 2025 and printed the 'gigasites' description on 17 Sept 2025; both added. Trust-land wording made exact. Revised before publication (late September 2026): absence stated as 'no article read'.
analysisconfirmed Local record in brief: a Carbon plan was public in 2025, the site was not; much talk in Emery, few chances to object
2026-09 · loc-033 · Valar Atomics, Carbon County, Emery County, Orangeville City, Utah Trust Lands Administration

As of late September 2026, testing against local records the view that the Carbon site should have been handled in public and that residents did not know. What holds for the company: in Emery County Valar appeared before towns, districts and residents at least 15 times and held open houses (loc-027); Emery's land sale was noticed by name and heard (loc-007); its fuel plant was disclosed in public (loc-016); and in 2025 the local paper printed Valar's 'gigasites' aim and reported a plan for a Carbon County manufacturing hub, without a site (loc-034). What the record shows on the Carbon site: the state's newspaper notice named no applicant or use (loc-032); no report or minutes of Valar's June-September appearances before Carbon bodies, including a Price council work session, name the Wellington site (loc-012); the local paper first reported it the day after the vote (loc-011); a week before the vote the CEO spoke publicly of hundreds of reactors in Carbon and Emery without, as reported, naming a site (loc-001); a commissioner said project NDAs are usually companies' demand (loc-002), and the county's own minutes record it kept a 'strict' NDA on a different factory prospect until August 2026 (loc-036); no NDA with Valar was found in the records read. Gaps between words and records: the state lab director, as ETV reported, said firms must show 'no dose' at the fence, while Valar's own analysis gives a small dose (loc-035); Carbon commissioners, as reported, called the test reactor 'commercial' and the data center waterless (loc-005); a local report of a chamber tour said meltdown risk is gone (loc-006); Valar told Castle Dale its reactor needs about 10 acre-feet of water for industrial use while DOE's review lists only domestic use (loc-025); officials and the state port authority describe the Emery land as sold while Valar said in August it awaited clean title (loc-014); Valar said it 'relocated' from California while most of its openings are there (loc-029); in April Valar said many of its 120 Emery workers did not live in Utah (loc-004). Process gaps: district minutes record a staff report that Valar tied into the sewer 'without prior authorization' (loc-015); the state declined to review the reactor building's fire plans and no record read shows who did (loc-018); Emery had no nuclear zoning rules and has now paused new major permit applications (loc-024); Orangeville is drafting a zone for Valar's land, its drafts to go through the city's and Valar's attorneys, with no hearing on it found as of 17 October 2026 (loc-013); no water-right application by Valar was found among the State Engineer's notices in the local paper (loc-031). None of this shows intent; it shows where the public was and was not given the facts in time to act, and which records requests would close each gap (open_questions).

In plain termsIn Emery County, Valar talked to people a lot, and some of what it and local officials said, as reported, differs from the documents. In Carbon County the general idea was public: the local paper reported in 2025 that Valar planned a factory hub there. But the specific plan north of Wellington was handled by the state in Salt Lake City; the local ad did not say what it was for, and Valar's local talks before the vote did not mention it, and the local paper first reported the site the day after it was approved; before then, the records we found name Valar for the site only in the state board's online notices and papers, from 10 August, and at its meetings in Salt Lake City. The formal moments when residents can object, a county permit hearing, a water-right protest, a zoning hearing, have mostly not happened yet. Those are the next chances to take part.
verified 2026-10-18: Rewritten after the earlier check: adds the 2025 local reports of a Carbon plan (loc-034), the lab director's dose statement (loc-035), the county NDA record (loc-036) and the Ferron staffing figure; corrects the fire item and the moratorium status. Each point rests on the fact it cites. Revised before publication (late September 2026): sewer, dose and comparison lines restated.
recordconfirmed Valar's Castle Country page mentions 'gigasites' but not where: no Carbon lease, Green River or BLM applications
2026-09 · mine-020 · Valar Atomics

Valar's community page for Carbon and Emery counties, read in late September 2026, describes Ward 250, open houses ('more than 400 neighbors' at the first), town halls, the Emery County Commission's unanimous backing, local partners and news items. The words Green River, Wellington, Beehive, Raceway, BLM, Bureau of Land Management, trust, lease, acres and Price do not appear on it; 'Carbon' appears only in the page's two 'Carbon & Emery' headings and on a Carbon County logo among its 'Public Partners'. The company's document library (valaratomics.com/docs) lists five documents (a Series B announcement, the NOVA criticality release, a pilot-program selection, a roadmap and its NRC lawsuit) and no land, siting or environmental document. The page does say Valar 'is building America's first nuclear gigasites', energy campuses powered by fleets of reactors, without saying where; that text is the same in the Internet Archive's copy of 18 September 2026 and on 29 September.

In plain termsThe company's page for local residents describes the test reactor and community events and says Valar is building nuclear 'gigasites', but not where: nothing on it names the land it is seeking in Carbon or Emery County. That appears in state, county and federal records and in local news reports.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read in late September 2026: word checks and the '400 neighbors' quote confirmed; library lists 5 documents, none on land or siting. Corrected in late September 2026: the first reading missed 'gigasite'; the Sept 18 archive copy was compared with the live page (identical text).
analysisconfirmed Valar has sought its sites by lease, BLM applications and purchase; separately a Notice of Location names its lode claim RW 453
2026-09 · mine-027 · Valar Atomics, Bureau of Land Management, Utah Trust Lands Administration, Emery County

Checking each route to a reactor site against the record: the Carbon site is state trust land that Trust Lands approved leasing to Valar (mine-010, mine-011), where federal claims cannot be staked (mine-021); the Green River and 'Project Beehive' sites are FLPMA land-use applications to BLM (mine-006), with no claims in the Green River footprint (mine-007); the Emery expansion is a land purchase from Emery County (mine-018); the test reactor sits on the state's lab by agreement (orig-045). No mining claim, 3809 notice or plan of operations in BLM's public layers is linked to Valar by name or customer (mine-005, mine-030). Federal law allows an unpatented claim to be used only for prospecting, mining or processing (mine-022, mine-023). Separately, a Notice of Location shows Valar located the RW 453 lode claim in Section 28, two miles south of the lease, on 12 September 2026 (mine-453, csite-019); it was not in BLM's layers when checked in late September 2026, within the 90-day filing window (dir-005).

In plain termsOn the record, the company has not been using mining claims to get land for reactors; it has used leases, federal land-use applications and a purchase, each of which leaves a paper trail. A Notice of Location shows a Valar mining claim, RW 453, two miles south of the lease; what mineral it claims is not stated anywhere read (disc-003).
verified 2026-10-02: Re-checked in late September 2026 against the re-verified facts it cites (mine-005, -006, -007, -010, -011, -018, -021, -022, -023, -030); the conclusion holds on the records read. Updated in late September 2026 for the RW 453 notice (mine-453). Revised before publication (late September 2026): use-limit sentence restated as what the law allows; lease wording now 'approved leasing'.
recordconfirmed No BLM mining notice, plan of operations, lease, permit or easement in Valar's name was found in BLM's public layers (late September 2026)
2026-09 · mine-030 · Valar Atomics, Bureau of Land Management

Queries of BLM's public MLRS layers for 'VALAR' in the customer or case name returned 0 locatable-mineral notices, 0 plans of operations and 0 leases/permits/easements nationwide, and 3 rights-of-way cases (mine-006). The layers include pending and authorized cases.

In plain termsOn federal land, Valar has asked for land-use rights three times and, as of late September 2026, had no mining notice or plan of operations in BLM's public layers. A Notice of Location names Valar as locator of the RW 453 lode claim (mine-453), which was not yet in BLM's claim layer (dir-005).
verified 2026-10-02: Re-checked in late September 2026: 0 notices, 0 plans, 0 leases/permits/easements, 3 rights-of-way. The notices layer description confirms it holds 'Authorized' or 'Pending' cases. No copy of the query results is kept; the figures rest on BLM's layers as they stood when checked.
recordconfirmed No record read ties Valar's reactor fuel to Utah uranium; its planned enriched feedstock may be shipped in
2026-09 · mine-038 · Valar Atomics, U.S. Department of Energy

The Trust Lands memorandum says HALEU, LEU+ or LEU feedstock may be delivered to the Carbon site in certified special-nuclear-material containers under NRC, DOT and DOE rules and made into TRISO fuel there. POWER magazine's 19 June 2026 report on Ward 250 noted Utah hosts the nation's only fully licensed operating conventional uranium mill, but said it would add details on fuel sourcing later. POWER's report on DOE's second round of HALEU allocations (27 August 2025) names Antares, Standard Nuclear and Abilene Christian University/Natura as recipients; it mentions Valar only as a Reactor Pilot Program participant. DOE's own releases on all three announced HALEU rounds (April 2025, August 2025 and July 2026) do not name Valar among the recipients (gov-008). DOE's May 2026 packaging review cleared Ward 250's HALEU fuel for shipment from a federal criticality center in Nevada (safe-010). As of 16 October 2026, no record read names who made Ward 250's fuel or where its uranium came from, or the supplier of Valar's planned feedstock, and none links either to Utah mines or mills. None of the 1,136 Emery County claims created in BLM's system since 2024 carries a name pointing to Valar (mine-003), and no mining notice or plan of operations under Valar's name was found in BLM's public layers, as of late September 2026 (mine-005). A Notice of Location names Valar Atomics Inc as locator of the 'RW 453' lode claim in Carbon County, located 12 September 2026; the notice names no mineral (mine-453, csite-019).

In plain termsValar plans to make its own fuel pellets, but from uranium that has already been enriched elsewhere and shipped in. DOE cleared fuel for Ward 250 to be shipped from a federal site in Nevada; who made that fuel and where its uranium came from were not found in any record read, as of 16 October 2026. A notice names Valar as locator of a mining claim in Carbon County, but it names no mineral. On the record, local uranium mining and Valar's fuel are separate stories.
verified 2026-10-16: Re-read in late September 2026: memo p. 28 quote exact; POWER Ward 250 article (19 June 2026) and HALEU article (dated 27 Aug 2025, not 26 Aug) match. Re-checked 16 October 2026: DOE's May 2026 packaging review added for the Nevada origin of Ward 250's fuel; no record read names who made that fuel or where its uranium came from.
analysisconfirmed The Emery parcel the county agreed to sell Valar (04-0019-0030) is 112.7 acres, matching the ~110 acres Valar says it is buying
2026-09 · mine-046 · Emery County, Valar Atomics, Utah Inland Port Authority

Emery County's 17 February 2026 agenda listed an MOU letting Valar do site-suitability testing on parcel 04-0019-0030 (orig-046); the minutes of that meeting record the item as 'Tabled'. The Utah Inland Port Authority's Castle Country plan (Amendment #3, approved 21 May 2026) gives the parcel's legal description, part of Section 24, Township 18 South, Range 7 East, as containing '112.70 acres more or less'. Valar said on 20 August 2026 that it was buying about 110 acres north of the lab from Emery County (mine-018). Emery County's minutes name this parcel as the land it is selling to Valar: after a 7 April 2026 public hearing on the proposed sale, the commission on 19 May 2026 approved a purchase and sale agreement with Valar for $394,500 (gov-022). On 7 July 2026 the commission ratified a 30-day extension of the due-diligence period under that agreement; the minutes record Commissioner Dennis Worwood explaining that the industrial park north of the San Rafael Lab 'has been sold by the county to Valar'. No recorded deed for the sale was found in the records read, as of 16 October 2026.

In plain termsThe land Valar says it is buying north of the energy lab matches, in size and seller, the 112.7-acre parcel Emery County agreed in May 2026 to sell it for $394,500. A recorded deed would show whether and when the sale closed.
verified 2026-10-19: Re-checked 16 October 2026: the 112.70 acres and the legal description confirmed in the Inland Port plan (Amendment #3, approved 21 May 2026); the 17 February 2026 agenda quote is exact, and that day's minutes record the testing MOU as 'Tabled'; the 7 April hearing, the 19 May agreement at $394,500 and the 7 July due-diligence extension confirmed in Emery County's minutes. The statewide parcel layer first used for the acreage is no longer cited, so its as-of date, block comparison and map point were dropped. Date set to the analysis date.
recordconfirmed Valar's public document trail: nine web posts, four unlisted, two technical PDFs; the safety analyses are not among them
2026-09 · orig-071 · Valar Atomics

Read in late September 2026, the page data behind Valar's Ward 250 page lists nine library posts. Five are listed: 'Valar Atomics is Suing the NRC' (April 7, 2025), 'Roadmap to the American Nuclear Golden Age' (May 23, 2025), the DOE selection post (August 12, 2025), the Project NOVA release (November 18, 2025) and the Series B post (August 4, 2026). Four are not listed but load at their addresses: the Ward250 NSDA post and the QA Program Description post (both dated October 13, 2025), the 'Ward 250 By the Numbers' draft (June 28, 2026, with placeholders) and the 'Ward Zero Whitepaper' (orig-058). The only technical documents found on the site are two PDFs in the site's 'Public Documents' asset folder, the NSDA (document 100403, rev 02, marked Draft) and the QA Program Description (document 100474, rev 02), both linked only from the unlisted posts. Three placeholder posts seen in April 2025, with 'Lorem ipsum' bodies, are gone. Nothing on the site publishes the PDSA, the final DSA, the Technical Safety Requirements, DOE's safety evaluation, the readiness review, the startup approval, the OTA or any Ward Zero test data (safe-007, orig-055, orig-059). The press list's newest entry is dated February 28, 2026 (orig-048), and the Ward 250 page's progress list still stops at the September 2025 groundbreaking.

In plain termsValar's own library of posts and documents fits on one short list: nine web posts, four of them not listed on the library page, and two technical PDFs, one marked 'Draft'. The documents that would show whether the reactor is safe as built, and what DOE required, are not among them. None of the other Valar pages read in late September 2026 links to the four unlisted posts.
verified 2026-10-15: Second check, late September 2026: library and Ward 250 page data re-read: nine posts, four unlisted (NSDA, QA, By the Numbers, Ward Zero Whitepaper), only the NRC post marked noindex; the two PDFs are linked only from the unlisted posts' bodies; NSDA marked 'Draft'; April 2025 archive shows three 'Lorem ipsum' posts, gone by October 2025. Match. Revised before publication (late September 2026): listing wording now 'unlisted'/'not listed'; source title parenthetical now 'unlisted'.
recordconfirmed What DOE has made public about Ward 250 safety, and what was not found: no DSA, TSRs, SER or startup approval, though DOE says its teams reviewed Ward 250's readiness before startup
2026-09 · safe-007 · U.S. Department of Energy, DOE Idaho Operations Office

Public DOE records found for Ward 250 as of late September 2026: the categorical exclusion DOE-ID-26-005 (signed 22 April 2026, posted with a June 2026 web path; csite-020); DOE's 18 June 2026 criticality release; and two DOE Packaging Certification Program documents on rampac.energy.gov (the Model 9979 fuel-shipment Safety Evaluation Report of 20 May 2026 and Valar's transport QA approval of 18 May 2026; safe-010, safe-012). Found on 30 September: the Office of Environmental Management's article of 14 July 2026, which says EM staff took part in DOE's readiness review for the four pilot reactors, naming Ward 250, and in reviewing contractor submittals for advanced microreactor designs, a sentence that does not name Ward 250 (dir-031). Found on 17 October 2026: a DOE Office of Nuclear Energy slide deck prepared for the NRC Commission's 21 July 2026 meeting and filed in the NRC's public document system lists for Valar 'February 2026 – PDSA Approved', 'April 23, 2026 - DSA Approved', criticality on 18 June '(zero power)' and 'July 2, 2026 – full power 100 kWt full power achieved'; it is a summary slide with no document numbers or data (plan-006). Not found on DOE's public sites: the NSDA approval letter, the PDSA and final DSA themselves (the DOE slide gives only their approval dates), the Technical Safety Requirements, DOE's Safety Evaluation Report on the DSA (which DOE-STD-1271 says the approval authority approves), the readiness-review report, the startup approval (signed by the Secretary of Energy or a delegate under the standard), any approval to exceed 100 kWth (none found as of 17 October 2026), and the DOE-Valar Other Transaction Agreement. The NSDA also refers to a Code of Record (document 100437, which it says was provided to DOE with the NSDA) and to a Physical Security Plan and a Material Control and Accountability Plan, which it calls separate controlled documents. The contents of the Idaho Operations Office's document server (id.energy.gov) were not available for checking. An absent posting shows only that a document was not found online; a FOIA request to the Idaho Operations Office would settle whether it exists and can be released.

In plain termsDOE has posted its environmental decision, a press release and its approval of the shipping drums for the fuel. No public copy was found of the reactor's actual safety analysis, the operating limits DOE approved, DOE's own review of that analysis, or the signed permission to start. DOE has said that federal reviewers checked contractor safety submittals for the pilot reactors and took part in Ward 250's readiness review before startup (dir-031); what was not found in public records is the documents and their findings, not a statement that the reviews happened. A DOE slide prepared for a Nuclear Regulatory Commission meeting in July 2026 lists the dates the two safety analyses were approved, but not the papers themselves. Those are the documents that show what the reactor is allowed to do and why DOE thought it was safe. A Freedom of Information Act request can ask for them.
verified 2026-10-17: Checked in late September 2026: energy.gov B5.26 listing, CX, DOE release, both rampac documents and DOE-STD-1271 sec. 8 re-read. Holds. id.energy.gov not retried (it refused an earlier request). Minor wording fixes. Corrected 2026-10-01: wording made more exact against the cited records.
recordconfirmed Carbon County: no safety document of any kind found in the public record for a Valar reactor or fuel plant there
2026-09 · safe-037 · Valar Atomics, U.S. Department of Energy, Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Carbon County

As of late September 2026: DOE's list of B5.26 advanced-reactor NEPA determinations names only 'Valar Ward250 Research Reactor' for Valar; no NSDA, QA program, safety analysis, emergency plan or radiation monitoring plan for any Carbon County facility appears in Valar's public documents, DOE sources or state records read. The state Trust Lands memorandum leaves the emergency planning zone to future licensing and relays Valar's own safety description (csite-009); it describes fuel manufacturing from HALEU, LEU+ or LEU on site (csite-007), spent-fuel storage only on land Valar would buy (csite-008), and both DOE and NRC as possible regulators (csite-010); Utah's 2026 waste-storage exemption fits state-owned test sites, not a private commercial campus (csite-023). Valar's Castle Country page is headed 'Carbon & Emery County, Utah' but its safety section describes only Ward 250 (csite-027). NPR reported on 30 September 2026 that Valar's Project Beehive proposal to federal regulators covers more than 9,000 acres of BLM land near Price, with about 456 reactors, a fuel production facility and nuclear-waste storage (plan-017); on 5 October the American Nuclear Society's Nuclear Newswire reported that Valar's regulatory pathway is unclear. Which federal agency would review a Carbon reactor, and whether its environmental review would be public, is open.

In plain termsFor the Carbon County site near Wellington no safety paperwork was found in public records as of late September 2026: no safety agreement, no environmental review, no emergency plan. That is expected at the land-lease stage; those documents come with licensing. It means every safety statement about the Carbon site so far is the company's own, and the public cannot yet tell whether it will get the NRC's public process or DOE's shorter one.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read DOE's B5.26 listing (five determinations; only CX-271015 names Valar) and Castle Country in late September 2026. Holds. Headline changed from 'exists' to 'found' (absence of a public record is not proof none exists).
analysisreported Valar and published investigations: three report no reply to requests for comment; a fourth interviewed Taylor twice and toured the site
2026-09 · ppl-029 · Valar Atomics, Isaiah Taylor, Kip Mock, The Utah Investigative Journalism Project, Mother Jones, ProPublica, The New Republic

How Valar and its people have responded to published investigative reporting, as the publications report it: the Utah Investigative Journalism Project (July 2025) says Valar 'did not respond to multiple requests for comment' and Kip Mock did not respond; Mother Jones (Feb 2026) says Taylor did not respond on several points, and that his promised write-up on the spent-fuel dose never came; ProPublica (Mar 2026) reports that 'Valar and its executives did not reply to requests for comment'; The New Republic (May 2026) interviewed Taylor in summer 2025 and again in early 2026; when its planned site tour with Taylor fell through (Valar told the reporter he had missed a flight), two Valar staff showed the reporter the site, and Valar's director of communication answered a question about an investor in one line; Jess Housekeeper told the reporter he had not read the ProPublica article and would not comment without doing so. No correction or reply to any of these pieces was found on Valar's website, whose spent-fuel claim remained online when read in late September 2026 (safe-026). Meanwhile Valar calls itself 'very open and transparent' (safe-040) and its staff speak of 'transparency to the public'. A company is free not to comment. Three outlets report no reply to requests for comment, and the fourth interviewed Taylor and was shown the site by Valar staff; no Valar correction was found on its site as of late September 2026.

In plain termsOf four published investigations, three report no reply from Valar to requests for comment; the fourth, The New Republic, interviewed Valar's chief executive twice and was shown the site by Valar staff. No correction of the disputed spent-fuel claim was found on Valar's website as of late September 2026. Valar describes itself as 'very open and transparent'.
verified 2026-10-16: Re-read the Utah Investigative Journalism Project, Mother Jones, The New Republic and ProPublica articles; Valar's NRC-lawsuit post with the spent-fuel sentence was still online in late September 2026. Valar's 'Ward 250 By the Numbers' page opened to confirm 'very open and transparent' (it still shows 'July XX' placeholders); added as a source. Corrected in late September 2026: headline, detail and plain restated to say what each outlet reports; Housekeeper's reply to The New Republic added; Valar's communications staff are described by role, not named. Corrected October 2026: ProPublica says Valar and its executives did not reply to requests for comment, so it is counted with the Utah Investigative Journalism Project and Mother Jones; The New Republic's two interviews with Taylor and its site tour with Valar staff are stated, and the one-line answer is credited to the person the article calls Valar's director of communication; the 17 September 2026 Trust Lands board transcript added as the source for 'transparency to the public'.
recordconfirmed Posted Sept. 25, closed Oct. 1: the state lab hosting Ward 250 advertised a time-limited Safety Manager job to lead its safety program
2026-09-25 · dir-006 · Utah Department of Natural Resources, Utah Office of Energy Development, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab, Valar Atomics

Utah state job requisition 2646 (Department of Natural Resources), opened September 25, 2026 with an application deadline of October 1, 2026, says the Utah Office of Energy Development (OED) is seeking a Safety Manager to lead the environmental, health and safety program at the Utah San Rafael Energy Lab (USREL), 800 N Coal Haul Rd, Orangeville. The role covers work with hazardous chemicals, molten salts, compressed gases, high-temperature systems, electrical and mechanical equipment, radioactive materials and industrial operations; it is to inspect and audit the lab and partner work areas, review new experiments and equipment before authorization, lead incident investigations, run training and emergency drills, coordinate emergency preparedness with local responders and regulators, and coordinate with the lab's Radiation Safety Officer on radiological training, dosimetry, incident response and license conditions, and with UOSH and Utah DEQ. It reports to the Lab Director, with authority to stop work on an imminent hazard. Minimum: ten years of safety experience and a bachelor's degree; radiological safety experience is listed as 'desirable'. The listing states: Schedule Code 'TL - Time Limited'; full-time, in-office, salary '$58.00' (unit not stated). OED owns the lab and is Valar's landlord there (mine-014); Valar reported first electricity from Ward 250 at the lab on July 1, 2026. The listing does not say whether the position is new or a replacement, or who led lab safety before; it does show that a Radiation Safety Officer role and radiological license conditions already exist at the lab. Ward 250's own nuclear safety basis is Valar's, under DOE's authorization; this job is the state's lab-wide safety lead.

In plain termsOn 25 September 2026 the state posted a job for the person who will run safety for the whole state-run lab where Valar's reactor operates: chemicals, high temperatures, radioactive materials and emergency plans, with power to stop work. It is a temporary (time-limited) state job, open for about a week, and radiation-safety experience is listed as 'desirable'. The listing does not say whether the position is new or a replacement; it does mention coordinating with a Radiation Safety Officer on license conditions.
verified 2026-10-02: Read on the State of Utah careers site (req2646) in late September 2026 and archived. Corrected in late September 2026: plain restated as what the listing shows; states what the listing does not say.
recordconfirmed Wellington City Council agendas from May to Sept 2026 had no Valar item; its 14 Oct agenda lists Valar's Harry Hansen; the site is outside city limits
2026-09-23 · csite-014 · Wellington City Council, Carbon County

The Wellington City Council's ten most recent notices on the Utah Public Notice Website (work meetings and regular meetings of 12 and 26 August and 9 and 23 September 2026, a special meeting on 14 September, and the signed 26 August minutes) list no item on Valar, a reactor, trust land or the parcel north of town, and the 26 August minutes (a scanned copy) do not mention them. The Trust Lands memo places the parcel in unincorporated Carbon County, so the county, not the city, is the land-use authority (csite-015). A rescan of all 26 council notices from 13 May to 23 September 2026 (agenda text on the notice website) found no such item either. The council's signed 9 September 2026 minutes, posted later and read 12 October 2026, record a Valar representative announcing the company's open house during public comment; they do not mention the Carbon site. The council's agenda for its regular meeting of 14 October 2026 (posted 13 October) lists an item 'Harry Hansen- Valor Atomics' (the agenda's spelling), after opening business, public comment and a Pioneer Days item; the agenda does not say what the item covers, and as of 17 October 2026 no minutes or recording of that meeting were listed on the state notice website.

In plain termsFrom May to September 2026 the nearest town did not have the project on its agenda, though a Valar representative announced the company's open house at its 9 September meeting, and its 14 October 2026 agenda lists an item for Valar's Harry Hansen, without saying what it covers. The land is outside town limits, so the county, not the city, decides its land use. Wellington's residents would be heard through the county's process instead.
verified 2026-10-17: Holds. Re-read in late September 2026: the council's notice list (ten notices, 12 Aug to late September 2026), each notice's agenda text, and the scanned 26 August minutes; memo p. 21 for 'unincorporated'. Second check, late September 2026: all 26 Wellington City Council notices from 13 May to late September 2026 searched (Valar, Valor, nuclear, reactor, trust land, SITLA, Section 16): none; headline widened to match. Re-checked 17 October 2026: the council's notice list and its 14 October agenda.
recordconfirmed No State Engineer notice naming Valar: 53 water-right notices in the local paper, Oct 2023 to Sept 2026
2026-09-23 · loc-031 · Utah Division of Water Rights, State Engineer, Valar Atomics, ETV News

Utah Code 73-3-6 requires the State Engineer to publish notice of a water-right application once a week for two successive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the county of the source and of use (and on the state's legal-notice site), and the notices set a deadline for written protests. ETV News, delivered to every home in Carbon and Emery, carries these 'NOTICE TO WATER USERS' notices. Its search feed returned 159 items titled as notices to water users from June 2018 to 23 September 2026, 130 of them State Engineer notices; 61 were published between 11 October 2023 and 23 September 2026, of which 53 are State Engineer notices (25 with Emery County applications) and 8 are local water companies' share-lease and canal notices; all were read. None names Valar Atomics or a nuclear use, and none concerns Section 16, T14S R11E (the Wellington lease) or industrial water near Orangeville for Valar. The Carbon applications are mostly irrigation and canal-company changes along the Price River; the Emery ones include coal, power-plant and ranch uses, and a 23 September 2026 notice lists a Trust Lands gravel-operation well 22 miles east of Castle Dale (protests due 20 October). This fits what Valar says so far: its current water comes through Orangeville's system with shares turned in to the city (loc-017), and no record read shows a state application for that; Orangeville's mayor told the city council on 9 July 2026 that talks on the 1,000 additional shares were 'still in the discussion phase' (minutes). It also means no public protest window on a Valar water use was found in these notices. The Trust Lands memo says the Wellington site must buy existing rights and move them by a publicly advertised change application (mine-015, mine-017). ETV's search may not return every notice, and the Emery County Progress, which may also carry them, did not answer (sources_not_read); the state's legal-notice website was not searched.

In plain termsWhen someone files an application with the State Engineer to take new water or change an existing water right in Utah, the state has to announce it in the local paper so neighbours can object. We read every such announcement we could find in the local paper back to 2018: none was for Valar. So the big water question, the up-to-1,000 shares and water for a Wellington campus, had not, as far as the local paper's notices show (to 23 September 2026), reached the stage where the public gets a formal say. Watch the 'Notice to Water Users' column for Valar's name.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read the statute, the latest notice and all 15 feed pages. Count corrected from 62 to 61 for Oct 2023-Sept 2026 (the feed goes back to 2018: 159 notices, none naming Valar). Softened an uncited legal inference about Orangeville's shares.
company claimreported Valar told The Washington Sun it dropped the 10,200-acre site; BLM's public record still listed it Pending in late September 2026
2026-09-18 · mine-008 · Valar Atomics, Bureau of Land Management, The Washington Sun

The Washington Sun (Mara Hoplamazian and Jade Lozada, published and updated 18 September 2026) reported that the largest data-center proposal it found on BLM land 'appears to be' a 10,200-acre project from Valar Atomics at a site near Green River, Utah, and that Valar had a second Utah proposal it called the 'Raceway Gigasite', with no estimated size. An editor's note added after publication says Valar contacted the paper, confirmed it had applied 'for survey access' at the 10,200-acre site, and that a company spokesperson said it had decided not to pursue the project. In late September 2026 BLM's public layer still showed UTUT106784007 as 'Pending' (last modified 26 May 2026) and titled for a reactor and data center, not a survey. No BLM case named 'Raceway' was found in BLM's public MLRS layers searched in late September 2026; the only other Valar case with a site name is 'Project Beehive' (mine-006). Whether 'Raceway' and 'Beehive' are the same site is not shown in any record read.

In plain termsWhat the company says now (the Green River site is dropped; it was a request to survey) and what the federal record shows (a pending application titled for a reactor and data center) do not yet match. That can be ordinary paperwork lag: a withdrawal letter may simply not have reached the public map. BLM's case file would show whether and when Valar withdrew, and what it asked for.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read in late September 2026: article and editor's note match (quote exact, 14 words); BLM status checked again, still Pending, not modified since 26 May 2026. No copy of the BLM search results for 'Raceway' is kept; the absence rests on BLM's layers as they stood when checked.
recordreported Reporters heard officials and advocates in several states, incl. Utah, were unaware of many BLM data-center proposals
2026-09-18 · mine-009 · The Washington Sun, HEAL Utah, Lexi Tuddenham, Bureau of Land Management, Office of the Federal Register

The Washington Sun reported that several local officials said they had not been aware of the federal government's deliberations on data-center proposals on public land; that local officials and advocates in Utah, Arizona, Oregon, Idaho and Wyoming said they were not aware of many of the projects; and that many proposals are not easily found on BLM's website. The only Utah voice it quotes by name is Lexi Tuddenham, executive director of the advocacy group HEAL Utah, who said there is little public awareness of the Utah projects; no Carbon or Emery County official is quoted. A search of the Federal Register for 'Valar Atomics' on 29 September 2026 returned one document, a DOE notice of 6 July 2026 on a Defense Production Act 'Nuclear Fuel Cycle Consortium' agreement; nothing from BLM. In BLM's NEPA register (eplanning.blm.gov), read in a browser on 8 October 2026, none of the 58 projects numbered for 2026 by the Price Field Office and the Green River District Office names Valar, a reactor or a data center; the register was not searched for Valar by name (see open questions).

In plain termsReporters heard across several Western states, including Utah, that local officials and advocates did not know about many of the federal land applications for data centers. In Utah the one person the article names is an environmental group's director, not a county official. The applications can be seen in BLM's public case map, but no Federal Register notice (searched 12 October 2026) or NEPA register entry (read 8 October 2026) for them was found. BLM's right-of-way rule leaves public meetings to BLM's judgment of whether there is enough public interest (mine-028).
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read in late September 2026: the 'several local officials' line is general, not Utah-specific; headline and plain field narrowed accordingly. Federal Register API re-run: 1 result (DOE, 2026-13486).
recordreported ETV News's first report of the Carbon County lease came the day after the state approved it
2026-09-18 · mine-041 · ETV News, Valar Atomics, Carbon County

In ETV News's coverage tagged to Valar (the 14 items from 16 July to 23 September 2026 in its search feed), the first report of the Carbon County land deal is 'Valar Atomics secures land agreement for Carbon County project' (Stephanie Olsen, 18 September 2026), the day after the Trust Lands vote. Each of the 11 earlier items was checked: none mentions Wellington, trust land or a lease. They covered, among other things, Valar's presentation to the East Carbon City Council on 21 July, an August energy summit where Valar's Jess Housekeeper spoke of plans to eventually manufacture reactors and fuel (no site named), the One Utah Summit, Orangeville council updates, and the September open house and planned Carbon County town hall. The Carbon County Commission's 19 August minutes of a Valar presentation also do not name the site (mine-013).

In plain termsPeople who followed ETV News would have learned of the lease only after it was approved. The formal notices (mine-012) did not name Valar, the company's local talks did not mention the site as reported, and the hearings were in Salt Lake City.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read in late September 2026: feed lists 20 items from 25 June; all 17 items before 18 Sept were read and none mentions Wellington, trust land or a lease. Corrected: the summit article says Valar plans to 'eventually' make reactors and fuel but does not say 'locally' at a site. ETV's print edition and other outlets (Sun Advocate, KOAL) not checked.
recordconfirmed Legal basis of the deal: an 'Other Business Arrangement', exempt from the normal lease rule and its 30-year norm
2026-09-17 · csite-004 · Utah Trust Lands Administration, Valar Atomics

The memorandum cites Utah Code 53C-1-303(3)(e) and Utah Administrative Code R850-30-305 as the authority. 53C-1-303(3)(e) (effective 1 July 2026) lets the Trust Lands director, with the approval of the board, enter into joint ventures and 'other business arrangements consistent with the purposes of the trust'. R850-30-305 says the director may enter into OBAs such as lease-to-sell agreements, that 'OBAs are exempt from Rule R850-30', and that OBAs must be approved by the board. The memo says the deal is an OBA because it includes an option to buy. Rule R850-30, which governs ordinary special use leases, says lease terms 'should not normally' exceed 30 years, with extensions not normally over 20 (the director may go longer). The Valar OBA runs 50 years plus two 25-year extensions (mine-011). Staff told the board on 20 August that a purchase option is a 'rare exception' in the surface-lease portfolio (August minutes).

In plain termsThe state used a special kind of deal, a 'business arrangement' rather than an ordinary lease, because Valar wanted the right to buy the land. That kind of deal is exempt from the normal leasing rule, whose usual limit is 30 years (the director can already go longer for ordinary leases). This one can run up to a century: 50 years plus two 25-year extensions. It needed the Trust Lands board's approval, which the board gave by public vote on 17 September 2026 (mine-011).
verified 2026-10-17: Holds. Re-read in late September 2026: memo p. 18 (authority); Utah Code 53C-1-303 effective 7/1/2026 on le.utah.gov; R850-30-200 and -305 in the Sept 2025 rulebook; August final minutes pp. 5-6 ('rare exception'). All quotes exact. Second check, late September 2026: plain text no longer says the OBA exemption is 'why' the term can be long (R850-30-200 already lets the director exceed 30 years), or that the deal was 'legal only' with a vote (the rule says board approval).
recordconfirmed Who would regulate a Carbon reactor? The memo names both DOE (pilot authorizations) and NRC (commercial licences)
2026-09-17 · csite-010 · U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, U.S. Department of Energy, Utah Trust Lands Administration

The memorandum describes a 'dual federal framework': DOE for development funding, pilot authorizations and research, and the NRC for commercial safety licensing and design certification. It says 'NRC licensing is a public process, requiring Federal Register notice' with meetings, comments and hearings, and that Valar will need NRC decommissioning financial assurance, 'Normally' before operations. The August slides list 'Federal oversight by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), US Department of Energy (DOE)' and the DOT. Neither document says which route a Carbon reactor would take. Ward 250 in Emery County operates under DOE authorization (the CX says so), with no NRC licence planned (orig-034). The slides also list 'Decommissioning bond is required by NRC' among the lease safeguards.

In plain termsTwo federal agencies can approve a reactor. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission licenses commercial reactors in a public process with hearings. The Department of Energy can authorize test reactors on its own, with less public process; that is how Valar's Emery County reactor was approved. The state's memo describes the public NRC route for Carbon but does not commit Valar to it. Which route is used decides how much say the public gets.
verified 2026-10-12: Holds. Re-read in late September 2026: memo p. 21 (Federal Regulation and Oversight) and p. 25 (Financial Assurance); August slides p. 49; the Ward 250 CX p. 1 for DOE authorization. Quotes exact. Second check, late September 2026: removed the clause 'the only Federal Register document naming Valar is a DOE consortium notice (mine-009)': mine-009 concerns reporters and BLM data-center filings, and no Federal Register search was re-run. Slide 49's NRC bond line added (exact).
newcompany claimconfirmed FAQ on the Carbon lease: the vote, $400,000 bonus, 50-year term and 'roughly $35 million' match the state's papers; the lease starts with 480 of the 640 acres
2026-09-17 · faq-003 · Valar Atomics, Utah Trust Lands Administration, Utah National Guard · upfront bonus due on lease execution (state memo; FAQ): $400,000; computed: bonus plus 50 years of rent, 640 acres, 3% yearly CPI in five-year steps from year 11: $35,024,420; computed: bonus plus 50 years of rent, 480 acres, same basis: $26,368,315; computed: bonus plus 50 years of rent, 480 acres, no CPI increase: $13,672,000

The FAQ (as of 16 October 2026) says the Trust Lands board voted unanimously on 17 September, in open session, to lease Valar 'about 640 acres of school trust land east of the Price airport', after 'a published board memo, two public board meetings, and a public comment period'; that 'Valar pays $400,000 up front', then yearly rent that steps up, and 'roughly $35 million to the trust over 50 years', from land that previously earned the schools about $200,000 over the same period (another answer gives about $4,000 a year); and that the term is 50 years with 'two optional 25-year extensions that have to be earned'. Where the record supports Valar: the board memorandum in the 17 September 2026 packet lists an upfront bonus of $400,000 due on execution; rent of $30 per acre in years 1-5, $206.25 in year 6, $418.75 in year 7 and $625 in years 8-10, with a CPI-based increase in year 11 and every five years after; and an initial term of 50 years with two optional 25-year extensions, 'provided the lease remains in good standing'. The memo says staff presented the proposal to the full board on 20 August 2026, when the board accepted public comments, before the 17 September vote; the board's published transcript of that meeting records a motion to approve 'on the terms set forth in the board memorandum' and the chair calling the vote unanimous. The memo calls the parcel's past income 'approximately $4,000 per year', which matches the FAQ ($4,000 x 50 years = $200,000). Two other records differ: the board's final minutes of 20 August 2026 record staff saying the parcel yields 'approximately $4,000 per month' from the Utah National Guard, and the board's published transcript of that meeting gives '$4,000 and some change' with no period stated; no record read explains the difference. Set beside the answer: the memo covers up to 640 acres, but the lease would include the 480 acres not under a Utah National Guard lease, with the other 160 acres added later only if that lease is moved. The memo gives no 50-year total, but the Trust Lands staff slides shown to the board on 20 August and 17 September 2026 do: 'Approximately $35,000,000 in lease rents over 50 years' (17 September), and 'approximately $35 million' (20 August). The FAQ's figure is that state projection; the slides do not say what acreage or inflation rate it assumes. This site's arithmetic, using the memo's rent schedule and the 3% a year CPI assumption the memo uses for its purchase price, applied in five-year steps from year 11: bonus plus 50 years of rent comes to $35,024,420 on 640 acres and $26,368,315 on 480 acres; with no CPI increase, $18,096,000 and $13,672,000. Actual CPI and the memo's possible appraisal resets after year 25 would change these totals, and the memo's purchase option could end rent early. On that arithmetic, the $35 million in the slides and the FAQ corresponds to the full 640 acres with 3% inflation, not to the 480 acres the lease would cover at the start. The memo places the parcel about five miles north of Wellington; the FAQ's 'east of the Price airport' was not checked against a saved map record.

In plain termsMost of what Valar's FAQ says about its state land lease matches the state's own papers: the unanimous vote on 17 September 2026, the $400,000 up-front payment, the rising rent, the 50-year term with two 25-year extensions, and the land's past income of about $4,000 a year, as the state's memo gives it (the board's August minutes say about $4,000 a month). The 'roughly $35 million' over 50 years is also the state's own estimate, shown to the board in August and September. One point is stated at its largest: the lease would start with 480 acres, not 640; the last 160 acres come only if a National Guard lease is moved. On this site's arithmetic, the $35 million works out for all 640 acres with prices rising 3% a year. For 480 acres on the same basis it is about $26.4 million, and without any price rise about $13.7 million.
verified 2026-10-17: Checked 17 October 2026: the FAQ answers and the board memorandum read in full; the 50-year totals recomputed from the memo's rent schedule; the vote checked in the meeting transcript; the 20 August minutes and transcript checked for the parcel's past income; the board slides of 20 August and 17 September 2026 checked for the 50-year projection. Quotes exact.
analysisconfirmed Carbon County by government record: hints in Emery minutes from 2025, then state action in 2026, little county record
2026-09-17 · gov-034 · Carbon County Commission, Utah Trust Lands Administration, Emery County Commission, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab, Valar Atomics

Pulling together the government records on Valar and Carbon County (details in the Carbon site and mining records). Earliest public hints came in Emery County, not Carbon (and at the April 2026 hearing Valar also promised 'to be open with all plans', gov-038): the state lab director told Emery's June 2025 hearing that Valar was 'looking at manufacturing in Emery or Carbon County' (gov-020), and at Emery's April 2026 land-sale hearing a commissioner called the lab-side purchase 'an intermediate step' while Valar looks for 'a larger piece of property with water' (gov-022). State steps: Trust Lands mapped the Wellington parcel on 9 April 2026 (mine-048); the state's RDCC notice of 20 April 2026 described an unnamed industrial and power project (csite-032); the Trust Lands board first named Valar on a public agenda on 10 August 2026 (csite-018) and approved the lease with a purchase option on 17 September 2026 (mine-011), its chair having spoken of working so the proposal 'is approved' (ppl-019). Carbon County: its commissioners signed a support letter on 29 June 2026 that no Carbon County agenda read through 16 September 2026 shows (mine-013, csite-026). Federal: no DOE, NRC or Federal Register record found as of late September 2026 names a Carbon site (csite-020, gov-029); BLM lists pending Valar land applications, including one near Green River in Emery County and one called 'Project Beehive' with no location shown (mine-006), which NPR reported on 30 September 2026 as over 9,000 acres of BLM land near Price (plan-017). Not found as of late September 2026: any Carbon County zoning, permit, development or incentive action for Valar (csite-012, csite-029); any GOED incentive for a Carbon site (csite-024 is Emery only); any Utah Energy Research Board or legislative item naming the Wellington site (csite-031, gov-019).

In plain termsPutting the government record together: people in Emery County heard in 2025 that Valar was eyeing Carbon County, and in April 2026 that it wanted more land with water, but no site was named. In 2026 state agencies moved first, mapping the Wellington land and then approving its lease, with a public notice that did not say who or what. Carbon County's commission backed the plan in a letter that appears on no public agenda found. In the records found, no public notice named Valar and the Wellington site together until August 2026, although Carbon County was mentioned in passing at Emery County meetings in 2025 and 2026, and officials had been talking with Valar well before (ppl-027).
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read both cited Emery minutes in late September 2026; quotes exact; cross-referenced facts exist in the Carbon site, mining and people records. Fixed: plain now states the 2025-2026 passing mentions of Carbon County. Corrected in late September 2026: absence stated as 'no record found'; lease wording now 'approving its lease'.
analysisconfirmed Valar before Carbon audiences, June to mid-Sept 2026: no report or minutes read name the Wellington site before the vote
2026-09-17 · loc-012 · Valar Atomics, Price City Council, East Carbon City Council, Carbon County Commission, Cory Gardner, Harry Hansen, Jess Housekeeper, Max Ukropina

Valar's appearances before Carbon County public bodies and audiences in 2026, with what the record of each shows: 24 June, Price City Council, public comment: Cory Gardner and Harry Hansen on Ward 250 reaching 'full power' and a future community event (ETV); the city's minutes record only 'an update on the progress of the company'. 1 July, Carbon County Commission: commissioners celebrated Valar's Emery reactor and NVIDIA plan (ETV; minutes, csite-026). 21 July, East Carbon City Council: four Valar staff presented the test reactor's start, helium cooling, local hiring and tours by appointment (ETV, 23 July); the posted agenda lists no Valar item, and East Carbon's minutes for July and September were not posted as of 29 September (its latest posted minutes are for 16 June). 12 August, the Carbon & Emery Energy Collaborative in Price: plans to manufacture reactors and fuel (loc-002). 12 August, Price City Council work session: the mayor welcomed Valar's Jess Housekeeper and colleagues 'to highlight the new nuclear energy plant in Orangeville', and future plans for that facility (workshop minutes). 19 August, Carbon County Commission, 'Valor Atomics presentation': Max Ukropina and Cory Gardner on the Orangeville reactor, which they called 'walk-away safe', local hiring, and a town hall in Price and an open house 'within the next 30 to 45 days' (minutes; mine-013). 1 September, East Carbon City Council: a Valar representative 'formally introduced the company' and announced the open house (ETV, 4 Sept); the agenda listed 'Valar presentation'. 2 September, Carbon County Commission: open house on 10 September and a town hall for Carbon County residents in late September or early October (ETV; minutes, csite-026). 9 September, Price council work session: staff reported a 'Valar Atomics field trip' set for 24 September (workshop minutes). 9 September, Wellington City Council, public comment: Valar's Harry Hansen announced the open house (the minutes give its date as 8-27-26); nothing else on Valar is recorded (minutes). 10 September, open house in Orangeville for both counties (loc-001). None of these records mentions the Wellington site, trust land, a lease or a Carbon site; the state board heard the lease on 20 August and approved it on 17 September in Salt Lake City (mine-014, mine-011). Price's regular council minutes of 22 July, 12 August, 26 August and 9 September have no Valar item, nor do the Carbon County Commission's minutes of 16 September, the day before the vote. The records are summaries (ETV reports and minutes), not transcripts, so a passing mention cannot be ruled out; the 19 August county meeting audio would settle that one meeting (an open question on this site). Valar held the promised Carbon County town hall on 29 September 2026 at the Southeastern Regional Development Agency in Price, 41 days after the 19 August meeting (within the 30 to 45 days in those minutes) and 12 days after the vote; ETV reported that Valar called the new site the starting point for a larger commercial project (ETV, 30 Sept). Earlier, in October 2025, the local paper had reported a Valar plan for a Carbon County manufacturing hub, without a site (loc-034). On 6 October 2026, at the Carbon County Planning Commission, a Valar speaker said 'We have a site proposed up north of Wellington' (county recording, about 0:57:38; loc-037).

In plain termsBetween June and mid-September 2026 Valar's staff spoke to the Price, East Carbon and Wellington city councils, a Price council work session, the Carbon County Commission twice, an energy meeting in Price and an open house. In every report and set of minutes we could find, they talked about the Emery test reactor, jobs and events, not about the land north of Wellington the state was about to lease to them. That land was discussed at the state board in Salt Lake City. This is the clearest support in the record that Valar did not raise the site with Carbon audiences before the vote, although a Carbon County factory plan had been in the local paper in 2025; the record does not show why. On 29 September, twelve days after the vote, Valar held its promised Carbon County town hall about the site.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read all cited pages and Price's minutes one by one. Correction: the earlier version said Price minutes from 8 July to 9 Sept had no Valar item; the 12 Aug Price work-session minutes record a Valar presentation and the 9 Sept work session a Valar field trip (no 8 July minutes are posted). Neither names the site, so the finding holds. Added the 19 Aug minutes' 'walk-away safe' and town hall promise, and the Oct 2025 Carbon plan report.
recordconfirmed Sept 17, 2026: Trust Lands board approved Valar's Carbon County lease with a purchase option (per transcript)
2026-09-17 · mine-011 · Utah Trust Lands Administration, Valar Atomics · up-front bonus payment to the trust: $400,000; appraised value of all 640 acres ($750/acre): $480,000; staff estimate of rent to the trust over 50 years: $35,000,000

At its 17 September 2026 meeting in Salt Lake City, the Trust Lands board took up the proposed SULA 2095 OBA with Valar Atomics, Inc. as an action item. The auto-generated transcript posted with the meeting records a motion to approve 'SULA 2095 OBA on the terms set forth in the board memorandum', a second, and the chair calling the vote unanimous. Terms in the memorandum: an initial lease of 480 acres (N1/2 and SW1/4 of Sec. 16), with the other 160 acres added if a Utah National Guard lease there is moved; 50 years plus two optional 25-year extensions; a $400,000 up-front bonus; $30 per acre a year in years 1-5, $206.25 in year 6 and $418.75 in year 7 (33% and 67% of the full rental of $625), $625 per acre in years 8-10, then CPI increases in year 11 and every five years after, and possible appraisal resets after year 25 and every 25 years; and an option to buy all or part at the greater of appraised value or the present value of 50 years of rent (about $10.2 million if bought in year 10, per the staff table). Staff said an independent appraisal valued the land at $750 an acre ($480,000 for 640 acres); the 17 September slides give 'Appraised Value: $750 Per Acre or $360,000' for the initial 480 acres and project 'Approximately $35,000,000 in lease rents over 50 years'. The memo gives no 50-year total. KOAL News (1 October 2026), citing 'SITLA meeting materials', reported that the initial lease 'will be for 480 acres at $750 per acre, or $360,000 total' and was expected to generate '$35 million in lease rents over 30 years'. In the slides, $750 an acre and $360,000 are the 'Appraised Value' of the 480 acres; the rent is $30 an acre in years 1-5 rising to $625, and the $35 million is over 50 years. ETV News (18 and 30 September) reported the same rents and about $35 million over 50 years. As of late September 2026 the official minutes of the 17 September meeting were not yet among the posted attachments.

In plain termsA state board has agreed to lease Valar up to a square mile of school trust land near Wellington for up to a century, with the right to buy it. This is a land deal only: it does not approve a reactor, which would still need federal, state and county permits (mine-015). Carbon County residents were not asked to vote on it; the decision was the trust board's.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read in late September 2026: motion quote exact (15 words); vote recorded as unanimous in the auto-transcript; terms match the September memorandum (unchanged from August); staff said $750/acre ($360,000 for 480 acres; $480,000 for all 640) and ~$35 million over 50 years. The agenda lists the item as an action item though the memo's cover page reads 'Notification Item 10A'. Sept 17 minutes still not among the notice attachments (last edited 23 Sept). ETV quote corrected to exact case.
recordconfirmed No comment opposing the lease is recorded at either Trust Lands board meeting; those who spoke on it were officials and Valar staff, in Salt Lake City
2026-09-17 · mine-014 · Utah Trust Lands Administration, Carbon County Commission, Utah Office of Energy Development, Jake Garfield, Tracy Rees, Jess Housekeeper, Harry Hansen, Cory Gardner

At the 20 August 2026 board meeting the public comments came from the three Carbon County commissioners, the Utah Office of Energy Development's deputy director Jake Garfield (whose office owns the San Rafael lab and is Valar's landlord there), Valar's director of Utah operations Jess Housekeeper, and one online commenter, an educator, who spoke about school trust funding. At the 17 September meeting the commenters were Commissioner Jensen in the room, Commissioners Haddock and Martines online, another Office of Energy Development deputy director (Tracy Rees), and five people who said they work for Valar, including its public-affairs staffer Harry Hansen, Jess Housekeeper and Cory Gardner; one other online commenter, a member of the state's Federalism Commission, spoke about workforce housing. No comment opposing the lease is recorded in either transcript or in the August minutes; Commissioner Jensen acknowledged 'a few in our community who will push back'. Both meetings were held at 102 South 200 East in Salt Lake City, with online attendance possible; the notices were posted on the Utah Public Notice Website on 10 August and 8 September 2026. In August the board chair said the committee had felt the need to step very carefully, and that the trust would work with Valar 'to make sure that this proposal is approved and that all the parties are satisfied'. The memoranda record committee discussions on 20 and 28 July (Surface Resources) and 25 August 2026 (Energy & Minerals); the Surface Resources Committee 'discussed the need for full transparency' and asked Valar to keep up local outreach.

In plain termsThe state's decision took public comment, but everyone who spoke about the lease supported it: county officials, the state office that is Valar's landlord, and company employees. No resident of the Wellington area spoke against it at either meeting, though a county commissioner said some residents will push back. That may reflect support, or that people did not know, or that the meetings were in Salt Lake City (one Valar employee from Emery County, who spoke for the lease, called it a 150-mile, three-hour trip); the record cannot tell which.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read in late September 2026: fixed the September speaker list (was 'four people' from Valar; the transcript shows five Valar staff plus OED deputy director Tracy Rees). Added Commissioner Jensen's acknowledgment of pushback and the chair's August remark, both from the auto-transcripts. The 25 August committee meeting is in the September memo, not the August one; source added. Lower-level employees who spoke are described, not named.
company claimconfirmed The Carbon County lease papers: a phased reactor-and-factory campus with no reactor count, size, schedule or job figure
2026-09-17 · plan-016 · Valar Atomics, Utah Trust Lands Administration

The state's lease record (staff memo and slides for the Trust Lands board, August and September 2026) describes the purpose of the Wellington-area lease as 'an integrated nuclear energy, advanced manufacturing, critical mineral refining, and data center computing campus': developing, manufacturing and operating helium-cooled high-temperature reactors to generate electrical power, TRISO fuel manufacturing, component manufacturing, concrete batch plants, training facilities, hydrogen and synthetic fuels, data centers, water desalination and steel. The memo says development is planned 'across multiple phases progressing from manufacturing construction to reactor fleet deployment' and that the campus 'will take many years to build'; rent is a low 'Development Phase' rate for years 1 to 5 (mine-011). The slides say Valar wants to lease the land 'while they complete site permitting'. Nowhere in the memo or slides is there a number of reactors, a power output, a construction date or a job count. Scale figures come from speech and from news reports, not from the lease papers: ETV reported the CEO saying Valar aims to build hundreds of reactors in Carbon and Emery (10 September; loc-001), and NPR reported on 30 September 2026 that a Valar proposal to federal regulators, which NPR reviewed, describes about 456 reactors on more than 9,000 acres of BLM land near Price, with the state land sought as part of the same project (pf-009). That proposal was not found in public records. Carbon County site facts (location, easements, notice, permits, water) are in the Carbon site records (csite-001 to csite-032) and mining records (mine-010 to mine-017); the RW 453 claim notice is mine-453.

In plain termsOn paper, the Carbon County project is a very large industrial park: reactors, a fuel factory, parts factories, maybe data centers, hydrogen and steel, built in stages over many years. But the state's documents give no numbers: not how many reactors, not how big, not when, not how many jobs. The lease mainly holds the land while Valar seeks permits. The big numbers people have heard came from speeches and from NPR's report on a Valar proposal to federal land managers; that proposal was not found in public records, and none of the numbers is in the state's lease papers.
verified 2026-10-15: Checked in late September 2026: memo (Sept packet pp. 18-26) and Aug 20 slides re-read; both quotes exact. No reactor count, power output, construction date or job count appears in either. Initial lease is 480 acres, with 160 more if the Guard lease is relocated (csite-003).
official statementconfirmed Carbon commissioners back the lease, one saying the county has worked with Valar 'since the beginning'; county agendas read did not name the site
2026-09-17 · ppl-020 · Larry Jensen, Jared Haddock, Tony Martines, Carbon County Commission, Valar Atomics

The three Carbon County commissioners (Larry Jensen, Jared Haddock, Tony Martines) signed the 29 June 2026 support letter (mine-013) and spoke for the lease at both Trust Lands board meetings. On 20 August Haddock said the county had worked with Valar 'since the beginning, when they were looking at other states', and praised its public education, 'not hiding anything'; Jensen stressed the lost coal tax base (no county coal for over four years, which holds, mine-039); Martines spoke of the county's energy history, infrastructure and workforce. On 17 September Jensen said the commission is 'committed to allowing these things to move forward' despite 'a few in our community who will push back', and that the 'silent majority' will support it 'as they're educated and learn how safe this process is'. Set beside the record: the commission's agendas from December 2023 to September 2026 name Valar once (a 19 Aug 2026 presentation), its minutes mention Valar only in that presentation and in remarks on 1 July and 2 September 2026, and none read names the Wellington site or the letter (csite-026); no safety document of any kind for a Carbon reactor or fuel plant was found in the public record as of late September 2026 (safe-037); and for the county conditional use permit Valar would need, state law requires approval if harms can be reasonably mitigated and does not itself require a hearing, the Trust Lands memo says Carbon's process includes one, and the conditional-use chapter of the county's 2023 Development Code does not require one (csite-015). The commissioners' long engagement with Valar is stated in their own remarks, in their 29 June 2026 letter ('working with Valor Atomics for over one year', mine-013) and by Valar (ppl-006); no county agenda or minutes recording it before the 19 Aug 2026 presentation were found (csite-026).

In plain termsCommissioner Jared Haddock said the county had worked with Valar 'since the beginning' and praised it for 'not hiding anything'; the letter all three commissioners signed says the county had worked with Valar for over a year. In the county agendas and minutes we read, from December 2023 to September 2026, the Wellington site was never named, and no public safety study for a reactor there has been found. No public safety document for a Carbon reactor or fuel plant was found as of late September 2026.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read both Trust Lands transcripts (Haddock 09:12 on 20 Aug; Martines 38:08 and Jensen 24:57 on 17 Sep) and the minutes. Quotes exact. Fixed: 'no safety document exists' restated as 'none found as of late September 2026'; the permit/hearing point restated to match csite-015 (state law does not require a hearing; the memo says Carbon's process includes one). Cross-refs mine-013, mine-039, csite-026, safe-037 checked. Revised before publication (late September 2026): plain and detail restated as what the records show; absence stated as not found. Revised before publication (2026-09-30): on 20 Aug Jensen spoke on the tax base; Martines on energy history, infrastructure and workforce Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): both quoted phrases are attributed to Commissioner Haddock; see Corrections.
recordreported Dates clash: full power on June 21 in the state's lease memo, yet on June 22 Valar announced 10 kWt of 100
2026-09-17 · plan-009 · Valar Atomics, Utah Trust Lands Administration, American Nuclear Society, Harry Hansen

The Trust Lands staff memo for the 17 September 2026 board meeting, in its 'Applicant' background section, states that Ward 250 'reached full power operations on June 21, 2026' and generated electricity on 1 July. The memo does not say who supplied the date; the next paragraph says 'The applicant represents' what its DOE approvals show. ANS reported on 22 June 2026 that Valar 'is now proceeding with a planned power ascension' and announced that day an output of 10 kWt, a tenth of the reactor's 100 kWt rating. If the reactor was at full power on 21 June, a 22 June announcement of 10 kWt with power ascension still under way does not fit: either the 21 June date is wrong or the 22 June announcement described an earlier step, and no record found says which, as of 17 October 2026. On 24 June Valar's Harry Hansen told Price's council the reactor had gone to full power 'shortly after' going critical (plan-006). A DOE slide prepared for the NRC Commission's 21 July 2026 meeting gives a later full-power date, 'July 2, 2026 – full power 100 kWt full power achieved', eleven days after the memo's date; the slide does not say where the date came from (plan-006). The memo also says Valar holds a DOE 'Certificate of Readiness' and has 'brought and sustained that reactor through an initial testing campaign'; no such certificate was found in public records as of 17 October 2026 (safe-007, gov-037). The board had these statements in its packet when it approved the lease on 17 September (mine-011, mine-016).

In plain termsTwo dated statements, a day apart, do not line up. The state's lease memo says the reactor hit full power on June 21. But on June 22 Valar announced the reactor had reached 10 kilowatts, one tenth of full power, and a nuclear trade journal reported it was still stepping the power up. This does not show that anything unsafe happened. It shows that a date the state had in front of it when it voted cannot be squared with the company's own announcement. A DOE slide shown to federal regulators in July gives a later full-power date, 2 July. No public logbook was found to settle it, as of 17 October 2026.
verified 2026-10-17: Checked in late September 2026: memo (packet pp. 18-19) and ANS re-read. Fixed: the memo does not attribute the June 21 date to Valar; 'first step' is not ANS's wording. Downgraded to 'reported': the June 22 side rests on one report (ANS) of a Valar post we could not read (x.com did not serve it). Vote reference corrected to mine-011 (the approval) as well as mine-016.
recordconfirmed Emery County moves to put 'nuclear development' under its Level III permit and adopts a 180-day pause on new big-permit applications
2026-09-15 · gov-024 · Emery County Commission, Valar Atomics

Emery County Commission agenda and minutes of 18 August 2026 list two items: a temporary moratorium on Level II and Level III conditional use permits while ordinances are updated, and updating ordinances so that large-scale industrial projects, among them solar, data centers and nuclear development, are classified as Level III conditional use permits; the minutes record the item titles with no discussion or vote. The 15 September 2026 agenda lists an ordinance 'establishing a temporary, 180 day moratorium' on accepting, processing and considering Level II and III applications (mine-043); the minutes of that meeting, posted on 8 October 2026, record that the ordinance passed 3-0; its wording covers new applications, and it was determined that it would not be retroactive. At the 21 July 2026 meeting a resident gave an informational presentation on data centers that also raised concerns about Valar and solar projects; no discussion followed. No Emery County conditional use permit item for Valar was found in a scan (29 Sept 2026) of 527 Emery County public notices from 2019 to 2026 (commission, planning and zoning, reinvestment agency, economic development board); its Ward 250 building permit was voted by the commission in September 2025 (gov-021).

In plain termsAfter a year of approving Valar's steps, Emery County's commission began writing tougher rules: nuclear projects, data centers and big solar would all need its Level III land-use permit, the level it reserves for large industrial projects, and it moved to pause new big-project permits for 180 days while the rules are rewritten. The September 15 minutes, posted October 8, record that the pause passed 3-0 and that it would not be retroactive. The change could matter for any new Valar facility that needs a county land-use permit.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read the 18 Aug 2026 minutes, the 15 Sept agenda and the 21 July minutes in late September 2026. Fixed: headline said the county 'pauses' permits, but the moratorium vote is unconfirmed (audio only); 'highest level' was not in the record; quote made exact (the minutes are in capitals). Resident not named.
recordconfirmed Emery County's Sept 15 agenda listed a proposed 180-day moratorium on major conditional-use permit applications
2026-09-15 · mine-043 · Emery County Commission

The Emery County Commission's 15 September 2026 agenda, posted on the Utah Public Notice Website on 14 September, lists for decision an ordinance setting 'a temporary, 180 day moratorium' on accepting, processing and considering Level II and Level III conditional use permit applications. The agenda does not say what prompted it. The meeting's minutes, added to the notice on 8 October 2026, record the ordinance approved 3-0, after Commissioner Jensen said the current ordinance needed cleaning up because some sections contradict each other; that item does not mention data centers. ETV News reported on 21 September 2026 that the review would also make sure county ordinances are ready for projects such as solar developments and data centers. The commission's 18 August 2026 minutes list a temporary Level II and III moratorium next to an item on classifying large industrial projects, including solar, data centers and nuclear development, as Level III uses; ETV News reported that the August moratorium was narrowed to commercial solar. The county also noticed a 5 October 2026 public hearing on a utility-scale solar ordinance.

In plain termsEmery County voted on 15 September 2026 to pause new applications for large land-use permits for up to 180 days while it fixes its rules. The pause could affect data centers or industrial projects on private or county land, including any Valar expansion, though the minutes do not say so; ETV News reported the review is partly meant to ready the rules for solar and data centers, and that in August the commission voted to start updating its ordinances so large solar, data-center and nuclear projects would be Level III uses.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read in late September 2026: agenda quote exact; notice posted 14 Sept 2026. Minutes were added to the notice on 8 October 2026 and have not yet been read, so the outcome is still unchecked. 5 Oct solar hearing notice confirmed.
recordconfirmed A Notice of Location names Valar Atomics Inc as locator of the 'RW 453' lode mining claim in Carbon County, dated Sept. 12, 2026
2026-09-12 · mine-453 · Valar Atomics, Carbon County, Bureau of Land Management

The claim's Notice of Location reads: locator Valar Atomics Inc, 20333 Normandie Ave, Torrance, CA 90501; the 'RW 453' Lode Mining Claim in quarter sections NW and NE of Section 28, Township 14S, Range 11E, Salt Lake Principal Meridian, Carbon County, Utah; located on the 12th day of September 2026. The claim is about 1,500 by 600 feet (1,490 feet east and 10 feet west of the monument, 300 feet each side), which is the largest size a single lode claim may take. It ties the claim's NW corner to the permanent monument at the SE corner of Section 32 (see dir-001 for a problem with that tie). No RW claim was found in BLM's public mining-claim layer when it was checked in late September 2026 (dir-005).

In plain termsA Notice of Location is the document a company must make when it stakes a mining claim. It names Valar Atomics as the claimant, gives the exact survey section, and dates the staking to September 12, 2026. A lode claim is a claim to a mineral vein or deposit in federal land; under federal law an unpatented claim may be used only for prospecting, mining or processing and uses reasonably incident to them (30 U.S.C. 612; disc-003).
verified 2026-10-02: Corrected 30 Sept 2026: reworded the plain-language text.
recordconfirmed Valar's own site first linked its 'Castle Country' page between Aug. 25 and Sept. 9, 2026
2026-09-09 · dir-008 · Valar Atomics, Internet Archive

Valar's website menu is the same on every page. In the Internet Archive's captures, no Valar page carries a 'Castle Country' menu link on 25 August 2026 (captures of /mission, /careers and /docs at 19:31-19:32 UTC), and the careers page carries it on 9 September 2026 (05:22 UTC); there is no capture of any of the pages in between. Every later capture and the live site (29 September) carry it. The Castle Country page itself has one archive capture, 18 September 2026, so when the page was first created is not shown; only when the menu began linking to it. For context: Valar's name first appeared on a public agenda for the lease on 10 August (csite-018), the Trust Lands board discussed it on 20 August (mine-014) and voted on 17 September.

In plain termsThe company's own web page for Carbon and Emery county residents was added to its website's menu sometime between August 25 and September 9: after the Trust Lands board first took up the lease at a public meeting and one to three weeks before the state voted. Valar may have spoken about its local plans elsewhere earlier; this is only about its own website.
verified 2026-10-02: Worked out from archived copies of Valar's pages (7 pages, 105 Internet Archive captures): the last capture without the menu line 'Castle Country' is from 25 August 2026 (/docs); the first with it is from 9 September 2026 (/careers). Of these captures, only the two careers-page captures cited and the 18 September 2026 Castle Country capture are kept; no copy of the others is kept.
recordreported Launch Pad (NRIC, Idaho): Valar moved in with no new money; the program also covers non-federal sites
2026-08 · gov-010 · National Reactor Innovation Center, Idaho National Laboratory, U.S. Department of Energy, Valar Atomics · DOE funding for Launch Pad participants (per POWER): $0

DOE's Office of Nuclear Energy set up the Nuclear Energy Launch Pad with the National Reactor Innovation Center at Idaho National Laboratory on 5 March 2026 (DOE fact sheet) as the successor to the Reactor Pilot and Fuel Line Pilot programs. POWER (Sonal Patel, 28 April 2026) reports DOE 'will provide no funding' and that authorization, NRC licensing and any lab engagement are paid by participants; it has two tracks, Launch Pad INL (about 2,000 acres near INL's Central Facilities Area) and Launch Pad USA, which extends DOE authorization to other DOE sites and non-federal locations. In late August 2026 (reported 25 August) NRIC named 13 more projects; POWER and ANS list Valar, describing Ward 250 (100 kWt) and the co-located 'Valarin' TRISO fuel facility, and ANS says Valar 'is now proceeding with a planned power ascension', citing Valar's 22 June announcement of 10 kWt. POWER says evaluators looked for waste-disposition planning, financial capacity and 'a credible route beyond demonstration'. The INL/NRIC pages themselves could not be read, so the program's own terms were not checked. Launch Pad USA would be the DOE route that could, in principle, reach a non-federal site such as Carbon County; as of 12 October 2026, no record found says Valar has proposed that (ANS reported on 5 October 2026 that Valar's plans for further DOE authorization were unknown).

In plain termsIn March 2026, ahead of the July 4 goal, DOE folded its test-reactor program into a new 'Launch Pad' run from Idaho. It again gives no money; it gives a priority place in DOE's approval line and access to lab experts. One branch can authorize reactors at private sites anywhere in the country. That matters for Carbon County: it is a possible federal path for a Valar test or demonstration reactor there that would not go through the NRC, though the NRC keeps authority over commercial plants (POWER). As of 12 October 2026, no record found says Valar has asked for it.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read both POWER articles, ANS and the DOE fact sheet in late September 2026. Fixed: quote capitalization made exact; the announcement is dated only as late August (reported 25 Aug). Content holds; stays 'reported' because the Launch Pad terms rest on POWER, not NRIC's own pages.
recordreported The state department that hosts and promotes Valar gave it an award, and also houses the water-rights regulator
2026-08 · loc-023 · Utah Department of Natural Resources, Utah Office of Energy Development, Utah Division of Water Rights, Valar Atomics, Isaiah Taylor, Larry Jensen

ETV News (9 Aug 2026) reported that at the One Utah Summit (4-6 August 2026, Cedar City) Valar received the Utah Department of Natural Resources' Horizon Award, and that Isaiah Taylor joined DNR's head, Joel Ferry (ETV calls him commissioner), on the main stage for a session on Utah's role in nuclear innovation; Carbon Commissioner Larry Jensen received a leadership award at the same summit. DNR's 2025 strategic plan lists among the department's units the Office of Energy Development (which owns the San Rafael lab, is Valar's landlord, signed its MOU and runs the state's nuclear education campaign: mine-035, gov-011, gov-025), the Division of Water Rights, which it describes as the regulatory body directed by the State Engineer (the office that would decide any change application for the water Valar seeks, loc-017, mine-015), and the Division of Oil, Gas and Mining; its measures include the state's acquisition of the San Rafael lab from Emery County. An award is not a regulatory act, and the Division of Water Rights decides applications under state law with public notice and a right to protest. Organizationally, the same department houses the office that hosts Valar and, through a separate division, the regulator of the water it seeks.

In plain termsUtah's natural resources department runs the office that owns Valar's test site and promotes the project; in August 2026 it also gave Valar an award. The same department contains the state office that rules on water rights, which Valar will need for any new or changed water use. The Division of Water Rights sits in the same department as the office that hosts Valar; it decides applications under state law with public notice and a right to protest.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read ETV (page dated 9 Aug) and the DNR plan: holds. Date set to August 2026 (summit 4-6 Aug); named the DNR head as ETV does; sourced the protest right. Revised before publication (late September 2026): plain and detail restated as how the department is organized.
analysisconfirmed Officials praised Valar's 'openness' and the lease's 'transparency'; the first public record found naming Valar for the site came Aug 2026
2026-08-20 · csite-028 · Jared Haddock, Carbon County Commission, Utah Trust Lands Administration, School and Institutional Trust Beneficiaries' Advocacy Office, Valar Atomics

At the 20 August 2026 Trust Lands meeting, per the approved minutes, Commissioner Haddock emphasized the county's 'long‑term collaboration with Valor Atomics from the early site‑selection phase' and praised the company's openness; the trust beneficiaries' advocacy director supported the lease citing its 'economic potential and transparency'; trustees thanked Valar for 'open communication' and public engagement. The memo lists the outreach officials relied on: public workshops on nuclear technology hosted by Carbon County, SERDA and the Office of Energy Development with Valar taking part, and a Valar open house at the San Rafael lab; on 17 September staff described open houses from May to September. Carbon's 29 June letter says the county had worked with Valar 'for over one year' (mine-013), and Valar's Max Ukropina told the board of meeting the county in 2024 (mine-018), though a later Valar account puts the first Carbon County visit in early 2025 (ppl-006). Against that, the records read show: no county agenda or minutes naming the site from December 2023 to September 2026 (csite-026); a public notice that named neither applicant nor use (csite-005); committee meetings not on the notice site (csite-017); an April state review notice describing an unnamed industrial and power project, not nuclear (csite-032); a first public agenda naming Valar for the site on 10 August 2026 (csite-018); workshops listed as general nuclear classes (mine-047); company pages silent on the site (csite-027); and ETV News's first report on the lease the day after the vote (mine-041). Commissioner Jensen told the board on 17 September that 'there are a few in our community who will push back' (mine-014). The memo also records that the Surface Resources Committee asked Valar to continue its local outreach 'with a specific focus on the project proposal', noting the outreach so far concerned its San Rafael project and nuclear energy in general. On 19 August Valar told the Carbon County Commission it planned a town hall in Price and a reactor open house within 30 to 45 days, and on 2 September Valar's Harry Hansen announced a Carbon County town hall for late September or early October; Valar held the open house on 10 September (loc-001), within the time it had given, and on 29 September 2026 held what KOAL News called an open-house event with a public Q&A at the Southeastern Regional Development Agency building (rnm-001), within the window given for the town hall. ETV News called it a town hall and reported presentations from Valar employees including chief executive Isaiah Taylor, head of projects Max Ukropina and director of Utah operations Jess Housekeeper, followed by nearly three hours of questions (ETV, 30 Sept).

In plain termsThose closest to the plan (county commissioners, state offices and the company) described the process as open, and pointed to public classes and open houses about nuclear power. But in the records we found, the first public document naming Valar and the Wellington site appeared on the state notice website about five weeks before the vote, for hearings in Salt Lake City. The state board's own committee asked the company in July to make its outreach specific to this project. Both things are true. The records show a gap between the two, and they do not show that anyone broke a rule.
verified 2026-10-17: Holds, with the officials' side added (memo p. 20 outreach paragraph; Sept 17 transcript on open houses) and the headline narrowed to the record naming Valar (unnamed notices were public from April). Re-read in late September 2026: August 20 final minutes pp. 3, 5-6 (Haddock, Mumford, trustees; quotes exact), memo p. 20, Carbon County letter p. 28 (scanned), Sept 17 transcript (Jensen, quote exact). Second check, late September 2026: added the committee's request (memo pp. 25-26, quote exact) and the 19 Aug and 2 Sept 2026 Carbon Commission minutes (scanned) on the promised town hall. Checked 16 October 2026: the scanned 19 August and 2 September minutes pages (quotes exact) and KOAL News's 1 October report on the 29 September event.
recordconfirmed What the approved Carbon lease would allow first (surveys, testing) and what a reactor there would still need (permits with hearings)
2026-08-20 · mine-015 · Utah Trust Lands Administration, Valar Atomics, Carbon County, Utah Division of Water Rights, Utah Department of Environmental Quality, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission

Per the Trust Lands memorandum and staff remarks: the lease would give Valar 'site control' so it can study the land and start permitting; before any earthwork it may survey the property, do geotechnical testing and cultural-resource inventories. Construction needs a Trust Lands-approved development plan, a reclamation and performance bond, and every federal, state and local permit, including a Carbon County conditional use permit (the land is zoned Mining and Grazing, where large industrial projects are a conditional use; that process requires notice, a public hearing and comment); water rights bought and moved through a Division of Water Rights change application (publicly advertised, open to protest); Utah DEQ water-discharge (UPDES) and air-quality permits with comment periods; and NRC licensing, which the memo calls a public process with Federal Register notice and hearings. Spent fuel may not be stored on trust land: Valar must first buy any part to be used for it. The land now carries easements for fiber-optic lines, a power line and a county road, a grazing permit (to be ended before construction) and a 160-acre Utah National Guard training lease.

In plain termsThe lease is the first step, not the last. Under it, Valar may survey the land, test the soil and rock and look for archaeological sites before any construction. According to the state's memo, before anything is built there must be a county hearing, water-rights notices, and state and federal permits, each with a chance for the public to speak. (Valar's test reactor in Emery County runs under DOE authorization, not an NRC licence, orig-034, so which federal route a Carbon reactor would take is not settled in the records read.)
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read in late September 2026: memo pp. 25-28 and August transcript (survey, geotechnical, cultural inventories; development plan approval; bond) match; quotes exact. Plain field now attributes the permit list to the memo and notes the DOE-vs-NRC question.
company claimconfirmed Valar at the Aug 20 board meeting: came to Utah in 2024 (a later Valar account says early 2025) and is 'currently purchasing' 110 acres from Emery County
2026-08-20 · mine-018 · Valar Atomics, Max Ukropina, Emery County, Utah Inland Port Authority, Utah Office of Energy Development

At the 20 August 2026 board meeting Valar's head of projects, Max Ukropina, said the company talked to more than 20 states and that in 2024 he came to Utah and met the Office of Energy Development, the Governor's economic office, SERDA and Carbon County. The auto-transcript then renders him as saying 'the first property I looked at was actually property', back when the plan was to make fuels from coal-plant flue gas; the garbled wording does not settle which property he meant. On 17 September another Valar speaker said 'Max came to look at sites in September', without a year. In later public remarks, including at the Carbon County Planning Commission on 6 October 2026, a Valar speaker introduced as Max put the company's first arrival in Carbon County in early 2025, so the year is not settled by the records. Ukropina said the Emery lab is no longer just a test facility but Valar's 'whole Utah operations', including its fuel facility, and that Valar is 'currently purchasing 110 acres north of the lab from Emery County'. The records differ on whether that purchase has closed: ETV News wrote on 28 July 2026 that, according to Valar, extra water shares would support development on 'the larger property Valar recently purchased from Emery County'; ETV reported on 20 August an 'ongoing annexation of Valar property into Orangeville City'; and the Utah Inland Port Authority wrote on 10 September 2026 that Valar 'has also purchased' more than 100 acres next to the state research center, inside its Castle Country Project Area. Set beside these, Orangeville's minutes record that on 13 August Valar's Harry Hanson (so spelled) said Valar was 'waiting on a clean title to purchase the property', and the city's draft minutes of 10 September 2026, the same date as the port authority's post, record in the mayor's report that annexation for Valar 'has been held up due to mineral rights on the property' and that the city is 'waiting for the purchase to be finalized'; the council approved those minutes on 8 October 2026 with no amendment moved (city recording, about 0:02:00 to 0:02:26). Staff described Valar as headquartered in Hawthorne, California (orig-036).

In plain termsBy the company's own accounts, it began talking to Carbon County and state offices in 2024 or early 2025 (its accounts give both years), well before the public heard of a Carbon County site; when this parcel entered the talks is not settled by the records read. It is also acquiring county land beside the Emery lab to grow there; one record says 'purchasing', others say 'purchased', and the mayor's report in Orangeville's minutes of 10 September (stamped DRAFT, approved on 8 October with no amendment moved) says the purchase was not yet finalized. Emery County's deed records would show whether and when the sale closed, and on what terms.
verified 2026-10-18: Re-read in late September 2026: overstatement fixed. The headline said Valar 'first eyed this parcel in 2024'; the auto-transcript is garbled at that point ('the first property I looked at was actually property'), so that is now reported as unclear. Purchase quotes exact. Added two ETV reports that say Valar already 'purchased' / owns property there, set against 'currently purchasing' (Aug 20); the deed would settle it. Corrected 17 October 2026: Updated 17 October 2026: later Valar remarks give early 2025 for the first visit; Orangeville's minutes on the purchase added. Corrected 17 October 2026: the year of Valar's first visit is given as 2024 or early 2025, since Valar's own accounts give both.
analysisconfirmed Stated scope grew from a 12-month test in a temporary facility (2025) to a long-term fuel-and-reactor base (2026)
2026-08-20 · mine-019 · Valar Atomics, Emery County

In July 2025 Valar told an Emery County town hall, and its slides said, that Ward 250 would be a test of about 12 months with 30 effective full-power days in a temporary facility (orig-045), and its safety agreement set a 12-month run within a life of about 18 months ending in decommissioning (plan-003). The same 2025 slide deck also projected 'Commercial Deployment by 2028', without naming a site. In September 2025 the state's groundbreaking release, printed by ETV News, ended with Valar's own description of itself as 'building America's first nuclear gigasites', and in October 2025 ETV reported Valar's 'current plan' for a manufacturing hub in Carbon County after about three years; neither named a site (loc-034). By August 2026 the company described the Emery lab as its 'whole Utah operations' including a fuel facility, was acquiring about 110 acres beside it (mine-018), had applied to BLM for a 10,271-acre site near Green River and a second site (mine-006), and on 17 September 2026 the Trust Lands board approved leasing Valar the Carbon County parcel for up to a century, for a reactor, fuel and industrial campus (mine-010, mine-011).

In plain termsWhat Valar first told Emery County about Ward 250, a short test in a temporary building, has become a plan for a long-term nuclear industry base across both counties. The 2025 slides did say the company aimed at commercial deployment by 2028, but named no site. Plans can change as a company grows. Valar spoke early of commercial deployment and 'gigasites', and ETV reported its plan for a Carbon County manufacturing hub in October 2025, but the specific larger sites surfaced later, mostly through state and federal land records.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read in late September 2026: 2025 deck re-read (slide 7: 'operates for 30EFPD, in 12 months in a temporary facility'; slide 6: 'Commercial Deployment by 2028'); August transcript quote exact. Added the 2028 line for fairness. Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): 10,270 acres rounded to 10,271, and it notes Valar's early talk of commercial deployment and 'gigasites'; see Corrections.
official statementconfirmed Trust Lands' chair, per the auto-transcript: the trust would help so 'we speak with one voice' and 'make sure that this proposal is approved'
2026-08-20 · ppl-019 · Mike Nelson, Mike Mower, Liz Mumford, Bryan Harris, Utah Trust Lands Administration, School and Institutional Trust Beneficiaries' Advocacy Office, Valar Atomics

At the 20 August 2026 Trust Lands board meeting (the first public board meeting on the Carbon lease), newly elected chair Mike Nelson, a trustee who said he once worked for Westinghouse Electric, said the board wanted to step carefully because the technology is new and can frighten people, and that the trust would help with explanations to 'inquiring members of the public' so that 'we speak with one voice', moving together 'to make sure that this proposal is approved' (auto-transcript). Per the approved minutes, Trustee Mike Mower and Chair Nelson thanked Valar for 'open communication' and public engagement, and Liz Mumford, director of the School and Institutional Trust Beneficiaries' Advocacy Office, supported the lease citing its 'economic potential and transparency'. Outgoing chair Bryan Harris opened the meeting. The board approved the lease on 17 September (mine-011). On public notice, the record shows: no notices of the committee meetings where terms were discussed were found on the public notice site as of late September 2026 (csite-017), and the public notice, in line with the agency rule that keeps applications confidential, named neither Valar nor a nuclear use (csite-005). The board's legal mission is revenue for schools.

In plain termsThe head of the state board that approved leasing the Carbon County land to Valar said before the vote, as the meeting's auto-generated transcript records it, that the trust would help explain the project to the public so that 'we speak with one voice' and 'make sure that this proposal is approved'. The board's legal mission is revenue for Utah's schools; it is not an independent safety review.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read the 20 Aug auto-transcript (Nelson at 58:23: Westinghouse, 'one voice', 'this proposal is approved') and the approved minutes (Nelson elected chair at that meeting; Mower and Nelson thanks; Mumford). Holds; the key quotes rest on an auto-generated transcript. Fixed: 'first public hearing' to 'first public board meeting' (committee meetings came earlier, csite-017); 'the board saw' to 'the chair's remarks describe'; plain calmer. A private online questioner named in the minutes is not named here. Revised before publication (late September 2026): the chair is quoted; headline quotes his words as transcribed.
company claimreported The state's lease memo repeats Valar's performance claims as fact, including full power on June 21, 2026
2026-08-20 · mine-016 · Utah Trust Lands Administration, Valar Atomics, U.S. Department of Energy

The Trust Lands memorandum (August and September versions) says Ward 250 'reached full power operations on June 21, 2026' and generated electricity on 1 July 2026; that DOE reviewed and approved preliminary safety documentation including the Documented Safety Analysis; and that Valar 'has received' a Certificate of Readiness. It also places Valar's November 2025 NOVA criticality 'at Los Alamos National Laboratory'; Valar's own library titles that event a Los Alamos-Valar milestone 'in Nevada', and a Valar speaker told the board on 17 September it took place at a criticality research center in Nevada. DOE's own 18 June 2026 release described a zero-power criticality demonstration; that release predates the claimed full-power date, so it neither confirms nor contradicts it. The Utah Inland Port Authority's 10 September 2026 update likewise describes only the zero-power criticality demonstration. A DOE Office of Nuclear Energy slide prepared for the NRC Commission's 21 July 2026 meeting lists 'July 2, 2026 – full power 100 kWt full power achieved', with electricity generation in the same line; that is eleven days after the memo's 21 June date, and the slide gives no data or source for it. The slide also lists 'February 2026 – PDSA Approved' and 'April 23, 2026 - DSA Approved', in line with the memo's account of DOE approvals. No DOE operating log or independent power record was found in public records as of 17 October 2026 (orig-010, orig-012, orig-013, plan-006). The memo also passes on, as 'information submitted by the applicant', that the site is in a low-seismicity zone with no Quaternary-active faults inside the boundary (see mine-040, where this holds), and, as information provided by Valar, its reactor safety features. On 17 September staff told the board they believed Valar could do what it says, citing its selection for DOE's pilot program and its reactor reaching criticality.

In plain termsThe state board heard the company's own account of its reactor's performance, restated by state staff as plain fact. A DOE slide shown to federal regulators in July lists full power and electricity on 2 July, eleven days after the memo's full-power date, without saying where that date came from; no independent measurement was found as of 17 October 2026. The board's packet carried the company's account and date. The fault statement, by contrast, checks out against the state's fault map (mine-040).
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read in late September 2026: memo wording and DOE release quote exact. FIXED: staff in September cited pilot selection and criticality, not full power; memo says Valar 'received' a Certificate of Readiness (issuer not named). Confidence set to 'unverified' because the full-power and electricity claims are Valar's and remain unconfirmed; that the memo states them is confirmed. Added the LANL/Nevada wording difference (loose wording, not a contradiction) and the Inland Port Authority's zero-power description.
recordreported Carbon County move: state trust-lands board agenda lists a 640-acre special use lease with Valar near Wellington
2026-08-20 · orig-044 · Valar Atomics, Utah Trust Lands Administration

The Utah Trust Lands Administration posted a notice that it had received an application, from an applicant it did not name, for Section 16, Township 14 South, Range 11 East, SLB&M, about 640 acres near Wellington in Carbon County, and invited competing bids to lease, buy or exchange it by August 7, 2026. The board's August 20, 2026 agenda lists a discussion item on a Special Use Lease Agreement (SULA 2095 OBA) for 640 acres in Carbon County with Valar Atomics. It was not the first record of Valar applying for land beyond the test lab: BLM's rights-of-way layer lists a 10,271-acre 'Green River Gigasite' case with Valar as applicant, created February 13, 2026 and shown as closed on October 6, 2026 (mine-006, mine-008). Later records settle what this fact first left open: the board memo gives Section 16 as the lease (csite-002), and the board approved the arrangement on September 17, 2026 (mine-011, csite-001). The notice named neither Valar nor a nuclear use (csite-005, mine-012).

In plain termsIn the public state records found, Valar's name is first tied to its Carbon County site in August 2026, as a lease of a square mile of state trust land north of Wellington. The state board approved it on September 17, 2026 (csite-001).
verified 2026-10-15: Second check, late September 2026: agenda PDF (item 10A, SULA 2095 OBA, 640 acres, Valar Atomics) and Trust Lands notice (Sec. 16 T14S R11E, near Wellington, bids by Aug 7, applicant unnamed; page now marked 'archived') re-read. Match; quotes exact.
recordconfirmed Carbon and Emery move to share a $60,000 consultant to chase coal, gas, nuclear and manufacturing deals
2026-08-19 · loc-029 · Carbon County Commission, Emery County Commission, Utah Public Affairs Consulting, Valar Atomics · joint Carbon-Emery economic development consulting agreement (Carbon approved 19 Aug 2026): $60,000

Carbon County Commission minutes, 19 August 2026, item 9 (the item right after the 'Valor Atomics presentation'): commissioners approved, contingent on Emery County's approval, on Commissioner Haddock's motion seconded by Commissioner Jensen (the motion carried), a joint $60,000 consulting agreement with John Cox of Utah Public Affairs Consulting 'to identify and secure economic development opportunities' across coal, natural gas, nuclear and advanced manufacturing, split $30,000 each with Emery County; Carbon's half comes from unused economic-development consulting funds; the commission approved it contingent on Emery's approval. Emery County's 1 September minutes approve 2027 rural county grant projects that include $30,000 (printed '$30,00') for a 'potential Economic Development Consultant' (the grant money comes from the state's rural county grants); one commissioner said he would rather Emery had its own consultant, not one shared with Carbon; on 15 September the commission 'agreed to move ahead with a possible partnership' with Carbon to hire the consultant (ETV). The signed agreement and its text were not found in the county minutes, agendas and news reports read (to late September 2026). On the same 19 August item 8, the minutes record Valar saying it 'relocated to the region from California two years ago'; Valar's job board listed 71 of its 92 openings in Torrance, California when read in late September 2026, and 81 of its 101 openings when read on 16 and 17 October 2026 (loc-019), and its Carbon claim notice gives a Torrance address (orig-036).

In plain termsThe two counties agreed to share the cost of a paid consultant whose job is to bring in new industry, nuclear included. Both counties took it up in public meetings, and it shows they are actively recruiting new industry. The contract itself was not found in the county records read in late September 2026; it could be requested from either county under Utah's public records law (GRAMA).
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read the Carbon 19 Aug minutes (scanned), the agenda, Emery's 1 Sept minutes and ETV 21 Sept: holds. Revised before publication (2026-09-30): the minutes name Haddock as mover and Jensen as seconder
recordconfirmed Carbon County kept a 'strict' NDA on a $600M factory prospect until Aug 2026; no NDA with Valar was found in records read
2026-08-19 · loc-036 · Carbon County Commission, Larry Jensen, Georgia-Pacific, Valar Atomics · planned Georgia-Pacific wallboard factory, canceled (per Carbon County minutes): $600,000,000

Carbon County Commission minutes, 19 August 2026, 'Unscheduled Public Update': Commissioner Larry Jensen said the commission had lifted a long-standing non-disclosure agreement (NDA) to give an economic update, announcing that Georgia-Pacific had canceled plans for a $600 million wallboard factory on county-owned land because of rising project costs. The plant would have employed 160 people using a gypsum mine in Emery County, and the minutes say the strict NDA was needed to protect the company's plans because the new plant would have closed two factories in California. The same meeting heard the 'Valor Atomics presentation' (loc-012) and approved the joint economic-development consultant (loc-029). A week earlier Commissioner Jared Haddock had said such agreements are typically required by companies, not the county (loc-002). This is a primary record that Carbon County has handled a major industrial prospect under an NDA and announced it after the agreement was lifted, once the company had canceled. It does not show an NDA with Valar: none appears in any record read, and the minutes do not say whether other NDAs are in force. A GRAMA request to the county would settle it.

In plain termsA non-disclosure agreement is a promise to keep talks confidential. Carbon County's own minutes show that a large factory prospect was handled under such an agreement for a long time, and announced only after the company pulled out. That shows the county has used such an agreement for a company prospect. It does not show there was one with Valar; a public-records request for any such agreement would answer that.
verified 2026-10-02: New in an earlier check: found on page 1 of the 19 Aug minutes while checking loc-029. Bears on the NDA question in loc-002 and the open questions.
recordconfirmed Was the Emery land sale finished? Valar said Aug 13 it was 'waiting on a clean title'; the state says it 'has also purchased'
2026-08-13 · loc-014 · Valar Atomics, Emery County, Orangeville City Council, Harry Hansen, Utah Inland Port Authority · agreed price for parcel 04-0019-0030: $394,500

Records on whether Valar's purchase of Emery County parcel 04-0019-0030 (about 112 acres beside the lab, $394,500, gov-022) has closed: 7 July 2026, an Emery commissioner who signed the due-diligence extension said the land 'has been sold' (gov-022), and the extension itself gave 30 more days for a survey (ETV, 8 July). 28 July, ETV, reporting the 21 July county meeting, described 'the larger property Valar recently purchased' (mine-042). 13 August, Orangeville council minutes: Valar's Harry Hansen said Valar is 'waiting on a clean title to purchase the property', and the mayor said Valar was working on a title search and mineral rights and that annexation could begin 'once sale is finalized'. 20 August, Valar's Max Ukropina told the Trust Lands board Valar is 'currently purchasing' the land (mine-018). 10 September, the Utah Inland Port Authority wrote that Valar 'has also purchased' more than 100 acres there (gov-018). By Valar's own account in mid-August the purchase was not complete. Orangeville's council minutes of 10 September, stamped DRAFT, record that annexation for Valar 'has been held up due to mineral rights on the property' and that the city was 'waiting for the purchase to be finalized'; they do not name the parcel or the seller, and the council approved them on 8 October 2026 by a voice vote, without a roll call and with no amendment moved (city recording, about 0:02:00 to 0:02:26). So on the city's account the sale was still pending on 10 September, the date of the Inland Port Authority's update; no record read shows whether it has closed since, as of 17 October 2026. A deed recorded with the Emery County Recorder would settle it.

In plain termsA county commissioner, a local news report and the state's port authority have described the 112 acres next to the lab as already sold to Valar. Valar's own representative told Orangeville on 13 August that the company was still waiting for a clean title before buying, and a Valar manager said a week later it was 'currently purchasing'. Orangeville's council minutes of 10 September (stamped DRAFT, and approved on 8 October with no amendment moved), the same date as the port authority's statement, say the city was still waiting for the purchase to be finalized. No recorded deed was found in the records read as of 17 October 2026, so whether the sale is done now is not settled; a deed at the county recorder would show it.
verified 2026-10-18: Re-read the 13 Aug Orangeville minutes and ETV 8 July: holds ('waiting on a clean title to purchase the property'; 30-day extension for a survey). Other dates rest on the cited cross-references. Re-read 17 October 2026: added Orangeville's 10 September 2026 draft minutes (purchase not yet finalized; annexation held up over mineral rights). Corrected 17 October 2026: Added Orangeville's draft council minutes of 10 September 2026, which record the city still waiting for the purchase to be finalized.
recordconfirmed Residents pushed back in 2026: pleas for data-center pauses reached Emery, Cleveland and Wellington
2026-08-13 · loc-026 · Wellington Planning Commission, Emery County Commission, Orangeville City, Cleveland Town, Carbon County Planning Commission

Public records of local concern, residents described and not named: Wellington City Council's minutes of 11 March 2026 record a speaker's request for 'a 5-year moratorium on data centers' (the same speaker advised that, if considering tax revenue, Wellington should consider energy-producing facilities such as nuclear power) and another attendee's suggestion that the planning commission give the council criteria for ordinances limiting data centers; the city's planning commission then put 'Data Centers moratorium and/or strict guidelines' on its 1 April 2026 agenda (its minutes of that meeting were approved on 6 May but were not found on the state's public notice website as of 30 September 2026); its posted minutes for 6 May, 3 June and 5 August do not return to the item and mention neither Valar nor the trust-land site five to six miles north of town (csite-002), and record no public comments on 3 June or 5 August. At the Emery County Commission on 21 July 2026 a resident asked for a 180-day pause on data-center applications, proposed eight areas for rules (water, chemicals, noise, heat, water-rights transparency, ratepayer protection, emergency power, reclamation bonds) and questioned the county's sale of land to Valar and its annexation into Orangeville (ETV, 28 July; the commission's minutes list only an informational presentation, gov-024). Orangeville's 13 August minutes record that a resident had raised concerns with Valar at a planning and zoning meeting, and Cleveland Town's 13 August minutes record a resident's email asking for a moratorium on AI and data centers, which the council tabled for research. In Carbon County, the planning commission began drafting rules for 'highly contested industries' in August (minutes, 4 Aug; csite-013), and at the Trust Lands hearings no comment recorded in the transcripts opposed the lease: a Carbon commissioner acknowledged 'a few in our community who will push back', and the board's chair and a state energy official spoke of public worry about data centers generally (mine-014). Officials and the local paper in turn spoke of misinformation: an Orangeville councilman on 9 July ('mis- information on social media', minutes), ETV on 28 July about the water shares, and Orangeville's mayor saying data-center talk was speculation (ETV, 20 Aug). On 15 September Emery County approved a 180-day pause on new Level 2 and 3 permit applications (ETV, 21 Sept; loc-024). On 6 October 2026 Valar gave a presentation to the Carbon County Planning Commission; the agenda listed no public comment or hearing item and no vote on Valar, and KUTV reported that public comment was not allowed (loc-037). No local public hearing on Valar's Carbon site was found in the county's notices, as of 17 October 2026.

In plain termsSome residents did not wait to be asked. In 2026 they went to their town, city and county meetings to ask for a pause on data-center projects until rules exist, and to question the Valar land deals. Local officials mostly answered that nothing had been applied for yet and warned about rumours. Emery County has since approved a six-month pause on new major permit applications. In Wellington, the town nearest the Carbon site, the planning board's posted minutes never mention Valar, and in Carbon County no local public hearing on the Valar site itself was found as of 17 October 2026, though Valar presented its plans to the county planning commission on 6 October.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read all cited minutes and reports: holds. Updated the Emery moratorium (approved 15 Sept, not just proposed), added Wellington's later posted planning minutes, which never mention Valar, and replaced quotes that did not bear on this fact.
recordconfirmed Aug 12, 2026: the state energy research board's agenda set its meeting at the San Rafael lab, with a public-comment item and a board tour of the lab and Valar listed
2026-08-12 · gov-042 · Utah Energy Research Board, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab, Valar Atomics

The Utah Energy Research Board's amended agenda for 12 August 2026 (file dated 6 August 2026) places the meeting at the Utah San Rafael Energy Lab, 800 North Coal Haul Rd, Orangeville, 10 to 11 a.m., with a video and phone option. It lists a lab update (item 7), 'OTHER BUSINESS: Open to public comment' (item 13), and, after the meeting, a 'Tour of Utah San Rafael Energy Lab and Valar Atomics for Board Members'. The agenda has no item on a Valar project (gov-014) and does not say whether the public could join the tour. The board's first meeting, on 13 August 2025 in Salt Lake City, at which it approved 'the Valar Project', also closed with a public comment period, in which attendees, per the minutes, expressed appreciation for the board's formation (gov-013). The 12 August 2026 minutes were not read.

In plain termsThe state board that approves projects at the San Rafael lab set its August 2026 meeting at the lab itself in Emery County, with time on the agenda for public comment, and listed a tour of the lab and Valar Atomics for its members afterwards. The agenda does not say whether the public could join the tour, and the meeting's minutes were not read. The board's 2025 meeting that approved Valar's project also ended with public comment.
verified 2026-10-02: Added 1 October 2026. Read the amended agenda (last modified 6 August 2026) and the 13 August 2025 minutes (item 8); quotes exact. The 2026 minutes were not read. On a second check the headline and plain summary were reworded to what the agenda shows: the meeting place, the comment item and the tour are listed; whether the tour took place is not in any record read.
recordconfirmed A commissioner said in Aug 2026 that Emery County has little ordinance language specific to nuclear projects; its planners set out to recommend updates
2026-08-12 · loc-024 · Emery County Planning and Zoning Commission, Emery County Commission, Orangeville City, Green River City Planning & Zoning, Valar Atomics

Emery County Planning Commission minutes: 10 June 2026, a county commissioner said no formal data-center application had been filed though the county had had informal inquiries, and staff said current zoning has general setbacks but no standards specific to data centers; 8 July, members discussed ordinances for data-center water use, cooling, noise and siting, and, in the solar discussion, 'acknowledged previous shortcomings in notification procedures' after residents raised a lack of public maps and project information; 12 August, staff said several different versions of the county ordinances 'had been circulating, creating confusion', compiled one consolidated book as the starting point, and members discussed updating ordinances for emerging industries 'including nuclear projects, data centers, and solar'. On 18 August the County Commission listed putting nuclear development under its Level III conditional use permit and a moratorium on Level II and III permits, and on 15 September an ordinance for a 180-day moratorium (gov-024, mine-043). ETV reports that on 18 August the commission suspended new commercial solar applications and directed ordinance changes classifying large-scale industrial projects, 'including solar, data centers and nuclear facilities', as Level III conditional uses, with Commissioner Keven Jensen noting the county 'currently has little specific ordinance language' on data centers or nuclear development, and that on 15 September it unanimously approved a 180-day pause on new Level 2 and Level 3 applications, not affecting projects already in process (the minutes, posted 8 October 2026, record a 3-0 vote and that the pause is not retroactive). For the Ward 250 building the commission voted the building permit itself (gov-021). Valar's lab-side parcel is headed for annexation into Orangeville, whose planning commission discussed an 'Advanced Energy and Manufacturing' zone ordinance in July 2026 (loc-013); the city council's draft minutes of 10 September 2026 record the annexation as held up over mineral rights on the property, with the city waiting for the purchase to be finalized (loc-014); the council approved those minutes on 8 October 2026 with no amendment moved, and at that meeting a city official reported that the city is creating ordinances it 'might possibly need in the future, like a heavy industrial manufacturing ordinance', naming no company (city recording, about 0:02:00 to 0:02:26 and 0:55:24 to 0:55:47). Green River City's planning commission put 'Discuss Nuclear Reactors - When, where, why, how' and a matching data-centers item on its 21 July and 18 August 2026 agendas (state notice site; only audio of those meetings was posted as of late September 2026).

In plain termsThe county that hosts Valar's test reactor had, as of mid-2026, no zoning standards written for data centers and little ordinance language specific to nuclear plants, and its planners found that different versions of the county's own rulebook had been in circulation. They began compiling ordinance updates in August 2026, and in September the county approved a six-month pause on new applications for major permits while they do. The main Valar expansion may end up under the town of Orangeville's rules instead.
verified 2026-10-18: Re-read the three planning minutes and both ETV reports: holds. The Green River sentence had no cited source; read both agendas on the state notice site and added them (Green River's own website could not be read). Plain field no longer calls the reactor Utah's first 'privately built'.
official statementreported Aug 12, 2026: a Carbon commissioner said project nondisclosure agreements are usually the companies' demand
2026-08-12 · loc-002 · Jared Haddock, Carbon County Commission, Valar Atomics, Southeastern Regional Development Agency · Carbon County taxable value lost over a decade, per Commissioner Haddock (roughly, as ETV reported it): $1,000,000,000

ETV News (14 Aug 2026) reported the Carbon & Emery Energy Collaborative held on 12 August 2026 at the Southeastern Regional Development Agency's offices in Price. Carbon County Commissioner Jared Haddock said the county had lost roughly $1 billion in taxable value over the past decade and that one large data center could provide a tax base comparable to about 4,200 homes. Beside that figure, the Tax Commission's annual reports show the value of centrally assessed property (mines, oil and gas, utilities and railroads, which the State values) down about $243 million from 2015 to 2025 and $879 million from 2008 to 2025, while total taxable value rose over both periods; the county's June 2026 minutes record another $48 million drop in 2026. He also addressed concerns about nondisclosure agreements connected to economic development projects, saying (as ETV paraphrased him) that such agreements are typically required by the private companies considering an area rather than by the county, and that another company was looking at bringing industry to Carbon County, with details limited. At the same event Valar's Jess Housekeeper spoke of plans to eventually manufacture reactors and fuel (loc-003). The report names no Valar site. Eight days later Haddock told the Trust Lands board the county had worked with Valar 'since the beginning' (ppl-020). One week after the summit, the commission's own minutes (19 Aug 2026) record it lifting a 'long-standing' NDA on a separate $600 million factory prospect that had been canceled (loc-036). No nondisclosure agreement between Carbon County and Valar appears in any record read; neither the report nor the minutes say one exists.

In plain termsA nondisclosure agreement (NDA) is a contract to keep talks confidential. A Carbon County commissioner said in public that such agreements come up in economic-development talks and are usually the company's demand, not the county's, and a week later the county's own minutes recorded that a big factory prospect had been under a long-standing NDA, lifted and announced after the company canceled (loc-036). It does not show that the county signed one with Valar: a public-records (GRAMA) request to Carbon County for any NDA or confidentiality agreement with Valar would settle that.
verified 2026-10-03: Re-read ETV 14 Aug: holds as ETV's paraphrase of Haddock. Replaced a quote that was Housekeeper's, not Haddock's. Added the 19 Aug minutes recording a county NDA on another project (loc-036). Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): the amount is labeled as ETV's rounded report and set beside the Tax Commission's annual reports; see Corrections.
recordconfirmed The first public Trust Lands agenda found naming Valar is dated Aug 10, 2026, for the full board's initial consideration of the lease, four months after it was mapped
2026-08-10 · csite-018 · Utah Trust Lands Administration, Valar Atomics

The Trust Lands board's 2026 agendas and packets for 22 January, 5 and 19 February, 19 March, 16 April, 21 May and 18 June do not mention Valar, SULA 2095, Section 16 or Wellington. They do name other applicants in agenda titles (for example 'with ST Oil Utah, LLC' in January), and the 16 April agenda lists a closed session, citing Utah Code 53C-1-201(8)(a)(i), on market conditions for possible sales of unnamed trust assets; no link between it and this lease was found in the records read. The lease map was produced on 9 April 2026 (mine-048) and the state RDCC review notice, which did not name Valar, ran from 20 April (csite-032). Valar's name first appears in the notice for the 20 August meeting, posted 10 August (orig-044, mine-014); the board voted on 17 September (mine-011). The board's notice list shows no board meeting in July.

In plain termsFrom the state's side, the first public record found naming Valar for this site dates from August 2026. The lease had been mapped in April, posted for state review in April without Valar's name or the word nuclear (csite-032), and discussed by a board committee on 20 and 28 July, but the first public agenda naming Valar came out ten days before the August board meeting and about five weeks before the vote. That is within the law's notice rules (csite-016); the board meetings were held in Salt Lake City, with online participation offered. The board's memo says the committee suggested a discussion at the August meeting and a possible vote in September because its members 'wanted to ensure the full board had ample time to evaluate the proposal and that stakeholders were informed'.
verified 2026-10-17: Holds. Re-read in late September 2026: the seven 2026 board notices before August and all 48 attached documents, including the scanned pages: no Valar, SULA 2095, Section 16 or Wellington. The 20 August notice was posted 10 August 2026. Quotes exact. Copies of the 5 February, 19 February, 19 March, 21 May and 18 June notices were not kept; for those meetings the finding rests on the notices as read in late September 2026. Re-checked 17 October 2026: holds.
recordconfirmed The public notice for the Wellington parcel named neither Valar nor a nuclear use; the memo says other notices were also given
2026-08-07 · mine-012 · Utah Trust Lands Administration, Valar Atomics, Carbon County Commission, Southeastern Regional Development Agency, Utah Division of Water Rights

Trust Lands' public notice for the parcel (now archived) said the agency had received an application on 640 acres in Sec. 16, T14S R11E near Wellington and invited competing bids to lease, buy or exchange it by 5 p.m. on 7 August 2026 (with $51,100 in deposits and fees). It did not name the applicant or say what the land would be used for. The board memorandum says notices were also posted in the local newspaper (not named), on the agency website, and sent to existing lessees, permittees and adjoining landowners under rule R850-30-500; that notice ran for 30 days on the state Resource Development Coordinating Committee (RDCC) dashboard and went to the Carbon County Commission and the Southeastern Regional Development Agency; and that no competing offers came in. The only agency comment the memo records is from the Division of Water Rights.

In plain termsTrust Lands' memo says other notices were also given. The state's public notice, and a matching notice in ETV News (loc-032), said only that 'an application' had been received for the land, not who or what for; the agency's rule keeps an initial application confidential (csite-005). Someone reading them would not have learned that a nuclear company wanted the land.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read in late September 2026: notice (archived) names no applicant or use; deadline 5:00 PM 7 Aug 2026; $50,000 + $700 + $250 + $150 = $51,100. Memo notice paragraph matches; quote exact. The date field is the bid deadline; the notice's first posting date is not shown on the page. Revised before publication (2026-09-30): reworded the plain-language text.
recordconfirmed Carbon County's planners are drafting rules for big 'contested' projects and data centers; the zoning administrator would like a hearing in November
2026-08-04 · csite-013 · Carbon County Planning Commission

Signed minutes of the 4 August 2026 Planning Commission meeting (scanned) record the zoning administrator presenting a map of possible development areas with a one-mile buffer around cities for 'big infrastructure projects' and a half-mile buffer around county addresses, limited to the Mining & Grazing zone. A commissioner proposed a conditional overlay permit for 'highly contested industries' and said he did not want large computer companies to 'fly under the guise of Industrial zoning'; members listed possible conditions (water use, evaporation, heat, power supply, the county's finances). The administrator asked members to list conditions and said he would like a public hearing in November 2026, aiming to finish the code update by year end. Valar, nuclear power and the Wellington parcel are not mentioned. The parcel lies about five miles from Wellington (csite-002), outside a one-mile city buffer.

In plain termsThe county is writing new rules that could set conditions on very large industrial projects such as data centers, and its zoning administrator would like a public hearing on them in November 2026. The minutes do not say whether nuclear plants or Valar's campus are in view. The minutes say the hearing would gather public feedback before the code update is finished.
verified 2026-10-02: Holds. Re-read in late September 2026: August 4 minutes pp. 5-6 (the rest searched for Valar/nuclear/reactor/Wellington: none). Quote exact. The speaking commissioner is named in the minutes; here described by role.
recordconfirmed Board committees discussed the lease before the vote, as they did other deals; no notices of the board's committee meetings were found on the state notice website
2026-07-28 · csite-017 · Utah Trust Lands Administration

The memoranda say the Trust Lands board's Surface Resources Committee discussed the Valar lease on 20 July 2026 and again on 28 July, when Valar presented, and that the Energy & Minerals Committee discussed it on 25 August; the committees raised safety, water, radioactive materials, outreach and 'the need for full transparency', and directed staff to discuss some of the proposed financial terms further with Valar (mine-014). Committee review before a board vote was not special to this lease: the board's approved minutes for 20 August say two geothermal agreements and a minerals agreement approved that day were 'reviewed in the Energy and Minerals Committee meeting in July', and that a development deal at St. George Regional Airport was reviewed at the Real Estate Committee's July meeting; the same minutes note the Valar lease's two July committee reviews. As of late September 2026, the Trust Lands board's page on the Utah Public Notice Website lists board meetings only (its five most recent, April to September 2026) and no committee meetings. As of late September 2026, no agenda, minutes or recording of these committee meetings was found on the Utah Public Notice Website or in the board packets read. Whether board committees are 'public bodies' under the Open and Public Meetings Act (whose definition includes, among other tests, being supported in whole or part by tax revenue and being 'vested with the authority to make decisions regarding the public's business') is a legal question the records read do not answer.

In plain termsSome of the detailed discussion of the Wellington lease, including the company's presentation and the call for transparency, happened in two board committees whose meetings were not found on the state's public notice site. The board handled other deals the same way: its minutes show other agreements going through board committees first, and no notices of those committee meetings were found either; its memo later summarized the Valar discussions. The full board's votes were public; no agenda or minutes of the committee work on the deal were found in the public records searched. A records request would show whether minutes exist.
verified 2026-10-02: Holds, with two fixes: 'renegotiate' overstated the memo ('further discussion ... regarding some of the proposed financial terms'), and an unsourced remark on how Trust Lands is funded was removed. Re-read in late September 2026: memo pp. 25-26; PMN entity 30 body list (SITLA Board of Trustees, SITLA Wildlife Advisory Committee, Trust Lands Administration Board of Trustees) and body 69/8609 notice lists (2026 board meetings only; none in July).
analysisconfirmed DOE says it beat the July 4 goal with four reactors; three were at Idaho National Laboratory, only Ward 250 outside
2026-07-24 · gov-006 · U.S. Department of Energy, Valar Atomics, Antares Nuclear, Deployable Energy, Aalo Atomics, Idaho National Laboratory

EO 14301's pilot program is for reactors 'outside the National Laboratories' (gov-005), and DOE's program page still describes the aim as three reactors 'located outside of the national laboratories' by 4 July 2026. DOE's releases then count four criticalities toward that goal: Antares's Mark-0 (4 June 2026, at INL), Valar's Ward 250 (18 June, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab), Deployable Energy's Unity (30 June, at INL, under DOE's Nuclear Energy Launch Pad, which DOE calls 'the next evolution' of the pilot program, and not on the pilot program's selection list) and Aalo-X (4 July, at INL). DOE's 1 July release says Unity's criticality marked 'the fulfillment' of the order's directive; its 25 July fact sheet says DOE 'delivered and exceeded' the goal with four and that four pilot projects would be hosted at the INL site. By DOE's own descriptions, Ward 250 is the only one of the four outside a national laboratory; all four were zero-power criticality demonstrations. For Valar, DOE's statement that Ward 250 was the first DOE-authorized reactor built outside a national laboratory (orig-010) holds. Measured against the order's own wording, a pilot program 'outside the National Laboratories', only Ward 250 qualifies. DOE's application rules, as Hogan Lovells summarized them, did let pilot applicants site reactors on land managed by a national laboratory, which is how Antares and Aalo came to count (gov-032); the gap is between the order's title and how DOE ran and counted the program; DOE's own releases state where each reactor was.

In plain termsThe president asked for three test reactors running outside the national laboratories by July 4, 2026. DOE announced four, but three of them were at Idaho National Laboratory, a national laboratory. Valar's Ward 250 in Emery County was the only one actually outside a lab. DOE's own rules for applicants allowed reactors on laboratory land, so this is about what the goal meant; DOE's own releases say where each reactor was.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read the DOE program page, 1 July and 6 July releases, the 25 July fact sheet and EO 14301, in late September 2026; quotes exact. Fixed: the 'holds only for Valar' line now notes that DOE's RFA (per Hogan Lovells, read in late September 2026) allowed siting on national-lab land, so the INL reactors were within DOE's own program rules. Wording restated in late September 2026.
analysisconfirmed DOE's three announced HALEU rounds named nine recipients; Valar was never among them, yet DOE cleared HALEU fuel shipments to Ward 250
2026-07-23 · gov-008 · U.S. Department of Energy, National Nuclear Security Administration, Valar Atomics, HALEU Availability Program

DOE's HALEU Availability Program is the announced route by which companies get high-assay low-enriched uranium from federal stocks, including NNSA material. DOE's releases name the recipients of each round's conditional commitments (ten commitments to nine recipients; Radiant twice): round 1 (9 April 2025, 15 companies had applied) TRISO-X, Kairos, Radiant, Westinghouse and TerraPower; round 2 (26 August 2025) Antares, Standard Nuclear and Abilene Christian University/Natura; round 3 (23 July 2026) NASA and Radiant again. Valar is not in any of them. DOE's Fuel Line Pilot launch release makes each company responsible for 'the procurement of all nuclear material feedstock' (gov-007), and its 30 September 2025 selection release, which named Valar, says selected companies may apply for HALEU through the HALEU Availability Program (orig-032). Set beside that: Valar says it supplied the HALEU TRISO fuel for NOVA at Los Alamos's Nevada criticality center (orig-008), and DOE's own May 2026 packaging review cleared limited shipments of HALEU TRISO fuel compacts, packed in a Valar graphite fuel block holding about 235 grams of uranium-235 at under 20% enrichment, from that federal center to Ward 250, with DOE's Savannah River Operations Office as the applicant (safe-010, safe-012). As of 12 October 2026, no public record read says where Valar's HALEU came from, who owns it, whether it is federal material on loan, or on what terms. The pilot program's own Request for Application, as summarized by the law firm Hogan Lovells, told applicants needing HALEU to 'ensure they are in the allocation process' of that program (gov-032). This is a gap in the public record, not evidence of wrongdoing; the fuel may have been supplied under the OTA or another agreement not found in public records (gov-003).

In plain termsHALEU is uranium enriched to between 5% and 20%, more than ordinary power-plant fuel, and DOE says none is available from domestic suppliers, so DOE hands out federal stock through an announced program. In its three announced rounds DOE named every company it promised HALEU to, and Valar is not on the list. Yet DOE's own shipping review cleared HALEU fuel to be shipped from a federal site in Nevada to Valar's Utah reactor. Where that uranium came from, who owns it and what Valar paid or promised for it was not found in public records as of 12 October 2026; a FOIA request could ask for it.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read the three HALEU releases, the 9979 SER (20 May 2026) and Hogan Lovells in late September 2026. Fixed: 'ten recipients' was ten commitments to nine recipients; the HALEU-application line comes from DOE's Sept 2025 selection release (now cited), not the July launch release; the SER covers fuel compacts in a graphite block. The core gap (no public HALEU allocation to Valar) holds.
recordconfirmed Orangeville is drafting an 'Advanced Energy and Manufacturing' zone for Valar's land; drafts to go through city and Valar attorneys
2026-07-16 · loc-013 · Orangeville City Council, Orangeville City Planning and Zoning, Valar Atomics, Jess Housekeeper, Emery County Commission, Castle Valley Special Service District

Orangeville City records: on 11 December 2025 the mayor told the council he would like to see Valar annexed into the city (minutes; he had first raised annexation in September 2025). On 17 March 2026 a special service district asked Emery County to require that Valar annex the parcel next to the lab into Orangeville (gov-022), and on 19 May the county sent annexation notices (gov-022); on 21 May the Castle Valley Special Service District board reviewed pending annexations including property near Orangeville 'that may be developed by Valor', noting recent state law changes that allow a streamlined annexation by landowner petition (minutes). The city's 11 June minutes record staff 'working on annexation requirements' and the mayor meeting Valar about annexation. On 9 July council minutes record staff 'working on Nuclear Energy Ordinance', and that the city had sent a draft of 'the nuclear energy industry ordinance' being coded to allow Valar to be annexed; the annexation process was to begin at the August meeting with a Valar representative present. The Planning and Zoning Commission's 16 July minutes record an agenda item 'Ordinance I-2 Advanced Energy and Manufacturing District', with Valar's Jess Housekeeper present as its representative: 'There needs to be a plan for an ordinance for this company and future companies', he 'explained the wants and needs for this company', a public meeting would need to be posted by 30 July in draft form, and 'Everything needs to go through the attorneys from the City and Valar.' The commission's later agendas (11 August, 8 September, 17 September work meeting) do not list the I-2 ordinance, and no public hearing on it was found in the council's or the planning commission's notices, as of 17 October 2026 (the council's 8 October agenda has a hearing on a disinterment fee and no annexation, zoning or Valar item; the planning commission's latest listed meeting, on 13 October, has only an audio recording posted). In the reports at the end of the council's 8 October meeting, a city official said 'There may or may not be an annexation' in the future, naming no party, and that the city is creating ordinances it 'might possibly need in the future, like a heavy industrial manufacturing ordinance', with conditional use permits and comprehensive water ordinances, so that they are in place before any applications are turned in; no company was named in that report (city recording, about 0:55:18 to 0:57:47). On 13 August the mayor said annexation could begin once the sale is final (loc-014). The planning commission's 8 September agenda and the council's 10 September agenda list an 'Updated Annexation Policy', the council's item 'to reflect legislative changes'. The council's minutes of that 10 September meeting, stamped DRAFT in the saved copy and approved by the council on 8 October 2026 by a voice vote, without a roll call and with no amendment moved (city recording, about 0:02:00 to 0:02:26), record all five council members voting yes on a motion to 'Approve Annexation policy to reflect legislative changes', and record that annexation for Valar (spelled 'Valor') 'has been held up due to mineral rights on the property' and that the city was 'waiting for the purchase to be finalized to begin the annexation process'. The minutes do not name the parcel or the seller. At the county, commissioners said on 21 July that annexation would put the land under Orangeville's authority for services and future land-use decisions, that it was meant to let Orangeville provide services such as water and sewer, and that it had been considered before Valar's current development plans (ETV, 28 July).

In plain termsValar's growing Emery site may be moved from county control into the town of Orangeville: the county has sent annexation notices, and the mayor said annexation could begin once the sale is final. In July 2026 the town was writing a new zoning district, called I-2 'Advanced Energy and Manufacturing', meant for this company and future companies, and its planning minutes say the draft goes through both the city's lawyers and Valar's. Zoning is what decides what can be built and where. No public hearing notice on the new zone was found in the city's or planning commission's posted notices as of 17 October 2026; when one is, it will be residents' chance to comment. The council's minutes of 10 September, approved on 8 October with no amendment moved, say the annexation was held up over mineral rights while the city waited for the purchase to be finalized. On 8 October a city official told the council the city is writing new ordinances, such as one for heavy industrial manufacturing, before any applications come in; no company was named.
verified 2026-10-18: Re-read 17 October 2026: added the council's 10 September 2026 draft minutes (annexation held up over mineral rights; annexation policy approved) and its 8 October agenda; no hearing on the zone found as of 17 October 2026. Earlier: re-read all minutes, agendas and both notice lists: holds. Made the 8-10 Sept item exact (agenda listings, not recorded action), described Housekeeper as the minutes do, added the CVSSD May annexation discussion, and removed an uncited legal claim from the plain-language summary.
recordconfirmed The public workshops cited as outreach were advertised as general nuclear classes; their listings did not mention the Wellington site
2026-07-16 · mine-047 · Utah Office of Energy Development, Southeastern Regional Development Agency, Carbon County, Valar Atomics

The Trust Lands memorandum cites public workshops hosted by Carbon County, SERDA and the Utah Office of Energy Development, in which Valar took part, as part of the outreach behind the lease (mine-012, mine-014). The Office of Energy Development's events page lists a 'Carbon County– Community Nuclear Series' at the Carbon County Event Center in Price on 21 May and 18 June (both described as a look at how modern SMRs work) and 16 July 2026 (how modern nuclear waste is handled, stored and reused). The listings do not mention Valar, Wellington, trust lands or a planned campus. Staff told the board in September that further sessions were held in August and the week before the 17 September meeting; those are not on the events page. Whether the Wellington site was discussed at any session is not in the records read.

In plain termsResidents were offered classes on nuclear power in Price over the summer, which is real outreach. But as advertised, they were about the technology in general, not about the specific plan to put a reactor campus north of Wellington.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read in late September 2026: events page listings and the September staff remarks match.
recordconfirmed The Wellington notice ran in ETV July 15-29 and named no use; of three other Trust Lands notices read from that paper, two named a use and one gave only a lease number
2026-07-15 · loc-032 · Utah Trust Lands Administration, ETV News, Valar Atomics · earnest money required of any competing bidder: $50,000

The newspaper notice the Trust Lands memo mentions without naming the paper (csite-005, mine-012) matches ETV News's 'TRUST LANDS OPPORTUNITY', published 15, 22 and 29 July 2026: Trust Lands 'has received an application on the following property near Wellington' (T14S R11E, Section 16, about 640 acres) and will take bids to lease, buy or exchange it by 5 p.m. on 7 August 2026; a bidder must submit a bid, a development plan and an application with $50,000 earnest money and $1,100 in fees; details by phone or at the Monticello office. It names no applicant, no use and no lease number (the lease was already numbered SULA 2095 and mapped by 9 April, mine-048). The first printing gave 23 days to prepare a competing bid and development plan; the web notice had gone up on 8 July (csite-005). The same agency's notices in the same paper do sometimes state the use: a 19 August 2026 notice for 319.55 acres of Carbon County trust land says the application is 'for a commercial photovoltaic solar power generation project', and a 24 June 2026 notice describes an application to remove sand and gravel; a December 2025 Emery notice gives no use but cites its lease number (SULA 2087). Those three notices ran under the heading 'PUBLIC NOTICE' and directed applications to the agency's Salt Lake City office; the Wellington notice ran under the heading 'TRUST LANDS OPPORTUNITY', directed bids to its Southeastern Area Office in Monticello, and was the only one of the four to ask for a development plan and earnest money. The one that gave no use, SULA 2087, is, like the Wellington lease (SULA 2095), a special use lease. Trust Lands' rule requires a notice to include other information that may create interest, so long as it does not breach the confidentiality of the application (csite-005); the record does not say whether the use was treated as confidential, or why the Wellington notice omitted it.

In plain termsThe state did advertise the Wellington land in the local paper, three times in July 2026. But the ad said only that someone had applied for the square mile and that others could bid, with no word of who, or that the plan was a nuclear campus. A month later the same agency, in the same paper, told readers another application was for a solar farm; that notice came from a different Trust Lands office, and a December 2025 notice for an Emery lease gave no use either. Trust Lands' rule let the Wellington ad leave out who and what (csite-005), but a reader could not have known from it what was coming.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read all four legal notices: holds (fees $700+$250+$150; 23 days to the 7 Aug deadline). Plain field no longer asserts the notice 'met the rules' as our finding; it cites the rule record.
official statementconfirmed DOE confirms federal readiness reviews of the four pilot reactors, Ward 250 among them, ending in a final report to the startup authority; no report was found in public records as of Sept. 30, 2026
2026-07-14 · dir-031 · U.S. Department of Energy, DOE Office of Environmental Management, National Nuclear Security Administration, Valar Atomics

DOE's Office of Environmental Management (EM) wrote on 14 July 2026 that 17 EM team members 'took part in DOE’s readiness review process for facility startup' and transition to operations for the four Reactor Pilot Program reactors that went critical by 4 July, naming Valar Atomics' Ward 250. It says readiness review team members reviewed documents, took part in onsite interviews and performance demonstrations, and 'prepared the final report with recommendation to the startup authorization authority' for approval to proceed with nuclear operations. They also reviewed corrective action plans and closure documents answering 'DOE-identified pre- and post-start findings'. The article does not say which reactor any finding concerned, or give each reactor's report or recommendation separately. It also says EM staff reviewed contractor safety submittals from preliminary to final design before recommendation to the safety basis approval authority. Separately, the DOE Nuclear Criticality Safety Program manager wrote in the program's Summer 2026 newsletter that NNSA's NA-ESH office 'has been helping out performing the federal readiness reviews for these reactors'. This is DOE's own confirmation of the kind of review Valar described to the state lab board in May (gov-037). No copy of the readiness report, its findings or the startup authorization was found in public records as of 30 September 2026 (safe-007). (Updates gov-037.)

In plain termsDOE now confirms that federal teams reviewed Ward 250 and three other test reactors before startup and wrote a final report with a recommendation to the official who approves startup. That report, and any problems it found, were not found in public records as of 30 September 2026.
verified 2026-10-02: Checked 2026-09-30: re-read the EM article in full (published 14 July 2026) and the NCSP Summer manager's message (PDF created 10 Aug 2026); quotes exact. Tightened the headline: the article describes the review process across four reactors and speaks of 'the final report' generically, so a Ward-250-specific recommending report is not stated outright. Added the safety-basis review sentence from the same article. EM staff names omitted (roles only).
analysisconfirmed Two separate DOE tracks: the categorical exclusion was the environmental (NEPA) step; safety approval runs through the safety basis, readiness review and startup approval
2026-07-14 · safe-041 · U.S. Department of Energy, DOE Office of Nuclear Energy, DOE Office of Environmental Management, Valar Atomics

DOE's NEPA determination DOE-ID-26-005, signed on 22 April 2026 by a DOE NEPA compliance officer, decided that Ward 250 fits categorical exclusion B5.26 and needs no further NEPA review (csite-020). Federal law defines a categorical exclusion as a category of actions an agency has determined 'normally does not significantly affect the quality of the human environment' (42 U.S.C. 4336e(1)). B5.26 still requires DOE to determine that a project's attributes 'reduce sufficiently the risk of adverse offsite consequences' (CX p. 6), and the determination summarizes what the 'Documented Safety Analysis demonstrates' (p. 5). Nuclear-safety authorization is a separate track with separate officials. Under DOE's nuclear safety rule, a contractor 'may not begin operation' of a new Hazard Category 1, 2 or 3 facility before DOE issues a safety evaluation report approving its safety basis (10 CFR 830.207(a)); Valar's NSDA names 10 CFR 830 as its governing rule and classes Ward 250 as Hazard Category 2. DOE-STD-1271-2025 makes DOE's Office of Nuclear Energy the Safety Basis Approval Authority, which approves the Safety Evaluation Report, and the Secretary of Energy (or a delegate) the Startup Approval Authority, and says satisfactory completion of a DOE readiness review 'results in DOE issuing Startup Approval'. DOE's Office of Environmental Management wrote on 14 July 2026 that readiness assessments 'are necessary for NE to authorize startup' and that its staff took part in the readiness review for the four pilot reactors, naming Ward 250 (dir-031). So the categorical exclusion is neither DOE's safety approval nor evidence that the safety review was skipped. What is public from each track: the NEPA determination is posted; from the safety track, DOE's statements that Ward 250 was authorized (orig-010) and that readiness reviews took place (dir-031) are public, while no copy of the safety evaluation report, the approved safety basis or the startup approval was found in public records as of 30 September 2026 (safe-007).

In plain termsDOE handled Ward 250 on two different tracks. The 'categorical exclusion' was the environmental paperwork: DOE decided the project fits a class of actions that normally has no significant environmental effect, so no full environmental study or comment period was needed. Safety approval is a separate track: DOE's rules bar a reactor like this from operating until DOE approves its safety analysis in a written report, and startup follows a federal readiness review, which DOE says took place. So the categorical exclusion does not show the reactor is safe, and it does not show safety review was skipped. The safety track's own documents (the safety evaluation report, the approved safety basis and the startup approval) were not found in public records as of 30 September 2026.
verified 2026-10-15: Added 1 October 2026. Read: DOE's categorical-exclusion record (pp. 1, 5-7), 42 U.S.C. 4336e, 10 CFR 830 (sec. 830.207(a) and the definition of a Safety Evaluation Report), DOE-STD-1271-2025 (sec. 3.0, 8, 9.1), the DOE Office of Environmental Management article, and Valar's Nuclear Safety Design Agreement (Hazard Category 2; 10 CFR 830). Quotes exact. The rule shows what must come before operation; the Safety Evaluation Report itself was not found in public records (safe-007). Dated to the Environmental Management article, the latest record used. On a second check, eCFR's version history for Part 830 listed no amendment after 18 November 2020, so the 2024-edition text of 830.207(a) is current; a quote's capitalization was corrected to the record's 'Documented Safety Analysis demonstrates'.
recordconfirmed Utah approved up to $106.7M in tax credits for Valar in July 2026 (Emery County); like all 13 tax-credit applicants the board took up from April to September 2026, it was not named on the public agenda
2026-07-09 · csite-024 · Governor's Office of Economic Development, Valar Atomics, Emery County · maximum REDTIF post-performance tax credit, 10 years: $106,737,499; projected capital investment (Emery County): $1,299,110,000

The Board of the Governor's Office of Economic Development approved, by unanimous consent on 9 July 2026, a REDTIF post-performance refundable tax credit for Valar Atomics Inc. of up to $106,737,499: 50% of new state tax revenue for 10 years, with projected capital investment of $1,299,110,000, 275 jobs at an average wage of $137,567, in Emery County. The credit is paid only after new revenue is receipted, is 'site specific and subject to local incentive participation', and needs a local incentive approved by the GOED Incentives Committee. The notice and agenda, posted 7 July, described the item only as a company in 'the energy and advanced manufacturing industry' (the same agenda named the three companies up for economic development zones, but not the other tax-credit applicant); every agenda of the board from April to September 2026 described its tax-credit applicants only by industry (13 companies in five meetings, up to about $549 million in all, from a food manufacturer to a lithium project; Valar's share was about 19%), and the materials naming them were posted during or after each meeting; the board materials naming Valar were attached to the notice at 1:00 p.m. on 9 July, after the meeting, which was scheduled for 10 a.m. to noon. Utah's records law lets agencies protect records that would reveal incentive negotiations if disclosure would cause the company actual economic harm or put the agency at a competitive disadvantage (63G-2-305(35)), though that protection may not be used to withhold a record evidencing a final contract; the July 9 minutes carry that label. The minutes record that Valar's representatives told the board of a data center in Orangeville, described as waterless, and of plans to install more commercial units in the area, and that an Emery County commissioner spoke in support. As of late September 2026, no state incentive record for the Carbon County campus was found in the GOED board records read.

In plain termsThe state approved giving Valar back up to about $107 million in state taxes over ten years, paid only out of new state tax revenue and tied to job and wage targets; the board materials project a $1.3 billion investment and 275 jobs in Emery County. Per the minutes, Valar's representatives spoke of a data center in Orangeville and more commercial units in the area. Before the vote, the public agenda said only that an energy company was up for approval; the documents naming Valar were posted after the meeting. The board's agendas described all 13 of its tax-credit applicants from April to September 2026 only by industry, and the documents naming them were posted during or after each meeting. State law allows incentive talks to be kept confidential in some cases. The Carbon County campus is not part of this incentive.
verified 2026-10-18: Holds, with one addition. Re-read in late September 2026: July 9 notice (posted 2026-07-07 15:18; attachments: agenda and June minutes added 7 July, board materials added 9 July 13:00, audio 13:05); agenda docx (no company named for incentives); board materials pp. 1-3; July 9 minutes (headed as minutes of the Incentive Committee and labelled as protected under 63G-2-305(35), attached to the Sept 10 notice); Utah Code 63G-2-305(35). Unsourced expansion of 'REDTIF' removed. Named individuals other than officials are Valar staff speaking publicly for the company. Corrected 2026-09-30: reworded the plain-language text. Corrected 17 October 2026: Wording taken from the state economic development board's minutes of 9 July 2026 is now given as a paraphrase rather than a quotation.
recordconfirmed $106.7M state tax credit: the board's minutes record Valar's plans for more commercial units and behind-the-meter power sales
2026-07-09 · gov-033 · Governor's Office of Economic Opportunity (GOED) Board, Valar Atomics, Emery County Commission, Jordan Leonard, Harry Hansen, Cory Gardner · maximum REDTIF post-performance refundable tax credit approved for Valar (10 years): $106,737,499; projected capital investment in the Valar incentive application (Emery County): $1,299,110,000

Re-reading the GOED board's 9 July 2026 materials and minutes (csite-024 has the incentive terms): the executive summary describes a $1,299,110,000 Emery County project with 275 jobs averaging $137,567, and says the up-to-$106,737,499 REDTIF credit (half of new state tax revenue for 10 years, paid only after the revenue comes in) is 'site specific and subject to local incentive participation', with a local incentive proposal needing GOED Incentives Committee approval. The minutes record that Valar's Harry Hansen cited the NVIDIA chip demonstration and a data center announced for Orangeville, described as waterless, and that Valar's Cory Gardner said Valar plans to install more commercial units in the area; that the quickest way to switch reactors on is to sell the power behind the meter (directly to a user, not through the utility grid), avoiding long waits to connect to the grid; that in the near term it is aiming at such customers who would pay a higher price; and that no one has yet sold power from an advanced reactor in America. The minutes list Emery County Commissioner Jordan Leonard among the visitors under Valar Atomics' name (they do not say why) and record him speaking in support. Set beside the record: three months earlier, at the county's 7 April hearing, the answer recorded to 'what incentives has the county given you?' was 'None', with a commissioner adding Valar had 'not even asked' for a tax incentive (gov-022); no local incentive for Valar appears on the Emery County Commission's or its Community Reinvestment Agency's agendas through September 2026 (Utah Public Notice Website scan, 29 Sept 2026); and DOE's legal basis for authorizing Ward 250 without the NRC is that pilot reactors do not produce commercial electric power (safe-030, gov-007), so power sold from commercial units would need NRC licensing (csite-010).

In plain termsUtah's economic development board approved up to $106.7 million in future tax rebates for Valar, based on a $1.3 billion, 275-job plan in Emery County, far larger than the one-year test first described. To collect, Valar must actually create the jobs and pay the taxes, and a local incentive must also be approved; none had been found as of late September 2026. The meeting's minutes record Valar speaking of more commercial units and of selling power directly to paying customers. Selling power is exactly what the federal shortcut does not cover, so those units would need a license from the NRC.
verified 2026-10-18: Re-read the GOED 9 July 2026 materials and minutes and the Emery 7 April minutes in late September 2026; quotes and figures exact; a scan of 527 saved Emery notices found no Valar incentive item. Holds.
recordconfirmed Water: Valar says it has the shares it needs and seeks up to 1,000 more, in a year of critically low reservoirs
2026-07-09 · loc-017 · Valar Atomics, Orangeville City Council, Castle Valley Special Service District, Cottonwood Creek Consolidated Irrigation Company, Utah Division of Water Rights · CVSSD outside-district water connection fee approved for Valar (19 Feb 2026): $20,000

What local records show about Valar's water: 11 December 2025, Orangeville approved a future 8-inch water line for Valar's new building, Valar saying it 'acquired the necessary water shares', on condition that fees are paid and the correct shares turned in (minutes). 19 February 2026, the utility district approved a $20,000 connection contingent on all shares being submitted to Orangeville (loc-015). 9 July 2026, Orangeville minutes: the 1,000 water shares under discussion are 'still in the discussion phase' and not for the data center; ETV, reporting on the county commission's 21 July meeting, said that according to Valar the extra shares would support possible future development on the larger property it is acquiring from the county (mine-042). For scale, the mayor told the council in November 2025 that the city itself held 998.4 Class A and 94 Class B shares of Cottonwood Creek irrigation water and was still 89 shares short. On 16 July 2026 the utility district reported 'critically low reservoir levels' and Orangeville's secondary water at 233 acre-feet for the year. Which company's shares Valar holds or seeks, and how much water 1,000 shares represents, is not stated in any record read as of late September 2026. Utah Division of Water Rights records, where a change of use would be filed and advertised, could not be searched. At Orangeville's council meeting of 8 October 2026, in the reports at the end of the meeting, a city official said of Valar's water use that 'they've slowed the use down', and a city official said one item being looked at for a new ordinance is that anyone filling 'large systems' must give the city 'so many days notice'; Valar was named in that discussion, and other companies were said to 'have been mentioned' (city recording, about 1:10:35 and 1:11:29 to 1:11:55).

In plain termsValar says it already has the water for its current buildings and wants up to 1,000 more water shares for future growth. That is about as many shares as the whole town of Orangeville holds, though shares differ in size and nobody has said which kind Valar wants. The same summer, the local water district was warning of critically low reservoirs. When someone files an application with the State Engineer to take or change water, the state must advertise it in the local paper and people can protest; we could not search the state's water-rights records, so a resident should check them directly.
verified 2026-10-18: Re-read the Orangeville minutes (Nov 2025, Dec 2025, July 2026), CVSSD Feb and July minutes and ETV reports: holds. Replaced a quote that did not bear on water. The plain field's notice-and-protest statement now cites the statute and a notice.
company claimreported ETV: Valar seeks up to 1,000 water shares for future growth on land it is acquiring from Emery County, not a data center
2026-07-09 · mine-042 · Valar Atomics, Harry Hansen, Emery County Commission, Dennis Worwood, Orangeville City Council, ETV News

ETV News reported on 16 July 2026 that at the Orangeville City Council's 9 July meeting Valar's Harry Hansen said the 1,000 water shares Valar is seeking to buy would support possible future expansion and are not meant for a data center, as some rumours suggested. Orangeville's own minutes of that meeting record, in the mayor's report, that talk of 1,000 water shares 'is still in the discussion phase' and that the shares are 'not for use in the Data Center'. ETV's 28 July 2026 report on the Emery County Commission's 21 July meeting said Valar had recently announced plans to create or obtain as many as 1,000 water shares over the coming years; that, according to Valar, the company already has the water for the proposed NVIDIA data center; and that the extra shares would support possible future developments on the larger property Valar recently purchased from Emery County (mine-018). At that commission meeting Valar representatives offered to speak with residents one-on-one afterwards; a resident asked for a 180-day pause on new data-center applications while zoning standards are written; and Commissioner Dennis Worwood said no formal building application for a data center had been received and that planning and zoning should set standards first.

In plain termsValar has said it is seeking up to 1,000 water shares in Emery County for possible future growth, and that its proposed data center already has the water it needs. A resident has already asked the county to set rules for data centers before any arrive. Both news reports come from one local outlet, and Orangeville's 9 July minutes also record that the shares are not for the data center; Utah's water-rights records would show any actual filings.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read in late September 2026: corrected. The July 28 article does not say Valar told the commission about the water shares at the 21 July meeting; it says Valar 'has recently announced' them. The earliest dated statement found is Hansen's at the 9 July Orangeville council meeting. The two news reports are both ETV's; Orangeville's minutes of the 9 July meeting also record, in the mayor's report, that the shares are not for the data center. The resident who asked for the pause is described, not named.
recordconfirmed The notice rule protects the application's confidentiality; Trust Lands' Wellington notice named neither Valar nor any use
2026-07-08 · csite-005 · Utah Trust Lands Administration, Carbon County Commission, Southeastern Regional Development Agency, Resource Development Coordinating Committee

Rule R850-30-500 requires Trust Lands, on accepting a special use lease application, to solicit competing interest by giving at least 30 days' notice by certified mail to the county's legislative body, lessees or permittees of record and adjoining landowners; it may add other methods. The notice must describe the land and its location, give the agency contact, and must also include any other information 'that may create interest in the subject property' that 'does not violate the confidentiality of the initial application'. R850-30-150 also requires lease proposals to go to the state Resource Development Coordinating Committee (RDCC). The memorandum says Trust Lands posted notices in the local newspaper and on its website, sent them to lessees, permittees and adjoining landowners 'per agency rule R-850-30-500', posted the proposal on the RDCC dashboard for 30 days and sent it to the Carbon County Commission and SERDA. The web notice (which Trust Lands' own site now marks as archived) matches this format: it says an application was received for Section 16 near Wellington and invites bids to lease, buy or exchange by 7 August 2026, naming no applicant or use; it points inquiries to the Southeastern Area Office in Monticello. The notice page itself records a publication date of 8 July 2026 (last modified 9 August), 30 days before the bid deadline. Because OBAs are exempt from R850-30 (csite-004), our reading is that this notice was given by choice rather than by requirement; the memo does not say. The certified-mail list, the newspaper's affidavit and the RDCC posting's recipients were not in the records read; a matching Trust Lands notice ran in ETV News on 15, 22 and 29 July 2026 (loc-032).

In plain termsWhat the notice told readers was limited: it said only that someone had applied for the land near Wellington, and invited competing bids. That matches the state's rule, which calls for extra details that may draw interest, but only ones that keep the application confidential. The rule requires notice by certified mail to the county commission, existing users of the land and neighboring landowners; Trust Lands says it also posted the notice in a local newspaper and on its website. So the silence about who and what fits the rule rather than departing from it. Whether people were fairly informed is a separate question from whether the rule was followed (csite-018, csite-028).
verified 2026-10-02: Holds, with the plain text corrected (the certified-mail list is the rule's minimum, not the only notice) and the date set to the notice's posting. Re-read in late September 2026: rulebook R850-30-150, -305, -500; memo p. 20 ('Notice and Advertising'); the notice page's own published and modified dates (8 July and 9 August 2026, UTC). Quotes exact.
recordconfirmed What the DPA pact means for public records: meetings noticed in the Federal Register, confidential business information withheld
2026-07-06 · gov-002 · U.S. Department of Energy, Valar Atomics

The same agreement (gov-001) sets its own openness rules. Records kept under DOE's rule for these agreements (10 CFR 821) are 'available for public inspection and copying' unless exempt as classified, statutorily protected or confidential business information, and DOE says it will withhold participants' confidential commercial and financial information from FOIA (5 U.S.C. 552(b)(4)) and may restrict attendance at meetings to protect them. The Chairperson (the Assistant Secretary for Nuclear Energy) must publish a Federal Register notice of each Consortium meeting, in advance if open, or within 10 days with reasons if closed; public notice is promised as each participant joins or withdraws, and the participant list is to be published in the Federal Register every year. Each participant must keep all records of its dealings under the agreement for five years and produce them to DOE, the Attorney General and the FTC on request. Direct sharing of competitively sensitive information among companies is limited to 'Exigent Circumstances' and supervised by DOJ and FTC. The detailed work happens in committees, and the agreement says all committee-level meetings 'will be closed by default'; DOE says it will aim to publish monthly committee schedules, with summaries and participation reports, in the Federal Register.

In plain termsBecause this pact lets competitors talk to each other with a legal shield, the law requires some sunshine: meetings must be announced in the Federal Register, and the member list is published yearly. But the committee meetings where the detailed work is done are closed by default, and confidential business information shared under the pact can be kept from the public. For anyone following Valar, this means its role in the fuel-supply group can be tracked through future Federal Register notices, while confidential commercial and financial information it gives DOE can be withheld under FOIA, and members agree to keep what is shared in the pact's meetings confidential.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read in late September 2026: records, FOIA, meeting-notice and five-year retention clauses hold. Fixed: added that committee-level meetings are closed by default, which the earlier wording left out and which limits the 'sunshine' the plain field described.
recordconfirmed Carbon commissioners signed a June 29 support letter; no Carbon County agenda read from May to mid-Sept shows it or the site
2026-06-29 · mine-013 · Carbon County Commission, Larry Jensen, Tony Martines, Jared Haddock, Valar Atomics

The Trust Lands packets include a letter on Carbon County Board of Commissioners letterhead dated 29 June 2026, addressed to the 'SITLA Board of Trustees' and signed by Commissioners Tony Martines, Jared Haddock and Larry Jensen, supporting Valar's desire to locate 'north of Wellington on SITLA lands' and saying the county had worked with Valar for over a year; it does not mention nuclear power or a reactor. The commission's agendas and minutes posted on the Utah Public Notice Website for its meetings of 6 May through 16 September 2026 (most are scanned images; the 5 August meeting was canceled; 16 September minutes not yet posted as of 1 October 2026) contain no item approving that letter and no item on the Wellington site. Valar appears in commissioners' remarks on 1 July 2026 (celebrating the Emery reactor and a data-center partnership), in a 19 August 2026 'Valor Atomics presentation' about the Orangeville operation and planned public events (the minutes add that commissioners highlighted the tax benefits 'the plant will bring', without saying where), and in a 2 September 2026 announcement of an Orangeville open house and a planned Carbon County town hall. By contrast, Emery County put its support letter for Valar on a public agenda (17 February 2026, orig-046).

In plain termsThe county's support for the Carbon site was put in writing and sent to the state, but we found no public county meeting where it was discussed or voted on before it was sent. Minutes of the meetings of 7 January to 15 April 2026, also read, show no such item either. Whether a vote was needed is a legal question for the county; the county clerk's records would show how the letter was approved.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-checked in late September 2026: letter read in the September packet (p. 28); all 17 Carbon agendas and minutes on file re-read for Valar/Valor/atomic/nuclear/Wellington/SITLA/trust/letter; only the items described appear. The archived Aug 19 minutes match the live file. carbon.utah.gov was not searched for the letter.
company claimconfirmed On an unlisted draft page, Valar calls itself 'very open and transparent', pointing to its photos and video; of its Ward 250 safety papers, two were found published, and the others, most listed for DOE review, were not found in public records
2026-06-28 · safe-040 · Valar Atomics

In its unlisted 'Ward 250 By the Numbers' page (28 June 2026), Valar says its beliefs have led it to be 'a very open and transparent company', that its reactor has been more photographed and filmed than any other in history, and that it is sharing raw data to be refined by internal and external peer review over the following weeks. The page still contains placeholders ('July XX', '[xxx]') and one chart, 'Reactor Power Ascension', which plots an unlabeled 'Q_Total' on a 0-100 scale and thermocouple readings of about 30-80 F against a 'sample index', with no power units, dates or time scale, so it cannot be used to check the power reached. Of the safety documents the NSDA and DOE records name for Ward 250, two were found published by Valar: the NSDA (marked 'Draft', safe-005) and the QA Program Description (safe-018). Not found among Valar's published documents as of late September 2026: the PDSA, final DSA and Technical Safety Requirements, the Code of Record (document 100437), the startup and commissioning plan, the radiation protection program, the transport QA program (document 100719, which DOE approved, safe-012) and any emergency plan. The Physical Security Plan and Material Control and Accountability Plan are security documents, which the NSDA calls separate controlled documents. County and state officials praised Valar's openness at the Trust Lands board meetings (csite-028).

In plain termsValar describes itself as unusually open, and it has published many photos and videos. The safety documents are a different matter: of the documents that define how the reactor is kept safe, we found two the public can read, and one is labeled a draft, though Valar says DOE approved it; the others were prepared for DOE's review. Some documents, like security plans, are normally kept private. The safety analysis and operating limits are not security plans; they can be requested from DOE under FOIA (safe-007).
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read 'By the Numbers' (single embedded image, the 'Reactor Power Ascension' chart, read from the image: Q_Total 0-100 with no units, thermocouples about 30-80 F, x-axis 'Sample index'), NSDA and QA Approval 0049 in late September 2026. Holds. Softened 'has published two' to 'two were found published': Valar's docs library page as posted lists five posts and no safety documents, so a complete inventory could not be made. Corrected 2026-09-30: reworded the plain-language text.
recordconfirmed June 17, 2026: Carbon commissioners approved three 2026 certified rates; minutes say state-assessed values fell $48 million, mainly from a gas field sale
2026-06-17 · ptax-003 · Carbon County Commission, Larry Jensen, Tony Martines · 2026 drop in centrally assessed values reported in the minutes: $48,000,000

Final minutes of the Carbon County Commission meeting of 17 June 2026, item 7 'Review and possible approval of Certified Tax Rates' (scanned PDF of 4 pages, created 2 July 2026; read from the page images). In the county clerk's absence, Commissioner Larry Jensen explained the need to adjust the county's certified tax rates; the minutes summarize that centrally assessed industry values, 'such as gas fields and coal mines assessed by the state', had dropped by $48 million that year, primarily due to a gas field sale (PDF pp.2-3). On Commissioner Tony Martines's motion, seconded by Commissioner Jensen, the commission approved (PDF p.3): General Operations .002667 (up from .002556); County Assessing and Collecting .000422 (up from .000407); Municipal Service Fund .002180 (up from .002056); these are rises of 4.3%, 3.7% and 6.0% (arithmetic on the printed rates). The 'up from' figures equal the 2025 adopted rates for those levies in the Tax Commission's 2025 Report 600 for Tax Area 009-0000 (PDF p.41). The minutes do not name the gas field or give the school district's 2026 rate. The commissioners' description of the change is in ptax-012.

In plain termsEach year the county sets its property tax rates. In June 2026 the commissioners raised three county rates by about 4 to 6 percent; the minutes say this was because the value of state-assessed industry in the county dropped by $48 million, mostly because a gas field was sold. A rate of .002667 means about $2.67 of tax for every $1,000 of taxable value.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read the page images of the 17 June 2026 final minutes (PDF pp.1-3): names of those present, item 7 text, the $48 million and gas-field wording, the three rates and the motion by Commissioner Martines with Commissioner Jensen's second all match; PDF p.4 is a retirement-rate attachment. The three 'up from' rates match the 2025 adopted rates for levies 1010, 1020 and 6010 in Tax Area 009-0000 (Report 600, PDF p.41). Replaced 'a little' with the computed rises (4.3%, 3.7%, 6.0%).
official statementconfirmed June 17, 2026 minutes: Carbon commissioners called the rate change a state-mandated adjustment to keep taxing entities whole, not a county tax increase
2026-06-17 · ptax-012 · Carbon County Commission, Larry Jensen

Final minutes of the Carbon County Commission meeting of 17 June 2026, item 7 on certified tax rates (PDF pp.2-3, read from the scanned pages). After recording Commissioner Jensen's explanation that centrally assessed values fell $48 million, primarily due to a gas field sale, 'which shifted the tax burden slightly' (ptax-003), the minutes state that the commissioners repeatedly stressed this was 'a state-mandated adjustment to balance the budget and keep taxing entities whole', not a county tax increase. The three rates were then approved (PDF p.3). This is the minutes' summary of the discussion, not a transcript. Under Utah's truth-in-taxation law (Utah Code 59-2-924), a certified tax rate is the rate that gives a taxing entity the same property tax revenue it budgeted for the prior year (ptax-006). The minutes do not say which taxpayers the shift fell on.

In plain termsAt their 17 June 2026 meeting, the commissioners stressed that the certified rates were an adjustment required by state rules to keep the county's and other taxing bodies' money the same, not a county tax increase. The minutes say the drop in industry value shifted the tax burden slightly, but do not say onto whom.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read the scanned pages of the 17 June 2026 final minutes, item 7 (PDF pp.2-3): the full sentence quoted in the detail and both short quotes match word for word on PDF p.3 (the clause 'which shifted the tax burden slightly' starts at the foot of p.2), and the rates were approved after that sentence. The minutes do not say who bears the shift.
official statementconfirmed June 11: Utah's radiation board was told state oversight of the site's 'radioactive materials' would pass to DOE at criticality
2026-06-11 · dir-030 · Utah Waste Management and Radiation Control Board, Utah Division of Waste Management and Radiation Control, U.S. Department of Energy, Valar Atomics

Approved minutes of the Utah Waste Management and Radiation Control Board's 11 June 2026 meeting (approved 9 July 2026) record that, under 'Commissioner Davis's Report', Commissioner Davis said the Valar test reactor in Orangeville (spelled 'Valor') was expected to go critical between then and 4 July. He described it as a small test reactor designed to generate a couple of hundred kilowatts of heat, not electricity. He said that 'once the reactor goes critical (on-line), oversight of the radioactive materials will transition' from the Division to the U.S. Department of Energy. He added that this was the first such transition he had been involved in and that such transitions are expected to become more common. The minutes do not say what radioactive materials were at the site, whether reactor fuel had arrived, or under what state authorization the Division oversaw them. The board's 14 meeting notices from June 2025 to 10 September 2026 list no Valar item (csite-023); the remark came in the commissioner's report. The meeting audio is posted but was not reviewed. (Updates plan-025.)

In plain termsIn June, a state official told Utah's radiation board that the state was overseeing radioactive materials at the reactor site until the reactor started up, when DOE would take over. The minutes don't say what those materials were.
verified 2026-10-12: Second check, 2026-09-30: re-read the full minutes (3 pages, 1,431 words; header 'MEETING MINUTES APPROVED ON JULY 9, 2026'); quote exact. Removed the identification of 'Commissioner Davis' as Tim Davis: the minutes list a Tim Davis among board members but do not state it, and a staff member named Brandon Davis also appears. The claim that the May and July minutes have no Valar item was not re-checked.
recordconfirmed Emery's other nuclear site: Green River's Blue Castle plan revived with Holtec reactors; Valar applied nearby, then said it dropped that plan
2026-05-27 · loc-020 · Blue Castle Holdings, Holtec International, Fulcrum Point Holdings, Hi Tech Solutions, HEAL Utah, Kane County Water Conservancy District, San Juan County Water Conservancy District, Jordan Leonard

Nuclear siting in Emery County is not only Valar. Near Green River, Blue Castle Holdings leased water rights totalling 53,600 acre-feet from the Kane County (29,600) and San Juan County (24,000) water conservancy districts for a proposed nuclear power plant; the Utah Court of Appeals affirmed approval of the change applications in July 2016 against a challenge by HEAL Utah and others, noting the project still needed an environmental review and an NRC early site permit application (2016 UT App 153). On 27 May 2026 Fulcrum Point Holdings (a Hi Tech Solutions affiliate) announced a joint venture with Blue Castle (KSL; Holtec's release is dated 28 May and Utah Business carried the Fulcrum release on 29 May) to take the project through federal licensing with Holtec SMR-300 reactors, which can use air cooling; Emery Commissioner Jordan Leonard and the governor's energy adviser are quoted in support. Neither release gives an NRC filing date; the Fulcrum release's company description puts the multi-unit Blue Castle project at up to 2,200 megawatts, while KSL noted the announcement did not specify the Green River capacity. KSL (27-28 May) reported HEAL Utah's concerns about water use, the Colorado River and waste. At the 30 June 2026 Carbon/Emery economic development committee, a Hi Tech Solutions director said the site had been studied, land and access secured, and the project was in the application process (ETV). The Emery Commission voted in September 2025 to support Green River as a site for a state nuclear project (gov-021). Separately, Valar filed a 10,271-acre 'Green River Gigasite' reactor and data-center application with BLM in February 2026 (BLM case UTUT106784007), which it later told a reporter it had dropped while BLM's public layer still listed it 'Pending' in late September 2026 (mine-006, mine-008). No record read as of late September 2026, connects the Blue Castle project to Valar. The NRC's site could not be read, so no NRC filing for either could be checked.

In plain termsGreen River, at the east end of Emery County, has had a nuclear plant proposal since the 2000s, backed by a large block of river water rights a court upheld in 2016. In May 2026 new partners revived it with smaller reactors that can be air-cooled. Valar separately applied for a huge tract near Green River and then said it had dropped it. So Emery County faces two or more nuclear proposals besides the test reactor, each on its own track.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read the court opinion, both releases and KSL: holds, except 'neither release gives capacity' (the Fulcrum release's boilerplate says up to 2,200 MW), now corrected; announcement date set to 27 May per KSL. Revised before publication (late September 2026): tool names removed from the note and source title.
analysisconfirmed Records disagree: Emery voted Valar's parcel out of the Inland Port zone; the port's plan and news still count it in
2026-05-21 · gov-023 · Emery County Commission, Utah Inland Port Authority, Valar Atomics

Emery County Commission minutes, 19 May 2026, item 17: the commission passed (2-0) 'a resolution removing parcel 04-0019-0030 from the UIPA Castle Country Industrial Park Project Area', a commissioner saying annexation into Orangeville 'makes it a little cleaner with taxes'. Two days later, on 21 May 2026, the Utah Inland Port Authority board adopted Castle Country plan Amendment #3; the final plan posted with that meeting still lists '04-0019-0030' ('San Rafael Energy Research Center') among the project area's parcels (gov-018). UIPA staff told the UIPA board on 4 August 2026 that Valar's operations 'will be expanding into the Castle Country project area', and UIPA's 10 September 2026 news post says Valar's 100-plus acres are 'located within the Castle Country Project Area'. Amendment #3 itself was one of a batch of 'recruitment incentive clarifications and minor adjustments' across several project areas and changed no acreage (15,370.25 acres before and after), so the county's request is not reflected in it. No UIPA resolution removing the parcel was found on the 2026 UIPA board agendas read (March to October), and UIPA's 2026 trigger resolution for Castle Country covers only other parcels (gov-018). Orangeville's council minutes of 10 September 2026, stamped DRAFT, record that annexation for Valar 'has been held up due to mineral rights on the property', with the city waiting for the purchase to be finalized before beginning the annexation process (loc-014). The council approved those minutes on 8 October 2026 by a voice vote, without a roll call, after no discussion and with no amendment moved; the presiding officer saw no opposition (city recording, about 0:02:00 to 0:02:26). Which record is current, and so whether future property tax on Valar's land flows mostly to UIPA or to local taxing entities, cannot be settled from the records read as of late September 2026. On 7 July 2026 commissioners also discussed asking UIPA for inland-port funds for speed-limit signs on the road used by workers at Valar and a nearby mine.

In plain termsThe county voted to pull Valar's parcel out of the state Inland Port tax zone, but the port authority's own plan, adopted two days later, still includes it, and the port authority keeps describing Valar's land as inside the zone. Both are official records and they disagree. The answer matters for local taxpayers, because inside the zone most new property tax from Valar's development would go to the port authority for 25 years instead of to the county and schools.
verified 2026-10-18: Re-read the 19 May and 7 July Emery minutes, the Amendment #3 plan, the 10 Sept UIPA post and the Mar-Oct 2026 UIPA agendas in late September 2026; quotes exact. The conflict holds; added that Amendment #3 was a minor clarifying amendment with no acreage change.
recordconfirmed What legislators were shown: OED briefings in 2025, and a 17-slide Valar deck in May 2026 that is all photographs
2026-05-20 · gov-019 · Utah State Legislature, Public Utilities, Energy, and Technology Interim Committee, Valar Atomics, Isaiah Taylor, Utah Office of Energy Development, Emy Lesofski, Jaron Wallace, Natura Resources

The Legislature's Public Utilities, Energy and Technology Interim Committee has heard about Valar at three meetings, per its posted agendas, minutes and materials. 18 June 2025, under an agenda item titled 'Valar Atomics Nuclear Test Reactor' (described as a plan for 'a new nuclear test reactor running by 2026'): OED Director Emy Lesofski and lab director Jaron Wallace gave 'an update on companies partnering' with the lab, 'including Valar Atomics and NuCube' (approved minutes); OED's slides list 'Valar MOU signed May 16, 2025'; later in the meeting the chair opened public comment on the nuclear discussion (gov-040). 15 October 2025: OED's slide update says the Energy Research Board first met 13 August, Valar broke ground on 11 September 2025, Natura Resources is 'leasing the majority of the space' at the lab, and the state Energy Research Grant Program is 'on hold' until money exists both for grants and to run the lab. 20 May 2026: Isaiah Taylor gave a 'Valar Atomics Update' in a 20-minute agenda slot and 'answered committee questions' (minutes, no detail). The presentation Valar filed with the committee is 17 slides of photographs and headings ('Concept to Thermal Prototype', '10 Months', 'Ward 250 Site Ground Breaking', 'Criticality', 'Reactor Transport', 'Ward 250 Site'): it contains no figures on power, fuel, safety, emergency planning or waste, and does not mention Carbon County, although the state's Wellington lease map was dated 9 April 2026 and the state notice went out 20 April (mine-048, csite-032). One slide shows the reactor vessel on a trailer in front of the State Capitol. Its 'Criticality' slide predates Ward 250's own criticality (18 June 2026), so it can only refer to the November 2025 NOVA test in Nevada (orig-008); the slide does not say which. The meeting audio is posted on the Legislature's site but has not been transcribed for this site.

In plain termsWhen Valar's chief executive briefed the state legislators who oversee energy, the slides he left for the public record were photos: machinery, a groundbreaking, a cargo plane, the reactor on a truck at the Capitol. There were no numbers on safety, fuel or waste, and no mention of the Carbon County site the state was already mapping. Legislators asked questions, which the minutes do not summarize (the recording exists), but the slides and minutes read contain no figures on safety, fuel or waste. A year earlier, in June 2025, the same committee had heard about the Valar test reactor under its own noticed agenda item, and later in that meeting took public comment on the nuclear discussion (gov-040).
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read the June 2025 and May 2026 minutes, OED's June and October 2025 slides, and viewed all 17 Valar slides in late September 2026. Holds; fixed 'written update' to slides, added the June 2025 agenda item title and that the 'Criticality' slide predates Ward 250's criticality. Corrected 1 Oct 2026: wording made more exact against the cited records.
recordconfirmed May 2026: Carbon County voted to enter 'the beginning stages' of a BLM gas-pipeline right-of-way for Altigen plants east of Wellington
2026-05-20 · mine-050 · Carbon County Commission, Altigen, Bureau of Land Management

The Carbon County Commission's 20 May 2026 agenda listed, for possible approval, a partnership with ALTIGEN ('Jurassic Spark Project') on a natural gas pipeline right-of-way across BLM land. The minutes (scanned) say Altigen intends to build natural gas power plants on private property east of Wellington; that BLM offered Carbon County the option to hold the right-of-way for a pipeline across the North Coal Creek area; that Altigen will bear all environmental work, costs, maintenance and erosion control, and the county is not paying; and that the commission voted to enter 'the beginning stages' of the right-of-way. No BLM right-of-way case naming Altigen or Carbon County created since June 2025 appears in BLM's public layer as of late September 2026. No record read links this project to Valar.

In plain termsA separate energy project, gas-fired power plants east of Wellington with a pipeline across federal land, got early county approval in an open public meeting in May 2026.
verified 2026-10-02: Found during verification in late September 2026 while re-reading the May-September Carbon minutes for mine-013; archived copies checked again and unchanged. Updated in late September 2026. No copy of the BLM query result is kept; the absence rests on BLM's layer as it stood when checked.
recordconfirmed How Emery County approved selling Valar the 112-acre lab-side parcel: bid rule amended, then a $394,500 direct sale approved
2026-05-19 · gov-022 · Emery County Commission, Emery County Local Building Authority, Valar Atomics, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab, Dennis Worwood, Keven Jensen, Jordan Leonard, Max Ukropina · sale price of parcel 04-0019-0030 from Emery County / LBA to Valar Atomics (average of two appraisals): $394,500

From the Emery County Commission's minutes. 20 Jan 2026: the commission began 'the disposition process' for parcel 04-0019-0030 ('the property next to the Research Center') 'solely for the purpose of economic development'. 17 Feb: a letter of support for Valar passed; the MOU for Valar's site-suitability testing on the parcel was 'Tabled' (the agenda listing is in orig-046). 17 March: the county's property ordinance required 30 days' notice to neighbors, posting three weeks before sale, and 'sealed bids'; the commission added a section letting it sell under state statute 17-78-103 (notice, public comment and fair value by two appraisals, no bidding) when a parcel is not posted within 30 days; the county attorney said he had not reviewed the new wording and Commissioner Worwood voted no for that reason; the same meeting then approved selling the parcel to Valar under 17-78-103, subject to a hearing and two appraisals, and let Valar use it as a staging area if the county were released from liability. 7 April hearing: Valar said it wants the land for 'Fuel fabrication and manufacturing' and possible temporary employee housing; the state lab director said the state also wanted to buy it, for 'contiguous ownership to maintain safety', and asked whether a bid process could be requested; Commissioner Worwood answered that the county followed state requirements and called the sale 'an intermediate step' while Valar looks for 'a larger piece of property with water'; asked about incentives, the answer recorded was 'None'. 19 May: the commission (2-0) approved the purchase and sale agreement at $394,500, the average of two appraisals, sent annexation notices for the parcel and the lab parcel into Orangeville, and passed a resolution removing the parcel from the Inland Port project area (gov-023). 7 July: a 30-day due-diligence extension, already signed by one commissioner, was ratified; he said the land 'has been sold' to Valar. Other items in these minutes: on 17 March a local special service district asked that Valar annex the parcel into Orangeville, and the sheriff reported a recent meeting with Valar on safety. Orangeville's council minutes of 10 September 2026, stamped DRAFT, record that annexation for Valar 'has been held up due to mineral rights on the property' and that the city was 'waiting for the purchase to be finalized to begin the annexation process'; they do not name the parcel or the seller (loc-014). The council approved those minutes on 8 October 2026 by a voice vote, without a roll call, after no discussion and with no amendment moved; the presiding officer saw no opposition (city recording, about 0:02:00 to 0:02:26). No recorded deed was found in the records read, as of 17 October 2026 (open question).

In plain termsEmery County approved selling Valar about 112 acres next to the state lab for $394,500, roughly $3,500 an acre, set by averaging two appraisals. The county's own rule had called for sealed bids; the commission changed that rule at the meeting where it first approved selling the parcel to Valar, subject to a hearing and two appraisals, and its attorney said he had not reviewed the new wording. The state lab said it wanted the land too, to keep ownership around the reactor in one hand for safety, and asked whether a bid process could be requested; the county went ahead with the sale to Valar. Valar says it wants the land for making nuclear fuel and manufacturing. The sale used the state-law route (a published notice, a public hearing, and a price set by two appraisals) instead of bidding, so it was not a competitive sale.
verified 2026-10-19: Re-read the Jan 20, Feb 17, Mar 17, Apr 7, May 19 and Jul 7 2026 minutes and Utah Code 17-78-103 (version effective 6 May 2026: notice, public comment, two-appraisal fair value, no bidding requirement) in late September 2026; all quotes exact. Holds; added two related items from the same minutes. Corrected in late September 2026: sale wording now 'approved selling' (no deed read). Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): the sale is described by the route used, not as a legal conclusion; see Corrections.
recordconfirmed The state runs a nuclear education campaign county by county, with unpaid experts who 'believe in the technology'
2026-05-19 · gov-025 · Utah Office of Energy Development, Tracy Rees, Emery County Commission

At the 19 May 2026 Emery County Commission meeting, OED Deputy Director Tracy Rees presented the Office of Energy Development's 'statewide nuclear education and community outreach campaign'. Per the minutes, commissioners asked about safety and new technology and about funding; she said the subject-matter experts 'are not paid because they believe in the technology', that OED first meets county commissioners, city councils and mayors to hear local concerns and uses that to shape each community event, and that the state wants people to understand nuclear 'so communities can engage in a meaningful way'. The regional economic development district's board listed 'Nuclear Community Campaigns' updates on its May and July 2026 agendas (csite-031), and the public workshops later cited as outreach were advertised as general nuclear classes, and their event listings did not mention the Wellington site (mine-047). OED is also the landlord and promoter of Valar's project (ppl-018, gov-011). No campaign budget, contractor or list of experts was found in the records read as of late September 2026.

In plain termsThe state energy office, which hosts Valar and wants more nuclear projects, is also running the public education campaign about nuclear power in rural counties, with volunteer experts described as believers in the technology. The information may be accurate and useful, but it comes from an office with a stake in the outcome, not a neutral party. Residents can ask for the underlying safety documents to judge for themselves.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read the 19 May 2026 minutes in late September 2026; quote exact. Plain wording made neutral; the fact itself holds.
company claimreported Valar told the state lab board in May 2026 that a DOE team of 18-20 experts had reviewed readiness; DOE later confirmed a readiness review covering Ward 250, but no report was found in public records
2026-05-13 · gov-037 · Valar Atomics, Jess Housekeeper, Utah Energy Research Board, U.S. Department of Energy

Minutes of the Utah Energy Research Board's 13 May 2026 meeting record that, in public comment, Jess Housekeeper, Valar's Director of Utah Operations, reported a recent onsite DOE evaluation by 18 to 20 nuclear and emergency-safety experts and said the final readiness report was expected that Friday, to prepare for receiving fuel and starting the reactor. This is the company's account as recorded by the state; the minutes give no findings. The same minutes record that the lab had a letter of support from Valar for a University of Utah-led DOE grant application, and 'verbal interest' from Valar in a digital-twin project; the board's 12 August 2026 agenda ends with a board tour of the lab and Valar's facility. No DOE readiness report, evaluation-team report or startup approval for Ward 250 was found in public records as of late September 2026 (safe-007).

In plain termsValar told a state board in May 2026 that a team of 18 to 20 Energy Department safety and emergency experts had just evaluated its site, and that a final readiness report was due that week, before fuel arrived and the reactor started. That report would show what DOE checked and what it found. No public copy of it was found as of 30 September 2026, though DOE confirmed in July 2026 that federal teams carried out readiness reviews of Ward 250 and three other test reactors and wrote a final report with a recommendation to the startup official (dir-031). A FOIA request to DOE would settle what it says.
verified 2026-10-12: New in an earlier check, late September 2026, from minutes read that day. Kept as 'reported': the minutes confirm the statement was made; DOE has since confirmed a readiness review covering Ward 250 (dir-031), but its report was not found in public records.
recordconfirmed A 2026 Utah law makes counties notify water regulators before approving a large data center; it is not public notice
2026-05-06 · csite-025 · Utah Legislature, Utah Division of Water Rights

H.B. 76 (2026, 'Data Center Water Transparency Amendments', effective 6 May 2026) enacted Utah Code 73-5-8.3. A 'large data center' is one withdrawing 75 acre-feet or more of water a year, with at least 10,000 square feet of buildings. Before a county or city land use authority approves a land use application for a new one, it must notify the Division of Water Rights, the Division of Water Quality and the relevant water provider by mail or email. On or after 1 July 2026 the operator must, at least 90 days but no sooner than 360 days before construction, tell the water provider its expected water use and report to the Division of Water Rights; after opening it reports yearly, and the Division publishes each new center's withdrawals. The Carbon campus plan includes data centers (mine-010); whether any would reach 75 acre-feet a year is not stated.

In plain termsIf the Carbon campus includes a big water-using data center, a 2026 state law requires the county to tell the state's water agencies before approving it, and requires the data center's operator to report expected and actual water use, which the state then publishes. That gives the public a later window into water use, but the law does not itself require a public hearing or public notice.
verified 2026-10-02: Holds, with the date corrected: the bill takes effect 6 May 2026 (Section 3); 1 July 2026 is when the operator's reporting duty starts. Re-read in late September 2026: H.B. 76 enrolled copy and the LRGC 2026 NRAE summary (May 20, 2026). Quote exact.
recordconfirmed 2026 HB 78: a waste-law exemption that fits Ward 250 exactly, conditioned on a state permit and license not yet found
2026-05-06 · gov-017 · Utah State Legislature, Utah Division of Waste Management and Radiation Control, Nuclear Energy Regulatory Office, Carl Albrecht, Derrin Owens, Valar Atomics

2026 H.B. 78, 'Nuclear Regulatory Amendments' (Rep. Carl Albrecht, Sen. Derrin Owens; effective 6 May 2026), creates a Nuclear Energy Regulatory Office inside the Division of Waste Management and Radiation Control (DWMRC), lets the division regulate fuel-cycle activities (enrichment, fabrication, storage, waste) 'subject to authorization' by the NRC, directs it to weigh expanded Agreement State status, and requires a yearly report to the Natural Resources interim committee by 30 November. Its new 19-3-321 exempts from Part 3 of the Radiation Control Act, 'Placement of High Level Nuclear Waste' (whose licensing path requires approval by the governor and Legislature, 19-3-304), the interim storage of waste that is 'produced from a project authorized by' DOE, 'from a test reactor', and 'at a facility owned by the state', but only if the project 'is permitted and licensed by the division'. Ward 250 is the one DOE-authorized test reactor on state-owned property in Utah found in the record (csite-023, mine-035). No DWMRC permit or license naming Valar was found in public records as of late September 2026 (csite-023); the lab itself holds low-level radioactive-material licenses, per its director's August 2025 remarks to the Energy Research Board (gov-013). The bill does not give the state any authority over a DOE-authorized reactor's operation, which stays with DOE (safe-034). Separately, its new 19-14-103 says Part 3 does not apply to fuel-cycle activities the division regulates or licenses under the new chapter, subject to NRC authorization.

In plain termsUtah law normally restricts placing highly radioactive waste in the state and requires the governor's and Legislature's approval for it. In 2026 the Legislature carved out an exception for interim storage of waste from a DOE-approved test reactor at a state-owned facility, which describes Valar's Emery County reactor and nothing else found. The exception only applies if the state's radiation division issues a permit and license, and as of late September 2026 no such permit had been found in public records. The same law sets up a state nuclear office, but it regulates fuel and waste, not how the reactor runs.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read HB 78 (2026) in late September 2026: sponsors, 6 May 2026 effective date, 19-3-321 conditions and quote exact. Holds; named the exempted part of the code (read) and its governor-and-Legislature approval path.
recordconfirmed Utah law: a business using tax-exempt state land pays a privilege tax equal to the property tax the land would pay, unless its lease gives no exclusive possession; the state-land exemption does not cover buildings on state land
2026-05-06 · ptax-005 · Utah State Legislature, Utah Trust Lands Administration, Valar Atomics

Utah Code 59-4-101 (version effective 6 May 2026): a tax is imposed on the possession or other beneficial use of property that is exempt from taxation, if the property is used in connection with a business conducted for profit ((1)(a)). The tax is the same amount the ad valorem property tax would be if the user held the property outright ((2)(a)); it is assessed, collected and distributed at the same time and in the same manner as ordinary property taxes ((3)(a)), and it is not a lien on the exempt property ((3)(b)). Utah Code 59-4-103 (enacted by 2026 Laws ch. 299, effective 6 May 2026) says the privilege tax does not apply to the use or possession of a lease, permit or easement 'unless the lease, permit, or easement entitles the lessee or permittee to exclusive possession' of the premises ((2)(f)); a lessee still has exclusive possession if the landlord keeps the right to enter the premises, approve leasehold improvements or inspect them ((3)(b)). Agricultural leases of public land are also exempt ((2)(e)). Utah Code 59-2-1103 (Part 11 PDF p.10): state lands held under a contract of sale or lease from the State are exempt ((1)), but the section does not exempt improvements on state lands ((2)(a)), a buyer's paid-in interest under a contract of sale ((2)(b)), or land otherwise subject to the privilege tax ((2)(c)). Applied to SULA 2095: the Trust Lands board memorandum (dated 17 September 2026, the day the board approved the lease on the memorandum's terms; mine-011) does not use the word 'exclusive' (memo text, PDF pp.18-27, searched), and, as of 12 October 2026, no signed lease was found in the records read, so whether the privilege tax applies to the land was not determined; buildings Valar might put there would not be exempt under 59-2-1103.

In plain termsLand the State of Utah holds does not pay property tax. But when a business uses that land to make money, Utah law usually charges a 'privilege tax' equal to the property tax the land would pay. That tax does not apply if the lease does not give the business the land to itself, and the records we read, as of 12 October 2026, do not show what the Valar lease says about that. Buildings a business puts on state land do not get the state land exemption.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read Utah Code 59-4-101 and 59-4-103 (versions effective 6 May 2026) and 59-2-1103 (Part 11, PDF p.10): every subsection cited and every quote matches, including the 2026 Laws ch. 299 history lines. Searched the SULA 2095 memorandum (PDF pp.18-27) and the whole 17 September 2026 packet: 'exclusive' does not appear. The board approval date rests on mine-011, now cited. Softened 'buildings on state land are not exempt' to what 59-2-1103 says (its exemption does not cover improvements), and limited the statement about the lease terms to the records read.
recordconfirmed Utah's energy-zone law as of May 2026: counties and cities may not give incentives to a nuclear baseload project outside a designated zone (the 2025 text covered all baseload projects); Trust Lands may apply for a zone
2026-05-06 · ptax-010 · Utah State Legislature, Utah Energy Council, Utah Trust Lands Administration, Utah Inland Port Authority

Utah Code 79-6-1104 (version effective 6 May 2026, amended by 2026 Laws ch. 373): a county or municipality 'may not offer financial incentives for a baseload electrical energy project' that is not in a designated electrical energy development zone ((2)(a)). The exceptions are incentives for a municipal power project, a project that uses only intermittent resources, or 'an electrical energy project that is not a nuclear energy project' ((2)(b)(i)), and any project whose project area plan was approved before 1 July 2026 ((2)(b)(ii)). The 2025 text enacted by H.B. 249 (enrolled copy, PDF p.23, bill lines 766-774) had only the municipal and intermittent exceptions and the 1 July 2026 cut-off; the non-nuclear exception is in the 2026 version but not in the 2025 enacted text, so the limit now applies only to nuclear projects. Counties and cities may apply to the Utah Energy Council for a zone ((3)). A 'regional economic development authority', defined to include the School and Institutional Trust Lands Administration (called a 'state land use authority' in the 2025 text), may propose a zone on its lands and apply for it ((1)(f), (4)). The council must decide an application within 60 days ((5)(b)). Once a zone is designated, the county auditor each year computes the property tax differential (tax from current value minus tax from the base value) and the county treasurer transfers it to the council for the Electrical Energy Development Investment Fund, subject to agreements with an overlapping community reinvestment agency or the Utah Inland Port Authority ((5)(d)-(e), (7)); the council may also make agreements with taxing entities on the differential ((8)). Record gov-016 describes the 2025 version. Whether any zone has been proposed for the SULA 2095 land was not checked for this fact.

In plain termsUtah has special 'energy development zones'. The 2025 law said a county or city may not give special money deals to a big power plant outside one of these zones, with a few exceptions. The version in force since May 2026 keeps that rule only for nuclear plants. Trust Lands can ask for a zone on its land. Inside a zone, the extra property tax from value added after the zone starts goes to a state energy fund instead of the usual local budgets, unless agreements say otherwise.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read Utah Code 79-6-1104 (version effective 6 May 2026, last amended by 2026 Laws ch. 373), subsections (1)(e)-(f), (2)-(5), (7) and (8), and H.B. 249 (2025) enrolled copy, PDF p.23, lines 759-774. All quotes match. Reworded 'was added in the 2026 version' and '2026 change' to a comparison of the two texts, since the records read do not show whether any other amendment came in between; the plain text now says the 2025 rule covered all big power plants and the zone money is tax on value added after the zone starts.
company claimreported Ward 250's DOE safety approvals: a DOE slide lists the PDSA (Feb 2026) and final DSA (Apr 23) dates Valar gave, and DOE confirms a readiness review took place; no approval document was found
2026-04-23 · safe-006 · Valar Atomics, U.S. Department of Energy, DOE Idaho Operations Office, Bob Boston

The NSDA scheduled submittals of the NSDA (22 Sept 2025), PDSA (1 Nov 2025) and final DSA and TSRs (6 Jan 2026), each with a 45-day DOE review, construction complete by 13 April 2026 and initial criticality on 30 June 2026. POWER (19 June 2026) reports preliminary DSA approval in February 2026 and final DSA approval on 23 April 2026; its links for both dates go to Valar's LinkedIn posts, which require a login and were not read. A DOE Office of Nuclear Energy slide prepared for the NRC Commission's 21 July 2026 meeting lists the same dates, 'February 2026 – PDSA Approved' and 'April 23, 2026 - DSA Approved', with no document numbers. Valar's Castle Country page says Ward 250 operates with 'DOE-approved safety documentation and a completed operational readiness review'. ANS reports that the federal review was led by Bob Boston, a manager at DOE's Idaho Operations Office, and, citing Boston's LinkedIn post, that a joint test group had to sign off on key start-up steps before DOE authorized the criticality test. DOE's 18 June 2026 release calls Ward 250 'the first DOE authorized reactor built outside of a national laboratory' but does not mention the DSA, the readiness review or the startup approval. DOE's categorical exclusion, signed 22 April 2026, already describes what 'the Documented Safety Analysis demonstrates', the day before the final approval date POWER reported and the DOE slide lists (it may refer to the DSA as submitted). No DOE document approving the PDSA, DSA, TSRs or startup was found on DOE's sites as of late September 2026; the DOE slide gives dates only (see safe-007). DOE's Office of Environmental Management wrote on 14 July 2026 that its staff took part in DOE's review of advanced microreactor designs 'from preliminary to final design', and that 17 EM team members took part in the readiness review for the four pilot reactors that went critical by 4 July, naming Ward 250 (dir-031); the article gives no Ward 250 dates or documents. Under 10 CFR 830.207(a), the rule the NSDA names, a contractor may not begin operating a new Hazard Category 1, 2 or 3 facility before DOE issues a safety evaluation report approving its safety basis; DOE's statement that Ward 250 was authorized and went critical fits that step having been completed, though the report itself was not found (safe-041).

In plain termsEach step of the safety review is supposed to end with a DOE approval. The dates of the two safety-analysis approvals come from the company's own posts, repeated by a trade magazine, and from a DOE slide shown to federal regulators in July 2026, which lists the same dates. DOE's public announcement confirms the reactor was authorized and went critical, which means approvals happened, but no public copy of the approvals themselves, or of the conditions they set, was found as of late September 2026. DOE has since said, in a July 2026 article by its Office of Environmental Management, that its staff reviewed contractor safety submittals for the pilot microreactors and took part in the readiness review of Ward 250 and three other test reactors before startup (dir-031); the article gives no dates or documents for Ward 250.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read POWER (links for both approval dates go to Valar LinkedIn posts, checked in the page HTML), ANS, DOE release, Castle Country, NSDA Table 7 and CX signature (22 Apr 2026 07:01 MDT) in late September 2026. Holds; ANS's account attributed to Boston's own post. Stays reported: the approval documents were not found; on 17 October 2026 a DOE slide listing the same two approval dates was found. Revised before publication (2026-10-01): wording made more exact against the cited records.
recordconfirmed Valar's Utah reactor cleared federal environmental review with a categorical exclusion, so no EA or EIS was required
2026-04-22 · csite-020 · U.S. Department of Energy, DOE Idaho Operations Office, Valar Atomics

DOE's NEPA determination DOE-ID-26-005, digitally signed on 22 April 2026 by a DOE NEPA compliance officer (the PDF's web address places its upload in June 2026), categorically excluded 'Valar Ward250 Research Reactor' at the Utah San Rafael Energy Research Center from further NEPA review under category B5.26. DOE created B5.26 by a Federal Register notice effective 2 February 2026 (comments were taken afterwards, to 4 March), under Executive Order 14301; it covers 'Authorization, siting, construction, operation, reauthorization, and decommissioning of advanced nuclear reactors' if DOE finds the risk of offsite release is sufficiently reduced and wastes can be managed, and says a project 'may include multiple reactors'. The notice states that reactors 'developed for additional purposes, such as power production and industrial applications' are also appropriate for it. DOE's B5.26 listing showed five determinations in late September 2026. No DOE NEPA document for a Carbon County site was found in the records read as of late September 2026.

In plain termsFederal law (NEPA) makes agencies study environmental effects before approving projects, for larger actions in a public environmental assessment or impact statement. A 'categorical exclusion' is a category for actions the agency has decided are normally minor: no environmental assessment or impact statement, and no comment period on the project. It is an environmental-review decision under NEPA, separate from DOE's nuclear-safety approval of the reactor (safety analysis, operating limits, readiness review, startup approval; safe-041, dir-031). DOE created one for advanced reactors in February 2026 and used it for Valar's Emery County reactor in April. It is written broadly enough to cover power reactors and multi-reactor sites. If a Carbon County reactor goes the DOE route, neighbors may get no federal environmental report to comment on at all; if it goes through the NRC, a public review would be expected (csite-010).
verified 2026-10-02: Holds. Re-read in late September 2026: CX-271015 (7 pages; signature dated 2026.04.22); Federal Register 2026-02071 (91 FR 4550; effective 2 Feb 2026, comments to 4 Mar) full text; DOE's B5.26 listing (Groves-1, SPARC, Ward250, Deployable Energy, Aalo-X). Quotes exact. 'Idaho Operations' removed: the document gives only the DOE-ID number. Second check, late September 2026: the notice is now cited from DOE's own posted copy, read in full: effective 2 Feb 2026, comments due 4 Mar 2026, B5.26 text, 'multiple reactors within a nuclear facility', 'additional purposes, such as power production and industrial applications'. Revised before publication (2026-09-30): reworded the plain-language text. Revised before publication (2026-10-01): wording made more exact against the cited records.
analysisconfirmed DOE reviewed Ward 250 as one short test ending in cleanup, while Valar was already mapping a bigger Utah build-out
2026-04-22 · csite-021 · U.S. Department of Energy, Valar Atomics, Bureau of Land Management, Utah Trust Lands Administration

The categorical exclusion (csite-020) describes a '24-month research program': about 12 months of operation, 6 of cooldown and 6 of decommissioning, a 'single limited-duration research mission', spent fuel as 'a single core loading' shipped in casks to a DOE-approved facility, and the site returned to unrestricted use; it states the proposal 'has not been segmented' (split up to look smaller). By the 22 April signing date, the record shows: a 10,270-acre 'Green River Gigasite' reactor/data-center application to BLM pending since 13 February (mine-006; in September 2026 Valar said it was a survey-access application it had decided not to pursue, mine-008); an Emery County MOU item for site testing on parcel 04-0019-0030 on 17 February (orig-046); Trust Lands' map of the Carbon lease produced 9 April (mine-048); and the state's RDCC review of that lease, opened 20 April, two days before the signing (csite-032). Afterwards, per the board's minutes, a Valar representative told the state's economic board on 9 July that Valar planned to install more commercial units in the area (csite-024), and a Valar representative told the Trust Lands board on 20 August that the Emery lab is now its 'whole Utah operations' including its fuel facility (mine-019). The CX's own text says segmentation 'does not include' phased proposals where each phase gets its own decision, and the CX concerns one reactor; whether DOE was told of the other sites is not in the records read.

In plain termsWhen DOE decided Valar's Emery reactor needed no public environmental study, it looked at a two-year experiment that ends with the reactor removed and the ground cleaned up. At the same time the company was lining up land for a much larger, long-term nuclear and industrial presence in Emery and Carbon counties. Treating each step separately can be legitimate under DOE's own rules. But it means no federal review found as of late September 2026 looks at what the whole plan adds up to for the area.
verified 2026-10-18: Holds. Re-read in late September 2026: CX pp. 1, 4-6 (24-month program, single core loading, 'has not been segmented', phased-proposal proviso); GOED July 9 minutes (docx); August 20 transcript (quote exact, auto-generated). Dates of the other records re-checked: BLM case UTUT106784007 created 13 Feb 2026, lease map 9 Apr, RDCC project created 20 Apr. 'Executive' changed to 'representative' (the transcript gives no title).
recordconfirmed The state's first public notice of the lease (RDCC, April 20, 2026) called it an industrial and power project; no nuclear, no name
2026-04-20 · csite-032 · Resource Development Coordinating Committee, Utah Trust Lands Administration, Carbon County

The Resource Development Coordinating Committee's public project layer (the data behind rdcc.utah.gov) holds project 87203, 'SULA 2095 - Lease Agreement with possible option to purchase', sponsor Trust Lands Administration, created 20 April 2026 with a comment deadline of 18 May 2026, legal description 'T14S, R11E, Sec. 16 N2, SW4', Carbon County, local government contacted 'Y' on 20 April 2026, status 'State Comment Published'. Its abstract says TLA received a lease application 'from a private entity' for 'a large-scale industrial project' including manufacturing, 'power generation infrastructure' and other industrial uses, with a possible purchase option, on 480 acres. It lists impacts as permanent land-use change, landscape change, traffic and 'noise associated with manufacturing and power generation'. It does not name Valar or mention nuclear reactors, fuel or radioactive material. This broadly matches the memo's statement that the proposal ran 30 days on the RDCC dashboard (the layer's comment period, 20 April to 18 May, is 28 days) and went to the county (csite-005); the only comment the memo records is from the Division of Water Rights (mine-012). The same layer holds the Guard lease on the section, 'SULA 1321 - Utah National Guard Training Area' (project 588), whose document link is filed under 2001.

In plain termsRDCC is the state's clearinghouse where agencies and local governments can comment on projects on state land. The Wellington lease was posted there from 20 April to 18 May 2026, and Carbon County was formally contacted on 20 April, more than two months before the commissioners signed their letter of support. The posting described a big industrial and power-generation project, which is accurate as far as it goes, but did not say the power would be nuclear or who the company was. A reader of the state dashboard would not have known this was a nuclear campus.
verified 2026-10-02: Holds. Checked again in late September 2026: RDCC public layer, projects 87203 (created 2026-04-20 17:14 UTC; comment deadline 2026-05-18; local government contacted Y on 2026-04-20; status 'State Comment Published') and 588. Abstract quote exact. The 2001 date for SULA 1321 now rests only on the record's document link, as stated.
recordconfirmed The state's lease map for SULA 2095 was produced on 9 April 2026, four months before the bid deadline
2026-04-09 · mine-048 · Utah Trust Lands Administration, Valar Atomics

The 'Special Use Lease Agreement No. 2095' map attached to both Trust Lands board packets (August packet p. 35, September packet p. 29) outlines the 480-acre N1/2 and SW1/4 of Sec. 16, T14S R11E, and its footer reads 'Produced: April 09, 2026'. So by 9 April 2026 Trust Lands had given the lease a number and mapped its area. That is about four months before the 7 August 2026 deadline in the agency's public notice, which named no applicant and no use (mine-012), and about eleven and a half weeks before the Carbon County Commission's 29 June support letter (mine-013). The records read do not show when Valar's application was filed or when the public notice was first posted.

In plain termsA map's 'produced' date is the day the state made it. This one shows the state was already preparing this particular lease, under its lease number, by early April 2026. The public notice inviting competing offers came later and did not say who had applied or what the land was for. When the application arrived and when the notice first ran are in Trust Lands' files, which a records request can get.
verified 2026-10-02: Found during verification in late September 2026: map footers read from both packets.
company claimconfirmed At the April 2026 land-sale hearing Valar promised 'to be open with all plans'; its Carbon site was not named
2026-04-07 · gov-038 · Valar Atomics, Cory Gardner, Keven Jensen, Dennis Worwood, Emery County Commission, Utah Trust Lands Administration

Emery County's minutes of the 7 April 2026 public hearing on selling parcel 04-0019-0030 record Valar's commercial development representative, Cory Gardner (spelled 'Gardiner' there), saying the company is part of the community and will 'promise to be open with all plans', and Commissioner Keven Jensen saying Valar 'has been transparent'. Set beside the record: at that hearing Valar described its plans for the Emery parcel (fuel fabrication, manufacturing, possible temporary employee housing), and Commissioner Dennis Worwood said the sale was 'an intermediate step' while Valar looks for 'a larger piece of property with water' (gov-022), but no Carbon County site was named; the state's lease map for the Wellington section is dated two days later, 9 April 2026 (mine-048); the state's 20 April public notice named neither Valar nor nuclear (csite-032); and the first public agenda found naming Valar with the Carbon site came on 10 August 2026 (csite-018). On the other side of the ledger, Valar did open its Emery facility to the public: on 17 February 2026 it told the commission it would hold open houses, the first on 24 February 2026. The gap is between a general promise of openness and the public records found, which did not show the Carbon site for four months; what Valar knew about the Wellington lease on 7 April is not in the records read.

In plain termsAt a public hearing in April 2026, Valar told Emery County residents it would be open about all its plans, and a county commissioner called the company transparent. Two days later the state produced the lease map for Valar's Carbon County site, and no public notice found named Valar as the applicant for that site until August. Valar did hold open houses in Emery County, and a commissioner said at the hearing that Valar wanted more land with water. But no public record found connected Valar to the Wellington site for four months after the promise.
verified 2026-10-02: New in an earlier check, late September 2026; both minutes read in that check; dates of the Carbon records rest on mine-048, csite-032 and csite-018. No intent asserted.
company claimconfirmed Valar told residents 'every design' is reviewed and approved by DOE; true for the test reactor, not its commercial plans
2026-04-07 · gov-039 · Valar Atomics, Max Ukropina, Emery County Commission, U.S. Department of Energy, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission

At the same 7 April 2026 Emery County hearing, a resident asked about safety buffer zones; Valar's representative answered that every design has to be reviewed and approved by the Department of Energy. Asked about 'turmoil' between the state and the NRC, Valar's Max Ukropina said past laws had been burdensome and that President Trump had loosened some regulations. Set beside the record: for Ward 250 the answer holds, since DOE alone authorizes it (safe-001, gov-005). For what Valar has described next it is incomplete: three months later, the state incentive board's minutes record Valar describing plans for more commercial units in the area and behind-the-meter power sales (gov-033); the executive order behind the DOE route covers reactors that do not produce commercial electric power (gov-005); and DOE's own releases, and Hogan Lovells' summary of the law, place later commercial licensing with the NRC (gov-007, gov-032, csite-010). DOE's Launch Pad USA pathway can authorize non-federal sites; a House subcommittee's hearing charter lists Valar among the 13 Launch Pad projects the National Reactor Innovation Center announced on 24 August 2026, but no record read as of late September 2026 shows Valar using the pathway for another site (gov-010).

In plain termsAsked about safety at a public hearing, Valar said every design must be reviewed and approved by the Energy Department. That is true of the test reactor running now. But Valar has told state officials it plans commercial reactors that sell power, and under the President's own order, reactors that produce commercial power fall outside the Energy Department's shortcut. Those would need a license from the Nuclear Regulatory Commission instead.
verified 2026-10-18: New in an earlier check, late September 2026; all three sources read that day. The resident who asked is described, not named.
company claimreported Emery expansion as told in public: more land 'to expand their factory', plans 'not firm', a 10-acre staging yard
2026-04-07 · plan-024 · Valar Atomics, Emery County Commission

ETV's report (9 April 2026) of Emery County's 7 April hearing on selling the 112-acre parcel beside the lab says Valar's representatives explained they needed more land to expand their factory and ready the reactor, and, asked what they planned to build, replied that plans were not firm yet but they were considering expansion and 'maybe even housing'. Later in the same meeting the commission approved a real-estate use agreement letting Valar use 10 acres south of the lab as a laydown and staging area during construction, with a waiver of liability. The county's own minutes add that Valar named 'fuel fabrication and manufacturing' for the parcel and that a commissioner called the sale an 'intermediate step' while Valar looked for a larger property with water (gov-022, gov-038); the sale price was $394,500 and closing was not confirmed as of mid-August (loc-014); Orangeville is drafting an advanced-energy zoning district and annexation for the land, and its council's draft minutes of 10 September 2026 record the annexation 'held up due to mineral rights on the property' while the city waited for the purchase to be finalized, minutes the council approved on 8 October 2026 with no amendment moved (loc-013, loc-014; city recording, about 0:02:00 to 0:02:26); Valar is seeking up to 1,000 more water shares for future development there (loc-017). The Wellington lease map was drawn two days after this hearing (mine-048).

In plain termsValar is buying a large piece of county land next to the lab. When residents asked what would go there, the company said its plans were not settled: more factory space, maybe housing. A county commissioner described the purchase as a stepping stone while Valar looked for a bigger site with water. Two days after the hearing, the state mapped a Carbon County lease for Valar; the first public record we found that names Valar for that site is from August 2026 (csite-018, csite-028).
verified 2026-10-19: Checked in late September 2026: ETV (9 April 2026) re-read; quotes exact; hearing date (7 April) from the county's 7 April minutes. Fixed: the plain text said the public 'did not learn of' the lease until August; a notice without Valar's name was posted in April (csite-032), so it now says the first record naming Valar for the site is from August.
recordconfirmed March 31, 2026: the Utah Energy Council's agenda put a Valar update at the San Rafael lab just before a public-comment item
2026-03-31 · gov-041 · Utah Energy Council, Utah Office of Energy Development, Valar Atomics, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab

The Utah Energy Council's agenda for its 31 March 2026 meeting (virtual, with an anchor location at the Cannon DHHS Building in Salt Lake City; posted on the Utah Public Notice Website, file dated 30 March 2026) lists item 7, 'Valar Atomics at San Rafael Lab Update', and item 8, 'Public comment', two minutes per speaker, which the agenda describes as 'time set aside for citizens to express their views' and says no immediate action can be taken on matters raised. Item 9 is a closed strategy session on the purchase, exchange or lease of real property under H.B. 70 (2025), which names no property (csite-031). The minutes of this meeting were not read, so what was said in the update or in public comment is not known. It is one of several noticed state meetings at which Valar's Emery work came up with a public-comment item on the same agenda (gov-040, gov-042).

In plain termsIn March 2026 the state's Energy Council had a Valar update on its posted agenda, followed directly by time for the public to speak. The agenda shows the chance to comment existed; the record read does not show what was said.
verified 2026-10-02: Added 1 October 2026. Read the agenda (last modified 30 March 2026), items 1-13; quotes exact (the second quote is split across a line break in the PDF, so only its first line is quoted). Minutes not read. Checked a second time on 1 October 2026.
recordconfirmed Emery's notice of its land sale named Valar in the local paper; the state's Carbon notice named no one
2026-03-25 · loc-007 · Emery County Commission, Valar Atomics, Utah Trust Lands Administration · sale price later set for parcel 04-0019-0030 (gov-022): $394,500

Emery County's legal notice for the sale of parcel 04-0019-0030, headed 'Proposed Property Transaction of Parcel 04-0019-0030 between Emery County and Valar Atomics', ran in ETV News on 25 March and 1 April 2026 under Utah Code 17-78-103, announcing a public hearing on 7 April 2026 at 3:00 p.m. in Castle Dale and a price set by the average of two independent appraisals. The hearing was held and reported (ETV, 9 April; minutes, gov-022). By contrast, Trust Lands' notice for the Wellington section, posted on its website from 8 July 2026 and printed in ETV News on 15, 22 and 29 July (loc-032), named neither the applicant nor the use (csite-005, mine-012), and the state's April RDCC notice called it an unnamed 'large-scale industrial project' (RDCC project 87203; csite-032). Emery County's hearing concerned a sale of county land, which state law makes subject to notice and a hearing; Trust Lands' arrangement is exempt from its ordinary lease rule (csite-004). The different treatment follows different rules; the result is that Emery's notice in the local paper named Valar before the vote, while the state's application notices for the Carbon parcel did not; the first public record found naming Valar for the site was the Trust Lands board's agenda posted online on 10 August 2026, for a meeting in Salt Lake City (csite-018).

In plain termsWhen Emery County approved selling land to Valar, it put Valar's name in the local paper two weeks ahead and held a hearing. When the state approved leasing the square mile north of Wellington, its public notice said only that someone had applied for the land, without saying who or for what. Different agencies follow different rules, but the effect was that Emery's notice in the local paper named Valar, while the state's notices for the Carbon land did not; the first public record found naming Valar for the Carbon site was a state board agenda posted online in August, about five weeks before the vote.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read the ETV legal notice and 9 April report: holds. Named the paper that carried the Wellington notice (ETV, loc-032). Revised before publication (late September 2026): sale and lease wording now 'approved selling'/'approved leasing'.
recordconfirmed Utility district minutes: Valar 'tied into the county sewer system without prior authorization'; state permit needed
2026-03-19 · loc-015 · Castle Valley Special Service District, Valar Atomics, Utah Division of Water Quality, Jess Housekeeper

Castle Valley Special Service District (CVSSD) runs water and sewer for Castle Valley towns including Orangeville. Its approved minutes of 19 February 2026 record Valar's Jess Housekeeper presenting Valar's plans (by video), the board approving a $20,000 outside-district water connection for Valar contingent on all water shares being submitted to Orangeville, and the manager reporting that Valar 'will be required to apply to' the state Division of Water Quality (DWQ) for a sewer discharge permit, which DWQ would administer for four years, and that no sewer connection would be approved until DWQ approved the permit. The approved minutes of 19 March 2026 (whose opening line misdates the meeting to 19 February) record the manager's update: sewer plans 'were not submitted to the State as required', water service work was paused pending DWQ approval, 'Valar tied into the county sewer system without prior authorization', Valar was asking for ordinary sanitary sewer service for restrooms only with no process water, a site visit with the regional DEQ engineer was planned, and water service would not be provided until all sewer permits and approvals were in place; no action was taken. The district's May, July and August 2026 minutes (read; the June minutes, approved on 16 July, were not found on the state public notice website as of 30 September 2026) do not return to the sewer issue, though the May minutes discuss annexing property near Orangeville 'that may be developed by Valor', and its 17 September agenda lists no Valar item. DOE's categorical exclusion puts water use under 1,000 gallons a day for domestic use, with no process-water discharges, which matches the restrooms-only request. As of 30 September 2026, no record read shows whether DWQ issued a permit, or how the tie-in the minutes report was resolved.

In plain termsThe local water-and-sewer district recorded in March 2026 a staff report that Valar had 'tied into the county sewer system without prior authorization', and had not sent its sewer plans to the state as required. The request itself was ordinary, toilets and sinks only, not reactor water. The district's minutes are the only record of it found, and no Valar response or later resolution appears in the records read. Whether the state permit was later issued was not found in the records read as of 30 September 2026; a GRAMA request to the Division of Water Quality and to the district would show it.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read the Feb and Mar minutes (text) and the May and July minutes (scanned): holds. Corrected 'June minutes read' (June's are not posted). Plain-language text: 'habit' implied a pattern from one record, now 'process'. Revised before publication (late September 2026): the plain-language text attributes the tie-in to the staff report and drops a conclusion. Revised before publication (2026-09-30): reworded the detail.
recordconfirmed DOE's new NEPA exclusion drew formal objections, incl. from Utah groups; no DOE response was found on its NEPA page as of late September 2026
2026-03-04 · safe-029 · U.S. Department of Energy, Nuclear Information and Resource Service, HEAL Utah, Uranium Watch

DOE announced categorical exclusion B5.26 on 2 February 2026 (91 FR 4550), already included in its procedures (the notice says it is 'effective on February 2, 2026'), and invited comments until 4 March 2026 (csite-020). On 4 March the Nuclear Information and Resource Service filed comments for itself and 25 groups, including HEAL Utah and Uranium Watch of Moab, arguing among other things that the exclusion expressly allows multiple reactors in one facility, that stacking exclusions and judging segmentation or 'extraordinary circumstances' would be shielded from public input, and that public involvement improves reviews. Uranium Watch wrote that coverage of the Valar reactor gave no information on worker and resident protection, emergency response planning, spent-fuel storage, who to contact, oversight or the need for NRC licensing if power is sold to non-federal entities. DOE's categorical-exclusion page, read in late September 2026, still says DOE 'will consider' comments received by 4 March and links no response. DOE applied B5.26 to Ward 250 on 22 April 2026; that determination says no extraordinary circumstance applies, a category it defines to include scientific controversy about environmental effects. The exclusion's text, as printed in the determination, says 'a project may include multiple reactors within a nuclear facility'.

In plain termsDOE put the exclusion into effect first and took comments afterwards. Twenty-six groups, including two from Utah, objected in writing that it limits public input and can cover several reactors at one facility. Seven weeks after the comment period closed, DOE used it for Valar's reactor, finding no 'extraordinary circumstance', a category that includes scientific controversy. As of late September 2026, DOE's page shows no answer to those comments.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read NIRS comments (25 co-signers counted, incl. HEAL Utah and Uranium Watch), DOE's CX page and the CX in late September 2026. Holds. Fixed: 'effective 2 February' now sourced (DOE page plus NIRS); the CX finds no 'extraordinary circumstance', which it defines to include scientific controversy, rather than finding 'no scientific controversy' as such. Revised before publication (2026-09-30): reworded the headline; reworded the detail; reworded the plain-language text; removed the citation of Nuclear Information and Resource Service et al. (it was cited for what DOE said, which DOE's own notice now shows; the filing stays cited as the objectors' own comments); now cites U.S. Department of Energy (Federal Register notice) instead.
recordconfirmed Fire review of the reactor building: fire district minutes say the State Fire Marshal declined and the county lacked a fire inspector
2026-02-17 · loc-018 · Emery County Fire Protection Special Service District, Utah State Fire Marshal, Valar Atomics, Emery County Commission

Minutes of the Emery County Fire Protection Special Service District: 17 November 2025, item 'Getting 3rd Party to Review Plans for Nuclear Power Plant': the district was asked to approve fire plans for the 'Nuclear test plant' at Orangeville; the chair had called the State Fire Marshal's office, which 'didn't want to touch it'; the board tabled it to get information on the fire code and whether there was adequate water flow (GPM) for the building classification. 15 December 2025: the chair said he would sign the fire protection plans as soon as the paperwork arrived (safe-016). 17 February 2026 (the minutes' header reads 'Tuesday, February 17th, 2025', misprinting the year), item 'Valar Atomics': fire chiefs were asked to review building plans; 'State agencies declined to perform plan review and recommended third-party review'; responsibility may fall to the district or a local fire authority because there is no county fire inspector; the review concerns building fire-code compliance, not reactor design. 16 March 2026: 'The issue has been addressed with chiefs and is not currently a concern.' The April, May and June 2026 minutes do not return to it. Separately, Emery County's commission voted Valar's building permit itself on 2 September 2025 because its building department had not issued one (gov-021), and Orangeville's fire chief reported on 12 March 2026 that he had gone through Valar's safety protocols (loc-008). As of 30 September 2026, no record read says whether a third-party plan review was done, who did it, or what it found.

In plain termsBefore a building opens, someone normally checks its plans against the fire code. For the building that houses the reactor, the fire district's minutes say state agencies declined to do that check and recommended a third-party review, and that the county lacked a fire inspector of its own, so the job may fall to the county fire district or a local fire department. The March 2026 minutes say it 'has been addressed with chiefs and is not currently a concern', but not how, or by whom. This is about ordinary fire safety of the building, not the nuclear safety of the reactor, which DOE reviews.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read all fire district minutes. Corrected the meeting date to 17 Feb 2026 (Tuesday; the header misprints the year). Fixed the Orangeville fire chief item and removed 'volunteer' from the plain-language text (not in the source). Revised before publication (2026-09-30): reworded the plain-language text. Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): the fire-review statements are attributed to the fire district's minutes; see Corrections.
recordconfirmed Feb 2026 Emery County agenda: support letter for Valar and an MOU for site testing on a county parcel
2026-02-17 · orig-046 · Valar Atomics, Emery County Commission

The Emery County Commission's February 17, 2026 meeting notice lists two Valar items: approving or denying a county letter of support to Valar Atomics, and approving or denying an MOU letting Valar perform site suitability testing on parcel 04-0019-0030. This shows Valar was seeking to test county land next to the state lab by early 2026: county minutes of 20 January 2026 call the parcel 'the property next to the Research Center', and the county later approved selling it to Valar (gov-022). Valar's Castle Country page says the commission backed the project unanimously. The commission's minutes of the same day record the support letter approved 3-0, subject to the county attorney's review and approval, and the MOU item as 'Tabled'.

In plain termsIn February 2026 Emery County's agenda listed a support letter for Valar and a proposed agreement letting Valar test a county parcel next to the state lab; the commission approved the letter and tabled the agreement. The county later approved selling that parcel, about 112 acres, to Valar (gov-022).
verified 2026-10-19: Second check, late September 2026: Utah Public Notice page re-read: February 17, 2026 agenda with the support letter and the parcel 04-0019-0030 MOU. Castle Country page still says the commission backed the project unanimously. Match.
recordconfirmed BLM records show three pending Valar land applications, two in its Price office, incl. a 10,271-acre 'Green River Gigasite'
2026-02-13 · mine-006 · Valar Atomics, Bureau of Land Management, BLM Price Field Office

BLM's public rights-of-way layer lists Valar Atomics on three pending cases; the first two name it 'Applicant' and were filed with the Price Field Office (the office that handles most rights-of-way cases in Carbon and Emery counties in the same layer): (1) UTUT106784007, 'Green River Gigasite Small Modular Reactor/Data Center', a FLPMA land-use case, 'Pending' since 13 February 2026 (last modified 26 May 2026), 10,270.61 acres in T20S-T21S, R14E-R16E, north-west of the town of Green River in Emery County; (2) UTUT106801248, 'Project Beehive Small Modular Reactor/Data Center', 'Pending' (disposition date 13 April 2026, record created 30 April, last modified 15 September 2026), with no land description or map in the public layer; (3) UTUT106833224, filed under BLM's 'Oil and Gas Pipelines' product with the commodity 'DISTRIBUTION LINE', created 23 July 2026, 'Pending', also with no land shown and no case name. None of the three involves mining claims. No Federal Register notice naming Valar for any of them was found (mine-009). On 18 September 2026 Valar told The Washington Sun that the Green River filing was an application for survey access and that it had decided not to pursue that project; BLM's layer still listed the case as 'Pending' in late September 2026 (mine-008).

In plain termsBesides the reactor at the state lab, Valar has asked the federal government for the use of public land for at least one very large reactor-and-data-center site near Green River (about 16 square miles; in September 2026 Valar said it had decided not to pursue it, mine-008), for a second site called 'Project Beehive' whose location is not shown in BLM's public layer, and for a third case BLM files as a pipeline ('distribution line'), location not shown. These are applications, not approvals. They can be seen in BLM's public case map, but no public notice of them was found (mine-009).
verified 2026-10-02: Re-checked in late September 2026: all three cases, dates, acreage, legal description and 'Pending' status match. BLM's Price Field Office web page does not list its counties, so the coverage wording now rests on the case layer itself; the third case is described by BLM's own category (pipeline), not guessed as power or gas. The Federal Register search (in late September 2026) returned one document naming Valar, a DOE notice of 6 July 2026 on Defense Production Act voluntary agreements, not about these cases. Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): the headline says two of the three cases are in BLM's Price office, and the acreage is rounded to 10,271; see Corrections.
recordconfirmed Carbon County's state-assessed property fell from $1.49 billion (63% of taxable value) in 2008 to $609 million (23%) in 2025; oil and gas fell most, coal also fell
2025 · ptax-001 · Utah State Tax Commission, Carbon County · Carbon County centrally assessed (state-assessed) taxable value, 2008: $1,487,181,725; Carbon County centrally assessed taxable value, 2025: $608,548,196; Carbon County total local and central taxable value, 2008: $2,353,278,176; Carbon County total local and central taxable value, 2025: $2,662,874,222; fall in oil and gas value, 2008 to 2025 (categories changed in 2016; approximate pairing): $812,814,097; fall in coal and coal load-out value, 2008 to 2025 (approximate pairing): $137,447,698; Carbon County value in Table 1E's 'electric generation' column, 2025: $0

Utah State Tax Commission annual statistical reports, Carbon County rows. 'Centrally assessed' property is the property the Tax Commission values itself: 'utilities, mines and railroads', in the words of the 2025 report's overview (PDF p.4); in the tables this includes oil and gas, coal, pipelines and electric and gas utilities. 2008 report, Table 1 (PDF p.14): centrally assessed taxable value $1,487,181,725 of a total local and central value of $2,353,278,176 (63.2%; locally assessed $866,096,451; motor vehicles excluded). 2025 report, Table 1 (PDF p.8): centrally assessed $608,548,196 of $2,662,874,222 (printed share 22.85%; locally assessed real property $1,810,105,208 and personal property $244,220,818). Centrally assessed value fell by $878,633,529 (59%) over the period while the county's total taxable value rose. By kind of property (the natural-resource categories changed between the 2015 report, which still used 'oil & gas extraction' and 'coal mines', and the 2016 report, which first split coal, coal load-out and oil and gas gathering, production and disposal (Table 1F in each), so these pairings are approximate): oil and gas, $989,577,656 of 'oil & gas extraction' in 2008 (Table 1F, PDF p.23) against $176,763,559 of oil and gas gathering ($2,709,085), production ($174,054,474) and disposal ($0) in 2025 (Table 1F, PDF p.18), a fall of $812,814,097; coal, $248,987,164 of 'coal mines' in 2008 against $111,539,466 of coal ($103,491,557) and coal load-out ($8,047,909) in 2025, a fall of $137,447,698. Table 1E for 2025 (PDF p.16) shows $0 in its 'electric generation' column for Carbon County; that column is separate from 'electric utility', so it does not by itself show whether utility-owned generating property is in the county. Carbon's 2025 utility values were railroad $131,186,067, electric utility $71,569,257, gas utility $20,460,653 and gas pipeline $81,547,247. The 2008 report grouped utilities differently (power $88,834,310; Table 1E, PDF p.22). Differences and percentages are arithmetic on the printed figures.

In plain termsSome property in Carbon County, like gas wells, coal mines, railroads and pipelines, is valued by the state instead of the county. In 2008 that property made up almost two-thirds of the county's taxable value; by 2025 it was less than a quarter. The biggest drop was in oil and gas, and coal went down too. The 2025 tables list nothing for the county under 'electric generation'.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read the Carbon County rows of the 2008 report (Table 1, PDF p.14; Tables 1E and 1F, PDF pp.22-23) and the 2025 report (Table 1, PDF p.8; Table 1E, PDF p.16; Table 1F, PDF p.18) by row and column; every value matches and every difference and share was recomputed (63.2%, 22.85% printed, $878,633,529 or 59%, $812,814,097, $137,447,698). The 2016 category change was checked against Table 1F of the 2015 and 2016 reports. Reworded: a $0 in the 'electric generation' column, which is separate from 'electric utility', does not by itself mean the county has no power-plant value.
recordconfirmed Who pays Carbon property tax: state-assessed property's share fell from 58.7% (2008) to 22.7% (2025); primary homes' share rose from 19.0% to 38.5%
2025 · ptax-002 · Utah State Tax Commission, Carbon County, Carbon County School District · total property taxes charged in Carbon County, 2008 (local and central): $22,232,457; taxes charged on centrally assessed property, 2008: $13,055,483; taxes charged on primary residential property, 2008: $4,218,902; total property taxes charged in Carbon County, 2025 (local and central): $33,962,354; taxes charged on centrally assessed property, 2025: $7,709,579; taxes charged on primary residential real property, 2025: $13,060,580; general county taxes charged, 2025: $7,931,918; school taxes charged, 2025: $18,779,411; city and town taxes charged, 2025: $2,505,320; special district taxes charged, 2025: $4,745,706

Tax Commission annual statistical reports, Carbon County rows; taxes charged on locally and centrally assessed property, excluding motor-vehicle fees in lieu. 2008, Table 2 (PDF p.26): total $22,232,457, of which centrally assessed $13,055,483 (58.7%; utilities $2,262,199 and natural resources $10,793,284) and locally assessed $9,176,974; Table 2A (PDF p.27): primary residential property $4,218,902 (19.0% of the total). 2025, Table 2 (PDF p.22): total $33,962,354, of which centrally assessed $7,709,579 (22.7%) and locally assessed $26,252,775; Table 2A (PDF p.24): primary residential real property $13,060,580 (38.5%). Table 2F (PDF p.33) splits the 2025 total by who levies it: general county $7,931,918 (23.36%), schools $18,779,411 (55.29%), cities and towns $2,505,320 (7.38%) and special districts $4,745,706 (13.97%); the four parts add to $1 more than the printed total, and the table's note says differences may be due to rounding. Total taxes charged rose from $22.2 million to $34.0 million (not adjusted for inflation); these tables do not by themselves say how much of the rise came from rate changes, new levies or home values. Shares are arithmetic on the printed figures.

In plain termsProperty tax is split among many kinds of property. In 2008, state-valued industry like gas wells and coal mines was charged more than half of Carbon County's property tax, and people's main homes about a fifth. By 2025 industry's part had shrunk to under a quarter, and main homes' part had grown to almost two-fifths. More than half of the 2025 money went to schools.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read the Carbon County rows of the 2008 report (Table 2, PDF p.26; Table 2A, PDF p.27) and the 2025 report (Table 2, PDF p.22; Table 2A, PDF p.24; Table 2F, PDF p.33) by row and column; every value matches. Recomputed the shares (58.7%, 19.0%, 22.7%, 38.5%) and confirmed the Table 2F parts add to $33,962,355, $1 above the printed total, with the table's note on rounding.
recordconfirmed School equalization: Carbon's basic-levy money replaces state aid dollar for dollar, state guarantee money can shrink as certified rates change with property values, and the district got 53.9% of FY2025 revenue from the State
2025 · ptax-007 · Carbon County School District, Utah State Board of Education, Utah State Legislature · Carbon School District total revenue, year ended 30 June 2025: $54,002,145; state revenue to Carbon School District, year ended 30 June 2025: $29,121,531; basic levy yield in Carbon, FY2025 Minimum School Program: $3,716,815; state amounts on Carbon's voted and board levies, regular columns, FY2025 (arithmetic): $567,933; state amounts on Carbon's voted and board levies, all three state columns, FY2025 (arithmetic): $1,963,609; Carbon School District property taxes, year ended 30 June 2024: $17,856,807; of which in the debt service fund, year ended 30 June 2024: $2,605,254; statewide minimum basic local amount, fiscal year beginning 1 July 2026: $866,842,700

Utah Code 53F-2-301 (version effective 1 July 2026): each school board must impose the statewide minimum basic tax rate to receive the State's contribution ((4)(a)); the State contributes the difference between the cost of the district's basic school program and the revenue the district raises from the minimum basic rate and the basic levy increment rate, and if that local revenue equals or exceeds the cost there is no state contribution and the excess goes to the Uniform School Fund ((5)). The minimum basic local amount for the fiscal year beginning 1 July 2026 is $866,842,700 statewide, with a preliminary rate estimate of .001352 ((2)). Utah Code 53F-2-601 (Part 6 PDF pp.1-2): for each guaranteed local levy increment (.0001 of taxable value) of a voted or board local levy, the State guarantees a district an amount sufficient to reach a set amount per weighted pupil unit ($43.10 from the fiscal year beginning 1 July 2018, indexed to the unit's value) ((2)(a)(i), (3)(a)), for no more than 20 increments ((2)(a)(ii)); from fiscal 2026 the guarantee money may reduce as certified tax rates change with property values ((7)(a)), and a district getting more than the current certified rate alone would give keeps 100% of that fiscal 2025 excess in fiscal 2026, 66% in 2027, 33% in 2028 and none in 2029 ((7)(b)). Carbon School District: revenue for the year ended 30 June 2025 $54,002,145, of which local $20,846,245 (38.6%), state $29,121,531 (53.9%) and federal $4,034,369 (7.5%) (USBE 'Total Revenue by Source', PDF p.1). Minimum School Program FY2024-2025 Final Update (May 2025): basic levy 0.001408 of total district levies 0.006913 (20.37%), yielding $3,716,815 (PDF p.112); voted local levy 0.000837, local $2,209,499, state amounts $557,767 (regular), $297,007 (minimum basic growth) and $615,267 (local levy growth) (PDF p.103); board local levy 0.002336, local $2,259,654, state amounts $10,166, $5,345 and $478,057 (PDF p.104). The state amounts on the two levies total $567,933 in the regular columns and $1,963,609 across all three state columns (arithmetic). USBE fund statements for the year ended 30 June 2024 (in a file titled Fiscal Year 2025; submitted by the district, unaudited): property taxes $17,856,807, of which $2,605,254 (14.6%) in the debt service fund, $11,585,996 in the general fund and $3,665,557 in capital projects (PDF p.9).

In plain termsUtah shares school money so districts with less property value still get enough. In Carbon, more than half of the school district's money comes from the State. When local property taxes for basic school costs rise, the State's basic aid to the district falls by the same amount, and some extra state money tied to local levies can shrink too. So when property value in Carbon grows, the extra money from the basic school tax replaces state money instead of adding to the district's budget.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read 53F-2-301 (effective 1 July 2026), subsections (2), (4) and (5), and 53F-2-601 (Part 6 PDF pp.1-2), subsections (2), (3) and (7). Re-read the Carbon rows of the USBE FY25 Total Revenue by Source (PDF p.1), the FY2024-2025 Minimum School Program Final Update (voted levy PDF p.103, board levy p.104, basic rate revenues p.112) and the Carbon fund statement (PDF p.9, marked 'LEA submitted and certified (unaudited)'): every value matches; recomputed 20.37%, 14.6%, $567,933 and $1,963,609. Fixed the phase-out wording (districts keep 100%, 66%, 33%, then none of the excess), called the non-regular columns 'state amounts' rather than guarantee money, and tied the headline to (7)(a).
recordconfirmed Emergency planning: Valar asked to plan for on-site emergencies only; no public record found shows DOE agreed
2025-12-15 · safe-016 · Valar Atomics, U.S. Department of Energy, Emery County Fire Protection District, Emery County Emergency Management

The NSDA asks DOE to tailor its emergency-management order (NE O 151.1) to 'on-site emergency response only (no off-site planning required)', justified by the worst-case boundary dose and an 800 m distance to the nearest residence (Appendix C.3); it says 'Emergency planning requirements remain limited to on-site response'. It commits to coordination with Emery County Emergency Management, Emery County Fire and local responders: familiarization tours, table-top exercises, hazard information, direct notification links and annual coordination meetings. DOE-STD-1271 lets contractors use equivalent NRC or industry standards 'except where noted'; its Emergency Management entry (NE O 151.1) lacks the explicit 'may choose ... an alternative' sentence most other sections carry. The standard's general text does still let a contractor request a 'self-generated equivalent' or an exemption for any listed item, decided by DOE's approval authority, so a request like Valar's is not ruled out on its face. Valar's web summary does not list emergency planning among the alternatives DOE approved (safe-005). Local record: the Emery County Fire Protection District's 15 December 2025 minutes record the board discussing the 'nuclear test plant proposed in Orangeville' and its fire protection plans, and the outgoing chair saying he would sign them when the paperwork arrived. No public emergency plan for Ward 250, no record of a table-top exercise, and no public notification arrangement for residents were found as of late September 2026. In comments to DOE (March 2026), Uranium Watch said news coverage of the Valar reactor gave no information on emergency response planning, spent fuel or who to contact. The paper's justification (p.54) calls boundary doses under 0.5 rem 'well below Protective Action Guidelines'. EPA's guide for evacuating or sheltering the public starts at 1 rem over four days, a factor of 2 above that bound, and the paper does not address EPA's 5 rem child-thyroid guide for potassium iodide, although it names iodine-131 as the main dose contributor.

In plain termsBig power plants must plan for evacuating or sheltering people for miles around. For small reactors, reactors not cooled by water, and research and test reactors that apply to the NRC under 10 CFR 50.160, state and local emergency plans are required when the planning zone (where a projected public dose could top 1 rem over four days and prompt protective steps are needed) extends beyond the site boundary (10 CFR 50.33(g)(2)). Valar argued its worst accident is small enough that emergency planning can be limited to 'on-site response', as its paper puts it, with local fire crews briefed. DOE's own rulebook seems to leave less room to swap out the emergency rules than others, though a company can still ask, and the company's public summary does not say DOE agreed. The county fire board discussed fire-protection plans for the site in December 2025. No copy of the emergency plan itself was found in public records as of late September 2026: who gets called, and what neighbors would be told to do.
verified 2026-10-03: Re-read NSDA pp. 11, 20-21, 45, 54; DOE-STD-1271 Attachment 1; NIA; Emery County Fire Protection District minutes of 15 Dec 2025; NIRS comments in late September 2026. Fixed: the headline 'no stated opt-out' overstated the standard, whose general text lets a contractor request an equivalent or exemption for any item; the fire board 'discussed' (not 'reviewed') the plans. Corrected in late September 2026: added EPA's evacuate-or-shelter guide (1 rem, a factor of 2) and the unaddressed 5 rem child-thyroid guide. Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): fence wording replaced by Valar's own term, 'on-site response'; see Corrections. Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): adds the NRC rule for small, non-water-cooled and research reactors (10 CFR 50.33(g)(2)); see Corrections.
analysisconfirmed State lab's FAQ says 'the planned reactor' gets NRC licensing and NRC-tested operators; its working reactor has neither
2025-11-19 · gov-026 · Utah San Rafael Energy Lab, Utah Office of Energy Development, Valar Atomics, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, U.S. Department of Energy

The Utah San Rafael Energy Lab's FAQ page (a State of Utah site; created 3 Sept 2024, last modified 19 Nov 2025 per its WordPress record; read in late September 2026) answers 'What is the permit and regulatory process for a test reactor?' by saying 'the planned reactor' is a research and test reactor that will go through 'the 10 CFR Part 50 process just like a full sized nuclear power plant would', meeting 'Class 104 standards', that 'The state and county will also negotiate details', and that operators 'will have to maintain a 10 CFR Part 55 operator license', with 'frequent testing by the NRC'. Its WordPress record dates from 3 September 2024, before Valar's MOU, but that record's original address was a 'sage-grouse-mitigation-2' page, so when the FAQ text was written is not shown; parts of it read as generic text (it describes worst cases involving 'pressurized steam' and a 'containment building', features of water-cooled plants rather than helium-cooled Ward 250), but it is about Valar's project: re-read in late September 2026, it names Valar Atomics several times, and its spent-fuel answer says 'Valar Atomics will not produce spent reactor fuel with this reactor' (disc-021, disc-033). It was still the lab's live public answer, unchanged since November 2025, when re-checked on 12 October 2026. Ward 250, the only reactor operating at the lab, is authorized by DOE under 10 CFR 830 with no NRC license planned (safe-001), and its operators are qualified under a research-reactor industry standard, with no NRC operator licences involved (safe-017); the county has no approval role over the reactor (gov-020). The lab's own Valar page, also live, says Ward 250 reached 'full-power fueled criticality' on 18 June (DOE, ANS and UIPA all describe a zero-power test; orig-012), that its fuel will 'remain impossible to melt' (see safe-025), and calls the lab 'the premier independent site for commercial advanced nuclear deployment' and a route 'directly from localized testing to the commercial grid', while DOE says its Reactor Pilot Program is designed to foster research and development and 'not demonstrate reactors for commercial suitability', though DOE also calls the program a fast track toward later commercial licensing (gov-007). The state is Valar's host and landlord, not its regulator (ppl-018).

In plain termsThe state lab's question-and-answer page, last edited in November 2025, tells the public that 'the planned reactor' goes through the same federal NRC licensing as a big nuclear plant and that its operators are tested by the NRC. The page names Valar, yet the only reactor running at the lab, Valar's, has none of that: it was approved by the Energy Department instead, with no NRC licenses. The same state website calls June 18 a 'full-power' milestone when it was a zero-power test, and markets the site for commercial power. The state's pages and the record differ on these points.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read the FAQ, its WP record (created 3 Sept 2024, modified 19 Nov 2025) and the lab's Valar page in late September 2026; quotes exact. Added DOE's own commercial-licensing framing; zero-power now also sourced to ANS. Corrected in late September 2026: the FAQ names Valar Atomics several times, including in its spent-fuel answer (disc-021, disc-033). Detail and plain corrected; the headline's point (NRC licensing promised, none in place) is unchanged. Revised before publication (late September 2026): comparison restated as a difference.
recordconfirmed The county permit the state's lease memo says Valar will need: state law says approve it if harms can be reasonably reduced; state law requires no hearing
2025-11-06 · csite-015 · Carbon County, Office of the Property Rights Ombudsman

The Trust Lands memo says the parcel is zoned Mining and Grazing (M&G), where large industrial projects are a conditional use, and that the county conditional use permit (CUP) process is public, 'requiring the publishing of notice, a public hearing' and acceptance of public comments. Utah Code 17-79-506 (effective 6 November 2025) says a county land use authority 'shall approve a conditional use' if reasonable conditions can mitigate its reasonably anticipated detrimental effects (mitigation need not eliminate them), and may deny it only if they cannot be substantially mitigated. Utah's Office of the Property Rights Ombudsman states that state law does not require a public hearing on a CUP and that local ordinances decide. The conditional-use chapter of Carbon County's Development Code, as published on August 28, 2023, does not require a public hearing before a conditional use permit is approved; the memo's statement may reflect later changes or county practice, so ask the county which applies (see who decides, on the County Transparency page, which cites the code).

In plain termsA conditional use permit is the county's main say over what gets built on this land. But under Utah law it is not a yes-or-no vote on whether a project is wanted: if reasonable conditions can reduce the harms, the county must approve it with those conditions. State law does not require a public hearing; the county's own rules decide. The state's memo says Carbon's process includes notice, a hearing and public comment; the conditional-use chapter of the county code's 2023 edition does not require one (see who decides, on the County Transparency page). The county's planned code update (csite-013) is where residents can shape those conditions.
verified 2026-10-02: Holds. Re-read in late September 2026: memo p. 21 (Zoning and Local Land Use); Utah Code 17-79-506 (effective 11/6/2025); OPRO conditional-uses page (modified 2026-04-10). Quotes exact.
recordconfirmed Tax Commission 2026 percent-good tables: production machinery is taxed on 97% of cost in its first year and 11% by its eleventh; the guide lists a power-generation class (27) but prints no table for it
2025-11-01 · ptax-011 · Utah State Tax Commission

Utah State Tax Commission, 2026 Personal Property Classification Guide, Table 1 '2026 Personal Property Percent Good Valuation Schedules by Class' (updated 11/1/2025; guide p.iii, PDF p.5). Taxable value of business personal property valued on these schedules is acquisition cost times the percent good for its class and year of acquisition (guide p.ii, PDF p.4). Percent good by year acquired, from 2025 back: Class 8, Machinery & Equipment and Medical & Dental Equipment (used in production or processing industries, economic life of 12 years or more): 97, 93, 89, 82, 74, 65, 54, 43, 33, 22, 11 (2015). Class 16, Long Life Property: 97, 96, 94, 91, 90, 89, 85, 80, 73, 67, 59, 56, 54, 47, 40, 31, 25, 18, 9 (2007). Class 24, Leasehold Improvements (improvements made to exempt property where the exemption does not apply to them): 94, 88, 82, 77, 71, 65, 59, 54, 48, 42, 36, 30 (2014). The table prints no figure for those classes before the years shown. The guide's class list includes Class 27, 'Electrical Power Generating Equipment and Fixtures', described as equipment and fixtures used to generate consumer electrical power (PDF p.4), but Table 1, the only table in the guide, has no Class 27 column (columns printed: 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 8, 10, 12, 13, 15, 16, 17, 20, 21, 24, 25, 29). The guide refers readers to the separate 2026 Recommended Personal Property Valuation Schedules and to Tax Commission rule R884-24P-33 (PDF p.3); that schedule document was not read. Column values were read from the table's text layer and matched to the column numbers by position.

In plain termsMachines and equipment that businesses use are taxed too, and their taxable value shrinks each year as they get older. The state's 2026 table says a production machine bought in 2025 is taxed on 97% of what it cost, and one bought in 2015 on 11%. Power-plant equipment has its own class number, but this guide does not show its table.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read the 2026 Personal Property Classification Guide: introduction (PDF p.3), class list and valuation rule (PDF p.4) and Table 1 (PDF p.5, updated 11/1/2025). Matched every Class 8, 16 and 24 value to its column by printed position (rows with blank cells shift if read by order alone); all values match. The guide's table of contents lists Table 1 as its only table, and Table 1 has no Class 27 column. Noted the position-matching method in the detail.
recordconfirmed Who approves Ward 250: DOE alone. Its safety agreement says no move to an NRC license is planned
2025-10 · safe-001 · Valar Atomics, U.S. Department of Energy, Nuclear Regulatory Commission

Valar's Nuclear Safety Design Agreement (NSDA, document 100403 rev 02, October 2025) says Ward 250 is a contractor-owned, contractor-operated facility 'under DOE jurisdiction', authorized under the federal nuclear safety rule 10 CFR 830, with DOE-STD-1271-2025 as its primary authorization standard, and that no transition to NRC licensing is planned or intended. DOE's NEPA determination of 22 April 2026 says the same: the facility 'will operate under U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) authorization'. The legal basis is Executive Order 14301 (23 May 2025): section 3 finds that advanced reactors under enough DOE control that are not built 'to produce commercial electric power' fall within DOE's jurisdiction rather than the NRC's, and section 5 orders a pilot program outside the national laboratories under 42 U.S.C. 2140, approving at least three reactors 'with the goal of achieving criticality' in each by 4 July 2026. DOE-STD-1271 itself exempts anything the NRC regulates. The text of DOE-STD-1271 contains no public-hearing or public-comment step (searched for 'hearing', 'public comment', 'comment period'); its foreword only invites emailed suggestions for improving the standard itself.

In plain termsTwo federal agencies can approve a reactor. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) is the independent safety regulator for commercial reactors, and its licensing includes published notices and a chance for the public to ask for a hearing. The Department of Energy (DOE) can instead approve test reactors it controls. Ward 250 took the DOE route, so the agency that sponsors the pilot program is also the one that judges its safety, and the DOE rulebook used has no step where the public comments or asks for a hearing. This is the route the 2025 executive order set up (critics dispute its legal footing, safe-003).
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read in late September 2026: NSDA pp. 2 and 47, CX p. 1, EO 14301 secs. 3 and 5, DOE-STD-1271 sec. 2.1.d and full-text search. Fixed: headline said 'will never move' where the NSDA says no NRC transition is 'planned or intended'; the EO sets criticality by 4 July 2026 as a goal, not a requirement; Federal Register page corrected to 90 FR 22591.
recordconfirmed Utah's role: the state 'may observe but not direct'; the claimed state-DOE notification agreements were not found
2025-10 · safe-034 · State of Utah, Utah Office of Energy Development, Utah DEQ, U.S. Department of Energy, Valar Atomics

Valar's NSDA says that while Ward 250 is under DOE authority, Valar will coordinate with Utah DEQ, the Division of Waste Management and Radiation Control, Emery County Emergency Management, Emery County Fire and local responders; that state representatives 'may observe but not direct DOE regulatory activities'; and that 'The State of Utah maintains agreements with DOE regarding notification and coordination' for nuclear facilities in the state, including environmental data sharing and emergency coordination. No such Utah-DOE agreement was found in state or DOE sources searched in late September 2026. The state's own pieces: the Office of Energy Development owns the lab and is Valar's landlord (mine-035); it advertised for a lab-wide Safety Manager in September 2026 (dir-006); Utah's 2026 H.B. 78 created a Nuclear Energy Regulatory Office and conditions spent-fuel storage on a DWMRC permit (csite-023). In its 2025 lawsuit post, Valar argued small test reactors could be regulated by states, some of which were creating regulatory bodies (safe-028).

In plain termsUtah hosts the reactor, owns the land under it and changed its laws in ways that fit it, but the safety decisions are DOE's. Valar's paperwork says state officials can watch but not give orders, and that Utah and DOE have agreements to keep each other informed. We could not find those agreements. If they exist, a records request to the state would turn them up.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read NSDA pp. 20-21 and Valar's 7 April 2025 post in late September 2026. Holds. The claimed Utah-DOE agreements remain not found.
recordconfirmed DOE's agreement with Valar (OTA DENE0009560): $0 like all nine pilot-reactor OTAs on file; Valar's is run from DOE Idaho
2025-10-22 · gov-003 · Valar Atomics, U.S. Department of Energy, DOE Idaho Operations Office, Office of Nuclear Energy · total obligation on OTA DENE0009560 (and on each of nine Reactor Pilot Program OTAs): $0

The USAspending record for FAIN DENE0009560 (API, read in late September 2026) adds to orig-055: the award type is 'other reimbursable, contingent, intangible, or indirect financial assistance' (type 11), under assistance listing 81.121, 'Nuclear Energy Research, Development and Demonstration'; the awarding office is DOE's Idaho Operations Office and the funding office is Nuclear Energy; the period runs 22 October 2025 to 4 July 2027; there is one transaction, a 'NEW' action dated 12 May 2026 obligating $0, with no modification number; the record was last modified 19 May 2026; place of performance is Hawthorne, Los Angeles County, California, the company's business address, not Emery County. A search of the same database for 'Reactor Pilot Program' agreements returns nine such OTAs, every one at $0: Last Energy (from 18 Sept 2025), Aalo (22 Sept), Antares (23 Sept), Valar (22 Oct), Deep Fission (14 Nov), Natura Resources (24 Nov), Terrestrial Energy (19 Dec 2025), Atomic Alchemy (6 Jan 2026) and Oklo (9 Feb 2026). Valar's period ends 4 July 2027, a year after the program's criticality deadline; some others ended on 4 July 2026. A search of contract subawards (FY2021-FY2026, run 30 September 2026) finds none to Valar either. The agreement text, milestones and any modifications were not found on USAspending or any public DOE page as of late September 2026 (safe-007).

In plain termsAn 'Other Transaction Agreement' is a flexible federal deal that is neither a grant nor a normal purchase contract; agencies use it to work with private companies on new technology with fewer standard rules. USAspending lists one for nine of the ten companies DOE selected for its test-reactor program (none for Radiant was found as of 30 September 2026), and each is recorded at zero dollars, so DOE's statement that the companies pay their own way holds for Valar on the federal record. What the agreement makes Valar promise, and what it lets DOE demand, is written in an agreement that was not found in public records as of late September 2026. Its location field says California, even though the reactor is in Emery County.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-ran the USAspending award, transactions and search queries in late September 2026: type 11, CFDA 81.121, Idaho Operations Office, 22 Oct 2025 to 4 Jul 2027, one NEW $0 action on 12 May 2026, Hawthorne CA; nine pilot OTAs all $0; 0 subawards; the only award of any type to Valar is this OTA. Holds.
recordconfirmed Federal award record: DOE's agreement with Valar for Ward 250 is on file at $0, running Oct 2025 to July 4, 2027
2025-10-22 · orig-055 · Valar Atomics, U.S. Department of Energy, DOE Idaho Operations Office · federal obligation recorded on OTA DENE0009560: $0

USAspending.gov, the federal spending database (API read in late September 2026), holds one award to Valar Atomics Inc. (unique entity ID WTMAF8SVNPR3, a small business): FAIN DENE0009560, described as Valar's Other Transaction Agreement (OTA) for DOE's Reactor Pilot Program, awarded by DOE's Idaho Operations Office for the Office of Nuclear Energy under assistance listing 81.121. The period of performance runs October 22, 2025 to July 4, 2027; the only transaction is dated May 12, 2026 and obligates $0, and total funding is $0. The place of performance is recorded as Hawthorne, California, not the Utah site. As of late September 2026, a USAspending search of every award type (contracts, grants, loans, direct payments, other) found no other federal award to Valar. The $0 matches DOE's statement that pilot companies bear all costs (orig-041). Valar's October 13, 2025 QA post already cites a requirement under its OTA with DOE, nine days before the recorded start date; no public copy of the agreement's text was found as of late September 2026 (safe-007).

In plain termsThe Energy Department's agreement with Valar, which sets the rules and milestones for the Utah test reactor, appears in the federal spending database as a $0 agreement: DOE is not paying for the reactor, as it said. But no public copy of the agreement was found as of September 2026, so what Valar agreed to and what DOE may require could not be read. The database lists the work as taking place in Hawthorne, California, rather than Emery County.
verified 2026-10-15: Second check, late September 2026: award and recipient API records re-read (FAIN, description, Idaho Operations Office, 81.121, Oct 22, 2025 to Jul 4, 2027, one transaction May 12, 2026, $0, Hawthorne place of performance, small business). Award search re-run across all types: only DENE0009560. QA post quote exact. Revised before publication (late September 2026): the QA post's source title now notes it is not listed in Valar's library.
recordconfirmed Public NSDA is marked 'Draft'; Valar says DOE approved it; its summary lists as approved only 2 of the 6 rule substitutions asked for
2025-10-13 · safe-005 · Valar Atomics, U.S. Department of Energy

The NSDA PDF Valar posts (rev 02, October 2025, created 13 October 2025 per its file metadata) is marked 'Status: Draft' and 'issued for Public Release'. Valar's library page of the same date says DOE 'has approved' the NSDA under 10 CFR 830 and the DOE-Valar Other Transaction Agreement. The web summary describes a PDSA 'at 50% design completion' and a final DSA 'for the as-built facility', while the PDF proposes, as an alternative requirement, submitting the final DSA 'at 90% design completion' and verifying the as-built plant afterwards (Appendix C.5). The PDF asks DOE to accept six alternatives to standard requirements: ANS-15.8 instead of NQA-1 for quality assurance; ANS-15.4 operator qualification; on-site-only emergency response; OSHA rules instead of DOE's worker safety rule 10 CFR 851; early DSA submittal; and tailored DOE O 420.1C facility safety. The web summary lists three alternatives as approved (ANS-15.8 QA, ANS-15.4 conduct of operations, reduced surveillance); only the first two are among the PDF's six. The PDF itself says the OSHA substitution for the construction phase was 'approved through the OTA' (Appendix C.4); that is Valar's statement, and no DOE record of it was read. The same PDF's requirements table (page 48) notes a DOE Idaho Operations Office 'exemption request in process for construction activities pending 10 CFR 851 revision'. Apart from the OTA statement, no record read says whether DOE approved the emergency-planning, worker-safety, DSA-timing and DOE O 420.1C alternatives, and no DOE approval letter for the NSDA was found in public records as of late September 2026.

In plain termsThe safety agreement the public can read is labelled a draft, while the company says the government approved it. The company's own summary lists as approved only two of the six rule substitutions the document asks for, plus a third item (reduced surveillance) that is not among the six. The ones left unmentioned include two that bear directly on neighbours and workers: planning for emergencies only inside the site, and using ordinary workplace-safety rules instead of DOE's. Only DOE's approval letter would show what was actually agreed.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read NSDA (PDF created 13 Oct 2025 09:11 MDT per metadata, 'Status: Draft') and the web summary (dated 13 Oct 2025) in late September 2026. Holds. Added: the NSDA says its OSHA substitution for construction was 'approved through the OTA' (a company statement), which the earlier text missed.
recordconfirmed 2025: the local paper printed Valar's 'gigasites' aim and a plan for a Carbon County factory hub; no site named
2025-10-10 · loc-034 · Valar Atomics, ETV News, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab, Utah Office of Energy Development, Jaron Wallace

Two ETV News items from 2025, eleven months or more before the Wellington lease vote, show that a Valar project in Carbon County was in the local paper in general terms. On 17 September 2025 ETV printed the state Office of Energy Development's groundbreaking release (orig-067); its 'About Valar Atomics' paragraph says Valar 'is building America’s first nuclear gigasites', which it defines as clusters of thousands of high-temperature reactors. On 10 October 2025 an ETV article on the San Rafael lab, quoting lab director Jaron Wallace, reported that after about three years, once Valar completes its reactor and proves it can be run safely, 'their current plan is to build a manufacturing hub in Carbon County', which could bring hundreds of jobs to Carbon and Emery; it also said Valar was looking at powering data centers. The article does not say who told ETV about the Carbon plan, names no site, and says nothing about trust land or reactors in Carbon County. In sum, a Carbon County project by Valar was public in general terms from October 2025; no local record read from before the state vote tied Valar to the Wellington location, the trust-land lease or the plan for a reactor, fuel and industrial campus there; ETV's July 2026 trust-land notice for the section named no applicant or use (loc-011, loc-012, loc-032), while the state's own board packet and public meeting of 20 August 2026 named Valar and the site (mine-010). The lease was approved about eleven months after the article, sooner than the 'after three years' it described.

In plain termsIn the fall of 2025 the local paper printed that Valar aimed to build clusters of thousands of reactors, and that its plan was a manufacturing hub in Carbon County in about three years. What the paper's news reports read here did not say, until the day after the state approved it, was where: the square mile of state land north of Wellington (a July legal notice in the paper for that land named no applicant). So the general idea was public early; the specific place, and how soon it would come, were not.
verified 2026-10-02: New in an earlier check: both ETV pages read in full in late September 2026. Tests what was public before the vote: the general Carbon plan was public in 2025; the site was not. Revised before publication (2026-09-30): reworded the detail; reworded the plain-language text; corrected the description of ETV News (its source type and title).
official statementreported State lab director, as ETV reported, said firms must show 'no dose' at the site boundary; Valar's own analysis gives a small dose
2025-10-10 · loc-035 · Jaron Wallace, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab, Valar Atomics, U.S. Department of Energy

ETV News (10 Oct 2025) quoted Jaron Wallace, director of the state-run Utah San Rafael Energy Lab that hosts Ward 250: any nuclear company is 'required to show no dose at the site boundary during an accident event', adding that in the worst case the public 'will never see a dose of radiation above background'; the article also paraphrased him that Valar must prove no damage or radiation can pass the fence line of its 11 acres. Set beside the record: Valar's own Ward250 Nuclear Safety Design Agreement (revision 02, October 2025, marked draft) models a bounding 'maximum hypothetical accident' that assumes fuel-particle failures beyond demonstrated limits, a breach of the pressure boundary and stable, light-wind weather (Class F, 1 m/s) that the paper calls the most conservative. It puts the dose at the 400-metre site boundary below 0.5 rem (500 millirem) in one section and below 100 millirem in another, and below 0.1 rem at the nearest home about 800 metres away (safe-013). It measures these against a 25 rem evaluation guideline, not against zero. DOE's categorical exclusion gives natural background radiation in central Utah as about 100-120 millirem a year, and the routine public dose limit as 100 millirem a year. So the company's own analysis does not show 'no dose' at the boundary: it shows a small calculated dose in an accident it treats as a worst case, far below the guidelines it uses. Whether the lab director meant routine operation or a different standard is not in the record; this rests on one news report of his words.

In plain termsIn 2025 the head of the state lab where the reactor sits told local readers, as ETV reported it, that companies must show 'no dose' at the site boundary even in an accident. Valar's own safety paper does not say that. Its worst-case study, which assumes things go wrong beyond what testing has shown, estimates that a person at the site boundary could get a small dose: no more than about one year's worth of central Utah's natural background radiation by one of its figures, or about four to five years' worth by the other. That is well below the guideline figures the paper measures against (a 25 rem evaluation guideline, and a 1 rem limit it lists for NRC non-power reactors), but it is not zero. As reported, the director's description and the company's own numbers differ.
verified 2026-10-12: The ETV page, Valar's safety agreement (pages 11 and 36-37) and DOE's exclusion were read directly in late September 2026. A documented gap between an official's local reassurance and the company's own numbers; no intent is implied. Revised before publication (late September 2026): weather now 'stable, light-wind (Class F, 1 m/s)' as the paper states it. Revised before publication (late September 2026): the director's reported words and the paper's numbers are set side by side.
recordconfirmed Governor's office: 'Operation Gigawatt' names nuclear; no Valar release found beyond a weekly schedule; state records date the groundbreaking Sept 11
2025-09-11 · gov-015 · Spencer Cox, Office of the Governor of Utah, Valar Atomics, Idaho National Laboratory

Gov. Spencer Cox launched 'Operation Gigawatt' on 8 October 2024, a plan to double Utah's power production in ten years, one of whose four goals is policies 'to enable clean, reliable energy like nuclear and geothermal'; his January 2026 update credits it with 'breaking ground on a nuclear test reactor'. A search of the governor's website (WordPress search API, 29 Sept 2026) for 'Valar' returns a single item: his public schedule for 8-14 September 2025, which lists '10:00 a.m. Speak at Valar Atomics groundbreaking', San Rafael Energy Research Center, Orangeville, on a Thursday. That schedule's day labels do not match its own title (it heads the week 'Sept. 8 - Sept. 14' but labels the days Sept. 8, 2, 3, 4 and 5), so the schedule alone does not fix the date; the Thursday of the titled week was 11 September. The Office of Energy Development's written update to the Legislature's Public Utilities, Energy and Technology Interim Committee (15 October 2025) states that Valar 'held groundbreaking for a nuclear test reactor on September 11, 2025', which matches the state release's 9/11-anniversary line; Valar's Ward 250 page gives 09.17.2025, the day the release was published (orig-007, orig-067). On the state's records, 11 September 2025 is the date; Valar's date does not match. The governor first described the Valar deal publicly on Bloomberg TV and to KUTV in May 2025 (ppl-018, orig-065); no governor's press release, executive order or signed agreement naming Valar was found on governor.utah.gov. On 28 April 2025 Utah leaders signed an MOU with Idaho National Laboratory that envisions a new Utah Advanced Nuclear and Energy Institute as a hub linking INL, the state's universities, OED and the San Rafael lab.

In plain termsThe governor's energy plan, 'Operation Gigawatt', is the umbrella for Utah's nuclear push, and he was scheduled to speak at Valar's groundbreaking. But as of late September 2026 no news release from his office naming Valar was found: the only mention found on his website is a line in his weekly schedule. The state energy office's report to legislators dates the groundbreaking to September 11, 2025; Valar's own page says September 17, the day the announcement was published.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read the Gigawatt release, the schedule, the WP search (1 result), the Built Here update, the INL MOU release and OED's 15 Oct 2025 slides in late September 2026. Fixed: the INL MOU 'envisions' an institute linking the lab (it does not make the lab part of it); the schedule's mislabelled days mean it cannot fix the date on its own; plain says 'no release found' rather than 'never issued'.
recordconfirmed Emery County's commission itself voted Valar's building permit, as the building department had not issued one
2025-09-02 · gov-021 · Emery County Commission, Valar Atomics, State of Utah Division of Facilities Construction and Management, Utah Office of Energy Development · proposed price for Emery County's sale of the San Rafael Energy Research Center to the State of Utah (Nov 2024): $2,111,444

The Emery County Commission's minutes of 2 September 2025, item 16: 'Valor Atomics is getting ready to break ground' at the San Rafael Energy Research Center 'on September 11' and hopes to start 'next year on July 4th'; 'The Building department has not issued a building permit, so this is the process to move forward.' The commission voted 3-0 to approve a building permit for Valar 'so they can move forward with their project'. No building-code review, plans or conditions are recorded in the minutes. The same meeting voted to support Green River as a potential site for the state energy office's nuclear power generation project after the governor's agreement with TerraPower. The county's Economic Opportunity Board minutes of 9 September 2025 note the Valar groundbreaking 'scheduled for Thursday at 9:30 a.m.', i.e. 11 September (gov-015). Earlier county-state steps: on 19 November 2024 the commission approved selling the San Rafael Energy Research Center to the State of Utah (Division of Facilities Construction and Management) for $2,111,444, and on 4 February 2025 extended contract #231366 with OED to June 2025 so the county could keep being reimbursed for bills it paid on the state's behalf at the lab.

In plain termsFor Valar's facility at the lab, the elected commission voted to approve a building permit directly because the county's building department had not issued one, days before the groundbreaking. The minutes do not say what was reviewed. The county had approved selling the lab to the state for about $2.1 million the year before.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read the 2 Sept 2025 minutes, 9 Sept economic board minutes and 19 Nov 2024 minutes in late September 2026; quotes exact. Fixed: the 4 Feb 2025 contract point had no cited source; the minutes were found and read and are now cited.
recordconfirmed DOE rulebook for Ward 250: 45-day reviews, company as design authority, DOE observers, Energy Secretary signs startup
2025-08 · safe-002 · U.S. Department of Energy, Valar Atomics

DOE-STD-1271-2025 (August 2025), written to carry out EO 14301, sets the path Ward 250 followed: a contract (for Valar, an Other Transaction Agreement), then a Nuclear Safety Design Agreement, a Preliminary Documented Safety Analysis at about 50% design, a final DSA with Technical Safety Requirements, a DOE readiness review, and startup testing under a Joint Test Group that includes a DOE representative. DOE's review standard is 45 days per document, and DOE 'will limit its comments' to issues affecting the safety of the public or workers. The contractor under an OTA is the Design Authority; DOE staff attend the company's design reviews 'as observers only', reserving comments for a clear deviation from a requirement, and DOE may use non-DOE experts. The Secretary of Energy is the Startup Approval Authority for new reactors (delegable), and DOE's Office of Nuclear Energy is the Safety Basis Approval Authority, which approves a Safety Evaluation Report. Fuel above Hazard Category 3 quantities may not be loaded until the readiness review and startup approval are complete. After startup testing, the contractor may operate 'without needing to request DOE permission for approved activities', subject to ongoing DOE oversight under the contract. The standard lets the contractor substitute NRC or industry standards, or its own 'self-generated' equivalents approved by DOE, for most listed DOE orders.

In plain termsThis is the checklist DOE used instead of an NRC license. The company writes the safety case; DOE's target is to approve or comment on each piece within 45 days, and it confines its comments to worker and public safety. The company is in charge of its own design, DOE staff watch design meetings without directing them, and the Energy Secretary (or a delegate) gives the go-ahead to start. Once the start-up tests are done, the company runs the reactor within its approved limits without asking DOE each time. As of late September 2026, no public copy was found of several key documents this process produces, such as DOE's Safety Evaluation Report (see safe-007); DOE has said that the readiness-review step took place for Ward 250 (dir-031).
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read DOE-STD-1271-2025 in full in late September 2026 (secs. 3, 6-9, Attachment 1). Holds; two small precision fixes (observers reserve comments for clear deviations; the SBAA approves the SER). DOE's own posting of the standard was not found; the copy read is NIA's, marked 'Approved for public release'. Revised before publication (2026-10-01): wording made more exact against the cited records.
recordconfirmed The state board that must approve lab projects approved 'the Valar Project' Aug 13, 2025, at a 35-minute first meeting
2025-08-13 · gov-013 · Utah Energy Research Board, Utah Office of Energy Development, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab, Valar Atomics, Dennis Worwood, Jaron Wallace, Emy Lesofski, Natura Resources

Utah law (Title 79, Chapter 6, Part 10) creates the Utah Energy Research Board inside OED to oversee the San Rafael Energy Lab; the lab must receive and evaluate project proposals and recommend them, and the board 'shall review the project proposals' and make 'final decisions on approval' (79-6-1005); the lab may contract with users, with revenue going to the Utah Energy Research Fund (79-6-1004(2)(d)). The board's first meeting, noticed on the Utah Public Notice Website, was held 13 August 2025 at the State Capitol, 10:00 to 10:35 a.m. Per its approved minutes, members took the oath, appointed Jaron Wallace lab director, and then heard 'Project Valar', 'a 250-kilowatt microreactor test site' that 'recently received approval' from DOE; they discussed private funding, returning the site to a 'Greenfield' state and financial assurance for liability; Emery County Commissioner Dennis Worwood, a board member, 'noted strong public support' in Emery County; the motion to approve, made by member Larry Howell and seconded by Worwood, passed 7-0. Set beside the record: by then OED had signed its MOU (16 May), Valar had held its Emery town hall (8 July) and DOE had announced its selection a day earlier (12 August), a selection, not an authorization; DOE's agreement with Valar for the pilot program (an 'other transaction agreement') began 22 October 2025 (gov-003). The same meeting approved a Natura Resources molten-salt project at the lab. The minutes record that the meeting closed with a public comment period, in which attendees expressed appreciation for the board's formation.

In plain termsState law gives a specific board the final say on which projects go into the state energy lab. That board approved Valar's reactor project at its very first meeting, in Salt Lake City, in a meeting that lasted 35 minutes, after the state had already signed with Valar and announced the project. The meeting was legally noticed and ended with a public comment period, and its notice offered video-call and phone participation; it was held after the state had signed its non-binding MOU and DOE had announced its selection; under state law, this board makes the final decision on approving projects at the lab (79-6-1005). The minutes say the project 'recently received approval' from DOE; DOE had only selected it the day before.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read Utah Code 79-6 Part 10, the 13 Aug 2025 notice and minutes in late September 2026; quotes exact. Fixed: the 'DOE selected it a day earlier' point had no cited source; DOE's 12 Aug 2025 selection release was read and is now cited. Added that Worwood seconded the approval. Corrected 1 Oct 2026: wording made more exact against the cited records.
recordconfirmed The 'CONFIDENTIAL' marking is on a Valar deck posted publicly on the state's notice website; the Legislature's June 2025 Valar item used state slides without it
2025-07-08 · dir-038 · Valar Atomics, Utah Public Notice Website, Utah State Legislature, Utah Office of Energy Development

Valar's 12-page deck 'Valar Atomics + SRERC in Emery County' (PDF created 8 July 2025; server date 9 July 2025) is posted on the state-run Utah Public Notice Website as file 1295975, and 11 of its 12 pages carry the line 'CONFIDENTIAL. DO NOT DISTRIBUTE.'; the public body that posted it and the notice it is attached to were not found in the records searched (as of 1 October 2026). Its content (under 250 kW, 30 effective full-power days in 12 months in a temporary facility, commercial deployment by 2028) matches Valar's 8 July 2025 Emery County town hall as reported (orig-045) on the 12-month test and the 2028 commercial goal; the report does not give the power level or full-power days, or call the facility temporary. The Legislature's record of its 18 June 2025 committee meeting lists, for the Valar item, only OED's four-page 'Nuclear Update' slides, whose text carries no such marking (gov-040); Valar's own 17-slide deck filed with the same committee in May 2026 carries none either (gov-019). The marking shows how Valar labeled one deck. The deck itself is public, and the marking on its own does not show that any meeting or decision was confidential.

In plain termsOne Valar slide deck from July 2025 is stamped 'CONFIDENTIAL. DO NOT DISTRIBUTE.' on most pages, yet it is posted on the state's public notice website for anyone to download. The stamp shows how Valar labeled its slides; it does not show that any meeting or decision was closed to the public. The only slides on the Legislature's record for the June 2025 briefing were the state energy office's own, with no such stamp.
verified 2026-10-02: Added 1 October 2026. Read: the Valar deck as posted on the state notice website (PDF created 8 July 2025, server date 9 July 2025; the marking is on most pages); the Legislature's meeting record for 18 June 2025; and the Office of Energy Development's slides (no marking in their text). The May 2026 Valar deck was read in full, page by page. The notice this deck is attached to was searched for and not found.
company claimconfirmed July 2025 Emery County town hall: Valar pitched a 12-month test, ~40 jobs, 'commercial development by 2028'
2025-07-08 · orig-045 · Valar Atomics, Emery County Commission, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab, Jaron Wallace, Jeremy Pearson

ETV News (Julie Johansen, July 9, 2025) reported the Emery County Commission's July 8, 2025 town hall in Castle Dale, requested by Valar after an MOU was signed and before its contract with the state lab was final. As reported, Valar said the company was about two years old, had a non-fueled test reactor near Los Angeles, aimed for July 4, 2026 (the nation's 250th birthday, hence 'Ward 250') with commercial development by 2028, expected about 40 employees for roughly 12 months of testing with local contractors for construction, and chose Utah because Carbon and Emery counties are the state's energy hub. A Valar slide deck posted on the state-run Utah Public Notice Website (file created July 8, 2025, server date 9 July 2025; 11 of its 12 pages are marked 'CONFIDENTIAL. DO NOT DISTRIBUTE.', yet the file is publicly posted; the public body and notice it is attached to were not identified) says the same: under 250 kW, 30 effective full-power days over 12 months in a temporary facility, commercial deployment by 2028.

In plain termsAt a July 2025 town hall Valar told Emery County residents about a small 12-month test with about 40 jobs, and a goal of commercial reactors by 2028. By 2026 the company was planning far larger sites (mine-019).
verified 2026-10-02: Second check, late September 2026: ETV report and the slide PDF (created Jul 8, 2025; 'CONFIDENTIAL'; <250 kW, 30 EFPD, 12 months, temporary facility; commercial deployment by 2028) re-read. Match. Corrected 1 Oct 2026: wording made more exact against the cited records.
analysisconfirmed What Valar itself said in public about Carbon County, and when: general praise, invitations; a Sept 29, 2026 town hall on the site; no Valar publication naming it found
2025-07-08 · orig-075 · Valar Atomics, Carbon County

July 8, 2025, Emery County town hall (as ETV News reported): Valar said it chose Utah because Carbon and Emery counties are the state's energy hub (orig-045). In 2024, by its head of projects' later account to the Trust Lands board, Valar had met Carbon County officials when its plan was to make fuels from coal-plant flue gas (mine-018). February 24, 2026: Valar's open-house notice invited residents of Carbon and Emery counties to the Emery site, its head of projects saying Valar wanted neighbors to understand exactly what it is building and why; the notice mentions only Ward 250. Between August 25 and September 9, 2026, Valar's site first linked its 'Castle Country' page, headed 'Carbon & Emery County, Utah', which promises gigasites but names no Carbon site (dir-008, mine-020, csite-027). Meanwhile the record shows a state lease map for the Wellington parcel produced April 9, 2026 (mine-048), a Carbon County support letter signed June 29, 2026 (mine-013), the first public agenda naming Valar for the site on August 10, 2026 (csite-018), a Valar mining claim staked September 12, 2026 (mine-453) and the board's approval on September 17, 2026 (mine-011). No Valar publication read names the Carbon County site as of late September 2026. Valar's staff did speak at the Trust Lands board's August 20 and September 17, 2026 public meetings that took up the lease (mine-018), and on the evening of September 29, 2026 Valar held a town hall in Price on the proposed Carbon County site, as ETV News reported the next day.

In plain termsValar has spoken about Carbon County in general terms since 2025, and by its own account has been meeting Carbon officials since 2024. But no publication by Valar itself was found that names the square mile north of Wellington the state approved leasing to it, or the nearby mining claim whose Notice of Location names it as locator. The public learned of the site from state board records in August 2026 and from local news after the vote. Valar's staff spoke at the state board's public meetings on the lease in August and September 2026, and on September 29, 2026 Valar held a town hall in Price on the site.
verified 2026-10-15: Second check, late September 2026: ETV town-hall report, ETV open-house notice (Feb 24, 2026; only Ward 250 named) and Castle Country page ('Carbon & Emery County, Utah'; no Carbon site named) re-read; quotes exact. The dated steps cited by id match those facts' headlines. Revised before publication (late September 2026): lease wording now 'approved leasing'; the claim is attributed to its Notice of Location; absence stated as not found.
company claimreported July 2025 town hall, after the site was picked: Taylor answered a Chernobyl worry with coal deaths
2025-07-08 · ppl-025 · Isaiah Taylor, Max Ukropina, Valar Atomics, Emery County

The New Republic (May 2026), from the audio recording of Valar's 8 July 2025 town hall in Castle Dale (see orig-045), reports: by then the site was picked and, as TNR puts it, construction was moving forward (state records put the groundbreaking on 11 September 2025, orig-007); when a resident asked if the reactor had run, Max Ukropina, whom TNR calls Valar's head of projects (a Valar slide deck from July 2025, posted on the Utah Public Notice Website, gives the title Head of Commercialization), said 'We had it on since February. On and off, in different ways', which referred to the non-nuclear thermal prototype, and the resident concluded the reactor was technically untested; Taylor said Valar was 'hesitant to be the company that comes in and promises the world'; and when a resident raised Chernobyl and said the town did not want to be part of a race with China, Taylor asked how many people had died in the coal industry in Carbon and Emery counties and said 'the deaths are terrible, but power is important.' The magazine describes the residents as having had 'very little say'. The town hall itself was requested by Valar after the state MOU (orig-045); the state lab director says the contract followed about two weeks after Valar first said it wanted to build there (ppl-027). Residents who spoke are described, not named.

In plain termsAt a July 2025 town hall Valar held in Emery County, after the site had been picked, residents asked safety questions. The company's answer on testing referred to a prototype without nuclear fuel, and its chief executive answered a question about nuclear accidents by pointing to deaths in the coal industry. As The New Republic put it, the residents had had very little say in the choice.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read TNR (delivered part, which ends with this passage). Holds. Fixed: plain called it 'the one big public meeting before construction', but TNR says construction was already moving forward and no source shows it was the only meeting; 'real safety questions' reduced to 'safety questions'. Residents are described, not named.
recordconfirmed DOE's terms for the pilot: research, 'not' commercial suitability; companies pay all costs; picked on readiness
2025-06-18 · gov-007 · U.S. Department of Energy, Valar Atomics, Chris Wright

DOE's 18 June 2025 release opening the Reactor Pilot Program (Request for Application issued that day; first applications due 21 July 2025, then rolling) says the program is designed for research and development of nuclear reactors 'and not demonstrate reactors for commercial suitability', while also calling DOE authorization 'a fast-tracked approach to enable future commercial licensing activities' (DOE's program page says the program aims 'to fast-track commercial licensing'), that applicants bear all costs of designing, building, operating and decommissioning each test reactor, and that selection would weigh technological readiness, site evaluations, financial viability and a detailed plan to reach criticality. DOE's 16 July 2025 Fuel Line Pilot release likewise says fuel lines 'will serve for research, development, and demonstration purposes', with each company paying for its facility and 'the procurement of all nuclear material feedstock'. Set beside Valar's statements to Utah bodies: at the July 2025 town hall it spoke of commercial development by 2028 (orig-045); the minutes of the state's economic board in July 2026 record its representatives speaking of plans to install more commercial units in the area (csite-024); and the Carbon County lease is for a nuclear 'campus' with fuel manufacturing (csite-007). Commercial units would fall outside the DOE pilot pathway and need NRC licensing (safe-030, csite-010); Hogan Lovells' summary of the application rules says the administration intends DOE-authorized reactors to be fast-tracked for future NRC licensing (gov-032). The Request for Application itself (FedConnect) was not read.

In plain termsDOE was explicit that its fast-track program is for research reactors, not for proving that a reactor is ready to sell power. Valar's test reactor fits that. DOE also sells the program as a fast track toward later commercial licensing, but that later licensing is the NRC's. But Valar has told Utah officials about commercial reactors and a bigger campus in Carbon County, and by DOE's own terms those would fall outside that pathway: they would need a license from the independent Nuclear Regulatory Commission, with its public process. On DOE's stated terms, the faster DOE authorization path used in Emery County, which has no public-hearing step, would not cover commercial units in Carbon County.
verified 2026-10-18: Re-read both DOE releases in late September 2026; quotes exact. Fixed: added DOE's own 'fast-track commercial licensing' framing, which the earlier text omitted and which the state lab's own materials echo; the conclusion (commercial units need the NRC) still holds.
recordconfirmed June 18, 2025: legislators heard a noticed agenda item, 'Valar Atomics Nuclear Test Reactor', then took public comment on nuclear
2025-06-18 · gov-040 · Utah State Legislature, Public Utilities, Energy, and Technology Interim Committee, Utah Office of Energy Development, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab, Valar Atomics, Emy Lesofski, Jaron Wallace

The Legislature's Public Utilities, Energy, and Technology Interim Committee met on 18 June 2025 at the State Capitol. Its agenda (file dated 13 June 2025) lists item 3, 'Valar Atomics Nuclear Test Reactor', 9:00 to 9:30 a.m.: Valar had 'partnered with the San Rafael Energy Research Center' to have 'a new nuclear test reactor running by 2026', and the committee would hear about the plan from the Office of Energy Development and the research center. Per the approved minutes, OED Director Emy Lesofski and lab director Jaron Wallace 'gave an update on companies partnering' with the lab, 'including Valar Atomics and NuCube'. The Legislature's meeting record lists, for item 3, only OED's four-page slides, 'Nuclear Update', which give 'Valar MOU signed May 16, 2025'; no presentation filed by Valar is listed for this meeting, and OED's slides carry no confidentiality marking in their text. After the committee voted on a draft nuclear-manufacturing resolution, the chair 'opened the meeting to public comment on the nuclear discussion': four members of the public spoke, some for more nuclear power and others urging caution and asking that communities be included in decisions. The meeting record also lists the meeting notice, the approved minutes and an audio/video recording. The meeting came 33 days after the OED-Valar MOU (gov-011) and the day after Emery County's public hearing on nuclear industries (gov-020). It was an informational update: the committee took no action on Valar, and it was not a hearing on the reactor's safety.

In plain termsA year before Ward 250 started up, state legislators had a posted agenda item called 'Valar Atomics Nuclear Test Reactor', describing a test reactor planned at the Emery County lab by 2026. State energy officials briefed the committee, and later in the same meeting members of the public spoke on the nuclear discussion, some supporting more nuclear power and others urging caution. It was a briefing, not a hearing on whether the reactor is safe, but it shows the plan itself was discussed in public by June 2025.
verified 2026-10-02: Added 1 October 2026. Read: the meeting agenda (file dated 13 June 2025), the approved minutes (pp. 1-3), the Office of Energy Development's slides (their text carries no confidentiality marking) and the Legislature's meeting record (read 1 October 2026; four materials, none filed by Valar). Quotes exact. Members of the public who spoke are not named. The audio was not transcribed. Checked a second time on 1 October 2026.
analysisreported The pilot's rules, per a law-firm summary: OTAs not grants, DOE bears its review costs, no local-government role mentioned
2025-06-18 · gov-032 · U.S. Department of Energy, Hogan Lovells, Valar Atomics

The Reactor Pilot Program's Request for Application (DE-FOA-0003569, issued 18 June 2025) is posted only on the FedConnect portal, which was not read. Hogan Lovells' summary of it (1 July 2025) says: it is 'not a funding opportunity' and applicants bear all costs, including spent-fuel storage and fuel procurement, but 'Applicants will not be responsible for DOE costs incurred reviewing documents' during authorization; applicants must have a mature design, 'established fuel plans' with a fabrication and disposition pathway, adequate money and qualified staff; they must secure their own site 'on public or private lands'; applicants needing HALEU must be in DOE's HALEU allocation process; DOE would use Other Transaction Agreements, not contracts or grants; the level of NEPA review was not yet set; and there are nine selection criteria, including site status and foreign-ownership risk. The summary mentions no requirement for state or local government consent, support letters or public engagement. Set beside the record: Valar's OTA is recorded at $0 (gov-003); NRC applicants, by contrast, pay the NRC's hourly review fees (EO 14300 refers to 'the NRC's recovery of hourly fees', gov-009); Valar's spent fuel is to go to an unnamed 'DOE-approved facility' (safe-023); Valar is not in any announced HALEU allocation (gov-008).

In plain termsUnder DOE's fast-track program the companies pay to build and run their reactors, but the government's safety review is free to them, while companies licensed by the NRC pay the regulator by the hour. So the $0 in federal money recorded on the program's agreements is true for cash but not for government effort. The law firm's summary of the program's rules mentions no requirement for any local government's consent or any public meeting, and describes no formal role for the county or residents.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read Hogan Lovells, the DOE program page and EO 14300 in late September 2026; quotes exact; nine criteria counted. Holds; plain no longer states a cause the summary does not show. Stays 'reported' (one secondary summary; the RFA itself sits behind FedConnect).
recordconfirmed June 2025 Emery hearing: lab director said Valar was 'looking at manufacturing in Emery or Carbon County'
2025-06-17 · gov-020 · Emery County Commission, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab, Jaron Wallace, Valar Atomics, NuCube

The earliest county meeting on Valar found in Emery County's posted minutes followed news reports: at the 3 June 2025 Emery County Commission meeting a commissioner referred to 'the article floating around and on social media' about reactors at the San Rafael Energy Research Center and said a public hearing had been set for 17 June (its notice was posted 29 May). The minutes of that 17 June 2025 hearing on 'Nuclear Industries in Emery County' record the state lab director, Jaron Wallace, saying Valar 'would like to build nuclear reactors at the Research Center' and was 'looking at manufacturing in Emery or Carbon County', that another company, NuCube, was also interested, and that permitting 'will take some time'; later he said 'Transparency is imperative. We are not trying to keep anything from anyone', that the meeting was 'the first of many', and that safety was 'the number one priority'. Residents spoke both ways: several supported nuclear power and jobs; others asked whether the county has any control over a state-owned site, worried about being 'by-passed by the State', security, waste staying in the county, and cancer in families exposed in the past; one said she had not heard enough to be convinced. Set beside the record: the OED-Valar MOU signed a month earlier said the agreement and related information were confidential and barred publicity without both parties' consent (gov-011), terms that yield to Utah's records law and that the energy office also uses with other nuclear developers; DOE's pathway gave the county no approval role over the reactor (safe-001). This is also the earliest public record found that ties Valar to Carbon County, fourteen months before the Trust Lands agenda of August 2026 (csite-018, ppl-027); it names the county, not a site.

In plain termsEmery County's commissioners held a public hearing on nuclear in June 2025 after residents saw news stories. There, the state's lab director said Valar wanted to build reactors at the lab and was looking at manufacturing in Emery or Carbon County. So Carbon County was mentioned in public over a year before Valar's name appeared on a Trust Lands agenda for the Wellington lease (August 2026), but only in passing, at an Emery County meeting, with no site named. Residents asked who actually controls a state-owned nuclear site; on the record, the reactor's authorization rests with the federal Energy Department, a state board approves projects at the state lab (gov-013), and the county commission later approved Valar's building permit (gov-021).
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read the 17 June 2025 hearing minutes, the 3 June minutes and the notice in late September 2026; all quotes exact; residents described, not named. Fixed: the hearing had already been noticed (29 May) when the 3 June meeting mentioned it; plain wording made neutral.
analysisreported Governor told the public the NRC would help assure safety; the state's signed MOU named DOE, and Utah was suing the NRC
2025-05 · gov-012 · State of Utah, Spencer Cox, Utah Office of Energy Development, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Valar Atomics, Last Energy

Three state positions within six months, each from its own record. (1) In court: the State of Utah was a plaintiff, with Texas and Last Energy, in the suit filed on 30 December 2024 (per the NRC's litigation status report; Louisiana joined the suit in April 2025, per its environmental agency's release) in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, asking the court to set aside the NRC's reactor-licensing rule 'at least as applied to certain small, non-hazardous reactors' and to exempt the plaintiff states' research reactors and Last Energy's reactors from NRC licensing (World Nuclear News, 10 Jan 2025); Valar joined in April 2025 (orig-016, safe-028). ANS reported on 5 October 2026 that the states had since filed a notice of voluntary dismissal (the filing itself was not read). (2) In its signed agreement: the OED-Valar MOU of 16 May 2025 names compliance with DOE regulations and does not mention the NRC (gov-011). (3) In public: KUTV (story dated 28 May 2025, from an interview days earlier; the only report of this remark found) reported Gov. Spencer Cox saying safety would be assured by working with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission through planning, building and implementation, and in July 2025 OED's director said Valar would have to follow all federal licensing rules (orig-065). The record: Ward 250 was authorized by DOE alone, with no NRC license planned (safe-001). The gap is between the governor's public account of NRC oversight and the state's own documents, which pointed to DOE and, in court, argued against NRC licensing of small reactors. What the governor was told before speaking is not in the record.

In plain termsAccording to KUTV, when Utah's governor first described the Valar deal, he said the federal nuclear regulator, the NRC, would help make sure it was safe. But the paper his energy office had signed days earlier named the Energy Department's rules and did not mention the NRC, and the State of Utah was at the same time suing the NRC to keep small reactors out of its licensing. The reactor was in fact approved by the Energy Department alone. The public was given a picture of oversight that the state's own documents did not describe; what the governor was told before speaking is not in the record.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read WNN, KUTV and the MOU in late September 2026. Fixed: the filing date was not in WNN (30 Dec 2024 per the NRC's litigation status report, now cited, and a copy of the court docket); event date set to May 2025 (KUTV's story is dated 28 May from an earlier interview); plain no longer says the MOU named 'only' DOE rules. Downgraded to 'reported': the governor's NRC remark rests on one outlet (KUTV).
official statementreported May-July 2025: Utah's governor cited NRC oversight and near-zero cost; the energy office called the deal non-binding
2025-05 · orig-065 · State of Utah, Governor Spencer Cox, Utah Office of Energy Development, Valar Atomics

KUTV (published May 28, 2025, from an interview the governor gave that week or the week before) reported an early account by Governor Spencer Cox of the Valar arrangement: a memorandum of understanding letting Valar use the San Rafael Energy Research Center; a test reactor that would lead to energy production over the next ten years; a cost to the state of 'virtually nothing', with Utah just providing space and infrastructure; and safety assured by working with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission through planning, building and implementation. KUTV reported the reactor would not produce any energy, and that it had filed records requests for the MOU. In July 2025 the director of the Utah Office of Energy Development told the Utah Investigative Journalism Project the MOU was non-binding, that there was not yet a commitment, and that Valar would still have to follow all federal licensing rules. Set beside the later record: Ward 250 was authorized by DOE alone, with no NRC license planned (safe-001); Valar says, and Deseret News reported, that it generated electricity at the site on July 1, 2026 (orig-013, orig-042); the lab is state-owned and Valar is its tenant (mine-035); and the state approved up to $106.7 million in post-performance tax credits for Valar in July 2026, paid only as a share of new state tax revenue the project generates (csite-024). The oversight the governor described in 2025 was not the path the reactor took.

In plain termsWhen Utah first announced Valar in May 2025, the governor said it would cost the state almost nothing and that the federal nuclear regulator, the NRC, would help assure safety. In the end DOE, not the NRC, authorized the reactor, and Valar's safety agreement plans no NRC license. The state energy office stressed that the deal was not binding. The reactor, described then as not producing energy, made electricity for a demonstration in July 2026, by Valar's account and a newspaper's report.
verified 2026-10-15: Second check, late September 2026: KUTV (page data: published 2025-05-28) and UIJP re-read; the governor's 'virtually nothing', space-and-infrastructure and NRC-safety remarks and the energy director's 'non-binding' remarks match; quotes exact. Date set to May 2025 (the interview day is not given). The July 2026 electricity claim is now attributed.
recordconfirmed The order behind Ward 250 tells DOE to assign a team to help each applicant, and to work with DOGE to implement it
2025-05-23 · gov-005 · Executive Office of the President, U.S. Department of Energy, Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), Office of Management and Budget, Office of Science and Technology Policy

Executive Order 14301 (23 May 2025, 90 FR 22591), read in full on govinfo: section 3 finds that reactors under DOE's 'sufficient control' that do not produce commercial electric power are for research and fall within DOE's jurisdiction, rather than needing an NRC license; section 4 has DOE rewrite its rules to 'significantly expedite' approvals and, once an application is substantially complete, form a team from the Secretary's office, a national laboratory, DOE's General Counsel and any office able to 'deconflict, oppose, or approve' it, which 'shall provide assistance to the applicant to ensure expeditious processing', each member reporting to the Secretary; section 5 creates the pilot program 'outside the National Laboratories', orders the Secretary to approve at least three reactors with the goal of criticality in each by 4 July 2026, and assigns each approved applicant such an assistance team; section 6 orders NEPA reform, including new categorical exclusions (the one used for Ward 250, csite-020); section 7 has the Secretary implement the order with 'the DOGE Team Lead at the Department', OMB and OSTP. The order sets no public-hearing or comment step for reactor approvals. See safe-001 and safe-002 for how DOE carried it out.

In plain termsThe presidential order that made Ward 250 possible tells the Energy Department to speed up approvals and to put together a team, including officials who have power to approve or object, whose job is to help each company get through the process quickly. It also tells DOE to work with the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) on carrying it out. That is a different model from an independent regulator that reviews an application at arm's length and in public. The order does not provide for public hearings.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read EO 14301 on govinfo in late September 2026: sections 3-7 as described; the word 'public' appears only in the publication line, so no hearing or comment step. Holds; one phrase made closer to the text.
recordconfirmed The other May 2025 orders: NRC told to rethink radiation limits, DOE told to form fuel pacts, Army to run a reactor
2025-05-23 · gov-009 · Executive Office of the President, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, U.S. Department of Energy, U.S. Army, Valar Atomics

Three companion orders signed with EO 14301 on 23 May 2025, read on govinfo: EO 14300 orders the NRC to rewrite its rules within 18 months, set fixed licensing deadlines (18 months for a new reactor) and 'reconsider reliance on the linear no-threshold (LNT) model' and the 'as low as reasonably achievable' standard, consulting DOD, DOE and EPA; it calls those models flawed. EO 14302 directs DOE to seek Defense Production Act voluntary agreements with nuclear companies, to 'prioritize' firms with milestones such as DOE-approved conceptual safety design reports or the ability to privately finance their fuel, and allows procurement support or offtake guarantees for consortia (the agreement Valar signed, gov-001). EO 14299 has the Army operate a reactor at a domestic base by 30 September 2028 and has DOE start designating AI data centers at DOE sites as critical defense facilities where appropriate. Valar's CEO praised these orders the day they were signed, including abandoning LNT (orig-019). The Army's Janus reactor program named five vendors on 26 August 2026; Valar is not among them (plan-012).

In plain termsThe same day as the order that created Valar's program, the President also told the nuclear regulator to reconsider the long-standing assumption, built into its radiation limits, that any dose carries some risk, told DOE to form industry fuel pacts, and told the Army to run its own reactor. Valar's chief executive publicly welcomed the orders the day they were signed. The radiation-limit change matters to neighbors: it would decide how much exposure the public may be allowed from reactors like Valar's. As of its October 2025 safety design agreement, Valar's safety papers use today's limits (safe-013).
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read EOs 14300, 14302 and 14299 on govinfo in late September 2026; quotes exact. Fixed: 'conceptual' safety design reports (the order's word); DOE is to start designating data centers 'where appropriate'; plain calls LNT an assumption, not a rule, and no longer says Valar cheered 'all of this'.
official statementconfirmed Utah officials who host Valar vouch for its safety and openness; by Valar's own safety agreement, state representatives 'may observe but not direct DOE regulatory activities'
2025-05-23 · ppl-018 · Emy Lesofski, Jaron Wallace, Jake Garfield, Tracy Rees, Spencer Cox, Utah Office of Energy Development, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab, Valar Atomics

The Utah Office of Energy Development (OED) owns and runs the San Rafael Energy Lab, is Valar's landlord there, and promotes the project. On 23 May 2025 Taylor announced the state deal on Bloomberg TV alongside Gov. Spencer Cox, who said of the July 2026 target, 'It's absolutely possible that we can do that' (The New Republic). OED's people, in their own words: Director Emy Lesofski said in July 2025 the state's agreement was a non-binding MOU, 'still not a commitment' (UIJP), and at the September 2025 groundbreaking called it 'a historic moment'. Lab director Jaron Wallace said in the same release that Valar's 'concentrated infrastructure' means industrial-scale power for Utah, told local news in October 2025 that Valar must show no dose at the fence (safe-015), and in April 2026, at the county hearing on selling land to Valar, spoke of the economic opportunities and the land's industrial zoning (ppl-021). Deputy Director Jake Garfield told the Trust Lands board on 20 August 2026 that Valar had been 'diligent in guaranteeing public safety' and worked with regulators 'both at the state and' DOE. Deputy Director Tracy Rees, who oversees the lab, told the board on 17 September that 'transparency and accessibility are ethos' for Valar. Set beside the record: Valar's own safety agreement says the state 'may observe but not direct' and the state-DOE agreements it cites were not found in state or DOE sources searched in late September 2026 (safe-034); no state permit or license for the reactor was found in the state records searched as of late September 2026 (csite-023); the worst-case analysis does show a dose at the boundary (safe-013); and no public record naming Valar for the Carbon site was found before August 2026 (csite-028). On 25 Sept 2026 the lab posted a time-limited Safety Manager position; the listing does not say whether it is new (dir-006). These are statements of support by the office that hosts and promotes the project; none is a safety finding.

In plain termsThe state officials who praise Valar's safety and openness are its landlord and business partner, not its safety regulator. By Valar's own paperwork the state can watch but cannot give orders on reactor safety. Their praise is support, not an inspection result, and it sits beside a record in which the Carbon County site was first named on a public agenda in August 2026, although officials had been talking with Valar since 2024.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read UIJP, the Sept 2025 groundbreaking release (which also calls Mitchell former USNC president and says the groundbreaking coincided with 11 September), both Trust Lands transcripts, the minutes and TNR. Quotes exact. Fixed: TNR says Taylor announced the deal with Cox beside him, not that Cox announced it; date set to the earliest statement (23 May 2025); plain no longer calls the praise 'sincere' (a state of mind) and states the Carbon gap with dates. Cross-refs safe-013, safe-015, safe-034, csite-028, dir-006 checked. NSDA opened to confirm 'may observe but not direct'; added as a source. Revised before publication (late September 2026): 'Against the record' now 'Set beside the record'; Safety Manager sentence states only what the listing shows.
recordconfirmed The state's earliest agreement with Valar found in public records (May 16, 2025) made it and 'related information' confidential, except as required by law, and barred publicity without consent; the energy office uses similar terms with some other nuclear companies
2025-05-16 · gov-011 · Utah Office of Energy Development, Valar Atomics, Emy Lesofski, Max Ukropina, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab

The memorandum of understanding between the Utah Office of Energy Development and Valar Atomics, dated and signed 16 May 2025 by OED Director Emy Lesofski and Valar's Max Ukropina (the MOU's signing note lists 'Max Ukropina - Valar Atomics', with no title), is posted on OED's website with signatures omitted (the file was uploaded 12 January 2026, per the site's media record). It sets a 'non-binding framework' to evaluate Valar 'activating a nuclear test reactor' and 'TRISO fuel fabrication' at the San Rafael Energy Lab 'for research'; the areas the parties 'intend to explore' include OED providing site, infrastructure and shared facilities, and Valar's responsibility for design, operation and 'regulatory compliance'. It targets 'Test Reactor activation by July 2026, with milestones for approvals', a week before Executive Order 14301 (23 May 2025, gov-005) set the 4 July 2026 criticality goal. Clause 5 says the MOU 'and related information are confidential' and shall not be disclosed without both parties' consent, except as required by law, and that OED 'requires Valar officer approval for external disclosures'; clause 4 treats information exchanged as confidential 'unless otherwise required by law', notes that OED is subject to GRAMA, and has the lab notify Valar of any records request touching Valar-designated confidential information; clause 8 says 'No publicity shall be issued without mutual consent'. Clause 6 names compliance with applicable laws 'including Department of Energy (DOE) regulations'; the NRC is not mentioned. Either side may end it on 30 days' notice; OED cannot indemnify Valar, and the MOU does not oblige it to spend money not appropriated. The confidentiality terms are not unique to Valar: two of OED's later nuclear MOUs posted on its website carry similar clauses, Deployable Energy's (18 Aug 2026) barring publicity 'without the prior written consent' of the other party, and Oklo's (27 March 2026) treating the MOU, its contents and 'the fact that the Parties are discussing' it as confidential. They are OED's common practice with nuclear developers, though not universal: its June 2026 MOU with Nuclea Energy has neither clause and says only that OED is subject to GRAMA.

In plain termsThis is the earliest signed agreement between the State of Utah and Valar found in public records. It is not a contract: it only says both sides will explore putting a test reactor and a uranium-fuel making operation at the state's energy lab in Emery County, with the reactor running by July 2026. It also says the agreement and 'related information' are confidential, that the state needs Valar's sign-off before disclosing things, and that neither side will publicize the deal without the other's consent. Utah's public-records law still overrides that. The agreement's own text went up on the energy office's website in January 2026, but the project itself was publicly discussed within weeks of the signing: after news reports, Emery County held a noticed public hearing on nuclear industries (17 June 2025, gov-020), and the next day a legislative committee heard an agenda item titled 'Valar Atomics Nuclear Test Reactor', where the state's slides gave the MOU's signing date (gov-040). And from the first day, the plan named the Energy Department's rules and did not mention the NRC. The state's energy office puts similar confidentiality terms in some of its agreements with other nuclear companies, so these terms are not unique to Valar.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read both pages of the Valar MOU in late September 2026 (clauses 1-12, signature note) and re-read the Deployable, Oklo and Nuclea MOUs and the media upload record (12 Jan 2026). Holds; added clause 4's own GRAMA acknowledgment. Corrected 2026-10-01: wording made more exact against the cited records.
recordconfirmed The lab-side parcel Valar is buying has been in an Inland Port tax zone since Jan 2025, on the port's records: 75% of new property tax for 25 years
2025-01-06 · gov-018 · Utah Inland Port Authority, Valar Atomics, Emery County, Carbon County · projected property tax differential to the Castle Country project area over 25 years (plan budget): $72,900,000

The Utah Inland Port Authority (UIPA) board created the Castle Country Project Area on 24 June 2024 and enlarged it on 6 January 2025 (Amendment #1, +10,754 acres of Emery County parcels), 23 April 2026 (#2, Carbon County) and 21 May 2026 (#3); it now covers about 15,370 acres in Carbon and Emery counties including parts of Green River and Wellington. The plan's parcel list includes '04-0019-0030', labelled 'San Rafael Energy Research Center', in Section 24, T18S R7E; that is the 112.7-acre parcel Emery County agreed on 19 May 2026 to sell to Valar for $394,500 (gov-022). The plan sends 75% of the growth in property tax to UIPA for 25 years (extendable 15), 25% to local taxing entities, projecting $72.9M to the project area; UIPA may use it for business incentives and public infrastructure districts. UIPA staff told its board on 4 August 2026 that Valar's operations 'will be expanding into the Castle Country project area', and UIPA's 10 September update says Valar 'has also purchased' more than 100 acres there. The only Castle Country business incentive on the board's 2026 agendas is for Anson Resources (3 September 2026); no UIPA incentive for Valar was found as of late September 2026. Tax-differential collection starts only when UIPA 'triggers' parcels by board resolution; its 2026 Castle Country trigger resolution (16 March 2026) covers only the Fossil Rock Area parcels, not 04-0019-0030. The parcel was placed in the zone in January 2025, four months before OED's MOU with Valar (gov-011). On 19 May 2026 the Emery County Commission voted to remove the parcel from the project area; UIPA's later records still include it (gov-023).

In plain termsThe land next to the state lab that Valar is buying has been inside a state 'Inland Port' tax zone since January 2025. In such a zone, most of the new property taxes a big development generates, 75 cents of every new dollar for 25 years, go to the state port authority rather than to the county and schools, and the authority can hand some back to companies as incentives. As of late September 2026, no port incentive for Valar was found. Emery County voted in May 2026 to take the parcel out of the zone, but the port authority's later records still include it (gov-023). If the parcel stays in the zone and the port authority 'triggers' it (so far it has triggered only other parcels there), the zone would decide where much of the property tax on Valar's development goes.
verified 2026-10-19: Re-read the Amendment #3 plan (parcel in the Amendment #1 legal descriptions, 15,370.25 acres, 75%/25%, 25+15 years, $72.9M), the 4 Aug minutes, the 10 Sept post and the 2026 UIPA agendas (Mar-Oct; only Castle Country incentive is Anson) in late September 2026. Fixed: plain overstated; the trigger resolution (read) shows collection has not been started on the Valar parcel.
analysisconfirmed By their accounts, officials talked with Valar about Carbon County from 2024 or early 2025; the first public agenda found naming Valar for the Wellington site is from Aug 2026
2024 · ppl-027 · Max Ukropina, Jared Haddock, Carbon County Commission, Utah Office of Energy Development, Governor's Office of Economic Opportunity, Southeastern Regional Development Agency, Utah Trust Lands Administration, Valar Atomics

Testing whether the public knew, against what the people involved have said on the record. Officials and Valar: Valar's Max Ukropina told the Trust Lands board that in 2024 he met the Office of Energy Development, the Governor's economic office, SERDA and Carbon County (ppl-006, mine-018); Carbon County's minutes of 19 August 2026, summarising Valar's presentation, say they 'relocated to the region from California two years ago'; the state energy office's MOU with Valar, naming Ukropina, was signed on 16 May 2025 (gov-011); Commissioner Jared Haddock said the county worked with Valar 'since the beginning, when they were looking at other states' (ppl-020); the county's 29 June 2026 letter says the county had worked with Valar for over a year (mine-013); Carbon's October 2024 minutes note that Commissioner Martines phoned in while traveling home from a trip to Idaho National Laboratory connected with the San Rafael lab; no mention of Valar was found in those minutes (csite-026). The New Republic reports that before the May 2025 executive orders Valar staff were exploring land in southern Utah for a first 'gigasite', and the lab director says a contract followed about two weeks after Valar said it wanted to build at the lab; in July 2025 the state called its agreement a non-binding MOU (ppl-018). Public: the state's lease map is dated 9 April 2026 (mine-048); the 20 April 2026 state notice called it an unnamed industrial and power project (csite-032); the first public agenda found naming Valar for the site is dated 10 August 2026 (csite-018); the first ETV News report of the lease that was found came on 18 September, the day after approval (mine-011). Finding: by the officials' and Valar's own accounts, county, state-agency and regional officials were in contact with Valar about Carbon County from 2024 or early 2025 (Ukropina gave 2024 to the Trust Lands board; at the Carbon County Planning Commission on 6 October 2026 a Valar speaker introduced as Max put the company's first arrival in Carbon County in early 2025), and in any case more than a year before a public agenda named Valar for the site (the county's 29 June 2026 letter says it had worked with Valar for over a year). The 2024 contacts, as Ukropina described them, concerned making fuels from coal-plant flue gas; when the Wellington parcel itself entered the talks is not settled by the records read (Ukropina's line in the auto-transcript, 'the first property I looked at was actually property', is garbled, mine-018; the state's lease map is dated 9 April 2026; the county's 29 June 2026 letter says it had worked with Valar for over a year). This is a gap in time before public notice, not proof of any intent, and the board's notices met the meeting law's timing (csite-016); no record of what was said in those 2024-2026 contacts was found in public records.

In plain termsBy their own statements, Carbon County's commissioners and several state offices had been talking with Valar since 2024 or early 2025 (Valar's own accounts give both years), at first, by Valar's account, about making fuels from coal-plant exhaust. The Wellington parcel shows up in state records from April 2026 (a lease map), but the first public record found attaching Valar's name to it was an August 2026 meeting notice, about five weeks before the vote. The emails and meeting notes from that period would show what was discussed, and they can be requested.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read the 20 Aug auto-transcript (Ukropina; Haddock), TNR (delivered part) and UIJP; quotes exact. Fixed: the finding said officials 'knew of Valar's interest in Carbon County' for two years; the record shows contact from 2024, first about coal flue-gas fuels, while the Wellington parcel appears in public-agency records only from April 2026 (map) and by name in August 2026. Plain's 'The people in charge knew' removed. Cross-refs mine-013, mine-018, mine-041, mine-048, csite-018, csite-026, csite-032 checked. Quote marks removed from wording taken from the county letter and minutes (mine-013, csite-026), which were not re-opened in this check; the substance rests on those facts. Corrected in late September 2026: the closing sentence on intent shortened to 'not proof of any intent'. Corrected 2026-09-30: the October 2024 county minutes record only that Commissioner Martines phoned in while traveling home from Idaho National Laboratory. Corrected 17 October 2026: Corrected 17 October 2026: Valar's own accounts give 2024 or early 2025 for the first contacts, not 2024 alone. Corrected 17 October 2026: Valar's own accounts give 2024 or early 2025 for the first contacts, not 2024 alone. Corrected 17 October 2026: Valar's own accounts give 2024 or early 2025 for the first contacts, not 2024 alone. Corrected 17 October 2026: the year talks began is given as 2024 or early 2025, since Valar's own accounts give both.
recordconfirmed Carbon County's past support letters: one approved by public vote; its attorney said one could go out off-agenda
2024-12-18 · csite-030 · Carbon County Commission, Utah Division of Wildlife Resources

Carbon Commission minutes show two earlier support-letter cases. On 16 October 2024, on an agenda item, the commission voted to approve a letter of support for a Division of Wildlife Resources land exchange and authorized the chair to sign it; the state's regional supervisor told the commission that the Governor's office always asks, on state land deals, whether the county has been notified. On 18 December 2024, when a conservation district asked for a support letter on an item not on the agenda, the deputy county attorney said the commission could not act on it that day because it was not on the agenda, 'but they can offer a letter of support'. For the 29 June 2026 Valar letter (mine-013) no agenda item or motion was found (csite-026), which fits the second pattern, not the first.

In plain termsCarbon County has sometimes approved support letters by a public vote, and its own lawyer has said a letter could still be offered when the item was not on the agenda. So the lack of a recorded vote on the Valar letter may be within the county's practice. What it means in practice is that no record found as of late September 2026 shows the county's formal backing of the Wellington site, which the state board relied on, being discussed in a public county meeting.
verified 2026-10-12: Holds. Re-read in late September 2026: October 16, 2024 minutes p. 3 (DWR letter; Commissioner Hopes, listed as Commission Chair, authorized to sign) and December 18, 2024 minutes p. 5 (Deputy Attorney: quote exact). County staff other than officials are described by role.
recordconfirmed Utah law: a claim post must carry a notice naming the claim and locators, recorded with the county in 30 days
2024-05-01 · mine-026 · Utah State Legislature, Carbon County Recorder

Utah Code 40-1-2 requires the locator to erect a monument at the place of discovery and post on it a notice of location giving the claim's name, the names of the locators, the date of location, and its size and description tied to a natural object or permanent monument. Utah Code 40-1-3 requires the claim's boundaries to be distinctly marked on the ground so they can be readily traced. Utah Code 40-1-4 requires a substantial copy of the notice to be recorded with the county recorder of the county where the claim lies within 30 days of posting.

In plain termsIn Utah, a mining claim's discovery monument must carry a notice on the post: the claim's name, who staked it and when. A copy must be recorded with the recorder of the county where the claim lies (for RW 453, Carbon County) within 30 days after posting. A Notice of Location names Valar Atomics Inc and its lode claim RW 453 (mine-453, csite-019).
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read in late September 2026 on le.utah.gov: 40-1-2 (effective 1 May 2024), 40-1-3 and 40-1-4 match; all three quotes exact. Updated in late September 2026 for the RW 453 notice (mine-453).
recordconfirmed Legislature built the lab's legal frame: a $2M lab law (2024 HB 410), then a council and tax-capture zones (HB 249)
2024-03 · gov-016 · Utah State Legislature, Utah San Rafael Energy Lab, Utah Energy Research Board, Utah Energy Council, David Hinkins, Christine Watkins, Carl Albrecht, Ann Millner · one-time FY2025 appropriation to OED for the Utah San Rafael Energy Lab (2024 H.B. 410): $2,000,000

2024 H.B. 410, 'Utah San Rafael State Energy Lab' (chief sponsor Rep. Christine Watkins, Senate sponsor Sen. David Hinkins), created the lab inside the Office of Energy Development, its board, the Utah Energy Research Fund (fed by federal money, lab users' payments and appropriations) and the project-approval process, and appropriated $2,000,000 one-time for fiscal 2025. 2025 H.B. 249, 'Nuclear Power Amendments' (Rep. Carl Albrecht, Sen. Ann Millner; effective 7 May 2025), renamed the board the Utah Energy Research Board and gave it the Advanced Nuclear and Energy Institute, created a Nuclear Energy Consortium and the Utah Energy Council, and set up 'electrical energy development zones': the council designates zones on application by a county, city or a state land authority (including Trust Lands and the Inland Port Authority); property-tax growth inside a zone goes to an Electrical Energy Development Investment Fund; and counties and cities 'may not offer financial incentives' for a baseload power project outside a designated zone, except for municipal power, intermittent-only projects (such as solar) and projects whose project area plan was approved before 1 July 2026; the version in force since 6 May 2026 (2026 Laws ch. 373) also exempts any project 'that is not a nuclear energy project', so the limit now applies only to nuclear projects (ptax-010). No record read names Valar in either bill; both passed before Valar's Utah deal was public (May 2025). Sen. Hinkins later thanked the Legislature at Valar's July 2026 event (ppl-017). In 2026 the Legislature also passed S.C.R. 1 (support for seeking NRC Agreement State status for more of the fuel cycle; Sen. Derrin Owens, Rep. Colin Jack) and H.C.R. 1 (support for advanced nuclear manufacturing in Utah; Rep. Albrecht, Sen. Hinkins); neither names Valar or the San Rafael lab. As of late September 2026, no council designation of a zone in Emery or Carbon County was found (open question).

In plain termsBefore Valar arrived, Utah's Legislature created the state energy lab in Emery County, put $2 million into it, and set up a board to approve projects there. In 2025 it added a statewide energy council and a new tool: special 'energy development zones' where growth in property taxes can be captured for energy projects. Under that law as amended in 2026, a county generally cannot give a nuclear power plant incentives unless it sits in one of those zones or its project plan was approved before July 1, 2026. Those rules matter for any future Valar reactor in Carbon or Emery County.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read HB 410 (2024), HB 249 (2025), SCR 1 and HCR 1 (2026) in late September 2026. Fixed: HB 249's incentive ban applies from the bill's effective date (7 May 2025); 1 July 2026 is the cut-off for grandfathered project area plans, not the start of the ban. Other points hold.
recordconfirmed Carbon County backed nuclear power in a public 2023 vote; no county agenda or minutes found name Valar's Wellington site
2023-12-20 · csite-026 · Carbon County Commission, Larry Jensen, Tony Martines, PacifiCorp

On 20 December 2023 the Carbon County Commission, on a posted agenda item, adopted Resolution 2023-06 'Supporting the energy industry, more specifically nuclear power'. Per the minutes, Commissioner Jensen said it was meant to tell PacifiCorp/Rocky Mountain Power the community favored nuclear plants and that 'we need to begin to educate the public about nuclear power'; it mirrored an Emery County resolution. The commission's minutes for January 2024 to April 2026 (50 sets; the examples below were read again for this check) mention nuclear only in brief remarks: a 3 January 2024 recap of that resolution; Commissioner Martines phoning in on 16 October 2024 while returning from Idaho National Laboratory 'in conjunction with' the San Rafael Energy Research Center; and, on 18 February 2026, Commissioners Martines' and Jensen's report on the Ward 250 reactor's delivery to the Orangeville test site, which Martines called the first of three prototypes. The one Trust Lands item, on 5 November 2025, renewed a county road easement on trust land along Ridge Road and Miller Creek, not the Wellington parcel. The commission's posted agendas from 6 December 2023 to 16 September 2026 (73 notices) name Valar once: a 'Valor Atomics presentation' on 19 August 2026. Its minutes record an update on the Emery lab, plans for a town hall in Price and a reactor open house within 30 to 45 days, and commissioners highlighting 'the tax benefits the plant will bring'; they do not name the Wellington site or the lease the state board heard the next day (mine-013). The 2026 minutes also record commissioners celebrating Valar's criticality (1 July) and Valar announcing a Carbon County town hall for late September or early October (2 September); none names the parcel or the letter. No commission agenda or minutes read for December 2023 to September 2026 name the Wellington parcel or the 29 June 2026 support letter, and none read shows a Valar zoning change, development agreement, road-use agreement, tax abatement or other county approval for the site.

In plain termsCarbon County's leaders told the public openly, in 2023, that they wanted nuclear power in the area, and voted on it in a public meeting. Valar gave a presentation at a county meeting in August 2026. In almost three years of county meeting records, none found shows the specific plan: the square mile north of Wellington, or the letter the commissioners signed backing it. The county may not have been legally required to vote on the letter (csite-016, csite-030), but residents reading the commission's posted agendas and minutes would not have found the site there.
verified 2026-10-02: Holds, with the headline narrowed (the 19 Aug 2026 agenda does name Valar, though not the site). Re-checked in late September 2026: December 20, 2023, October 16, 2024 and November 5, 2025 minutes (quotes exact); all 47 commission notices on body 1148 from 4 Dec 2024 to 16 Sept 2026 searched by their agenda text (only 19 Aug 2026 names Valar/Valor). The full 50-set minutes check for January 2024 to April 2026 was not repeated in this check. Date set to the 2023 vote. Second check, late September 2026: all 73 commission notices on body 1148 from 6 Dec 2023 to 16 Sept 2026 searched by their agenda text (only 19 Aug 2026 names Valar/Valor); minutes re-read for 3 Jan 2024 and all 16 sets from 7 Jan to 2 Sept 2026 (Valar or nuclear appears on 18 Feb, 1 July, 19 Aug and 2 Sept; none names the parcel, Section 16 or the support letter). The 2024-2025 minutes rest on the first reading of all 50 sets, apart from the four sets re-read. Quotes are exact to the text read from the scans. Revised before publication (late September 2026): absence stated as 'no record found'. Revised before publication (2026-09-30): the minutes name Martines (Oct 2024 call-in) and Martines and Jensen (Feb 2026 report).
recordconfirmed Federal law: a new claim must be filed with BLM within 90 days of staking, or it is treated as abandoned
1976-10-21 · mine-025 · U.S. Congress, Bureau of Land Management

43 U.S.C. 1744 (FLPMA sec. 314) requires the claimant, for any claim located after 21 October 1976, to file a copy of the recorded location notice with BLM within ninety days of location. Section 1744 also sets yearly filings with the county and BLM, but a yearly claim maintenance fee paid to BLM by September 1 is 'in lieu of' those filings (30 U.S.C. 28f). Failing to file is deemed conclusively to be abandonment of the claim.

In plain termsOnce a claim is staked, the claimant has 90 days to register it with BLM, or the claim is treated as abandoned. So claims staked recently may not show on BLM's map yet (mine-002), and BLM can take longer still to map a claim after it is filed (mine-045).
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read in late September 2026: (a)-(c) and the 21 Oct 1976 source credit match; quote exact. Plain field no longer says a claim must 'appear' on the map within 90 days (filing and mapping differ). Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): the yearly fee paid to BLM replaces the yearly filings; see Corrections.
recordconfirmed Surface Resources Act: an unpatented mining claim may be used only for prospecting, mining, processing and uses reasonably incident to them
1955-07-23 · mine-022 · U.S. Congress

30 U.S.C. 612(a) (Surface Resources Act of 23 July 1955) says a mining claim located after that date may not be used, before a patent is issued, for any purpose other than prospecting, mining or processing and uses reasonably incident to them. Subsection (b) keeps the United States' right to manage the surface and let others use it, so long as that does not materially interfere with mining.

In plain termsA mining claim is a right to prospect for, mine and process minerals, not a right to use the land for anything else. Building a reactor, a data center or a factory on an unpatented claim for anything other than mining or processing would be outside what the law allows.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read in late September 2026: 30 U.S.C. 612(a)-(b) and the 23 July 1955 source credit match; quote exact. Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): a claim also allows processing and uses reasonably incident to mining; see Corrections.
recordconfirmed The 1872 Mining Law opens federal land, not state land, to mineral claims
1872-05-10 · mine-021 · U.S. Congress

30 U.S.C. 22, from the Mining Law of 10 May 1872, declares valuable mineral deposits in lands belonging to the United States free and open to exploration and purchase by citizens, under federal law and local mining customs, 'except as otherwise provided'. The statute reaches only land of the United States; the Wellington parcel (Sec. 16) is state trust land (mine-010, mine-034), so a federal mining claim cannot be staked on it.

In plain termsA U.S. citizen can stake a mining claim on open federal land and look for minerals there without buying it first. But the law covers only federal land. The Carbon County parcel the state approved leasing to Valar is state school land, so a federal mining claim cannot be staked on it.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read in late September 2026 on uscode.house.gov: text and 10 May 1872 source credit match; quote exact. Plain field corrected from 'anyone' to citizens, as the statute says. Revised before publication (late September 2026): lease wording now 'approved leasing'.
analysisconfirmed Carbon site timeline, from the records: county nuclear vote (2023) to state lease vote and first news (Sept 2026)
undated · csite-006 · Valar Atomics, Carbon County, Utah Trust Lands Administration

In date order, each item sourced in the fact cited: 20 Dec 2023, Carbon County adopts a public resolution backing nuclear power (csite-026); 2024 or early 2025 (Valar's accounts differ), Valar's Max Ukropina first meets Carbon County and state offices (mine-018, ppl-006); 16 May 2025, the state energy office's MOU with Valar is signed, with Ukropina the Valar name on it (gov-011); 13 Feb 2026, Valar's 10,270-acre Green River application to BLM (mine-006); 19 Feb 2026, state RDCC posts a site-study permit application covering nearly all of Section 16, applicant not named (dir-035); 9 Apr 2026, Trust Lands maps the SULA 2095 lease (mine-048); 13 Apr 2026, BLM lists Valar's 'Project Beehive' reactor and data-center application as pending from this date, no location shown (mine-006; on 30 Sept NPR reported that it covers over 9,000 BLM acres near Price, plan-017, and that the state land is part of the same project); 20 Apr to 18 May 2026, state RDCC notice of an unnamed 'industrial' and power project, county contacted (csite-032); 22 Apr 2026, DOE's categorical exclusion for Ward 250 (csite-020); 6 May 2026, Utah's waste exemption for test-reactor waste takes effect (csite-023); 29 Jun 2026, Carbon commissioners sign a support letter, no agenda item found (mine-013); 8 Jul 2026, Trust Lands web notice naming neither applicant nor use (csite-005); 9 Jul 2026, up to $106.7 million state tax credit approved for Valar in Emery County, the company unnamed on the pre-meeting agenda (csite-024); 20 and 28 Jul 2026, Trust Lands committee meetings, no public notice found (csite-017); 7 Aug 2026, bid deadline, no competing offers (csite-005); 10 Aug 2026, first public agenda naming Valar for the site (csite-018); 19 Aug 2026, a 'Valor Atomics presentation' on the Carbon County Commission agenda, given by Max Ukropina and Corey Gardner, whose minutes record plans for a Price town hall but do not name the site (mine-013, csite-026); 20 Aug 2026, board hearing in Salt Lake City (mine-014); 25 Aug 2026, Energy & Minerals committee (csite-017); 2 Sep 2026, Carbon County's minutes record Valar's Harry Hansen announcing a 10 September open house, with a Carbon County town hall planned for late September or early October (csite-028); 12 Sep 2026, the RW 453 Notice of Location says Valar Atomics Inc located the lode claim in Section 28 (mine-453, csite-019); 17 Sep 2026, board approves the lease (mine-011); 18 Sep 2026, ETV News's first report of the lease (mine-041); 29 Sep 2026, Valar's event with a public Q&A at the Southeastern Regional Development Agency building in Price, which KOAL News called an open house and ETV News a town hall (csite-028); 6 Oct 2026, Carbon County Planning Commission agenda (amended 2 Oct) lists a Valar Atomics presentation on its proposed project (loc-037); November 2026 (planned), county code hearing on big projects (csite-013).

In plain termsPut in order, the record shows almost three years between the county's public support for nuclear power and the state's approval of the Wellington lease, with the first public document naming Valar and the site appearing only about five weeks before the vote. Five days before the vote, a mining claim two miles south was located in Valar's name, per its Notice of Location. As of late September 2026, no application for the next public decisions (county permits, water rights, state and federal licences) was found in the records read. Separately, BLM's public layer listed a pending Valar application, 'Project Beehive', with no location shown (mine-006); on 30 September NPR, citing state records, reported that this state land is part of the same project.
verified 2026-10-17: Rebuilt in late September 2026 from the cited facts; each date checked against a source read in this pass (memo, notices, RDCC layer, BLM layer, CX, H.B. 78, GOED notice, the RW 453 Notice of Location) or against the cited fact. Added the 19 Aug county agenda item and the 12 Sep claim. Second check, late September 2026: two items sharpened from csite-024 and csite-026. Revised before publication (late September 2026) (wording): plain attributes the RW 453 location to its Notice of Location.
recordconfirmed The meeting-law yardstick: 24-hour notice, agendas that list each topic, minutes within 30 days for state boards and county commissions, audio in 3 business days
undated · csite-016 · Utah Legislature, Utah Trust Lands Administration, Carbon County Commission

Utah's Open and Public Meetings Act requires a public body to give at least 24 hours' notice with the agenda, date, time and place (52-4-202(1)); the agenda must give 'reasonable specificity' about the topics, and a body may not take final action on a topic not listed on the agenda (52-4-202(6)). A 'meeting' is a gathering of the body with a quorum, convened to take comment, deliberate or act (52-4-103(5)). A state body must make pending minutes public within 30 days, post approved minutes within three business days of approval, and post the audio within three business days (52-4-203(4)(e)); a county commission must make pending minutes public within 30 days and audio available within three business days (52-4-203(4)(f)). Applied to the records: the Trust Lands board's notices were posted on 10 August for the 20 August meeting and on 8 September for the 17 September meeting; the 17 September audio recording was attached on 18 September and the transcript on 23 September, and pending minutes are not due until mid-October, so no lateness shows as of 29 September. The Carbon Commission's 29 June support letter was not found on any of its agendas posted for its 6 May to 16 September 2026 meetings (mine-013); the records do not show whether the commissioners agreed on it in any 'meeting' as the Act defines it, so whether the Act applied is a legal question.

In plain termsUtah's open-meetings law says public boards must announce meetings a day ahead, list on the agenda the topics they will take up, and not take final action on anything that was not on it. Measured against it, the state board's notices for the Wellington lease were on time. The county's letter of support is the open question: it was signed, but no public meeting record found shows the county deciding to send it.
verified 2026-10-02: Holds. Re-read in late September 2026: 52-4-202 (eff. 5/3/2023), 52-4-203 (eff. 5/1/2024), 52-4-103 (eff. 5/6/2026) on le.utah.gov; notice pages 1100659 (posted 10 Aug) and 1107027 (posted 8 Sept; audio added 18 Sept, transcript 23 Sept). Date set to null: the fact states a legal yardstick drawn from several sections, not one event. Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): agendas give topics with reasonable specificity, and the 30-day minutes rule covers state bodies and county commissions; see Corrections.
recordconfirmed Federal and Utah law: no lode claim may be located until a vein or lode is discovered within it
undated · dir-004 · State of Utah, Carbon County Recorder, Valar Atomics

Federal mining law, 30 U.S.C. 23, limits a lode claim to 1,500 feet along the vein and 300 feet each side of it, and says no claim may be located 'until the discovery of the vein or lode within the limits of the claim located'. Utah Code 40-1-1 says the same for Utah. 40-1-2 requires a monument at the place of discovery with the notice on it (claim name, locators, date, feet claimed along the vein each way, width, the general course of the vein, and a tie to a natural object or permanent monument). 40-1-3 requires the boundaries to be distinctly marked on the ground. 40-1-4 requires a substantial copy of the notice to be recorded with the county recorder within 30 days after posting: for RW 453, located September 12, 2026, by about October 12, 2026 (mine-453). 40-1-11 makes it a class B misdemeanor to intentionally or knowingly tear down or deface a posted notice, or take up or destroy a claim's stakes or monuments. The RW 453 notice therefore amounts to a claim that a vein or lode was discovered in Section 28; no record read says what mineral.

In plain termsIn Utah you may not stake a lode claim until you have found a mineral vein inside it; the notice post is supposed to stand at the discovery. So Valar's claim implies it found a vein in Section 28. What vein, of what mineral, was not found in the public records read so far. The deadline for the county copy at the Carbon County Recorder is about October 12.
verified 2026-10-02: Read from the Legislature's current chapter PDF (generated 2025-05-07). 30 U.S.C. 23 read in late September 2026 (LII): discovery-before-location sentence quoted exactly; size 1,500 ft x 300 ft each side. Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): the misdemeanor covers intentional or knowing acts; see Corrections.
analysisconfirmed What local audiences heard about scale: 'just testing' (July 2025) to 'hundreds of reactors' (Sept 2026)
undated · loc-003 · Valar Atomics, Emery County, Carbon County

In the order Carbon and Emery audiences heard it, from local reports and releases: 8 July 2025, Valar's Castle Dale town hall, reported by ETV the next day under the headline 'Not A Nuclear Plant Just Testing a Small Nuclear Reactor': a test of about 12 months with about 40 staff, and commercial development by 2028 (orig-045). 17 September 2025, the state's groundbreaking release printed in ETV ends with Valar's own description: it 'is building America’s first nuclear gigasites', clusters of thousands of reactors (orig-067, loc-034). 10 October 2025, ETV reported that after about three years Valar's 'current plan' was a manufacturing hub in Carbon County, no site named (loc-034). 23 January 2026, a lab release printed in ETV: the site will house Valar's fuel fabrication facility as well as Ward 250. 24 February 2026, Valar's open-house release: Ward 250 is a research reactor for engineering validation and 'it is not a commercial power plant'. 7 April 2026, Emery hearing on the land sale: plans for the extra land 'not firm yet', maybe housing (ETV); fuel fabrication and manufacturing (minutes, gov-022). 9 July 2026, to the state incentive board in Salt Lake City: plans for more commercial units in the area, as the board's minutes record them (gov-033); 9 and 21 July, up to 1,000 water shares for future development (mine-042). 12 August 2026: plans to eventually manufacture reactors and fuel, with mass production as the long-term goal (ETV). 19 August: 'potential plans' to produce reactors for industrial users so they can move off the grid (ETV, loc-006). 10 September: aims to build hundreds of reactors in Carbon and Emery (loc-001). 17 September: state lease for a Carbon reactor, fuel and industrial campus approved (mine-011). 29 September, after the vote, Valar's town hall in Price: the 640-acre parcel is the first step, and Valar is working with the BLM on more federal land (ETV, 30 Sept). None of these statements contradicts the company's published 'gigasite' aim (orig-001), and that aim was printed in the local paper in September 2025; the 2025 'just testing' framing described the first reactor only. The gap is in timing and specifics: the size of the plan reached local audiences in pieces, a Carbon County plan was reported in general terms in October 2025, and no statement by Valar to local audiences read named the Wellington site before the vote (loc-012); the Trust Lands notice ETV printed in July named the site but no applicant (loc-032).

In plain termsIn 2025 Emery County was told this was a small, one-year test, not a power plant, though Valar also spoke of commercial development by 2028. But that same year the local paper printed Valar's description of itself as building clusters of thousands of reactors, and reported a plan for a factory hub in Carbon County in about three years. Through 2026 the details grew: a fuel factory, more land, water for future growth, and by September 'hundreds of reactors' across both counties. Each piece was said somewhere in public, but in small pieces, and the one concrete new site, north of Wellington, was not tied to Valar in anything said or printed locally that we found before the state approved it.
verified 2026-10-18: Re-read all cited pages. Fixed the town hall date (8 July 2025; ETV reported it 9 July) and '19 Aug plans' to ETV's 'potential plans'. Found two 2025 ETV items the earlier version had not used: the Sept 2025 release with Valar's 'gigasites' description and an Oct 2025 report of a Carbon County manufacturing hub plan; the conclusion now reflects them.
recordconfirmed Claim holds in Emery: Valar went to the towns again and again, at least 15 public appearances in all
undated · loc-027 · Valar Atomics, Jess Housekeeper, Harry Hansen, Orangeville City Council, Castle Dale City, Ferron City, Cleveland Town, Castle Valley Special Service District

Valar says on its Castle Country page that its 'doors remain open through tours, town halls and straight answers' (csite-027). In Emery County the record bears out frequent public contact: at least 15 appearances counting the county commission's (gov-020 to gov-039). Those found besides the commission: Orangeville City Council, 11 December 2025 (water line; 30-40 workers over six months), 11 June, 9 July and 13 August 2026 (fuel building, water shares, title, town hall); Orangeville's council minutes of 10 September 2026 also record, under the heading 'Valor Open house', that 'Harry Hanson spoke' (so spelled), without saying for whom, and that 'approximately 1000 people came to the open house this evening'; Orangeville planning commission, 16 July 2026 (I-2 zone); Castle Valley Special Service District, 19 February 2026 (plans by video; a second Valar staff member also attended); Cleveland Town was told on 12 March that Valar had presented to that board; Castle Dale City Council, 12 March 2026 (construction, water, security); Ferron City Council, 15 April 2026 (how the reactor works; that testing is done at 'worse case scenario' [sic]; staffing: 120 people employed in Emery, many living out of state, loc-004); a farm bureau meeting on 30 April 2026 (ETV, 1 May); the Emery County Business Chamber tour, 19 August; open houses on 26 February and 10 September 2026; and the July 2025 town hall that the county commission held at Valar's request. The fire district put Valar on its agenda in February and March 2026 (loc-018). In Carbon County, before the Trust Lands vote, the appearances were fewer and none named the Wellington site (loc-012); since then Valar has held a town hall in Price on the proposed Carbon County site (29 September; ETV, 30 Sept) and presented its proposed Carbon County project to the county planning commission on 6 October (loc-037, pcm-001). What the record cannot show is how complete the answers were: minutes are summaries, and several statements made at these meetings go beyond the public safety record (loc-005, loc-006, loc-025).

In plain termsIn Emery County, Valar did what it says: its staff kept showing up at town councils, the water district and open houses to explain the test reactor. That part of the company's openness claim holds. The gap is elsewhere: in Carbon County the specific site was not discussed at these meetings before the state approved the lease, and some things said at them differ from the company's own safety papers.
verified 2026-10-18: Re-read every cited record, including the Ferron and Castle Dale minutes as page images. Corrected a misquote: Ferron's minutes say 'worse case scenario', not 'worst'. Removed 'engineering lead' (not in the CVSSD minutes). No single date is given: this rolls up many dates. Revised before publication (late September 2026): comparison restated as a difference.
analysisconfirmed Emery's public process for the San Rafael reactor: a general nuclear hearing, a land-sale hearing and many meetings; no hearing within the reactor's federal safety review was found in public records
undated · loc-030 · Emery County Commission, Utah Energy Research Board, U.S. Department of Energy, Orangeville City, Valar Atomics

What Emery residents were offered, in order: a county 'Nuclear Industries' hearing on 17 June 2025, called after news reports, where the state lab director said transparency is imperative (gov-020); a town hall on 8 July 2025 that the county hosted at Valar's request (ETV; orig-045); a state board approval in Salt Lake City on 13 August 2025 at a 35-minute first meeting that closed with a public comment period (gov-013); a county commission vote on 2 September 2025 issuing the building permit itself (gov-021); DOE's categorical exclusion of 22 April 2026, posted online later with no public comment period (csite-020, gov-029); a noticed hearing on 7 April 2026 on selling the lab-side parcel (loc-007, gov-022); open houses (February and September 2026) and frequent appearances at town councils (loc-027). Separately, state bodies listed the project, or a tour of it, on noticed agendas that also had public-comment periods: the Legislature's energy committee on 18 June 2025, whose minutes record public comment on the nuclear discussion (gov-040); the Utah Energy Council's 31 March 2026 agenda (gov-041); and the Energy Research Board's 12 August 2026 agenda, for a meeting at the lab with a members' tour of the lab and Valar listed afterwards (gov-042). What was not found in the records read: any public hearing or comment period within the federal safety review of the reactor, its emergency plan or fuel plant (safe-001, safe-016, safe-031; the June 2025 county hearing, gov-020, was a general one, which the commission's 3 June 2025 minutes said would address safety issues); any county land-use (conditional use) review of the reactor (the lab sits on state-owned land, and the county land-use chapter does not by itself give a county jurisdiction over state-owned land, dir-014); a state permit under the 2026 waste law (gov-017); a completed third-party fire plan review (loc-018); or, as of 17 October 2026, a hearing on Orangeville's new zone for Valar's land (loc-013). The March 2026 utility minutes record a staff report that Valar tied into the county sewer system without prior authorization (loc-015). Under the federal pilot program, local governments have no approval role over the reactor itself (gov-032); what they control is land, buildings, water, sewer and zoning; the county commission voted the building permit with no review recorded in its minutes (gov-021), and amended its bid rule at the meeting where it first approved selling the parcel to Valar, subject to a hearing and two appraisals (gov-022).

In plain termsEmery County residents got meetings, a hearing about selling land, open houses, many presentations, and public-comment periods at state meetings whose agendas included the project or a board tour of the lab and Valar (gov-040, gov-041, gov-042). No public hearing within the reactor's federal safety review was found in the records read; the federal program used here does not require one, and the lab sits on state-owned land, over which the county's land-use chapter does not by itself give the county jurisdiction (dir-014). Local officials approved the parts they control, like the building permit and the land sale (the sale after a noticed public hearing). In short: many meetings and presentations, and few formal review steps open to residents, were found in the records read.
verified 2026-10-18: Re-read the cited notice, minutes and DOE exclusion: holds. The July 2025 town hall was hosted by the county at Valar's request (ETV), now said so; fire-minutes date corrected to 17 Feb. Revised before publication (2026-10-01): wording made more exact against the cited records. Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): the state-land rule replaces an unsourced cause; 'taken quickly' removed; see Corrections.
recordconfirmed BLM's public mining-claim map shows claim names, serial numbers and status, but not who staked them or when
undated · mine-001 · Bureau of Land Management, MLRS

BLM publishes its Mineral & Land Records System (MLRS) mining claims as two public ArcGIS layers on gis.blm.gov: 'Mining Claims - Not Closed' and 'Mining Claims - Closed' (read in late September 2026, no key needed). Their fields are case name, serial number (e.g. UT106782094), legacy serial, claim type (lode, placer, mill site), disposition (Filed, Active, Under Review, Draft, Closed), acres, a Public Land Survey legal description, and record Created/Modified timestamps. They carry no claimant name, no location date and no county field. The closed layer holds only claims closed or modified within the last year. BLM's own layer description says claims are usually mapped only to the quarter section, and that the staked boundaries are in the Notice/Certificate of Location in the official case file. By contrast, BLM's public layers for mining notices, plans of operations, rights-of-way and leases do carry a 'Business Account Name' (the customer), which is how Valar's rights-of-way applications were found (mine-006).

In plain termsThe federal claim map tells you that a claim exists, its name and number, its type and roughly where it is (to about a 160-acre square). It does not tell you who owns it. To learn that, you look up the serial number in BLM's records (see mine-031) or read the notice nailed to the claim post. The 'Created' date appears to be when the record entered BLM's system (claims carried over from BLM's old system show the 2021 changeover date instead). Because a new claim must be filed with BLM within 90 days of staking (mine-025), a new claim was normally staked within the 90 days before that date.
verified 2026-10-12: Re-read in late September 2026: layer metadata re-fetched from gis.blm.gov; field list and the Closed layer's description match, quote exact (15 words).
recordconfirmed 43 CFR 3715: living on or fencing a mining claim needs BLM review first, and non-mining uses are prohibited
undated · mine-023 · Bureau of Land Management

BLM's use-and-occupancy rules (43 CFR subpart 3715) limit use of mining claims to what is 'reasonably incident' to prospecting and mining. Occupancy (living on site, structures, watchmen) beyond 14 days in 90 requires ongoing, observable mining work, BLM consultation and BLM's determination before it begins. Prohibited acts include uses not reasonably incident to mining, fences or gates that shut out the public without BLM approval, and blocking public passage by force or intimidation.

In plain termsNo claimant may live on a claim or keep structures on it for more than 14 days in 90, fence it off or keep people out without BLM's concurrence, or use it for non-mining purposes. These rules apply to anyone who occupies, fences or restricts access to a claim on public land that BLM manages; they do not cover state or private land, even where the United States kept the minerals.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read in late September 2026 from the 2024 annual CFR on govinfo (eCFR was not checked, so later amendments are unchecked): purpose, 14-days-in-90 rule, concurrence requirement and prohibited acts match; quote exact. Corrected in V1.1 (October 2026): the 14-days-in-90 limit and BLM's concurrence; see Corrections.
recordconfirmed 43 CFR 3809: small exploration needs only a notice; mining and bigger exploration need a plan with 30 days of public comment
undated · mine-024 · Bureau of Land Management

Under BLM's surface-management rules (43 CFR subpart 3809), exploration disturbing 5 acres or less needs a complete notice filed 15 days before starting (3809.21(a)); casual use with negligible disturbance needs neither. Any other work beyond casual use (all mining, and exploration over 5 acres), bulk sampling of 1,000 tons or more, or work in special areas needs a plan of operations, and before acting on a plan BLM publishes its availability and takes at least 30 days of public comment (3809.411(c)). The notice rule we read has no public-comment step. As of late September 2026, BLM's public layers showed 7 notices and 7 plans in Emery County and none in Carbon County; none is Valar's (mine-030).

In plain termsSmall-scale exploration on a claim can start after a notice to BLM, with no public-comment step in the rule read. Mining, and larger exploration, needs an approved plan, and those are published for comment. No mining notice or plan in Carbon County was found in BLM's public layers as of late September 2026.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read in late September 2026 from the 2024 annual CFR on govinfo: 3809.21(a) 15-day notice for 5 acres or less; 3809.11 plan triggers; 3809.411(c) 30-day comment; no comment step in the notice sections. Layer counts re-checked: Emery 7 notices, 7 plans; Carbon 0 and 0. No copy of the query results is kept; the figures rest on BLM's layers as they stood when checked.
recordconfirmed BLM right-of-way rules: public meetings are held if there is enough public interest; notice comes with review
undated · mine-028 · Bureau of Land Management

Under 43 CFR 2804.25 (2024 edition), BLM tells the applicant in writing when it receives a right-of-way application and the cost-recovery fees; it completes NEPA review, consults tribes and other governments, and then decides. The rule says BLM will hold public meetings if there is enough public interest to warrant them, announced in the Federal Register and by other means such as local newspapers or the internet; for solar and wind projects it must hold a local meeting when there is no other early engagement. Valar's three applications are pending (mine-006) and no Federal Register notice for them was found (mine-009).

In plain termsThe rule does not by itself require public notice when a company applies to use public land. Public involvement comes mainly through BLM's environmental review and any public meetings BLM decides to hold, announced in the Federal Register.
verified 2026-10-02: Re-read in late September 2026 from the 2024 annual CFR on govinfo: written notice to applicant, NEPA, consultation, meetings 'if sufficient public interest exists', Federal Register notice, and the solar/wind local-meeting rule match; quote exact. Later amendments unchecked (eCFR not checked).
recordconfirmed Where BLM keeps records of who holds a mining claim: its MLRS reports and case pages, searched by serial number
undated · mine-031 · Bureau of Land Management, MLRS

BLM's MLRS page says both old and new serial numbers are searchable and points to its public reports at reports.blm.gov/reports/MLRS. That index lists 'Mining Claims - Customer Info Report', 'Mining Claims - Serial Number Index', 'Mining Claims - Claim Name/Number Index', 'Mining Claims - Geographic Report' and a 'Public Mining Claims Serial Register Page', and notes the public versions carry Privacy Act redactions (unredacted access needs a Login.gov account). The reports themselves (under reports.blm.gov/report/) and the MLRS case pages (mlrs.blm.gov/s/) were not read for this record. BLM says serial numbers are 'searchable within the system', so a claim's serial number, such as UT106782094 (mine-002), can be searched on mlrs.blm.gov or used to run the Serial Register Page or Customer Info report at reports.blm.gov. Other routes: the Carbon County Recorder, where location notices must be recorded, and the notice of location that Utah law requires at the claim itself (mine-026).

In plain termsBLM's records of who holds a mining claim are in its MLRS reports and case pages, not on its claims map. Anyone can look a claim up there in a web browser with its serial number; BLM says the public reports carry Privacy Act redactions.
verified 2026-10-16: Re-read in late September 2026: BLM's MLRS page says both serial numbers are searchable and links reports.blm.gov/reports/mlrs; the reports index lists the mining-claim reports (incl. 'Public Mining Claims Serial Register Page (SRP) - Multi - List') and the Privacy Act/Login.gov note.