VALAR WATCHTake action

The accident math assumes the public stays 400 m away; the lab is 20.6 acres, and two commissioners, as reported, agreed the fence was buffer enough

unresolvedsafety

What was said

What the record shows

  • DOE's environmental review: the host lab is 'a 20.6-acre site'; Ward 250 occupies about 2 acres inside a security fence; 'No expansion of site boundaries occurs.' The same review says 'Radiation monitoring and controlled access are maintained during operations', without saying where the controlled area ends.
    NEPA Determination DOE-ID-26-005: Valar Ward250 Research Reactor (categorical exclusion B5.26) (U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Nuclear Energy, 2026-04-22)
  • A 400 m circle covers about 124 acres (3.1416 x 400 m x 400 m = 502,655 square meters), six times the whole lab; so the 400 m boundary runs over land outside it. No record read says who controls public access to that land.
  • The safety agreement's own dispersion factors: the one used at 100 m (4.0e-3 s/m3) is 16 times the one at 400 m (2.5e-4 s/m3), and its worst-case dose at 100 m is under 5 rem. Our check: the 100 m factor meets DOE's default, but the 400 m factor is 3.1 to 12.3 times lower than standard rural methods give for the paper's own stated weather (Class F, 1 m/s).
  • The county's own minutes of the same April hearing record the answer to the buffer-zone question as 'every design has to be reviewed and approved by the Department of Energy', and the lab director saying 'the State is interested in contiguous ownership to maintain safety'. That day the county approved a letter of commitment to sell, subject to two appraisals; on 19 May 2026 it approved a $394,500 purchase and sale agreement for the 112-acre parcel beside the lab (closing not confirmed in the records read).
The gap: The worst-case analysis in Valar's draft paper assumes no member of the public is closer than 400 m, which it calls 'the nearest point of public access'; no DOE document read sets 400 m as a required boundary, and DOE's approved analysis may use a different one. The reactor's fence encloses about 2 acres of a 20.6-acre state lab, far less than the roughly 124 acres a 400 m circle covers. An access-control agreement, state control of surrounding land, or Valar's purchase of the adjacent 112 acres (at the April hearing the lab director said the State, which also wanted the land, is interested in 'contiguous ownership to maintain safety') may cover the difference; the county approved the sale agreement in May 2026 and a commissioner said in July that the land had been sold, but as of late September 2026 no deed was read and no record read shows that land, any access agreement or state control of surrounding land covering the 400 m circle. As ETV reported it, residents were told the fence line is buffer enough, and two commissioners concurred with Valar.
In plain termsIn an accident, distance is protection: the farther away people are, the smaller the dose. Valar's worst-case math places the nearest member of the public 400 meters from the reactor. A circle that size covers about 124 acres, but the state lab the reactor sits on is 20.6 acres, and the reactor's fenced area about 2. So the math assumes the public is kept off land outside the lab, and no record we found, as of late September 2026, says who does that. Residents who asked about a buffer zone were told, as the local paper reported, that the fence is buffer enough. The land may be controlled by an agreement, or covered by the land next door that Valar is buying; the records read do not say.

Why it matters: If people can stand closer than 400 m, the paper's own numbers show the air concentration, and so the dose, rises steeply (16 times at 100 m).

What would settle it: The site description and public-access control in the approved DSA (FOIA to DOE Idaho Operations Office); GRAMA to the Utah Office of Energy Development for the USREL site plan, Valar's use agreement and any access-control agreements; the Emery County Recorder's deed for parcel 04-0019-0030.

Other sources for this entry:

Emery County Commission Meeting Minutes, May 19, 2026 (Emery County Commission (Utah Public Notice Website), 2026-05-19)
facts safe-014, ppl-021, mine-035, gov-022, loc-035, mine-046 · checked 2026-10-15: Checked for fairness to Valar, late September 2026: looked for an access-control arrangement in the NSDA, CX, Emery minutes and the lab pages; the only lead is the lab director's 'contiguous ownership' remark and the pending purchase of parcel 04-0019-0030 (disc-055). Nothing shows who controls public access out to 400 m. Status stays unresolved; summary line literally true. | Earlier check: Re-read in late September 2026: NSDA pp. 10, 36-38 (quotes exact), CX pp. 1-2, ETV 9 Apr 2026 and 10 Oct 2025, Emery 7 Apr 2026 minutes (the minutes record a different answer to the buffer question than ETV; both are given). Geometry re-checked. Private residents who asked questions are not named. | Revised before publication (late September 2026): claim pages corrected to 10, 11 and 39; dispersion-factor record reworded ('under 5 rem'; chi/Q not a concentration) with the 400 m check added. | Revised before publication (late September 2026): verification wording updated ('summary line'). Revised before publication (2026-10-01): wording made more exact against the cited records.

Code: disc-008 · short link: valarwatch.com/disc-008