VALAR WATCHTake action

Governor: the deal would cost Utah 'virtually nothing'; the state later approved up to $106.7 million in tax credits

unresolvedfunding

What was said

What the record shows

The gap: In May 2025 the governor described the state's cost as virtually nothing beyond space and infrastructure, describing the MOU as it then stood. The record shows that the space is a publicly funded lab whose use terms were not found in public records as of late September 2026, and that in July 2026 the state approved up to $106.7 million in post-performance tax credits for Valar, paid only out of new state tax revenue the project generates, and conditioned on a local incentive the county said in April it had not been asked for. Whether a credit paid from new revenue is a 'cost' is a matter of definition.
In plain termsWhen the deal was announced, Utah's governor said it would cost the state 'virtually nothing,' since Utah was only providing space. That space is a research lab the public paid about $15 million to build and $2 million to buy. In July 2026 a state board approved up to $106.7 million in tax credits for Valar over ten years. Those credits are paid only out of new tax money the company generates, so they are not a check written from existing funds; reasonable people can argue whether that is a 'cost.' But the state's financial commitment grew far beyond 'space,' and the public agenda for the meeting did not name the company.

Why it matters: Taxpayers are entitled to know what the state gives in exchange; the lab-use terms were not found in public records as of late September 2026.

What would settle it: GRAMA to the Governor's Office of Economic Opportunity for Valar's incentive application and agreement; GRAMA to the Utah Office of Energy Development for the lab-use agreement and payments; search Transparent Utah for payments to or from Valar.

Other sources for this entry:

GOED Board Meeting Minutes, July 9, 2026 (posted with the Sept 10, 2026 meeting) (Board of the Governor's Office of Economic Development (Utah Public Notice Website), 2026-09-10)
facts orig-065, csite-024, gov-033, fund-015, fund-016, fund-017, gov-021 · checked 2026-10-18: Checked for fairness to Valar, late September 2026: the governor spoke about the 2025 MOU; the 2026 credit is post-performance (GOED materials) and came 14 months later; the county's April answer ('None') was accurate when given. Status stays unresolved; summary line literally true (KUTV; GOED materials). | Earlier check: Re-read in late September 2026: KUTV, Emery 7 Apr minutes (quotes exact), GOED materials (Valar summary: $106,737,499; 50%; 10 years; site specific), HB 410 fiscal note ($2,000,000 one-time), Emery 19 Nov 2024 minutes ($2,111,444), ETV 2022 (about $15 million). The governor's words rest on one outlet. | Revised before publication (late September 2026): verification wording updated ('summary line').

Code: disc-035 · short link: valarwatch.com/disc-035