VALAR WATCHTake action

Local jobs and 'relocated' from California: the numbers told to towns, the state and job boards do not line up

unresolvedpeople

What was said

What the record shows

The gap: Valar told Carbon County it relocated from California, and told the state of about 40 full-time local residents and 275 future jobs. The record shows most of its openings and its registered place of work in California, and, in April, Valar saying many of its 120 Emery workers did not live in Utah. On 6 October 2026 a Valar speaker told the Carbon County Planning Commission 'we currently employ 70 locals down in Emery County' (county recording, about 1:14:49), and said a Carbon project would mean 'hundreds of jobs' 'if it were to work out' (about 1:00:57); KUTV reported the Emery facility 'employs 70 people'. The figures count different things; no payroll record was found in public records as of late September 2026 to check them.
In plain termsValar has told Carbon County officials it moved to the region from California, told the state's trust lands board it employs about 40 local people, and told the state it will create 275 jobs averaging $137,567 a year. But most of its job openings are in Torrance, California, its federal paperwork lists California as where the work is done, and in April its own Utah director said many of the 120 people working in Emery County did not live in Utah. These numbers can all be true at once, counting different groups at different times. None can be checked against a payroll, and the state tax credit depends on the 275.

Why it matters: Local jobs are the main public benefit officials cite; the state's $106.7 million credit is tied to them.

What would settle it: GRAMA to the Governor's Office of Economic Opportunity for Valar's incentive application and any annual job and wage reports.

Other sources for this entry:

facts loc-004, loc-029, plan-022, fund-017, orig-036, loc-019 · checked 2026-10-17: Checked for fairness to Valar, late September 2026: the figures count different groups at different times (site staff, company-wide staff, contractors, future jobs); 'relocated... two years ago' rests on summary minutes. No payroll or GOED job report found. Status stays unresolved; summary line literally true (Carbon minutes; job feed 71 of 92 in Torrance). | Earlier check: Re-read in late September 2026: Carbon 19 Aug minutes (image), 20 Aug TLA minutes, GOED materials, Ferron 15 Apr minutes (page image; quote exact), live job feed (70 'Torrance, California' + 1 'Torrance, CA', 21 Orangeville), USAspending record, ETV town-hall report. | Revised before publication (late September 2026): verification wording updated ('summary line').

Code: disc-039 · short link: valarwatch.com/disc-039