'Each company will be responsible for all costs': Valar's federal award is $0, as DOE said; help in kind is unpriced
claim holds upfunding
What was said
- U.S. Department of Energy (pilot selections) (2025-08-12): "Each company will be responsible for all costs" of designing, building, operating and decommissioning its test reactor.Department of Energy Announces Initial Selections for New Reactor Pilot Program (U.S. Department of Energy, 2025-08-12)
What the record shows
- USAspending (read in late September 2026) lists one federal award to Valar, DOE Other Transaction Agreement DENE0009560, run from DOE's Idaho office, obligating $0 (22 October 2025 to 4 July 2027).USAspending award ASST_NON_DENE0009560_089 (USAspending.gov (U.S. Department of the Treasury), 2026-05-19)
- In kind: 'Applicants will not be responsible for DOE costs incurred reviewing documents' (Hogan Lovells' summary of the rules); Ward 250's HALEU was cleared to ship from a federal site; who owns it was not found in public records as of late September 2026 (disc-018); Los Alamos ran the NOVA test on its own assembly (fund-012).
The gap: None on cash: the record shows $0 in federal money, as DOE said. No public value for DOE's free review, the federal fuel route or the Los Alamos test was found in public records as of late September 2026.
In plain termsDOE said companies in its pilot program pay their own way, and the federal spending database agrees: Valar's DOE agreement carries $0. That claim holds. What the $0 leaves out is help that is not cash: DOE reviews Valar's safety papers at no charge, the fuel was shipped to Utah from a federal nuclear site (Valar says it supplied that fuel for the Los Alamos test), on terms not found in public records as of late September 2026, and a national laboratory ran Valar's first core test. No published price for any of that help was found as of late September 2026.
Why it matters: Fairness on money: no federal grants; the unpriced help is the open question.
What would settle it: FOIA to DOE Idaho Operations Office for the OTA and DOE staff and contractor hours spent on Valar's reviews; FOIA to NNSA for the NOVA agreement and costs.
Code: disc-046 · short link: valarwatch.com/disc-046