VALAR WATCHTake action

Has the NRC suit been settled? No public settlement record found; the latest records show it paused, then still open in September 2026

analysislikely
2026-09-30 · dir-024 · Valar Atomics, Nuclear Regulatory Commission, State of Utah, State of Texas

No public record read shows a settlement of Texas et al. v. NRC. (1) The NRC General Counsel listed the case as active and in abeyance as of 27 January 2026 (dir-018). (2) Utah's Attorney General described it in January 2026 as stayed while the NRC considers rule revisions and exemptions (dir-019). (3) The NRC's May 2026 proposed Part 57 rule keeps the 'utilization facility' definition the suit attacks (dir-020). No final rule and no Federal Register notice about a settlement were found, and none of the NRC's 2026 Commission orders (CLI-26-1 to CLI-26-12) concerns the case. (4) The latest docket entry seen, in a commercial copy of the docket, is a joint status report of 2 September 2026, the only entry that copy shows, so the copy does not show earlier filings such as a dismissal (dir-022). (5) Press in May 2026 reported only that the NRC had been willing to settle (dir-021). (6) ANS Nuclear News reported on 5 October 2026 that the states in the suit had filed a notice of voluntary dismissal. It reported that the 2 September status report says the reactor companies, Valar included, were 'currently conferring on what their next steps will be'. Neither filing was read. A settlement agreed but not yet filed cannot be ruled out from public records, and its terms, if any, are unknown. Ward 250 runs under DOE authorization either way (safe-028). (Updates safe-028.)

In plain termsAs of 30 September 2026, we found no public record that the lawsuit has been settled. The last court filing we could see, from September 2, 2026, is a progress report on a case that is still open. A nuclear trade journal reported in October 2026 that the states in the suit, Utah among them, had filed to drop out, while the companies, Valar included, were weighing their next steps. The NRC's published proposal still treats every reactor as needing its license. A deal might exist that has not been filed, but nothing public shows one or what it would say.
verified 2026-10-12: Second check, 2026-09-30: re-read every underlying source (see dir-018 to dir-022). Re-ran the FR API search of NRC documents from 2 May to 30 Sept 2026 (microreactors, utilization facility, Valar): no final Part 57 and no settlement notice. Re-read the 2026 Commission orders page (12 orders, none on the case). Taylor's 2 Sept House testimony does not mention the NRC or the suit (dir-034). Earlier-pass checks of Valar's docs library, govinfo and justice.gov were not re-run. Headline reframed as the question the records answer.

Code: dir-024 · short link: valarwatch.com/dir-024

In tabs: Safety Related Issues, Connections to Government, Timeline