VALAR WATCHTake action

FAQ on the Carbon lease: the vote, $400,000 bonus, 50-year term and 'roughly $35 million' match the state's papers; the lease starts with 480 of the 640 acres

newcompany claimconfirmed
2026-09-17 · faq-003 · Valar Atomics, Utah Trust Lands Administration, Utah National Guard · upfront bonus due on lease execution (state memo; FAQ): $400,000; computed: bonus plus 50 years of rent, 640 acres, 3% yearly CPI in five-year steps from year 11: $35,024,420; computed: bonus plus 50 years of rent, 480 acres, same basis: $26,368,315; computed: bonus plus 50 years of rent, 480 acres, no CPI increase: $13,672,000

The FAQ (as of 16 October 2026) says the Trust Lands board voted unanimously on 17 September, in open session, to lease Valar 'about 640 acres of school trust land east of the Price airport', after 'a published board memo, two public board meetings, and a public comment period'; that 'Valar pays $400,000 up front', then yearly rent that steps up, and 'roughly $35 million to the trust over 50 years', from land that previously earned the schools about $200,000 over the same period (another answer gives about $4,000 a year); and that the term is 50 years with 'two optional 25-year extensions that have to be earned'. Where the record supports Valar: the board memorandum in the 17 September 2026 packet lists an upfront bonus of $400,000 due on execution; rent of $30 per acre in years 1-5, $206.25 in year 6, $418.75 in year 7 and $625 in years 8-10, with a CPI-based increase in year 11 and every five years after; and an initial term of 50 years with two optional 25-year extensions, 'provided the lease remains in good standing'. The memo says staff presented the proposal to the full board on 20 August 2026, when the board accepted public comments, before the 17 September vote; the board's published transcript of that meeting records a motion to approve 'on the terms set forth in the board memorandum' and the chair calling the vote unanimous. The memo calls the parcel's past income 'approximately $4,000 per year', which matches the FAQ ($4,000 x 50 years = $200,000). Two other records differ: the board's final minutes of 20 August 2026 record staff saying the parcel yields 'approximately $4,000 per month' from the Utah National Guard, and the board's published transcript of that meeting gives '$4,000 and some change' with no period stated; no record read explains the difference. Set beside the answer: the memo covers up to 640 acres, but the lease would include the 480 acres not under a Utah National Guard lease, with the other 160 acres added later only if that lease is moved. The memo gives no 50-year total, but the Trust Lands staff slides shown to the board on 20 August and 17 September 2026 do: 'Approximately $35,000,000 in lease rents over 50 years' (17 September), and 'approximately $35 million' (20 August). The FAQ's figure is that state projection; the slides do not say what acreage or inflation rate it assumes. This site's arithmetic, using the memo's rent schedule and the 3% a year CPI assumption the memo uses for its purchase price, applied in five-year steps from year 11: bonus plus 50 years of rent comes to $35,024,420 on 640 acres and $26,368,315 on 480 acres; with no CPI increase, $18,096,000 and $13,672,000. Actual CPI and the memo's possible appraisal resets after year 25 would change these totals, and the memo's purchase option could end rent early. On that arithmetic, the $35 million in the slides and the FAQ corresponds to the full 640 acres with 3% inflation, not to the 480 acres the lease would cover at the start. The memo places the parcel about five miles north of Wellington; the FAQ's 'east of the Price airport' was not checked against a saved map record.

In plain termsMost of what Valar's FAQ says about its state land lease matches the state's own papers: the unanimous vote on 17 September 2026, the $400,000 up-front payment, the rising rent, the 50-year term with two 25-year extensions, and the land's past income of about $4,000 a year, as the state's memo gives it (the board's August minutes say about $4,000 a month). The 'roughly $35 million' over 50 years is also the state's own estimate, shown to the board in August and September. One point is stated at its largest: the lease would start with 480 acres, not 640; the last 160 acres come only if a National Guard lease is moved. On this site's arithmetic, the $35 million works out for all 640 acres with prices rising 3% a year. For 480 acres on the same basis it is about $26.4 million, and without any price rise about $13.7 million.
verified 2026-10-17: Checked 17 October 2026: the FAQ answers and the board memorandum read in full; the 50-year totals recomputed from the memo's rent schedule; the vote checked in the meeting transcript; the 20 August minutes and transcript checked for the parcel's past income; the board slides of 20 August and 17 September 2026 checked for the 50-year projection. Quotes exact.

Code: faq-003 · short link: valarwatch.com/faq-003

In tabs: Carbon County Site, Public Process, Funding