VALAR WATCHTake action

Critical reporting in order: the Philippines (2025), a Utah investigation (mid-2025), national critiques (late 2025-26)

analysisconfirmed
undated · orig-072 · Valar Atomics

In date order, with what was read: March 27, 2025, Greenpeace Philippines condemns the PNRI deal, calling Valar a 2023 startup with no track record (read; orig-064); the scientists' group AGHAM criticized the project in a statement of March 24 (the Philippine Collegian, reporting it in April 2026, does not give the year; not read). April-May 2025, engineers dispute the 'CAT scan' claim online (as reported in the press; their own posts are not yet archived here; the claim: safe-026). July 8, 2025, the Utah Investigative Journalism Project with Utah News Dispatch, 'Who is Valar Atomics?': experts question its safety claims and note it had submitted no design to the NRC; Valar did not respond (read). July 23, 2025, E&E News on the NRC lawsuit (safe-028, csite-022). November 26, 2025, Washington Post, 'Kilowatts or connections?' (listed in Valar's own library; not read, subscription). December 17, 2025, NPR on safety worries (listed in Valar's library; not read, blocked). February 28, 2026, Neutron Bytes, 'Questions Abound About Valar Atomics' (read; orig-026). March 13, 2026, Partnership for Global Security, Ken Luongo (read; orig-073). March 20, 2026, ProPublica on DOE and the NRC. April 25, 2026, Philippine Collegian on opposition to Ward One (read; orig-064). May 26, 2026, The New Republic. July 9, 2026, MIT Technology Review on what criticality does and does not prove (read; orig-073). September 18, 2026, The Washington Sun on BLM data-center applications (mine-008). Locally, ETV News's first report of the Carbon County lease came the day after the state approved it (mine-041). Few public replies by Valar to these reports were found (ppl-029).

In plain termsThe earliest criticism of Valar found came from abroad, in the Philippines, in March 2025; it reached Utah in mid-2025 through an investigative nonprofit, and went national from late 2025 (The Washington Post and NPR, going by their headlines; neither was read) into 2026 (ProPublica, The New Republic and nuclear-policy critics). Few public replies from Valar to these reports were found. This list lets readers find each one.
verified 2026-10-15: Second check, late September 2026: Greenpeace, UIJP, Neutron Bytes, PGS, Collegian and MIT Technology Review re-read; dates and quotes exact; library dates for WaPo and NPR confirmed. The AGHAM statement's year is not given by the Collegian: wording fixed. Plain now counts the national 2025 pieces. Revised before publication (late September 2026): 'rarely answered' now 'few public replies were found'. Revised before publication (2026-10-01): wording made more exact against the cited records.

Code: orig-072 · short link: valarwatch.com/orig-072

In tabs: Origins, Timeline