Independent assessments, 2026: the airlift moved an unfueled, non-working unit in three pieces; criticality is not power
Partnership for Global Security (its president, Ken Luongo, March 13, 2026) argues the C-17 flight was political and public-relations 'cinema'; that what flew was a single non-operational, unfueled unit delivered in three pieces; that the Wall Street Journal reported Valar paid for the flights, roughly estimated at under $1 million (WSJ not read); that U.S. military aircraft had carried small reactors before, including two Russian TOPAZ-II space reactors flown by C-5 in 1992; that Valar is not part of any military reactor project (the Defense Department's Project Pele reactor is being built by BWXT); and, citing former DOE nuclear chief Katy Huff, that a cold zero-power test does not show hot, full-power performance. It wrote that Valar's reactor 'seems to have some advantages' because the U.S. government had approved its preliminary safety analyses. It also wrote that no power production would occur at the Utah site; Valar says, and Deseret News reported, that Ward 250 made electricity there on July 1, 2026 (orig-013, orig-042). MIT Technology Review (July 9, 2026) reports that four pilot reactors, Valar's among them, reached zero-power criticality by the July 4 deadline; that criticality and running a reactor that can make electricity are two different things; that startup timelines deserve caution; and that a Third Way memo called the federal push an 'unhelpful diversion'. Both are analysis, not findings by a regulator.
- A Hollywood Highlight Reel for the Nuclear Renaissance (Ken Luongo) (Partnership for Global Security, 2026-03-13) analysis “What was transported was a single, non-operational, and unfueled unit, delivered in three pieces.”
- Four nuclear reactors hit a big milestone in the US (weekly climate newsletter) (MIT Technology Review, 2026-07-09) analysis “reaching criticality and running a reactor that can produce electricity are two totally different things”
Code: orig-073 · short link: valarwatch.com/orig-073
In tabs: Origins, Safety Related Issues, Timeline