VALAR WATCHTake action

Lease money: about $5.43 million of bonus and rent over the lease's first 20 years on 480 acres ($7.10 million on 640) if prices rise 3% a year, paid to Trust Lands for the school trust; no payment to Carbon County government in the terms

analysislikely
2026-09-17 · ptax-009 · Utah Trust Lands Administration, Valar Atomics, Permanent State School Fund, Carbon County · upfront bonus due on execution of SULA 2095: $400,000; bonus plus rent, lease years 1-20, 480 acres, 3% CPI applied every five years from year 11 (arithmetic): $5,426,786; bonus plus rent, lease years 1-20, 640 acres, same assumption (arithmetic): $7,102,381; bonus plus rent, lease years 1-20, 480 acres, no CPI increase (arithmetic): $4,672,000; bonus plus rent, lease years 1-20, 640 acres, no CPI increase (arithmetic): $6,096,000; payment to Carbon County government in the lease terms: $0

Payment terms in the Trust Lands board memorandum for SULA 2095-OBA (17 September 2026 packet, PDF p.24), listed as 'Payments to Trust Lands Administration': an upfront bonus of $400,000 due on execution; rent of $30 per acre in years 1-5 (the 'Development Phase'), $206.25 in year 6, $418.75 in year 7 and $625 in years 8-10; a CPI-based increase in year 11 and every five years after; and a possible reset by appraisal after year 25 and every 25 years. No payment to Carbon County appears in the terms. The land's beneficiary is the Public Schools Trust (PDF p.18). The initial lease is the 480 acres not under the Utah National Guard lease; the other 160 acres may be added later (PDF p.20). Arithmetic (not in the memo): bonus plus rent for lease years 1-20 is $5,426,786 on 480 acres and $7,102,381 on 640 acres, using the memo's own purchase-price assumption of a projected annual CPI increase of 3%, adjusted every five years (PDF p.25), applied from year 11; with no CPI increase the totals are $4,672,000 and $6,096,000; if lease year 1 is 2027, these are the years 2027-2046. Over the full 50-year term, on the same assumptions and leaving aside any appraisal reset after year 25, bonus plus rent comes to $26,368,315 on 480 acres and $35,024,420 on 640 acres ($13,672,000 and $18,096,000 with no increase); the Trust Lands slides for the 17 September meeting project 'Approximately $35,000,000 in lease rents over 50 years' and do not state how that figure was reached; as of 12 October 2026, no signed lease or start date was found in the records read. Trust Lands says nearly all of its revenue is deposited into the Permanent School Fund, whose capital gains, interest and dividends are distributed each year to every school in the state based on enrollment ('Trust Lands to your school' page). The same page says '96% of the revenue generated from trust lands goes to public education', a figure for all trust-land revenue, not one stated for this lease. These payments are lease money, not a tax.

In plain termsValar's lease payments go to Trust Lands, the state office that manages land for Utah's schools, not to Carbon County's government. Over the first 20 years they would add up to about $5.4 million if prices rise 3% a year, and more if the lease grows to the full square mile. Trust Lands puts nearly all its money into a statewide school fund, and the fund's earnings are shared by all Utah schools based on how many students they have.
verified 2026-10-17: Re-read the SULA 2095 memorandum: payment terms (PDF p.24), beneficiary (p.18), the 480-acre initial lease and 160-acre option (p.20) and the 3% CPI purchase-price assumption (p.25); no county payment appears in the terms. Recomputed the 20-year totals: $4,672,000 and $6,096,000 with no increase, $5,426,786 and $7,102,381 with rent raised by 1.03^5 in year 11 and 1.03^10 in year 16. Re-read both quotes on the Trust Lands 'Trust Lands to your school' page. Added the 3% assumption to the headline.

Code: ptax-009 · short link: valarwatch.com/ptax-009

In tabs: Carbon County Site, Connections to Government