VALAR WATCHTake action

Public NSDA is marked 'Draft'; Valar says DOE approved it; its summary lists as approved only 2 of the 6 rule substitutions asked for

recordconfirmed
2025-10-13 · safe-005 · Valar Atomics, U.S. Department of Energy

The NSDA PDF Valar posts (rev 02, October 2025, created 13 October 2025 per its file metadata) is marked 'Status: Draft' and 'issued for Public Release'. Valar's library page of the same date says DOE 'has approved' the NSDA under 10 CFR 830 and the DOE-Valar Other Transaction Agreement. The web summary describes a PDSA 'at 50% design completion' and a final DSA 'for the as-built facility', while the PDF proposes, as an alternative requirement, submitting the final DSA 'at 90% design completion' and verifying the as-built plant afterwards (Appendix C.5). The PDF asks DOE to accept six alternatives to standard requirements: ANS-15.8 instead of NQA-1 for quality assurance; ANS-15.4 operator qualification; on-site-only emergency response; OSHA rules instead of DOE's worker safety rule 10 CFR 851; early DSA submittal; and tailored DOE O 420.1C facility safety. The web summary lists three alternatives as approved (ANS-15.8 QA, ANS-15.4 conduct of operations, reduced surveillance); only the first two are among the PDF's six. The PDF itself says the OSHA substitution for the construction phase was 'approved through the OTA' (Appendix C.4); that is Valar's statement, and no DOE record of it was read. The same PDF's requirements table (page 48) notes a DOE Idaho Operations Office 'exemption request in process for construction activities pending 10 CFR 851 revision'. Apart from the OTA statement, no record read says whether DOE approved the emergency-planning, worker-safety, DSA-timing and DOE O 420.1C alternatives, and no DOE approval letter for the NSDA was found in public records as of late September 2026.

In plain termsThe safety agreement the public can read is labelled a draft, while the company says the government approved it. The company's own summary lists as approved only two of the six rule substitutions the document asks for, plus a third item (reduced surveillance) that is not among the six. The ones left unmentioned include two that bear directly on neighbours and workers: planning for emergencies only inside the site, and using ordinary workplace-safety rules instead of DOE's. Only DOE's approval letter would show what was actually agreed.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read NSDA (PDF created 13 Oct 2025 09:11 MDT per metadata, 'Status: Draft') and the web summary (dated 13 Oct 2025) in late September 2026. Holds. Added: the NSDA says its OSHA substitution for construction was 'approved through the OTA' (a company statement), which the earlier text missed.

Code: safe-005 · short link: valarwatch.com/safe-005

In tabs: Safety Related Issues, Connections to Government, Public Process