Worst-case dose at the 400 m site boundary: the safety agreement says under 0.5 rem in one place and under 0.1 rem in another
The NSDA's 'Maximum Hypothetical Accident' assumes a large break in the reactor vessel, complete loss of helium coolant pressure, TRISO failures at twice unspecified AGR-1/2 test-program values, no credit for the building, filters or cooling systems, a ground-level release and stable air with a 1 m/s wind. Its results are stated two ways. Pages 11, 14 and 54 say site-boundary doses are below 0.5 rem (500 millirem); page 11 puts the nearest residence below 0.1 rem. Pages 32 and 37-38 say the public dose at the 400 m site boundary is below 1 mSv (100 millirem), a co-located worker at 100 m below 5 rem (the annual worker limit), and the control room below 0.5 rem; I-131 and noble gases dominate. The two boundary figures differ by a factor of five; both are stated as upper bounds, so they do not strictly contradict, but the looser 0.5 rem is the one Appendix C.3 relies on to justify on-site-only emergency planning (safe-016). Both are far below the 25 rem evaluation guideline the NSDA uses for 'Safety Class' equipment; on that basis the NSDA designates no Safety Class equipment and a 'Hazard Category 2' facility 'based on material at risk rather than consequence'. For scale, DOE's categorical exclusion puts natural background radiation in central Utah at about 100-120 millirem a year. The approved DSA's final figures were not found in public records as of late September 2026; DOE's categorical exclusion says only that its offsite doses 'remain well below DOE evaluation guidelines'. Our check: the 400 m dispersion factor it uses (2.5e-4 s/m3, p.36) is 3.1 to 12.3 times lower than standard rural methods give for its own stated weather; rescaled, the 0.1 rem bound would be about 0.31 to 1.23 rem, still far below 25 rem. DOE-STD-1271 lists DOE's NE-STD-1027-2025 for hazard categorization and says DOE's safety-basis approval authority may approve a lower category depending on the hazard; the NSDA lists that standard as applying in full.
- Ward250 Nuclear Safety Design Agreement, No. 100403, Rev 02 (status: Draft; issued for Public Release) (Valar Atomics, 2025-10) primary company “site boundary doses below 0.5 rem Total Effective Dose Equivalent”
- Ward250 Nuclear Safety Design Agreement, No. 100403, Rev 02 (status: Draft; issued for Public Release) (Valar Atomics, 2025-10) primary company “Public dose at site boundary (400m): <1 mSv (100 mrem)”
- NEPA Determination DOE-ID-26-005: Valar Ward250 Research Reactor (categorical exclusion B5.26) (U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Nuclear Energy (Idaho), 2026-04-22) primary government “Natural background radiation in central Utah is approximately 100-120 mrem/year.”
Code: safe-013 · short link: valarwatch.com/safe-013
In tabs: Safety Related Issues