VALAR WATCHTake action

Who decides day to day: Valar's own design authority, with DOE approval only for changes that cross the safety basis

recordconfirmed
2025-10 · safe-019 · Valar Atomics, U.S. Department of Energy, Mark Mitchell

The NSDA makes Valar the Design Authority for Ward 250, with the COO/Chief Nuclear Officer holding 'ultimate contractor responsibility for design safety decisions' (Valar's mission page lists Mark Mitchell as Chief Nuclear Officer, orig-003). Changes are screened by Valar's own Unreviewed Safety Question (USQ) process under 10 CFR 830.203; DOE's prior approval is needed for changes the screening flags, which the NSDA says include changes to safety-basis assumptions, TSR limits, safety equipment functions or approved codes. Otherwise 'Design decisions within the approved authorization basis are made by Valar Atomics' Design Authority'. DOE-STD-1271 sets the same division: the OTA contractor is the Design Authority, final design adequacy is approved through the DSA, and after startup testing the contractor operates without asking permission for approved activities. The NSDA planned a Joint Test Group, required by the standard, as a TSR for post-startup testing; Valar's draft post dated 28 June 2026 says the company had 'graduated' from the Joint Test Group; the post says it has been 14 days since first criticality and that Valar made power on July XX, so it reads as drafted about 2 July under an earlier 28 June date field; the count fits DOE's 18 June date (disc-040). No DOE record of the end of Joint Test Group oversight was found in public records as of late September 2026.

In plain termsThe company makes its own day-to-day safety calls, under DOE oversight. It decides whether a change needs DOE's permission by running its own screening process, and only changes that affect the approved safety case go to DOE. DOE's representative sat on the start-up test group, which the company says it had left within about two weeks of first starting the reactor. This is how DOE's system is designed; no record of the screening decisions or of when DOE signed off was found in public records as of late September 2026.
verified 2026-10-15: Re-read NSDA pp. 30-31, 'By the Numbers', DOE release (18 June) and DOE-STD-1271 secs. 3, 9 in late September 2026. Holds. New small discrepancy recorded: Valar's 28 June post counts 14 days since first criticality; DOE and Valar's Castle Country page give 18 June (10 days). Consistency check in late September 2026: the '14 days' comes from an unfinished draft whose 28 June date may not be when the words were written (18 June plus 14 days is 2 July); every dated DOE and Valar record gives 18 June. Revised before publication (late September 2026): 14-day count now explained (draft written about 2 July; fits 18 June), replacing 'unexplained mismatch'.

Code: safe-019 · short link: valarwatch.com/safe-019

In tabs: Safety Related Issues, Connections to Government