VALAR WATCHTake action

'No burden on our water supply'; yet 10 acre-feet 'for industrial use' and up to 1,000 more water shares sought

unresolvedsite

What was said

What the record shows

The gap: The reactor needs no cooling water, so that part of the claim holds, and Valar's 'waterless' wording refers to cooling. The site and campus plans do use water: Valar told Castle Dale about 10 acre-feet 'for industrial use', with no time period (it could be an allocation rather than a yearly draw), which DOE's review does not mention; Valar is working toward up to 1,000 more water shares for future development; and a Carbon campus would have to buy rights in a fully appropriated basin. At the Carbon County Planning Commission on 6 October 2026 a Valar speaker said of data centers powered by its reactors, 'We can use air cooling instead of water cooling', and said a very water-intensive activity such as electrolysis was 'not a good idea': 'There's not enough water for that' (county recording, about 1:03:33 and 1:23:48). No water volume for the Carbon project was found in that presentation, as checked on 17 October 2026. At Orangeville's council meeting of 8 October 2026, in the reports at the end of the meeting, a city official said of Valar's water use that 'they've slowed the use down', and a city official said one item being looked at for a new ordinance is that anyone filling 'large systems' must give the city 'so many days notice'; Valar was named in that discussion, and other companies were said to 'have been mentioned' (city recording, about 1:10:35 and 1:11:29 to 1:11:55).
In plain termsWard 250 is cooled by helium gas, not water, and DOE's review lists only household-scale water use; so 'the reactor needs almost no water' holds. But Valar told one city council the reactor needs about 10 acre-feet 'for industrial use,' which, if that is a yearly figure, is roughly nine times DOE's number and appears nowhere in DOE's review. Valar is also working toward up to 1,000 more water shares for future projects, and its Carbon County campus would have to buy water in a basin where the state says all water is already spoken for. 'No burden on our water supply' is true of the reactor's cooling, not of everything Valar plans to build around it.

Why it matters: Water is scarce in Castle Country; figures in the federal review and in local statements should match, and campus-scale use is where the burden would fall.

What would settle it: FOIA to DOE Idaho Operations Office for the environmental checklist Valar submitted for the categorical exclusion; GRAMA to Orangeville City and Castle Valley SSD for Valar's water connection records; watch the State Engineer's 'Notice to Water Users' for any Valar application.

Other sources for this entry:

facts loc-025, loc-017, mine-042, mine-017, orig-070, loc-005, loc-031 · checked 2026-10-18: Checked for fairness to Valar, late September 2026: 'no burden on our water supply' in the Series B post refers to reactors cooled without water, which holds for Ward 250 (CX: domestic use under 1,000 gal/day). The 10 acre-feet figure has no stated period and may be an allocation. Status stays unresolved; summary line literally true. | Earlier check: Re-read in late September 2026: Series B, GOED minutes, ETV 3 July (quote exact), CX, Castle Dale 12 March 2026 minutes (page image; quote exact), Orangeville 9 July minutes, ETV 28 July, TLA September memo. Arithmetic: 10 acre-feet = about 3.26 million gallons. | Revised before publication (late September 2026): verification wording updated ('summary line').

Code: disc-034 · short link: valarwatch.com/disc-034