VALAR WATCHTake action

State documents: 'full-power' criticality on 18 June and full power on 21 June; DOE and Valar itself describe 18 June as a zero-power test

documented conflicttechnical

What was said

What the record shows

  • DOE, 18 June 2026: Ward 250 'successfully completed a zero-power fueled criticality demonstration'. DOE's July fact sheet and the Utah Inland Port Authority's September update mention only criticality; a DOE Office of Nuclear Energy slide prepared for the NRC Commission's 21 July 2026 meeting lists 18 June as criticality '(zero power)' and 'July 2, 2026 – full power 100 kWt full power achieved'; the slide gives no data, time or source for that line.
  • ANS, 22 June 2026: Valar 'is now proceeding with a planned power ascension' and on 22 June 'announced it had reached a 10 kWt output', a tenth of the 100 kW limit.
    Valar's Ward 250 reaches criticality in Utah (American Nuclear Society, Nuclear Newswire, 2026-06-22)
  • As of late September 2026, the only power data from Valar found in public records is one chart with a 0-100 'Q_Total' scale that has no units, plotted against a 'sample index' with no dates or times (plan-007).
  • Valar's own page says that at criticality Ward 250 'completed zero-power testing' and reached full power 'days later': Valar does not claim full power on 18 June.
  • Valar's statement on 18 June, as POWER reported it: 'The reactor has now begun non-commercial power ascension'.
  • The state lab's page repeats, nearly word for word, Valar's statement (as POWER quoted it) that the reactor reached its milestones 'as a complete, fully integrated system configured for power operations'; 'full-power' may derive from that phrase (an inference).
    Valar Atomics (project page) (Utah San Rafael Energy Lab (State of Utah))
The gap: The state lab's page says Ward 250 achieved 'full-power' criticality on 18 June, which DOE's release and Valar's own page contradict: 18 June was a zero-power test. The Trust Lands memo's 21 June full-power date differs from the one DOE record found that dates full power, a DOE slide that lists 2 July 2026, eleven days later. Valar announced 10 kW on 22 June (ANS) and said on 24 June it had reached full power, and an announcement can trail the event. That slide, prepared for the NRC Commission's 21 July 2026 meeting, puts full power in the same line as the electricity demonstration, which Valar dates to 1 July; it gives no data or source for the date, and DOE's Theodore Garrish gave no full-power date in his spoken remarks at the meeting. No DOE operating log was found in public records as of 17 October 2026. The state board had the 21 June date in its packet when it voted.
In plain terms'Criticality' only means the chain reaction sustains itself; a reactor can be critical at almost zero power, and DOE and Valar both describe Ward 250's 18 June milestone that way. The state lab's web page instead calls it 'full-power' criticality, which is wrong. The state land board's memo says full power came on 21 June. Valar announced reaching 10 kilowatts on 22 June and told Price City Council on 24 June that it had reached its 100-kilowatt limit. A DOE slide prepared for a Nuclear Regulatory Commission meeting on 21 July 2026 gives a later date, 2 July, for full power of 100 kilowatts, without saying where the date came from. No record found, as of 17 October 2026, explains why these dates differ. The issue here is state paperwork repeating, and in one case overstating, company milestones, not a Valar claim.

Why it matters: State agencies are repeating performance claims as fact in documents that officials rely on to make decisions.

What would settle it: FOIA to DOE Idaho Operations Office for the power-ascension approvals, hold-point records and operating logs; GRAMA to Trust Lands for the application materials that supplied the 21 June date; ask OED to correct its lab page.

Other sources for this entry:

facts mine-016, plan-009, plan-006, plan-007, orig-012, orig-013, safe-020 · checked 2026-10-17: Checked for fairness to Valar, late September 2026: Castle Country ('completed zero-power testing'; full power 'days later'), POWER (Valar's 18 June statement: 'begun non-commercial power ascension'), ANS (10 kW announced 22 June; the date reached is not given), ETV Price (full power by 24 June), lab page ('full-power fueled criticality'; 'configured for power operations'). Valar is cleared of the 18 June claim; the state page's error survives; the 21 June date is left unproven. Summary line rewritten: the old line set a memo date against an announcement that may lag; the new one quotes the lab page and DOE/Valar exactly. | Earlier check: Re-read in late September 2026: TLA September memo p. 18 (quote exact; the memo does not say who supplied the date), lab page (still says 'full-power fueled criticality'), ETV Price council, Castle Country, Series B, DOE release and fact sheet, UIPA update, ANS; chart per plan-007. | Revised before publication (late September 2026): 'inflating' now 'overstating'; state-page inference restated neutrally.

Code: disc-024 · short link: valarwatch.com/disc-024